Cinco de Mayo: Authentic Mexican Cuisine & Catering in NYC

Cinco de Mayo Introduce

Cinco de Mayo is more than just a name—it's a destination for authentic Mexican flavors and a celebration of vibrant cuisine, right in the heart of New York City. Located in a bustling part of Manhattan, this restaurant offers a diverse menu that goes beyond standard fare, providing both traditional dishes and healthy, modern interpretations. It’s a place that caters to the city’s fast-paced lifestyle with quick service, while also providing a comfortable and casual setting for a relaxed meal. Cinco de Mayo is known for its wide variety of options, from classic tacos and burritos to unique "Power Plates" and healthy salads, ensuring there's something to satisfy every craving. It's a popular choice for everything from a quick lunch to a full-fledged catering event, positioning itself as a versatile and reliable eatery for New Yorkers.

What sets Cinco de Mayo apart is its commitment to both authentic flavors and dietary versatility. The menu, as extensive as it is, includes not only traditional Mexican dishes but also a range of healthy, organic, and vegan options. This makes it an inclusive spot for a diverse city with varying dietary needs. The fast service is a major highlight, a testament to the restaurant’s efficiency in a high-demand urban environment. Customer reviews often praise the authenticity of the food, with special mentions for their flavorful birria tacos and grilled chicken quesadillas. While the space is described as being a small little booth or walk-up, it is clear from the menu and the variety of services that the focus is on providing high-quality food, whether you're dining in, taking out, or having a large event catered. The friendly and accommodating staff further contribute to the welcoming atmosphere, making it a pleasant experience for solo diners, families, and groups alike.

Cinco de Mayo is conveniently situated at 113 E 31st St, New York, NY 10016, USA. This address places it in a prime, central location in Midtown Manhattan, specifically in a vibrant area known for its diverse dining options and commercial activity. The restaurant is easily accessible via New York City’s extensive public transportation system, with multiple subway lines and bus routes within a short walking distance. For those who are driving, both free and paid street parking options are available, a notable benefit in a crowded neighborhood like this one. The location’s accessibility and the variety of parking options make it a practical choice for both locals working nearby and visitors exploring the city. Its presence on a street with a mix of businesses and residential buildings ensures a steady flow of customers throughout the day for lunch and dinner.

Cinco de Mayo offers a comprehensive list of services designed to meet a variety of needs, from individual diners to large parties. Their business model is built around flexibility and convenience, ensuring that customers can enjoy their food in the way that best suits them. The services include:

Takeout is available for a quick and easy meal on the go.
Dine-in is an option, with seating available for a casual and relaxed meal.
Delivery and no-contact delivery services provide a convenient way to have food brought directly to your home or office.
The restaurant offers extensive catering services with dedicated catering menus for tacos, quesadillas, burritos, and more, making it an excellent choice for parties, corporate events, and large gatherings.
Counter service is available, which suggests an efficient and fast-paced ordering process.
The business accepts a variety of payment methods, including checks, credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, providing great flexibility for customers.
Reservations are accepted, which can be useful for planning group dinners or larger parties.

Cinco de Mayo boasts a number of highlights that make it a standout choice for Mexican food lovers in New York City. These features are a testament to its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.

The menu is a major highlight, with a wide array of offerings that go beyond standard Mexican fare. This includes not only classic burritos and tacos but also specialized "Power Plates," salads, and unique burgers like the "Bronx Quesadilla Burger."
The restaurant provides a range of healthy options, including organic, vegan, and vegetarian dishes, demonstrating a focus on catering to diverse dietary needs and preferences.
Fast service is noted as a key feature, which is essential for a restaurant in a busy city, especially during lunch and dinner hours.
The atmosphere is casual, making it an inviting and unpretentious space suitable for all types of customers, from solo diners to families. It is also listed as family-friendly and LGBTQ+ friendly, creating a welcoming environment.
The extensive catering menu is a significant highlight, offering everything from taco bars to dessert trays, making it a reliable and comprehensive solution for event planning.
The inclusion of traditional Mexican drinks like Horchata and Jamaica, as well as unique desserts like Protein Carrot Cake and Flan, adds to the authenticity and appeal of the menu.

For more information, to place an order, or to inquire about catering, you can contact Cinco de Mayo using the information below. Their team is ready to assist you with your dining needs.

