Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood Introduce
Nestled on a bustling street in Yonkers, Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood stands as a true local favorite, celebrated for its authentic and satisfying Caribbean cuisine. This restaurant is a testament to the power of tradition and flavor, offering a menu that feels like a taste of home. From the moment you interact with the staff, you are met with pleasant and friendly service that leaves a lasting positive impression. This commitment to great customer service, combined with a reputation for serving some of the most flavorful and generously portioned dishes in the area, has made Best Choice a go-to spot for those craving genuine Jamaican food.
What sets Best Choice apart is its dedication to both quality and quantity. While some might question the value, loyal customers are quick to defend it, with one reviewer noting that a large order of food "definitely filled me up and I still had leftovers!" This generosity is a hallmark of the restaurant and a major reason why it has cultivated such a devoted following. The food itself is praised for being well-seasoned, authentic, and consistently delicious. Whether you are in the mood for a quick and flavorful bite or a full, hearty meal, Best Choice delivers a satisfying culinary experience every time. The casual atmosphere makes it a great choice for solo dining or a simple, no-fuss meal with a group.
As a popular spot for both lunch and dinner, Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood has become an integral part of the local dining scene. Its focus on comfort food ensures that every dish is a treat, providing a welcome sense of warmth and familiarity. The restaurant’s ability to cater to a wide range of tastes, from those seeking rich and savory dishes to those looking for healthy options, showcases its versatility. This blend of authentic flavors, generous portions, and a friendly, welcoming environment makes it a true hidden gem that is well worth seeking out for any New Yorker with a love for Caribbean food.
---## Location and Accessibility
Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood is located at 96 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA. Situated in a central and bustling part of the city, its location is convenient for both residents and visitors in the area. The restaurant is easily accessible by various modes of transportation, and its position on New Main Street makes it a staple for anyone in the neighborhood. While a parking lot is not specifically mentioned, the urban setting of New Main Street offers nearby options for finding a place to park for a quick pickup or a meal. The restaurant's prominence in a central location makes it a known and reliable spot for delicious food.
---## Services Offered
- Delivery: The restaurant provides a convenient delivery service, ensuring you can enjoy its authentic Jamaican food from the comfort of your own home.
- Takeout: A popular choice for customers, the takeout service is fast and efficient, making it an ideal option for those on a tight schedule or looking for a meal on the go.
- Dine-in: While the atmosphere is casual and the space may be limited, a dine-in option is available for patrons who wish to eat their meal on-site.
- Catering: Best Choice offers catering services, allowing you to bring the flavorful and authentic taste of Caribbean cuisine to your next event or gathering.
## Features / Highlights
- Authentic Caribbean Flavors: The menu is a celebration of traditional Jamaican cooking, offering rich and savory dishes that are known for their authentic taste.
- Generous Portions: A key highlight praised by many customers, the portion sizes are hearty and satisfying, often leaving enough for leftovers.
- Friendly Staff: The employees are known for being pleasant and welcoming, providing great customer service that makes every visit a positive experience.
- Diverse Menu: The restaurant offers a wide range of options, including classic comfort food, quick bites, small plates, and even healthier options.
- Kids' Menu: Best Choice is a family-friendly spot, with a dedicated kids' menu that makes it a great choice for families with children.
- Flexible Payments: The restaurant makes paying easy, accepting all major credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
## Contact Information
Address: 96 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Phone: (914) 294-0770
---## What is Worth Choosing
The menu at Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood is a treasure trove of classic Caribbean dishes, each prepared with the kind of care and flavor that can only come from a family-run establishment. While the entire menu is a delight, some dishes have garnered a special reputation among regulars. The Oxtail, in particular, is a standout, with one customer stating that this is the "only place I get my oxtails from." This high praise is a testament to the dish's tender texture, rich flavor, and the generous portion sizes that make it a truly satisfying meal. The oxtail is often served with sides like rice and peas and steamed cabbage, which perfectly complement its deep, savory taste.
Beyond the oxtails, the menu offers a wide variety of chicken and fish dishes that are equally celebrated. The Stew Chicken, Curry Chicken, and Fried Chicken are all popular choices, known for their tender meat and well-balanced seasonings. For those who love bold flavors, the signature Jerk Chicken is a must-try, offering a smoky, spicy kick that is a staple of Jamaican cuisine. The seafood options are also a highlight, with dishes like the Steam Fish and various seafood platters providing a fresh and delicious alternative. The dedication to preparing these classic dishes with authenticity and a generous hand is what makes Best Choice a reliable and excellent choice for a meal.
The variety of food goes beyond the main dishes. The menu also includes traditional Jamaican breakfast items like Ackee & Saltfish and savory porridges, which are a perfect way to start your day. The sides are just as important as the mains, and Best Choice excels with classic options like fluffy rice and peas, sweet fried plantains, and rich mac and cheese. For a lighter bite or a quick snack, the Jamaican patties are a fan favorite, known for their flavorful fillings and flaky pastry. The inclusion of a kids' menu also makes the restaurant an excellent option for families, ensuring that even the pickiest eaters can find something they love.
In summary, what is worth choosing at Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood is the overall experience of getting authentic, high-quality, and generously portioned food in a friendly and casual setting. The commitment to great customer service, as highlighted by numerous positive reviews, ensures that every interaction is pleasant. The ability to choose between dine-in, delivery, or takeout makes it a convenient option for any occasion. The catering service also allows you to share these delicious flavors with a larger group. This restaurant is a perfect example of a local gem that may not have all the frills, but more than makes up for it with its incredible food and warm, welcoming spirit.
Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood Services
Breakfast Menu
- Ackee & Saltfish
- Okra & Saltfish
- Salt Mackrel
- Kidney
Lunch & Dinner
- Oxtail
- Stew Chicken
- Curry Chicken
- Fried Chicken
Menu
- Porridge
- Steam Fish $15.00
Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood Details
Service options
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Comfort food
- Healthy options
- Quick bite
- Small plates
Dining options
- Lunch
- Catering
- Dessert
- Table service
Atmosphere
- Casual
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Kids' menu
Parking
- Parking
Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood Photos










Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood Location
Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood
96 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood Reviews
oxtailpricesstewjamaican foodcurried chickencabbagerice and peasspicyreceiptwords
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1All my food was hot except for my fish. Could have been warmer. Employees were nice and friendly.
May 30 · James MifflinI’m not sure why everyone is complaining about the amount of food and price. This is what I got for $20 as a large, and it definitely filled me up and I still had leftovers! They are the only place I get my oxtails from, customer service is great, the ladies are always pleasant when I walk in to order or when I call in.
March 01 · Imani VKWas a bit shocked when I read other reviews. This is some really good Jamaican food and that’s coming from someone who was born and raised in Jamaica. The server was very polite and broke down the prices well. It was my first time going in there and I have to say, I will be going again. The food is cooked and spiced nicely. I do understand tho, that some people can’t handle spice. So maybe for stuff like curry chicken/curry goat, have a spicy and a non spicy option. Beside that, the food is good, clean place and nice customer service.
July 07 · Likkle ShanI was able to order a large curry goat with rice and peas and cabbage. It did not take long before my food is ready. I also have the island vibes nectar. Tropical island punch was very good. This food here is amazing. The only thing that kind of sucks is that there’s not really a place to eat but if you want good food on the goal definitely check this place out.
September 06 · Amir SaundersThe way this business is ran is very unprofessional. My colleague and I called about 2 weeks ago to place two orders for lunch while at work. We called to find out the status of our food and the lady who answers the phone stated that her delivery driver was on his way back to the restaurant & he would then head over to our office. Another 45 minutes passed by and we called again and she apologized then stated that she didn't know where the delivery driver was. We then tried to cancel the order because at this point it was over 3 hours waiting for our food, but the lady mentioned she wasn't authorized to do so that she had to speak with the owner to get the authorization. She then called us back to state the owner is going to personally bring the food to us, but at this point we were highly upset and just wanted to cancel, but still tried convincing us not to. The owner then said we can deliver the food and honor a free meal for the next time we order. My colleague and I agreed, but we asked for 2 free meals instead for receiving our food at 4pm when we had ordered about 12:30pm. Fast forward to today we tried calling back to place an order for our 2 free meals plus our other colleagues were going to place an order as well which we intended to pay for. That didn't go as planned because the owner had offered us 2 free meals and stated that as long as they are not both oxtails that it was fine, so today they changed their stories. They now said he never said that, the free meals either had to be curry or stew, which he never said! So moving forward my colleagues and I, which is an office of about 10-15 people, will no longer conduct business with them ever again! We thank Mr Booth for referring us to this place, but at the end of it very disappointing. If you're taking lunch and planning to order from don't waste your time and money! They are not people of word and scum!
February 17 · Yonkers Smile
More Best Restaurants Near Me

102 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

104 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

2 Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

7 Palisade Ave, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

32 S Broadway, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

11A Palisade Ave, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

14 Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

17 N Broadway, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

18 N Broadway, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

2 Hudson St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

24 Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Bites & Banter Posts





