Brunch & Snack Chat
Brunch & Snack ChatBites & BanterBest Restaurants Near Me
Ohio

Brunch & Snack ChatBest Restaurants Near MeNew YorkNew York CountyNew YorkBest Restaurants in Madison AvenueCome Prima
Come Prima ico

Come Prima
- 903 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021

Italian restaurant ★4.0 (73)·$50–100

903 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021, USA

4.0
An Unexpected and Absolutely Delicious Evening!We stumbled upon Come Prima and were completely blown away by the experience. Every dish we tried was a standout. The burrata was impossibly creamy, the mushroom risotto was rich and comforting, and the scaloppine piccata with spinach had just the right amount of heat. We finished with the tartufo dessert, which was the perfect indulgent end to the meal.A bottle of Vermentino complemented everything beautifully. The service was warm and attentive, and the ambiance felt like a cozy corner of Italy in the heart of NYC.If we had one small note—it would be that the decor could use a little refresh. But honestly, the food more than makes up for it.Authentic Italian, full of flavor and heart. - Iryna NYC
Come Prima Overview Intro Vibe Detail Photos Location Reviews
$50–100 per person Reported by 73 people$20–30$30–50$50–100$100+

Come Prima Introduce

Welcome to the vibrant and bustling culinary scene of New York City, where a world of flavors awaits around every corner. Tucked away on the prestigious Madison Avenue, you'll find

Come Prima

, a place that promises to transport you straight to the heart of Italy with its authentic dishes and warm, inviting atmosphere. This isn't just another restaurant; it's a destination for those seeking a genuine taste of Italian tradition, right here in the Big Apple. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted with a cozy and romantic ambiance that makes every meal feel like a special occasion. Whether you're a local or a tourist, Come Prima offers an escape from the city's fast pace, inviting you to slow down and savor every bite. Its reputation for exceptional food and service has made it a favorite among New Yorkers and visitors alike, particularly for those looking for a high-quality dining experience without the pretension.


Come Prima is conveniently located at

903 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021, USA

, placing it in the heart of the Upper East Side. This prime location makes it easily accessible for anyone in the city. The restaurant's spot on Madison Avenue means you can easily combine your dining experience with a day of exploring the area's famous museums, art galleries, and upscale boutiques. For those traveling by public transportation, the restaurant is a short walk from several subway stations, including the 77th Street stop on the 6 line, making it a hassle-free journey from nearly anywhere in Manhattan. If you’re driving, be prepared for paid street parking, which is typical for this busy part of the city. Additionally, Come Prima is committed to accessibility, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and restroom, ensuring a comfortable experience for all guests. The well-lit and easily navigable entrance makes it simple for everyone to come in and enjoy a meal.


At Come Prima, the services are designed to ensure a seamless and enjoyable dining experience. They cater to a variety of needs and preferences, making it a perfect spot for any occasion, from a casual lunch to a romantic dinner.

  • Dine-in Service: Enjoy a full, sit-down meal in the restaurant's cozy and romantic setting. Table service is provided for both lunch and dinner, allowing you to relax and enjoy the meal without any rush.

  • Takeout: For those who prefer to enjoy their meal at home or on the go, a full takeout service is available. You can savor the authentic flavors of Come Prima from the comfort of your own space.

  • Reservations: Given the restaurant's popularity and upscale, trendy atmosphere, reservations are highly recommended, especially for dinner. You can make a reservation to ensure you get a table at your preferred time, which is especially useful for special occasions or larger groups.

  • Private Events: While not explicitly listed, the cozy and upscale atmosphere suggests it’s a perfect venue for small private gatherings or celebrations. You can call ahead to inquire about special arrangements for group dining.

  • Online Presence: The restaurant maintains a professional online presence, where you can find the latest menu, hours of operation, and contact information. This ensures that you can plan your visit with all the necessary details.


Come Prima is celebrated for a number of features that set it apart from other Italian restaurants in New York. These highlights contribute to its reputation for excellence and make it a must-visit spot.

  • Great Dessert: The dessert menu is a true highlight, featuring classics like

    Tiramisu

    and

    Panna Cotta

    that are often praised by patrons. The

    Tortino al Cioccolato

    and

    Cannoli alla Siciliana

    also stand out, providing a perfect, sweet end to any meal.

  • Great Wine List: The restaurant boasts an extensive and well-curated wine list. A good bottle of wine can elevate any meal, and Come Prima's selection is specifically chosen to complement the authentic Italian flavors of their dishes. From crisp whites to robust reds, there is a wine for every palate and every dish.

  • Authentic Italian Cuisine: The menu is a testament to genuine Italian cooking, with a focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients. From the homemade pastas like the

    Ravioli di Ricotta e Spinaci

    and

    Fettuccine all’ Uovo al Ragu’ Bolognese

    to the perfectly cooked seafood and meat dishes, every plate reflects a commitment to traditional recipes.

