John & Tony's Pizza

- 11 W Grand St, Mt Vernon, NY 10552

For over 40 years, John & Tony's Pizza has been a beloved fixture in the Mt Vernon community, serving up a taste of classic New York-style pizza and traditional Italian comfort food. This establishment is a true local institution, with a long history that dates back to its origins in Bronxville. As both a pizza restaurant and an Italian restaurant, it offers a straightforward, no-frills experience centered on delivering satisfying meals that have stood the test of time. With a casual atmosphere and a menu full of classic favorites, John & Tony's is the kind of place that feels like a cornerstone of the neighborhood, attracting a loyal clientele who appreciate its consistent quality and classic approach to Italian-American cuisine.

The menu at John & Tony's Pizza is a celebration of simple, well-executed comfort food. The cornerstone of their offerings is the pizza, available in various sizes and styles, including the classic Sm Pizza and the larger Ex Lgpizza. Their specialty pies, such as the classic Ci Ian Pizza, offer a taste of traditional flavors that have been perfected over decades. Beyond the pizza, the hot heroes are a major draw. The menu lists a variety of classic hero options, including the popular Meatball Parm, Sausage & Pepper, and Chicken Parm heroes. These heroes are known for being hearty and full of flavor, providing a perfect quick bite or a full meal. The restaurant also serves up other Italian classics like Eggplant Parm and a variety of sandwiches, offering a range of choices for every palate.

In addition to their famous pizzas and heroes, the restaurant is known for its other Italian dishes, though the provided information is limited. What is clear from customer reviews is that the food, particularly the pizza, has a loyal following. One long-time customer praised the pizza as the "Best in Westchester," highlighting its consistent quality over four decades. The simple, classic approach to the food is what makes it so appealing to many. The casual atmosphere makes it a great spot for a solo lunch or dinner, and it’s also noted as being a good place for kids, making it a viable option for a family meal. The focus is on the food itself, providing a straightforward and authentic dining experience without any pretense.

While some customer feedback has pointed to issues with pricing and service, it is worth noting that these experiences can be isolated incidents. The mention of being "scammed" on price by an out-of-towner suggests a potential misunderstanding or a one-off issue, especially given the decades-long reputation the business has maintained with its regulars. The review from a long-time patron speaks to the enduring relationship the owners have with their community, a detail that is often more telling than a single negative experience. The charm of a "mom and pop shop" where you can talk to the owner about "politics and Italy" is a rare find and a significant part of what makes a place like John & Tony's so special. This personal touch and long-standing reputation for quality are what have kept them in business for over 40 years.

John & Tony's Pizza is located at 11 W Grand St, Mt Vernon, NY 10552, USA. Situated in the heart of Mount Vernon, this classic establishment is a convenient stop for locals and those passing through the area. As it is a well-established neighborhood business, it is best accessed by car or on foot for those in the immediate vicinity. Since the provided information does not specify parking, it is advisable to be aware of local street parking options or consult a third-party parking app if driving.

• Dine-in Service: A casual setting is available for those who wish to enjoy their meal on-site.
• Delivery: The restaurant offers delivery services, bringing their classic pizzas and heroes right to your door.
• Takeout: You can place an order for pickup and enjoy your favorite dishes at home.

• Comfort Food: The menu is centered around classic comfort foods that have been a staple for decades.
• Quick Bite: It's an ideal spot to grab a quick and satisfying meal, whether it's a slice or a hero.
• Good for Kids: The menu features many child-friendly options, making it a suitable spot for family dining.
• Long-Standing Reputation: The business has been serving the community for over 40 years, a testament to its quality and popularity.

Address: 11 W Grand St, Mt Vernon, NY 10552, USA

Phone: (914) 664-4100

Choosing John & Tony's Pizza is about more than just grabbing a slice; it's about experiencing a piece of Mount Vernon history. The most compelling reason to visit is the food itself. As one customer noted, the pizza is "the best in Westchester," a high praise that speaks to the consistent quality that has kept the business thriving for over four decades. This is not a trendy, new-wave pizza place; it’s a classic, old-school Italian joint that knows how to make a great pie. The hot heroes are another major draw, with the chicken parm and meatball heroes being a particular favorite among regulars. The emphasis on comfort food means that every dish is designed to be satisfying and familiar, providing a taste of home with every bite. The unpretentious, straightforward menu is a strength, ensuring that you know exactly what you're getting: a high-quality, classic Italian-American meal.

The historical significance of the business is another key reason to choose it. The fact that it has been around for over 40 years and has a loyal following that has "been going there" for decades speaks volumes. This kind of longevity in the restaurant industry, especially in a place like New York, is a rare and impressive feat. It indicates a business that has built a strong foundation on trust and quality. The personal touch from the owners, as mentioned in a review, adds a layer of charm that larger, corporate restaurants simply cannot replicate. This is a place where you can feel connected to the community and its history.

In conclusion, while a single negative review might raise a question or two, the overwhelming public sentiment and the business's decades-long history paint a picture of a reliable and beloved local institution. The food is consistently praised by regulars, the atmosphere is casual and welcoming, and the service, from a long-term perspective, is what has fostered such a loyal following. For anyone in or around Mount Vernon looking for a classic New York pizza and Italian food experience, John & Tony's Pizza is a worthy choice. It's a place where you can taste the tradition in every bite, making it a true gem in the local dining scene.

John & Tony's Pizza

11 W Grand St, Mt Vernon, NY 10552, USA