Old Fashioned Pizza Co.

- 202 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701

In the vibrant and diverse culinary landscape of New York, a truly great pizza place can feel like a cherished find. For those in and around Yonkers, there's a spot that's been quietly perfecting its craft, offering a taste of tradition that feels both authentic and refreshingly simple. Welcome to Old Fashioned Pizza Co., a local establishment that has garnered a reputation for its fantastic pies, friendly service, and a commitment to quality that shines through in every bite. Whether you’re a lifelong New Yorker or just passing through, this place offers a comforting and delicious experience that captures the essence of a classic neighborhood pizzeria.

What sets Old Fashioned Pizza Co. apart is its dedication to doing the basics exceptionally well. In a city where pizza styles abound, they stand out by focusing on a crispy, well-cooked crust—a detail that has won over many discerning palates. Their menu, while not extensive, is curated with care, featuring classic and unique options that are all executed to perfection. It's the kind of spot where you can grab a quick slice that hits the spot or enjoy a full pie with family and friends in a relaxed setting. They've become a go-to for many locals, and it's easy to see why. From the moment you place your order to the first delicious bite, the experience is all about simple, high-quality food served with a smile. The name itself, "Old Fashioned," is a promise—a promise of a pizza experience that honors tradition while delivering a product that's undeniably fresh and delicious.

Old Fashioned Pizza Co. is conveniently located at 202 New Main St in Yonkers, NY 10701, making it easily accessible for residents and visitors alike. Situated in a bustling part of the city, the restaurant is a convenient stop whether you’re on your lunch break or looking for a casual dinner spot. The location is well-served by local transportation, and its proximity to major roads ensures a smooth journey for those arriving by car. This prime spot makes it a perfect hub for grabbing a takeout order on your way home or for a spontaneous dine-in meal. The area around the restaurant adds to its appeal, with a lively neighborhood atmosphere that makes a visit feel like a true local New York experience.

The accessibility of Old Fashioned Pizza Co. is a major plus. Whether you’re walking from a nearby office or driving in from another part of town, finding the restaurant is straightforward. Its central location in Yonkers ensures that it's a practical choice for a quick bite without a lengthy detour. This ease of access, combined with its reputation for great food, has helped it become a well-loved fixture in the community.

Old Fashioned Pizza Co. offers a range of services designed to meet the needs of every customer, ensuring you can enjoy their delicious pizza no matter your preference.

• No-contact delivery: For those who prefer to enjoy their meal at home, this service provides a safe and convenient option, ensuring your food arrives hot and fresh without direct contact.
• Delivery: Standard delivery is also available, bringing their fantastic pizza right to your doorstep.
• Takeout: If you're on the go, simply call ahead or place your order in person and pick up your meal to enjoy wherever you like.
• Dine-in: The restaurant offers a casual and welcoming atmosphere for those who want to sit down and enjoy their pizza right out of the oven.

This variety of service options highlights their flexibility and customer-centric approach, ensuring that everyone can find a way to enjoy their food.

Old Fashioned Pizza Co. prides itself on a few key features that make it a standout choice for pizza lovers in Yonkers and beyond.

• Authentic and High-Quality Offerings: The menu is focused on quality, with offerings that are a cut above the rest. They specialize in comfort food and quick bites, making it an ideal choice for any occasion.
• Crispy, Perfectly Cooked Crust: Customer reviews consistently praise the "very crispy crust" that is "cooked well" with "no gumminess," a testament to their mastery of pizza-making.
• Unique and Delicious Gluten-Free Options: The availability of a "fantastic gluten free spinach white pizza" shows their commitment to catering to different dietary needs without compromising on flavor or quality.
• Casual and Welcoming Atmosphere: The restaurant's "casual" atmosphere makes it a relaxing place to dine, perfect for families, friends, or a solo meal.
• Family-Friendly: Recognized as "good for kids," it’s an excellent spot for a family dinner where everyone can feel comfortable.

These features, from the quality of the food to the welcoming environment, all contribute to a dining experience that feels special and satisfying.

For all inquiries, orders, and information, you can contact Old Fashioned Pizza Co. at the following:

Address: 202 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

Phone: (413) 841-1980

What truly makes Old Fashioned Pizza Co. a standout choice is its unwavering commitment to producing a superior product. In a market flooded with options, they distinguish themselves by focusing on the fundamentals: a great crust, fresh toppings, and a perfectly balanced flavor profile. The customer reviews speak volumes, with one user noting the pizza's quality "tasted like Italy," a high compliment indeed. This is the kind of place where the owners and staff genuinely care about what they're serving, and it shows. The fact that a customer found the woman who took their order to be "super nice" is a reflection of the friendly, personal service that makes the experience all the more enjoyable.

Choosing Old Fashioned Pizza Co. means choosing a restaurant that values quality over quantity, flavor over frills, and a personal touch over a generic experience. Whether you’re craving a classic pepperoni, a unique white pizza, or a gluten-free option, you can be confident you’re getting a meal that’s crafted with care. It's a local gem that offers a taste of authenticity and a slice of old-fashioned goodness right in the heart of Yonkers. For anyone in the New York area in search of a truly great pizza, this is a destination well worth the visit.

Old Fashioned Pizza Co.

202 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA