Crotty's Cheesesteaks: The Best of Philly in New Rochelle, NY

Crotty's Cheesesteaks Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For those in the New York region with a craving for an authentic and high-quality cheesesteak, Crotty's Cheesesteaks in New Rochelle is a destination that delivers. This establishment has earned a strong reputation for its dedication to the craft, using a custom steak blend that rivals some of the most famous spots in Philadelphia. The owners, who identify as women-owned, have cultivated a welcoming and modern atmosphere that is both casual and trendy. The space is clean, bright, and well-organized, with a fun "dripping cheese" theme that ties it all together. Crotty's is not just a fast-food joint; it's a place that prides itself on using homemade ingredients, from their chicken cutlets to their rich cheese sauce, which is a significant step up from typical fast-food fare.

The menu is a celebration of all things cheesy and comforting, centered around a wide variety of cheesesteak sandwiches. Beyond the classic "Traditional" with Whiz and caramelized onions, the offerings include imaginative creations like "The Irishman," with brown gravy and mushrooms, and "The Mac & Cheese," which brings two comfort food favorites together in one sandwich. Crotty's also caters to a diverse clientele with excellent vegetarian and vegan options, including a highly praised vegan cheesesteak made with Beyond meat and vegan cheese. The menu extends well beyond sandwiches, featuring a whole section dedicated to various mac and cheese bowls, as well as sides like Philly Cheese Steak Eggrolls and homemade cheesecake bites. This combination of classic flavors and creative, high-quality dishes makes Crotty's Cheesesteaks a standout spot for lunch, dinner, and late-night eats.

---

Location and Accessibility

Crotty's Cheesesteaks is conveniently located at 8 Eastchester Rd in New Rochelle, NY 10801. This location places it in the heart of a vibrant community, making it a popular spot for locals and students from nearby Iona College. Being situated on a main road means the restaurant is easy to find and access. While there is no dedicated private parking lot, customers can utilize the free street parking available in the vicinity, which is a common feature in this bustling area. The accessibility of the location is a significant plus, making it easy to pop in for a quick bite or to pick up a large order. For those who prefer to dine in, the restaurant offers comfortable seating in a casual and quiet setting.

The restaurant is also committed to providing an accessible experience for all. It features a wheelchair-accessible entrance and a wheelchair-accessible parking lot, ensuring that people with mobility needs can visit the establishment without difficulty. For customers who prefer not to dine in, Crotty's offers a range of service options, including outdoor seating for nice days, no-contact delivery, standard delivery, and takeout. This variety of choices ensures that everyone can enjoy their food in the way that is most convenient for them. The flexibility of its services and its central, accessible location make Crotty's Cheesesteaks a top choice for fast, delicious food in New Rochelle.

---

Services Offered

Dine-in and Outdoor Seating: Crotty's provides a clean and comfortable indoor dining space, as well as outdoor seating for guests to enjoy their meal on-site.
Takeout and Delivery: The restaurant excels in fast service for both takeout and no-contact delivery, making it a perfect option for a quick bite or for ordering in.
Catering: Crotty's offers extensive catering services, with options like "The Party Pack" and "The Crotty Hot Box" for gatherings. They also provide large trays of various menu items like mac and cheese, salads, and more.
Kid-Friendly Options: With a dedicated kids' menu that includes homemade chicken fingers and grilled cheese sliders, Crotty's is a great choice for families.
Late-Night Food: The restaurant serves a full menu for both lunch and dinner, and is a popular spot for late-night cravings.
Vegetarian and Vegan Options: They provide a variety of offerings for those who do not eat meat, including a highly-rated vegan cheesesteak and several vegetarian-friendly mac & cheese bowls.

---

Features / Highlights

Authentic Cheesesteak Quality: Crotty's is praised for its high-quality ingredients, particularly its custom steak blend and soft, fresh bread that holds up well to the contents of the sandwich.
Diverse and Creative Menu: The menu goes far beyond a simple cheesesteak, with a range of "Extreme Cheesesteaks" and a full Mac & Cheese menu that includes unique creations like the Chili Mac & Cheese and Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese.
Homemade Ingredients: Customers note the use of fresh, homemade ingredients, from the chicken cutlets used in the chicken fingers to the three-cheese blend used in their mac and cheese.
Fast and Friendly Service: The staff is consistently described as friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu, and the service is known for being quick, with little wait time.
Welcoming Atmosphere: The interior is casual and trendy, making it a great spot for college students and groups, while also being tidy and family-friendly.
Accommodating to All: The restaurant identifies as women-owned and offers vegetarian, vegan, and kids' menu options, showing a commitment to serving a wide demographic.