Address: 113 E 31st St, New York, NY 10016, USA

Phone: (212) 725-1411

What is worth choosing Cinco de Mayo? The answer lies in its ability to blend authentic Mexican flavors with modern dietary awareness and exceptional convenience. In a city saturated with dining options, Cinco de Mayo stands out by offering a menu that is not only delicious but also consciously crafted with healthy, vegan, and vegetarian choices. The positive customer reviews, particularly highlighting the birria tacos and the overall authentic taste, are a strong indicator of the food's quality. Moreover, the versatility of its services—from quick takeout and delivery to comprehensive catering—makes it a practical solution for a wide range of situations. Whether you're in the mood for a quick lunch, a relaxed dinner, or planning a large party, Cinco de Mayo has a menu and a service model that can accommodate your needs. Its casual and welcoming atmosphere, combined with fast service and a commitment to accessibility, ensures a positive and satisfying experience for everyone who walks through its doors. For a taste of Mexico that is both authentic and health-conscious, Cinco de Mayo is a top-tier choice in New York City.

Cinco de Mayo Menu

31st Street Menu - - Catering Quesadilla Trays
Catering Quesadilla Tray $109.95
12" Tortilla. Melted Muenster Cheese, Grilled Chicken (Pollo). On side: 28oz Plate (Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream and Avocado Tomatillo Green Sauce) one of each.
Catering Cheese Quesadilla Tray $99.95
12" Tortilla. Melted Muenster Cheese, Grilled Chicken (Pollo). On side: 28oz Plate (Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream and Avocado Tomatillo Green Sauce) one of each. (Serves 10-12 people)

31st Street Menu - - Catering Desserts
Whole Protein Carrot Cake $46.80
35 Protein Mini Carrot Muffins $17.50
Whole Frosted Protein Carrot Cake $59.40
12 Protein Carrot Muffins $28.95
Flan Napolitano $29.95
(Serves 8-10 people)
Fruit Salad $79.95
(Serves 8-10 people)

31st Street Menu - Tacos*
Taquiza $42.95
10 Soft Tacos. Choose Your Protein (10 Grilled Chicken) or (10 Grilled Steak) or Both (5 & 5). Green and Red spicy sauce on side (Include utensils) ALL TOPPINGS MUST BE ON TOP, ON SIDE REQUEST WILL REPRESENT EXTRA CHARGE.
Taco (1) $4.95
1. Choose Protein, 2. Choose Tortilla Style, 3. Choose Topping, 4. Choose extras if you like.
Tacos (3) $12.86
1. Choose Protein, 2. Choose Tortilla Style, 3. Choose Topping, 4. Choose extras if you like.
Birria Tacos (3) $17.48
6" corn tortilla, chopped birria, Muenster cheese and onions.

31st Street Menu - - Catering Taco Trays
Catering Taquiza $36.65
10 soft or hard corn tortilla tacos with a choice of protein and homemade tomatillo avocado sauce.
Catering Taco Tray $109.95
30 soft or hard corn tortilla tacos with a choice of protein and homemade tomatillo avocado sauce. (Serves 10-12 people)

31st Street Menu - - Catering Traditional Mexican Taco-Bar
Cinco De Mayo Taco Bar $13.95
MINIMUM 10 PEOPLE!!! $13.95 PER PERSON. Everything you need to make your own tacos. Choose up to 3 proteins. Includes: Avocado Tomatillo Green Sauce, Chopped Iceberg Lettuce, Beans (Black or Pinto), Mexican Yellow Rice, Guacamole, Cotija Mexican Powder Cheese, Pico de Gallo, Tortilla Chips, Sliced Limes, Diced Onions, Sour Cream, Cilantro, Tortillas (Soft Shell: Corn or Flour, Hard Shell: Corn Only)

31st Street Menu - Wraps & Burritos
Lazy Hustler Wrap Or Bowl $12.85
Bowl or whole wheat wrap, falafel, hummus, Romaine, tomato, cucumber, brown rice and chili beans topped with amari sauce.
Falafel Hummus Wrap $10.67
Whole wheat wrap, falafel, hummus, lettuce, cucumber and tomato topped with amari sauce.
The Pump Wrap $16.25
Double grilled steak and chicken guacamole with pico de gallo in a whole wheat wrap.
South American Burrito $13.79
Whole wheat wrap or bowl, grilled chicken, brown rice, chili beans, guacamole, lettuce, cucumber and tomato.
Greek Burger Wrap $11.80
Whole wheat wrap, sirloin burger, Feta pesto, lettuce, cucumber, tomato and onions topped with yogurt sauce.
Chicken Guacamole Wrap $13.65
Whole wheat wrap, grilled chicken, guacamole, lettuce, cucumber and tomato.