  • Upscale and Romantic Atmosphere: The ambiance is a key feature of Come Prima. It's described as cozy, romantic, and upscale, making it an ideal choice for a date night, an anniversary, or any special occasion where a refined setting is desired. The dim lighting and elegant decor create a sophisticated yet comfortable environment.

  • Versatile Dining Options: The restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner, as well as solo dining. This versatility makes it a great choice whether you're looking for a midday escape or an evening to remember. The menu offers a range of options suitable for different appetites and occasions.

  • Accessibility: The commitment to making the restaurant accessible to everyone is a notable highlight. With a wheelchair-accessible entrance and restroom, Come Prima ensures that all guests, regardless of mobility, can enjoy a comfortable dining experience.


To make a reservation or get more information, you can contact Come Prima directly.

  • Address: 903 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • Phone: (212) 517-7700


So, what makes Come Prima a standout choice among the countless Italian restaurants in New York? It's a combination of several factors that create a truly memorable dining experience. First and foremost, it's the commitment to authentic, high-quality Italian food. The menu is a journey through Italy's culinary landscape, from classic pasta dishes to meticulously prepared meat and seafood. As one reviewer noted, the food is "optimal," with dishes like the octopus cooked to perfection. The quality of ingredients is evident in every bite, whether it's the impossibly creamy burrata or the flavorful mushroom risotto. The restaurant also caters to dietary needs, offering gluten-free and wholewheat pasta options, which shows their dedication to accommodating all guests.

Beyond the food, the atmosphere is a significant reason to choose Come Prima. The cozy, romantic, and upscale vibe is perfect for a special evening out. While some may find the decor a bit dated, the warmth of the service and the excellence of the cuisine more than make up for it. The staff is consistently described as warm and attentive, adding to the feeling of being a welcomed guest rather than just another customer. This level of service enhances the overall dining experience, making you feel cared for from the moment you arrive until you leave.

Finally, the selection of beverages, particularly the great wine list, is a major draw. A good wine pairing can transform a meal, and Come Prima’s selection is designed to do just that. Whether you’re a wine connoisseur or just looking for a nice glass to enjoy with your dinner, the options are plentiful and well-chosen. The fact that the restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner also means it’s a great option for a variety of occasions. Whether you're planning a business lunch, a celebratory dinner, or a simple solo meal, Come Prima provides an excellent backdrop. With its prime Madison Avenue location, authentic menu, and welcoming atmosphere, Come Prima offers a slice of Italian charm and culinary excellence that is truly worth choosing for your next meal in New York City.

Come Prima Vibe

  • INSALATE

  • BARBABIETOLE, RUCOLA, MELA VERDE, NOCI E CAPRINO OLIO E SHERRY $25.00

    Golden and red beets, arugula, granny smith apples, walnuts, goat cheese with sherry dressing

