Brother's Seafood: A New Rochelle Gem for Fresh and Flavorful Seafood

Brother's Seafood Introduce

In a city as dynamic as New York, the search for truly fresh and perfectly seasoned seafood can lead you to some of the best hidden gems. In New Rochelle, one such treasure is Brother's Seafood. This casual and welcoming seafood restaurant has quickly earned a reputation for its flavorful, well-seasoned dishes and generous portions that leave you completely satisfied. It's the kind of place that feels like a home away from home, with a commitment to quality and a warm, friendly atmosphere that has captivated the local community.

Brother's Seafood is more than just a place to eat; it's a testament to passion and dedication. As a Black-owned, veteran-owned, and women-owned business, it brings a unique and inspiring story to the local dining scene. Customers consistently rave about the friendly and welcoming customer service, noting that the staff goes above and beyond to make every visitor feel valued. This blend of incredible food, generous portions, and outstanding service creates a dining experience that is truly worth recommending. As one delighted patron put it, "Your belly will thank you!"

## Location and Accessibility

Brother's Seafood is located at 407 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA. Its position on North Avenue makes it a convenient spot for residents and visitors alike. Whether you're in the mood for a quick lunch or a hearty dinner, the restaurant's location is easily accessible. While specific details about parking aren't provided, its street-side location in a bustling area of New Rochelle makes it a straightforward destination for those traveling by car. For those who prefer to dine at home, the restaurant's robust delivery and takeout options make it a top choice.

## Services Offered

Brother's Seafood offers a variety of service options to cater to every kind of dining preference, whether you're looking for a quick meal on the go or a relaxed dine-in experience. Their services are designed for maximum convenience and flexibility:

Dine-in: The restaurant provides a casual and comfortable setting for customers who want to enjoy their meal on-site. The simple yet inviting atmosphere is perfect for a relaxing lunch or dinner.
Takeout: For those with busy schedules, Brother's Seafood offers efficient takeout services. You can call ahead or place your order in person to enjoy their delicious food from the comfort of your own home or office.
Delivery: The restaurant has a strong delivery presence, ensuring that its fresh and hot food can be brought right to your doorstep with ease. They also offer a no-contact delivery option for added safety and convenience.
Accepts Reservations: For those planning a special meal or dining with a group, Brother's Seafood also accepts reservations, allowing you to secure a table and avoid any potential wait times.

## Features and Highlights

Brother's Seafood stands out in the New Rochelle dining scene not just for its food but also for its unique identity and offerings. Key highlights include:

Black-owned, Veteran-owned, and Women-owned: This establishment is a proud reflection of its ownership. This adds a layer of community support and authenticity that many patrons appreciate.
Diverse Menu of Fried and Baked Seafood: The restaurant offers a wide array of options, from classic fried fish to expertly baked salmon and lobster. This variety caters to different tastes and dietary preferences, making it a great choice for a diverse group of diners.
Generous Portions and Value: Customers consistently praise the restaurant for its generous portion sizes. Platters and combos like the "Fish Boat" are noted for being substantial and offering excellent value for the price, ensuring you get a satisfying meal every time.
Weekend Brunch: In addition to lunch and dinner, Brother's Seafood also serves brunch on Sundays. The brunch menu includes Southern-inspired favorites like Shrimp and Grits and unique creations like Cinnamon Strudel Chicken & Waffles, making it a perfect weekend destination.
Comfort Food and Small Plates: The menu is centered around classic comfort food with a seafood twist. It features a variety of satisfying meals as well as quick bites and small plates, allowing you to choose the perfect size for your appetite.

## Contact Information

To place an order for delivery or takeout, or to inquire about reservations, you can contact Brother's Seafood at their phone number. Their address is also listed below for in-person visits.

Address: 407 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA
Phone: (914) 740-3690

## What Is Worth Choosing

The menu at Brother's Seafood is a treasure trove of delicious options, but a few dishes have earned special acclaim from loyal customers. The restaurant's mastery of both fried and baked seafood is a major draw, with each preparation offering a unique and delightful experience. The consistent theme in customer reviews is the freshness and perfect seasoning of the food, which is what truly sets this place apart.

For those who love classic fried seafood, the Fish Boat is a highly recommended choice. This specialty fried combo, which includes a mix of fish, shrimp, and clam strips, is celebrated for its incredible flavor and perfect crispiness. Customers have called it "absolutely incredible," praising its generous size and the freshness of every component. The Fried Shrimp is another standout, described as "unbelievably fresh" and "extremely delicious with great seasoning." It's a simple dish executed with perfection, showcasing the quality of the ingredients.