---

Contact Information

Address: 8 Eastchester Rd, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA
Phone: (914) 636-7000

---

What is worth choosing

For residents of New Rochelle and the wider New York region, Crotty's Cheesesteaks is an exceptional choice for a delicious and satisfying meal. What truly sets this place apart is its unwavering commitment to quality. Unlike many fast-food spots that cut corners, Crotty's uses fresh, homemade ingredients that elevate every dish. Their custom steak blend is a major highlight, consistently receiving praise for its flavor and texture. This attention to detail means you’re not just getting a sandwich; you’re getting a thoughtfully crafted meal that’s a step above the rest. The positive customer reviews, which highlight the delicious food, great service, and clean environment, are a testament to their high standards.

Another strong reason to choose Crotty's is the sheer variety on their menu. The cheesesteak options alone are extensive, ranging from traditional to creatively "extreme" combinations. Furthermore, the inclusion of a comprehensive mac and cheese menu and delicious sides like fried pickles and homemade cheesecake bites means there is something to satisfy every craving. Their vegan cheesesteak is a standout, and a must-try for both vegans and non-vegans alike, praised for its flavor and quality. The convenience of their service options—including dine-in, takeout, and delivery—coupled with a friendly and efficient staff, makes the entire experience seamless. Crotty's Cheesesteaks is more than just a place to get a quick bite; it's a local gem that offers a taste of authentic Philly with a creative New York twist, making it a worthy choice for any occasion.

Crotty's Cheesesteaks Food & drink

Sides
Disco Fries $11.88
Crispy fries, brown gravy, caramelized onions & whiz
Small Side Of Mac & Cheese $6.19
Crotty's uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with shaved Parmesan
Philly Cheese Steak Eggroll $12.44
Two Philly cheese steak eggrolls served with a side cheese sauce
Fries $8.75
Large order of crispy & fresh fries!
Chicken Fingers $12.44
Fried crispy golden-brown & served with buffalo sauce and Honey Mustard
Mozzarella Sticks $11.19
Crispy mozzarella sticks served with a side of warm marinara
Tater Tots $8.75
Bite sized shredded golden potato balls
Fried Pickles $12.44
We love the salty pickle taste with the crunchy breadcrumb coating! Served with a side of ranch dressing
Onion Rings $8.75
Perfectly seasoned large order of onion rings. Comes with crotty's signature creamy onion vinaigrette
Large Side Of Mac & Cheese $15.00
Crotty's uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with shaved Parmesan

Kids
Kids Homemade Chicken Fingers & Scoop Of French Fries $10.62
With a scoop of french fries
Traditional Cheesesteak Slider (No Onions) & Scoop Of French Fries $10.62
Upside Down Grilled Cheese & Scoop Of French Fries $10.62
With a scoop of french fries

Salads
Signature Salad $13.69
Mixed greens, tomatoes, dried cranberries, & sunflower seeds topped with Gorgonzola cheese
Crotty's House Salad $12.44
Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, and cucumber
Caesar Salad $12.44
Chopped romaine hearts, shaved Parmesan, and freshly toasted croutons topped with our homemade savory Caesar dressing

The Party Specials
The Party Pack $275.00
6 Traditional Cheesesteaks, 6 Paulie Cheesesteaks, Half Tray Of French Fries, Half Tray Of Cesar Salad, a 2 liter of Pepsi and Diet Pepsi!

Best Mac N Cheese Shop
Chili Mac & Cheese $18.75
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Homemade Cheese Sauce and Loaded up with our Homemade meat Chili
Parmesan & Garlic Mac & Cheese $13.56
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Sauce which is blended with Garlic and Parmesan Cheese
Bacon Lovers Mac & Cheese $15.62
Elbow Pasta smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with Crispy Bacon
Cheesesteak Mac & Cheese $17.06
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce with Black Angus Beef, Caramelized Onions and Whiz
Classic Mac & Cheese $13.12
Elbow Pasta smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce (3 different cheeses!) and topped with Shaved Parmesan Cheese
Chicken Teriyaki Mac & Cheese $14.44
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with our tangy Teriyaki Chicken
Pesto Mac & Cheese $14.00
Elbow Pasta in a Creamy Pesto & Cheese Sauce
Cajun Mac & Cheese $13.56
Elbow Pasta smothered in our Spicy & Cheesy Sauce
Fresh Veggie Mac & Cheese $16.25
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Homemade Cheese Sauce and Piled High with our Chef’s selection of Fresh Veggies
Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese $16.62
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Buffalo Cheese Sauce Garnished with Blue Cheese
BBQ Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese $16.62
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with our Slow Cooked BBQ Pulled Pork