31st Street Menu - - Catering Beverages
Catering 96oz Box. Horchata Mexican Drink $24.95
Catering Individual Jarritos (Mexican Soda)
Catering 96oz Box. Jamaica Mexican Drink $24.95
CATERING Poland Spring Bottled Water $2.01
Catering Canned Soda $2.01
Catering Individual Mexican Coke (Crystal Bottle) $3.85
Catering 96oz Box. Home Made Lemonade $24.95

31st Street Menu - Cinco de Mayo Burgers
Bronx Quesadilla Burger $12.13
Fries, pico de gallo, guacamole, grilled onions and Muenster cheese.
Cheeseburger Deluxe $11.86
Served with French fries, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and mayo.
Hamburger Deluxe $10.88
Served with French fries, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and mayo.
Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe $13.13
Served with French fries, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and mayo.
Queso Spicy Burger $13.87
Served with French fries, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and mayo.

31st Street Menu - Our Newest Additions
California Burrito $14.93
Grilled steak, French fries, pico de gallo, Muenster cheese, sour cream and guacamole.
Grilled Chicken Guacamole Salad $14.89
Lettuce, corn, pico de gallo and guacamole.

31st Street Menu - Homemade Mexican Drinks
Lemonade
Jamaica
Horchata

31st Street Menu - Drink
Mexican Coke $3.54
Jarritos $3.02
Water $1.99
Canned Soda $1.99
Topo Chico $3.54

31st Street Menu - Burrito or Burrito Bowl
Burrito $12.95
Flour or whole wheat tortilla, Mexican rice, black or pinto beans, lettuce, pico de gallo, sour cream & cheese.
Burrito Bowl $12.95
Flour or whole wheat tortilla, Mexican rice, black or pinto beans, lettuce, pico de gallo, sour cream & cheese.

31st Street Menu - Smoothies
Green Blast Smoothe $8.34
Pineapples, mangoes, bananas, kale, spinach, apple juice, ice.
Tropical Delight Smoothe $7.65
Pineapples, mangoes, strawberries, bananas, orange juice, ice.
Chocolate Banana PB Crunch Smoothe $9.28
Skim milk or almond milk, chocolate, whey protein, peanut butter, bananas and vanilla frozen yogurt.
Very Berry Smoothe $8.34
Strawberries, blueberries, apple juice, ice, vanilla frozen yogurt.

31st Street Menu - - EVAS CATERING POWER PLATES
Catering Lean & Ripped Plate $120.00
Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, steamed vegetables.
Catering McMullan Power Plate $120.00
Serves 10-12 people. Baked tofu, steamed spinach, lentil soup, brown rice. Hummus on top.
Catering Chili Mexicana Plate $120.00
Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, chili beans, brown rice.
Catering Ultimate Plate $140.00
Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, vegetables, hummus, brown rice.
Catering Tony’s Plate $130.00
Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, tomato sauce, low fat Mozzarella, whole wheat pasta.
Catering Victory Plate $120.00
Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, steamed vegetables, brown rice.
Catering Bob’s Plate $120.00
Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, lentil soup, brown rice.
Catering Grand Slam Plate $120.00
Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, tomato sauce, tomato, onion, brown rice.

31st Street Menu - Desserts
Frosted Carrot Cake $6.31
Carrot Cake $4.29
Protein Carrot Muffin $4.00
Flan Napolitana $4.56
Protein Brownie $4.00

31st Street Menu - Taco Salad
Taco Salad $13.36
Hard tortilla with lettuce, tomato, black or pinto beans, guacamole, Cotija cheese and sour cream.

31st Street Menu - Tostadas
Tostadas (2) $10.43
2 Fried Flat Tortillas containing black or pinto beans, lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream and powdered cheese.
Tostada (1) $5.90
1 Fried Flat Tortilla, containing black or pinto beans, lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream and powdered cheese.

31st Street Menu - - EVAS Catering Desserts
12 Protein Carrot Muffins $38.95
Catering Eva’s Famous Carrot Cake $42.00
Serves 12-16 people. Frosting.
35 Protein Mini Carrot Muffins $14.95

31st Street Menu - Salad
South American Taco Salad $15.38
Grilled chicken, brown rice, chili beans, guacamole, lettuce, cucumber, tomato, salsa, corn and Cheddar cheese.
Falafel Hummus Salad $10.88
Lettuce, falafel, hummus, tomato and cucumber.
Salmon Salad $18.67
Grilled Salmon, romaine lettuce mix, pico de gallo, tomatoes & cucumbers.
Greek Salad With Chicken $16.04
Lettuce, grilled chicken, Feta cheese, olives lime, cucumber and tomato.