For those who prefer a healthier option, the baked dishes are equally praised. The Baked Salmon and Baked Red Snapper are noted for being tender, moist, and perfectly seasoned. These dishes are often served with delicious sides like Sautéed Broccoli and Garlic and Yellow Rice, which are also worth choosing on their own. The menu also includes a variety of tempting sides like Mac and Cheese and Collard Greens, which add a Southern comfort element to the meal.

Another item worth trying is the Shrimp and Grits, a classic Southern dish that is part of their Sunday brunch menu. The combination of creamy grits and perfectly cooked shrimp is a fan favorite. To complete your meal, be sure to check out the desserts from Lloyds Carrot Cake or their homemade pound cakes, which provide a sweet and satisfying end to a fantastic dining experience.

Brother's Seafood Fried shrimp

All Day - Fried Fish
Fried Whiting $10.80
Four to five pieces of whiting fried to perfection.
Fried Catfish $14.40
Catfish filet cut and fried to perfection.
Fried Red Snapper $30.72
Whole red snapper fried to perfection.
Fried All Fish $20.40
Eight to nine pieces of fried whiting with whole wheat bread.
Fish Boat $31.20
Four pieces of whiting, five shrimp, and clam strips, served with fries.
Fried Clam Strips $9.60
Crispy pieces of fried clam, golden and delicious.
Fried Salmon Nuggets $20.40
Salmon filet cut into nuggets and fried to perfection.

All Day - Fried Shrimp
Fried Shrimp $12.00
Extra large shrimp fried to perfection.
Shrimp And Grits $14.40
Southern style grits served with 7 perfectly fried shrimp.

All Day - Boats - Specialty Fried Combos
Fish Boat $31.20
Four pieces of whiting, five shrimp, and clam strips, served with fries.
Cruise Ship $46.80
Fried 6 oz lobster tail, four pieces of whiting, five shrimp, and clam strips, served with fries.
Land And Sea Combo $32.50
Fried lobster tail and five fried chicken wings, served with fries.
Paddle Boat $28.80
Three pieces of chicken (legs & thighs), five shrimp, and clam strips, served with fries.
Yacht $73.00
Fried lobster tail, four pieces of fried whiting, fried catfish filet (cut), salmon nuggets, five shrimp, and clam strips, served with fries.
River Boat $36.00
Catfish, 5 shrimp, clam strips, and natural cut fries

All Day - Fried Combos
Fried Catfish And Shrimp Combo $29.40
Catfish and five shrimp, served with fries.
Fried Fish And Shrimp Combo $26.40
Four whiting and five shrimp, served with fries.
Fish Boat $22.80
Four pieces of whiting, five shrimp, and clam strips, served with fries.
Fried Red Snapper And Shrimp Combo $34.50
Red snapper and five shrimp, served with fries.
Fried Salmon Nuggets And Shrimp Combo $27.60
Salmon filet cut into nuggets and fried, with five fried shrimp, served with fries.
Fried Chicken And Fish Combo $24.60
Four pieces of whiting and five chicken wings, served with fries.
Fried Chicken And Shrimp Combo $25.20
Get 4 buttery crispy Whiting fillet and 3 golden crispy pieces of chicken (legs and thighs). Served with our hand cut natural fries.
Salmon Nugget Combo $27.60
Delicious 8 oz Salmon cut into bite size nuggets served with 5 extra large shrimp, resting on a bed of golden hand cut fries.
Fried Lobster Combo $31.20
Fried 6oz Lobster tail and 5 extra large shrimp served on a bed of natural cut fries.

All Day - Crabs
Crab Cakes $21.60
Delicious real lump and jumbo lump crab meat, lightly breaded with Cajun herbs and spices. This is not like any other, this has more crab meat than cake. Two cakes per order. Please be careful, while we try to remove all the shells, small fragments may remain. Price may fluctuate based on market price.