Baked Potato
Crispy Stuffed Baked Potato $13.69
(Not available during summer months). Our hearty stuffed baked potatoes are made by deep-frying the shell and then stuffing the inside with our butter cream mashed potatoes. Delicious on its own or stuffed with your choice of additions. Always served with

Cheesesteak Sandwiches
The French Dip $19.94
Side of warm au jus for dipping provolone cheese and caramelized onions
The Vegan Cheesesteaks $19.94
Beyond meat, vegan cheese, and caramelized onions
The Rocky Cheesesteak $19.94
Mozzarella cheese, caramelized onions, homemade marinara sauce, cheese, and basil topped with shaved Parmesan cheese
The Steakhouse Cheesesteak $19.94
Gorgonzola, caramelized onions, cheese, & side of warm au jus for dipping
The Sicilian $19.94
Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, broccoli rabe, Italian hot peppers, and grilled tomatoes
Caesar Wrap Cheesesteak $19.94
Served on a bed of fresh romaine, caramelized onions, and imported shredded Parmesan cheese topped with Crotty's creamy Caesar dressing
The Custom Cheesesteak $16.88
The Irishman $19.94
Cheddar cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, mushrooms, and brown gravy
The New Yorker $19.94
Caramelized onions, grilled tomatoes, and Cheddar cheese
The Traditional $18.69
Whiz and Caramelized onion
The Club $19.94
American cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo
The BBQ Pit $18.69
Caramelized onions, signature BBQ sauce, and your choice of cheese
The Paulie $19.94
Provolone cheese and caramelized onions with the perfect amount of grilled bell peppers and jalapeños finely chopped

Dessert
Homemade Cheesecake Bites $11.88
Deep-fried, battered cheesecake balls, covered in powdered sugar, topped with chocolate & caramel syrup
Crotty's Signature Egg Cream $6.88
Delicious chocolate beverages made the old-school way!
Milkshakes $12.44
These Extra Large 32oz Milkshakes are Decadent, Creamy, Homemade & Customizable. Your Choice of either Vanilla or Chocolate Ice Cream. Mix-ins include Oreo, Heath Bar or Chips ahoy . Finished off with Whip Cream on top.

Beverages
Sport Top Poland Spring Water $2.81
Canned Beverage $2.19
Bottle Soda $3.44
Bottles are - pepsi, diet pepsi, canada dry seltzer water, poland spring water, ginger ale, snapple lemon iced tea, snapple mango madness, snapple apple, snapple kiwi strawberry & orange soda, sprite & gatorade
2 Liter Soda $5.62

Breakfast Sandwich All Day
Bacon Egg Cheese $8.75
Bacon Egg and American Cheese on a Brioche Roll or Toasted Hoagie. Add Saucy Rascal Hot Sauce at your request.
Steak Egg Cheese $11.25
Steak Egg and American Cheese on a Brioche roll or toasted Hoagie. Add Saucy Rascal Hot sauce at your request.

Summer Light Bites $15 Combo's
Half Traditional Combo $18.75
Half Traditional on a Toasted Garlic Hoagie with Caramelized onions, Whiz. Servied with choice of Fries or House Salad, and a Canned Beverage or Water
Half Paulie Combo $18.75
Half Paulie Cheesesteak 5-6 inch on Toasted Garlic Hoagie with Caramelized Onions, Finely chopped Bell and Jalapeño Peppers, Provolone cheese. Served with a choice of Fries or House Salad and a canned Beverage or Water
Crispy Chicken Sandwich Combo $18.75
Homemade Crispy Chicken Patty on a Soft Brioche Bun, With melted Paper jack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, and Crotty's Special Sauce. Served with a choice of Fries or House Salad and a canned Beverage or Water
Pulled Pork Sandwich Combo $18.75
Our BBQ Pulled Pork, with Coleslaw, on a Soft Brioche Bun. Served with a choice of Fries or House Salad and a canned Beverage or Water

Specials
Pint-Sized Vegan's Sweet & Spicy Italian Cheesesteak! $19.94
Beyond meat, vegan cheese caramelized onions, fries, hot Italian peppers, mushrooms & sweet teriyaki sauce on a hoagie
The RX Superstarwich $22.44
Steak and Chicken Mixed, Provolone cheese, Whiz, caramelized onions, bell peppers, bacon, onion rings, fried pickles, ketchup and buffalo sauce
The Iona Gael Cheesesteak $19.94
American cheese, caramelized onions, choice of protein, bacon, eggs, french fries, and ketchup

Burgers
Double CYO Burger $11.88
Create your own burger just the way you like!
Mushroom Swiss Burger Single Patty $13.12
A Single Philly Patty, with Melted Swiss and Grilled Mushrooms
Chili Cheese Burger Single Patty $14.38
Single Steak Patty, American Cheese, with Our Homemade Chili
Single CYO Burger $9.38
Create your own burger just the way you like!