31st Street Menu - - EVAS Catering Salads
Catering Greek Salad $95.00
Serves 0-10 people. Feta, olives, lime, tomato, cucumber, Romaine lettuce.
Catering Classic Vegetarian Salad $105.00
Serves 0-10 people. Hummus, falafel, lime, Feta cheese, olives, tomato, cucumber, Romaine lettuce.
Falafel Hummus Salad $90.00
Serves 0-10 people. Hummus, falafel, tomato, cucumber, romaine lettuce.
Baked Tofu Hummus Salad $100.00
Serves 0-10 people. Hummus, baked tofu, tomato, cucumber, Romaine lettuce.
Chicken Guacamole Salad $100.00
Serves 0-10 people. Grilled chicken, guacamole, tomato, cucumber, romaine lettuce.

31st Street Menu - Sides*
Hummus $2.79
Steamed Vegetables $7.08
Falafel $4.34
Sweet Potato Fries $3.79
Mexican Rice $4.03
Brown Rice $4.03
Guacamole
Beans $4.03
French Fries $3.79
Sour Cream $2.20
2 oz.
Side Steamed Sweet Potato $4.56
Chips $2.01
Pico De Gallo
Salsa & Chips
Salad $4.65
Guacamole & Chips

31st Street Menu - - Catering Burritos Trays
Catering Burrito Trays $109.95
12" Tortilla, Mexican Yellow Rice, Beans (Black or Pinto), Lettuce, Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream and Muenster Cheese. (Serves 10-12 people)

31st Street Menu - Flautas
Flautas $14.98
4 fried rolled-up tortillas with chicken inside, comes with Salad, Sour cream and powdered cheese on top. Side of Rice and Beans included on the side.

31st Street Menu - - Catering Sides
Catering Regular Salad Tray $24.95
(Serves 8-10 people)
Catering Side - Corn Tortilla Chips Tray $14.95
(Serves 8-10 people)
Catering Side - Guacamole And Corn Tortilla Chips Tray $36.95
(Serves 8-10 people)
Catering Tray Of Rice $24.95
(Serves 8-10 people)
Catering Tray Of Beans $19.95
(Serves 8-10 people)
Catering 28oz Red Spicy Hot Sauce $18.95
(Serves 8-10 people)
Catering Side - Pico De Gallo And Corn Tortilla Chips $29.95
(Serves 8-10 people)
Catering 28oz Guacamole $24.95
(Serves 8-10 people)
Catering 28oz Pico De Gallo $15.95
Catering Side - Salsa And Corn Tortilla Chips Chips Tray $27.95
(Serves 8-10 people)
Catering 28oz Avocado Tomatillo Green Sauce $17.95
(Serves 8-10 people)
Catering 28oz Salsa For Chips (Mild Sauce) $14.68
(Serves 8-10 people)
Catering 28 Oz Sour Cream $16.95
(Serves 8-10 people)

31st Street Menu - Power Plates*
Chicken Sweet Potato Plate $12.66
Grilled chicken breast with baked sweet potato.
Lean & Ripped Chicken Plate $14.65
Mixed vegetables and and grilled chicken.
Chili Mexicana Plate $15.38
Brown rice, grilled chicken topped with chili.
Ultimate Plate $15.95
Brown rice, grilled chicken, mixed steamed vegetables and topped with hummus.
The Riviera Salmon Plate $19.11
Grilled salmon, mixed steamed vegetables, brown rice with pico de gallo and salsa verde.
Bob's Plate $15.38
Brown rice, grilled chicken topped with lentil.
Mighty Jeff Ross Plate $17.38
Brown rice, chicken, chili beans, mozzarella cheese topped off with guacamole.
Lean Steak & Chipotle Bowl $16.39
Steak burger, grilled peppers and onions, guacamole, chili beans, brown rice and chipotle sauce.

31st Street Menu - Mexican Dishes
Cinco De Mayo Plate $15.65
Grilled chicken breast, chili beans, pico de gallo, salsa verde, Mozzarella cheese over brown rice or Mexican rice with guacamole.
Mexican Chipotle Plate $15.75
Grilled steak and onions, Mexican rice, black beans, guacamole, cilantro, pico de gallo with chipotle sauce.
Chicken Enchiladas $15.65
3 rolled up tortillas with chicken tomatillo sauce on top. Served with rice, black or pinto beans, sour cream, tomatoes, onions and lettuce.
Chipotle Chicken Tinga | Tinga De Pollo $15.14
Shredded chicken breast on chipotle sauce with onions and tomatoes. Served with rice, pinto or black beans and guacamole.
Gym Bowl $15.14
Brown rice, black or pinto beans, pico de gallo, and grilled chicken topped with guacamole.
Triple Meat (Finest Bowl) $16.13
Finest meat. Mexican rice, black or pinto beans with chicken, steak, carnitas sauteed with pico de gallo.
Fried Pork Sauteed With Onions | Carnitas Encebolladas $14.14
Fried pork sauteed with onions, rice, pinto or black beans and guacamole.
Grilled Chicken Breast Plate $13.85
Mexican rice, black or pinto beans and guacamole.
Veggie Mex $12.55
Black or pinto beans over brown rice topped with guacamole and pico de gallo.