All Day - Baked Foods
Baked Lobster Combo $36.60
Get our 6oz Lobster Tail with 5 Extra large shrimp paired with our seasoned yellow rice and sautéed broccoli and garlic. Moist buttery and delish.
Baked Lobster Tail $31.60
Get our 6oz Lobster Tail paired with our seasoned yellow rice and sautéed broccoli and garlic. Moist buttery and delish.
Cornbread $3.60
Baked cornbread that typically includes cornmeal and flour, offering a moist and slightly sweet flavor.
Baked Salmon $24.00
Get our delicious 8 oz Salmon paired with our seasoned yellow rice and sautéed broccoli and garlic. Have it with our original seasoning or your choice of sauce.
Baked Salmon Combo $30.00
Get our delicious 8 oz Salmon with 5 extra large shrimp, paired with our seasoned yellow rice and sautéed broccoli & garlic. Have it with our original seasoning or your choice of sauce.
Baked Red Snapper $36.00
Get our delicious whole Red Snapper, paired with our seasoned yellow rice and sautéed broccoli & garlic. Have it with our original seasoning or your choice of sauce.
Baked Red Snapper Combo $44.40
This meal you can eat on for days! Its a whole Red Snapper with 5 extra large shrimp, paired with our seasoned yellow rice and sautéed broccoli & garlic. Have it with our original seasoning or your choice of sauce.
Grilled Shrimp $20.40
Get our deliciously grilled extra large shrimp, 7 pieces paired with our seasoned yellow rice and sautéed broccoli & garlic. Have it with our original seasoning or your choice of sauce.

All Day - Fun Foods
Crab Cakes $21.60
Delicious real lump and jumbo lump crab meat, lightly breaded with Cajun herbs and spices. This is not like any other, this has more crab meat than cake. Two cakes per order. Please be careful, while we try to remove all the shells, small fragments may remain. Price may fluctuate based on market price.
Fried Clam Strips $9.60
Crispy pieces of fried clam, golden and delicious.
Cajun Fries $7.20
Our own hand-cut natural fries with Cajun seasoning and spices.

All Day - Side Items
Mac And Cheese $7.50
Creamy, classic macaroni in a rich, velvety cheese sauce.
Yellow Rice $6.00
Aromatic Saffron-Infused Rice with a Dash of Turmeric for Color and Health.
Dipping Sauces $0.90
Selection of dipping sauces including tartar, sweet Thai chili, ketchup, and NY Mambo sauce.
Dressing $0.90
A blend of finely chopped seafood and seasonings, typically served as an accompaniment to main dishes.
Cajun Fries $6.60
Our own hand-cut natural fries with Cajun seasoning and spices.
Bread $0.90
Two slices of whole wheat bread
French Fries $6.00
Hand cut natural fries
Sautéed Broccoli And Garlic $6.00
Our Sautéed Broccoli is flavorful, not over cooked with a slight crunch and a bright green burst of color. We add fresh cut garlic to the mix and the aroma is heavenly!
Sweet Potato Fries $7.80
Crispy sweet potato fries seasoned with a light sprinkle of salt.
Collard Greens $6.00
Savory delicious collard greens cooked with smoked turkey meat.
Yams $6.00
Deliciously baked candied yams.

All Day - Desserts
Lloyds Carrot Cake (Plain) $9.36
Moist carrot cake topped with a smooth layer of cream cheese frosting.
Lloyds Pineapple Coconut Cake $10.26
Moist cake layered with pineapple and coconut, topped with creamy frosting.
Lemon Pound Cake With Lemon Icing $5.76
Dense, moist lemon pound cake drizzled with a sweet lemon icing, embodying a refreshing citrus flavor throughout.
Chocolate Pound Cake With Chocolate Icing $5.76
Dense and rich chocolate pound cake, covered with smooth chocolate icing.

All Day - Beverages
Half And Half $5.40
A refreshing blend of iced tea and lemonade, offering a balanced mix of sweet and tart flavors.
Fruit Punch $5.40
A refreshing blend of juicy fruits, perfectly sweetened for a thirst-quenching treat.
Homemade Ice Tea $5.40
Refreshing homemade iced tea, perfect for a sunny day.
Lemonade $5.40
Refreshing citrus beverage.
Bottle Water $2.40
Pure and refreshing bottled water.
Can Soda $3.00
Selection of canned sodas including Sprite, Cola, and Diet Coke, alongside fruity options like Orange Sunkist and Grape Sunkist. Also, Dr. Brown's Black Cherry, Original Seltzer, Ginger Ale, and Strawberry Welch's.
Wild Berry Pomegranate $5.40
A vibrant blend of wild berries and pomegranate juice.
Pink Lemonade $5.40
Pink lemonade typically includes fresh lemon juice and cane sugar, blended with natural strawberry flavor for a refreshing beverage.

All Day - Fresh Pressed Juices
Snap $14.40
apples, lemon, ginger- no sugar or sweetener added Step into a world where zest meets zing with 'Snap,' our invigorating 12 oz fresh raw juice. Crafted from the crispest apples, the fieriest ginger, and the most vibrant lemons, Snap offers an anticipated dance of flavors that awaken your senses and brighten your day. But here’s where the unexpected comes into play: Snap is not just a juice; it's a bold statement of wellness and flavor. Beyond its refreshing taste, this unique blend harnesses the natural power of its ingredients to offer a revitalizing boost that supports digestion, energizes your body, and sharpens your mind. Each bottle is a crafted experience, promising more than just nourishment—it's a rejuvenating elixir that surprises with every sip. Dare to take a gulp of Snap and invigorate your routine with a burst of flavor and wellness that truly stands out.