New Philly's
The Chizeee $21.19
Choice of Protein, Caramelized onions, Whiz, Cheddar, and Provalone Cheese
The Chopped Chicken Parm Philly $21.19
Chopped Homemade Panko and Italian Seasoned Breaded Cutlets, Chopped Mozzarella Sticks, Smothered in our Homemade Marinara, with Caramelized Onions, Bell Peppers and Melted Mozzarella and Parmesan Cheese
The Crotty Hottie $21.19
Your Choice of Protein, Caramelized Onions, Chopped Fresh Jalapeños and Pickled Jalapeños, Hot Italian Pepper Relish, Pepper-jack Cheese and Warm Buffalo Sauce
The Glizzy Chili Philly $21.19
Boiled Sabrett Hot Dogs, Diced and Grilled with Caramelized Onions, Homemade Chili, Cheddar Cheese, and Warm Ketchup

Extreme Cheesesteak Sandwiches (Shorties)
The Philly Hangover (Shortie) $18.12
American cheese, caramelized onions, bell peppers, two fried eggs, crispy bacon and tator tots
The Wild Buffalo (Shortie) $18.12
Blue cheese, caramelized onions, spicy buffalo sauce, jalapeño peppers, onion rings and coleslaw
The Chili Philly Cheesesteak (Shortie) $18.12
American cheese, caramelized onions, and our homemade chili
The Mac & Cheese (Shortie) $18.12
Whiz, caramelized onions, mac & cheese, and crispy bacon
The Alpha Wolf (Shortie) $18.12
Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, onion rings, jalapeño peppers, served with a side of of crotty's signature creamy onion vinaigrette

Cheesesteak Sandwiches (Shorties)
The Irishman (Shortie) $16.88
Mozzarella cheese, caramelized onions, homemade marinara sauce, cheese, and basil topped with shaved Parmesan cheese
The BBQ Pit (Shortie) $16.88
Caramelized onions, signature BBQ sauce, and your choice of cheese
The Custom Cheesesteak (Shortie) $14.38
Build your own just the way you like it
The Frenchdip (Shortie) $16.88
6 Inch Hoagie, Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, with a warm side of au jus for dipping
The Rocky Cheesesteak (Shortie) $16.88
6-inch Hoagie, Mozzarella cheese, caramelized onions, homemade marinara sauce, cheese, and basil topped with shaved Parmesan cheese
The New Yorker (Shortie) $16.88
Caramelized onions, grilled tomatoes, and Cheddar cheese
The Club (Shortie) $16.88
Beyond meat, vegan cheese, and caramelized onions
The Paulie (Shortie) $16.88
6-Inch Hoagie, Provolone cheese and caramelized onions with the perfect amount of grilled bell peppers and jalapeños finely chopped
The Vegan Cheesesteaks (Shortie) $16.88
Beyond meat, vegan cheese, and caramelized onions
The Sicilian (Shortie) $16.88
Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, broccoli rabe, Italian hot peppers, and grilled tomatoes
The Steakhouse (Shortie) $16.88
Gorgonzola cheese, caramelized onions, & and side of warm au jus for dipping
The Traditional (Shortie) $15.62
6-Inch Hoagie, Caramelized onions and Cheese whiz
Caesar Wrap Cheesesteak (Shortie) $16.88
Served on a bed of fresh romaine, caramelized onions, and imported shredded Parmesan cheese topped with Crotty's creamy Caesar dressing

Extreme Cheesesteak Sandwiches
The Alpha Wolf $21.19
Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, onion rings, jalapeño peppers, served with a side of of crotty's signature creamy onion vinaigrette
The Philly Hangover $21.19
American cheese, caramelized onions, bell peppers, two fried eggs, crispy bacon and tator tots
The Wild Buffalo $21.19
Blue cheese, caramelized onions, spicy buffalo sauce, jalapeño peppers, onion rings and coleslaw
The Mac & Cheese $21.19
Whiz, caramelized onions, mac & cheese, and crispy bacon
The Chili Philly Cheesesteak $21.19
American cheese, caramelized onions, and our homemade chili

Crotty's Cheesesteaks Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Outdoor seating
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Vegetarian options

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy

Crowd
College students
Family-friendly

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
Kids' menu

Parking
Free street parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Crotty's Cheesesteaks Photos