31st Street Menu - Quesadillas*
Quesadillas $12.86
Flour or whole wheat tortilla. Served with pico de gallo, lettuce, sour cream and salsa verde.
Quesabirria $17.48
Flour or Whole Wheat Tortilla. Melted Muenster Cheese Chopped Birria (Beef) mixed with Pico de Gallo *inside*. Sour Cream, Avocado Green Tomatillo Sauce and 4oz Birria Consome on the Side.
Cheese Quesadilla $9.05
Flour or whole wheat tortilla. Served with pico de gallo, lettuce, sour cream and salsa verde.

31st Street Menu - - EVAS CATERING WRAPS/BURRITOS
Catering The New Yorker $120.00
Serves 8-10 people. Grilled chicken, falafel, grilled tomato, onion, peppers, choice of humus or feta pesto, whole wheat wrap.
Catering South American Burrito $115.00
Serves 8-10 people. Grilled chicken, guacamole, Romaine lettuce, cucumber, tomato, brown rice, chili beans, whole wheat wrap.
Catering Mediterranean Burrito $115.00
Serves 8-10 people. Grilled chicken, Feta pesto sauce, Romaine lettuce, cucumber, tomato, brown rice, chili beans, whole wheat wrap.
Catering The Greek Wrap $110.00
Serves 8-10 people. Sirloin burger, Feta pesto sauce, Romaine lettuce, tomato, cucumber, onion, whole wheat wrap.
Catering Lazy Hustler Burrito $115.00
Serves 8-10 people. Falafel, hummus, Romaine lettuce, cucumber, tomato, brown rice, chili beans, tahini sauce, whole wheat wrap.
Catering The Gennaro $125.00
Serves 8-10 people. 5 egg whites, tomato, sirloin burger, whole wheat wrap.

31st Street Menu - Nachos
Nachos $10.61
Corn tortilla chips, beans, melted cheese, sour cream, jalapenos & tomato.

31st Street Menu - - EVAS Catering APPETIZERS
Catering Hummus With Corn Chips $40.00
Catering Falafel With Hummus $45.00

Cinco de Mayo Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Comfort food
Healthy options
Organic dishes
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegan options
Vegetarian options

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Family-friendly
LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Checks
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Free street parking
Paid street parking
Parking

Cinco de Mayo Photos

Cinco de Mayo Location

Cinco de Mayo

New York New York County New York East 31st Street

113 E 31st St, New York, NY 10016, USA

Cinco de Mayo Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 375 user reviews.

healthyquesadillaareaburritocarrot cakedeliveryfalafelbirriaproteinbreakfast

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

The food I ordered from this store to be delivered tasted really good. I had veggie tacos stuffed with salad and falafel and veggie nachos. The tacos weren‘t visually impressive in the box, but the taste was all the better. I also liked the taste of the nachos pretty much. I would order the same again.
June 16 · Thomas Dafinger
Excellent very authentic Mexican cuisine. Loved the birria tacos. They were so full of flavor. And the grilled chicken quesadilla was on point. The staff was super friendly also. And they also offer catering.
August 11 · Curtis Beebe
I ate here few times and it was a good experience. But today it became horrible. I ordered shrimp burrito and at first I thought it’s just not tasty but after a few bites I realized that shrimp was moldy. Like really bad. I threw it away. And I went back to the place not only to return money but mostly to let them know cause it’s very dangerous. People could get really sick with not fresh seafood.But at the place they made me feel like I was a fool. They just didn’t care. They said that yeah we are going to check it but it was obviously not true. I had this horrible aftertaste of mold for about an hour. And had to take absorbent.And I felt so so bad about all that it’s just couldn’t get out of my head. I feel that they know that it’s not fresh that’s why they put so much salt. It’s obviously not a first time.I feel disappointed because I was really excited about this place before. Not gonna risk my health again. They should be inspected.
March 20 · Jen Sa
Amazing food, very tasty and fresh , birria tacos and guacamole 10/10
August 19 · Andrés Ramos
So Delicious! The beef birria (quesabirria) is bomb. Too bad I’m only here to visit for a few days from San Antonio, Tx… this would be my new Birria go to spot. The environment is chill. Good music at a good volume. Three tables to seat 2 people at each. The people were super nice too.
November 03 · Angelique Pierce