Sunday - Brunch Entrees
Cinnamon Strudel Chicken & Waffles $18.00
Soft warm cinnamon Waffle with walnuts, strudel crumble, and coffee cream, topped with crispy fried chicken.
Red Velvet Chicken & Waffles $18.00
Red Velvet Waffle with walnuts and coated with cream cheese sauce, topped with crispy fried chicken.
Shrimp And Grits $18.00
Toasted Grits with seven grilled shrimp.
Catfish And Grits $18.00
Toasted Grits with perfectly fried catfish.
Cheeseburger And Fries $15.00
Cheeseburger on a toasted bun with crispy natural cut french fries.
Fish And Chicken Basket $15.00
Three fried whiting and three fried chicken with natural cut french fries
Fried Shrimp Basket $15.00
Extra large shrimp fried to perfection served with french fries.
Fried Whiting Basket $13.00
Four to five pieces of whiting fried to perfection served with french fries
Fried Lobster Tail Basket $21.00
Lobster tail fried to perfection served with french fries.
Fried Salmon Nuggets Basket $18.00
Salmon filet cut into nuggets and fired to perfection served with french fries.
Fried Catfish Basket $17.00
Catfish filet cut and fired to perfection served with french fries.
Fried Chicken Basket $15.00
Fried chicken (three legs or thighs) served with fries.
Fried Red Snapper Basket $25.00
Whole Red Snapper fried to perfection served with french fries.

Sunday - Brunch Sides
Eggs $4.25
Two eggs cooked to perfection.
Bacon $4.25
Crispy thick-cut, smoked to perfection.
Sausage $4.25
Savory, perfectly seasoned sausage links, a classic breakfast favorite.
Cajun Fries $5.00
Our own hand cut natural fries with cajun seasoning and spices.
French Fries $5.00
Fresh natural cut fries
Waffle $8.00
Golden brown waffle, typically includes warm maple syrup.

Brother's Seafood Details

From the business
Identifies as Black-owned
Identifies as veteran-owned
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Offerings
Comfort food
Quick bite
Small plates

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner

Atmosphere
Casual

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards

Brother's Seafood Photos

Brother's Seafood Location

Brother's Seafood

New York Westchester County New Rochelle North Avenue

407 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA

Brother's Seafood Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 64 user reviews.

seasonedsalmonpricefried fishcollard greensmac and cheesecornbreadcajun friessweet potatoes friesmamba

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

HOLY HEAVEN! My boyfriend and I were craving seafood, and this place delivered. We ordered the fish boat, and it was absolutely incredible—flavorful, perfectly cooked, and generous in portion size. My boyfriend got his with sweet potato fries, and they were seriously delicious. Everything tasted fresh and well-seasoned, and it was totally worth the price. On top of that, the customer service was amazing—friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend... your belly will thank you!
April 14 · Evelyn luciano
Ordered the shrimp and crawfish combo, ate everything down to the shrimp tails. Unbelievably fresh stuff and extremely delicious with great seasoning. The owner was very nice and I'll be back for more this week.
May 25 · Raphael Bartolome
Finally a place in Westchester that makes fresh fried seafood. I drove past this place twice, but it’s actually very convenient. Street parking is right outside so it’s easy to find. I ordered the whiting and shrimp fried combo with Cajun fries and a fried shrimp meal with regular fries. It was freshly prepared and delicious. The food is flavorful even the tartar sauce is fresh. Next time I want to try the fish or shrimp and grits, I will now be a regular!
January 11 · Nadia Clarke
Fried to perfection!!! My family and I visited the area from MN and stopped in for a quick bite. Finger licking is the best way to describe the food. Sweet potatoes fries were on point. Fried shrimp to die for and the fried chicken was just right!!!!! And to top it off??!? Service with a smile!!! For those of you in the area, you’re lucky to have such an establishment in your backyard.
March 13 · Tanya & Ronnie King
It's tough to find a good Friday night fish fry in NewRo, so I'm glad I found Brother's! The whiting was perfectly fried, and I recommend trying the house mamba sauce for a deliciously sweet element.The even bigger superstar? The yams - WOW! Home-cooked to perfection.Excellent service to top it off. I will definitely be back!
April 04 · Matt Kelly