Crotty's Cheesesteaks Location

Crotty's Cheesesteaks

New York Westchester County New Rochelle Eastchester Road

8 Eastchester Rd, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA

Crotty's Cheesesteaks Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 255 user reviews.

mac and cheesepricescheesecakecheese whizstuffedbaked potatoseasonedvegancaramelized onionsreview

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Their Vegan Cheesesteak was delicious and highly recommend to vegans or anyone who wants to try vegan food. It is a little bit pricey but very worth the price in my opinion. And great service!:> little wait time.
August 05 · Julie
Thoroughly enjoyed this spot.We finally came in after following for years on social media when I believe the owners would be delivering food to locals throughout Westchester during the pandemic.So let’s get down to it, my family and I came in right around 4 o’clock on a Saturday afternoon. We know it’s a college spot so we didn’t want to risk going during a lunch or dinner rush.When we walked in we were the only ones there and were quickly greeted by a young gentleman and a woman in the kitchen area.Our order:1 order of chicken fingers & fries1 mac & cheesesteak bowl.1 traditional sandwich (shortie size)and 1 Chopped Chicken Parm Philly (New Item)I had originally asked for the Rocky Cheesesteak but since it had mozzarella and marinara sauce the young man took notice and recommended their new Chicken Parm Philly. As a chicken parm fan, I couldn’t say “no”Our order was in and I took some pictures of the shop. It’s clean, bright, tidy and printed menus are available along with a poster board on the left side wall with their full menu.I’ve seen interior picture of the location from before and it looks like the new color scheme and dripping cheese theme were put up recently. I think it ties in together very well.While we waited for our food to go, the gentleman told us that this week the shop was beginning to use its own custom steak blend so he was “excited for us to try it in the traditional sandwich and in the Mac & cheesesteak bowl.”So how is the food?We don’t know what the steak blend tasted like before.. but as of right now, this blend is delicious. It works very well.The traditional sandwich. Served on soft bread yet, it holds up very well to the steak with an adequate amount of whiz. The steak blend has a good amount of fat throughout. But don’t be discouraged, it doesn’t make the sandwich greasy at all. The mix in this sandwich is very well made.The chicken fingers are on point. They’re taken from their homemade chicken cutlets made to size and the textured fries are perfect for the little ones that may not be in the mood for a sandwich. Some other spots would cut corners and warm up frozen chicken fingers for little ones.. but Crotty’s makes their chicken fingers from their own cutlets. That’s a plus!The Mac & Cheesesteak Bowl. I didn’t see this on their available menu in the shop, but it came up as if I were going to do an order online. I’m glad I asked if it was available. Crotty’s isn’t using the “boxed stuff”. They have a three cheese blend plus their homemade cheese sauce mixed with their elbow pasta then topped with their steak blend. This dish is delicious! Can’t wait to try the other Mac & cheese bowls. There’s a chicken teriyaki bowl and a pesto bowl to name a few others.The Chopped Chicken Parm Philly. I’m a sucker for chicken parm but only if it’s done right and Crotty’s has done it right. The homemade cutlets, along with their homemade marinara sauce are mixed so well with caramelized onions and bell peppers. They then tuck all of it into the soft bread. You think it wont hold up, but there’s enough sauce to cover all the goods but it doesn’t make the bread soggy.OVERALL:Definitely want to come back with the family and try other items.Service was greatThe Shop was niceThe Food was greatCrotty’s, you guys have a great system in place and your location is outstanding. Keep up the great work, can’t wait to have some more.
February 22 · Richie Quiñones
Today I was driving by and saw this cheesesteak spot and asked my boy Frank who works close by how are their philly cheesesteak and he approved. Fast forward i ordered the BBQ Pit cheesesteak and man when I tell you it was a hit. I also met the owner who was super cool and extremely proud of his food menu. Food was extremely tasty and felt like I was in Philly eating one. I will definitely be going back to try other things on the menu.
May 30 · RV Lauren
Crottys Cheese steaks is an oasis for foodies, centered in New Rochelle. Vegan options and great gourmet sandwiches. Had an Irishman sandwich on Friday. Delicious real steak and mushroom gravy topped with bacon!! Yummy. If you are a commuters or resident of New Rochelle this is a hidden treasure on Eastchester Road and North Avenue!
March 23 · Edward Smith
Crotty’s Cheesesteaks catered our company event and absolutely crushed it! The food was incredible—cheesesteaks, burgers, hot dogs, chicken skewers, potato salad, mac and cheese, and Caesar salad—everything was fresh, flavorful, and a huge hit with the crowd. The service was smooth and professional from start to finish. We couldn’t have asked for a better setup. Highly recommend for any event!
July 19 · Chris Farina