  • INSALATA ROMANA ALLA CESARE $23.00

    Roman Caesar salad

  • CARCIOFINI FRESCHI, RUCOLA E SCAGLIE DI PARMIGIANO OLIO E LIMONE $25.00

    Artichoke slices with arugula and shaved Grana Padano, lemon dressing

  • INSALATA BIANCA COME PRIMA $26.00

    Endive, hearts of palm, pear, avocado, shaved Grana Padano, lemon dressing

  • ZUPPA DEL GIORNO $20.00

    Soup of the day

  • ANTIPASTI FREDDI

  • MOZZARELLA DI BUFALA, POMODORO “CUORE DI BUE” E PEPERONI ARROSTO $32.00

    Mozzarella bufala, beef tomatoes and roasted peppers

  • FILETTO DI MANZO IN CARPACCIO, RUCOLA E GRANA $32.00

    Filet of beef carpaccio, with arugula and Grana Padano

  • TARTARE di TONNO, ALGA MARINA, AVOCADO, CETRIOLO, OLIO, SOYA E LIMONE $34.00

    Tuna tartar, seaweed, avocado on cucumber carpaccio, soy lemon dressing

  • ANTIPASTI CALDI

  • PARMIGIANA DI MELANZANE, MOZZARELLA DI BUFALA, POMODORO FRESCO E BASILICO $31.00

    Eggplant parmigiana, mozzarella fior di latte, tomato and basil

  • POLIPO ALLA GRIGLIA E VERDURINE CROCCANTI $32.00

    Grilled octopus with mixed sautéed vegetables

  • GAMBERI, OLIVE NERE, CAPPERI E POMODORO FRESCO $32.00

    Sautéed jumbo shrimp, black olives, capers and fresh tomato

  • POLPETTE AL SUGO, COME PRIMA $34.00

    Beef and veal meatballs with special Come Prima tomato sauce

  • PASTE

    Gluten free and wholewheat pasta available

  • VERMICELLI AL FILETTO DI POMODORO E BASILICO $32.00

    Spaghetti with tomato and basil

  • RAVIOLI DI RICOTTA E SPINACI AL BURRO NOCCIOLA E SALVIA $32.00

    Spinach and ricotta ravioli with butter and sage

  • ORECCHIETTE, SALSICCIA DOLCE PICCANTE E CIME DI RAPE $35.00

    Ear-shaped pasta with sweet and hot sausage, broccoli rabe

  • FETTUCCINE ALL’ UOVO AL RAGU’ BOLOGNESE $36.00

    Egg fettuccine with Bolognese sauce

  • SPAGHETTI DI GRAGNANO ALLO SCOGLIO $39.00

    Spaghetti di Gragnano with mixed seafood

  • LINGUINE DI GRAGNANO ALLE VONGOLE VERACI $37.00

    Linguine with white clams, olive oil and garlic

  • SECONDI

  • COSTOLETTE D`AGNELLO IN CROSTA DI PISTACCHIO E RIDUZIONE DI VINO ROSSO $59.00

    Lamb chops in a pistachio crust, green apple purée and red wine reduction

  • POLLO PAILLARD $39.00

    Chicken paillard topped with mixed salad

  • TAGLIATA DI MANZO CON RUCOLA E PARMIGIANO $64.00

    Ribeye angus beef, arugula and shaved parmesan cheese

  • SALMONE SCOTTATO CON CREMA DI MOSTARDA ALL`ANTICA $48.00

    Pan roasted king salmon with mustard sauce and sautéed spinach

  • SPIGOLA CILENA CON ASPARAGI TARTUFO IN BRODO DI CHARDONNAY $55.00

    Chilean sea bass with asparagus, truffle oil in Chardonnay broth

  • TONNO SCOTTATO IN CROSTA SI SESAMO, CAPONATA SICILIANA E SALSA DI SOY $52.00

    Seared yellow fin tuna in a sesame seed crust, eggplant caponata and soy sauce

  • CONTORNI

  • Roasted fingerling potatoes $14.00
  • Asparagus $15.00
  • Spinach $14.00
  • Broccoli Rabe $16.00
  • DOLCI

    All Desserts

  • PANNA COTTA CON COMPOSTA DI FRUTTI DI BOSCO $16.00

    Italian panna cotta with mixed berry compote

  • TIRAMISU CON MASCARPONE E SAVOIARDI $16.00

    Whipped mascarpone cream, coffee soaked ladyfingers cookies

  • MILLEFOGLIE CON CREMA CHANTILLY E FRUTTI DI BOSCO $16.00

    Napoleon with Chantilly cream and mixed berries

  • TORTINO AL CIOCCOLATO CON SORBETTO DI LAMPONI $16.00

    Warm chocolate cake served with raspberry sorbet

  • CREMA BRUCIATA AL GRAND MARNIER $16.00

    Grand Marnier crème brulee`

  • SCELTA DI GELATI E SORBETTI $16.00

    Choice of ice cream and sorbet

  • CANNOLI ALLA SICILIANA CON RICOTTA $16.00

    Sicilian Cannoli filled with fresh ricotta and candied fruit

Come Prima Details

  • Service options

  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • Delivery
  • Highlights

  • Great dessert
  • Great wine list
  • Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining
  • Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Offerings

  • Alcohol
  • Beer
  • Cocktails
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
  • Hard liquor
  • Wine
  • Dining options

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Dessert
  • Table service
  • Amenities

  • Bar onsite
  • Restroom
  • Atmosphere

  • Cozy
  • Romantic
  • Trendy
  • Upscale
  • Crowd

  • Tourists
  • Planning

  • Dinner reservations recommended
  • Accepts reservations
  • Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • Credit cards
  • Parking

  • Paid street parking

Come Prima Photos

Come Prima Picture 1Come Prima Picture 2Come Prima Picture 3Come Prima Picture 4Come Prima Picture 5Come Prima Picture 6Come Prima Picture 7Come Prima Picture 8Come Prima Picture 9Come Prima Picture 10

Come Prima Location

Come Prima

903 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021, USA

Come Prima Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 272 user reviews.

priceswinediningfood and servicebarentreeglassgemseafoodgrilled octopus

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More Best Restaurants Near Me

  • Via QuadronnoVia Quadronno4.0 (983 reviews)

    25 E 73rd St, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • CaravaggioCaravaggio4.0 (349 reviews)

    23 E 74th St, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • Three GuysThree Guys4.0 (680 reviews)

    960 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • Le Pain QuotidienLe Pain Quotidien3.0 (544 reviews)

    East 72nd St And, 5th Ave, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • Leo Cafu00e9 at Asia Society MuseumLeo Cafu00e9 at Asia Society Museum4.0 (9 reviews)

    725 Park Ave, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • Casa Tua New YorkCasa Tua New York4.0 (133 reviews)

    20 E 76th St, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • Peng's Noodle FolkPeng's Noodle Folk4.0 (660 reviews)

    1016 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • Marlow EastMarlow East4.0 (153 reviews)

    1022 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • Le CharlotLe Charlot4.0 (371 reviews)

    19 E 69th St, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • BLT PrimeBLT Prime4.0 (388 reviews)

    1032 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • Chez FifiChez Fifi4.0 (98 reviews)

    140 E 74th St, New York, NY 10021, USA

  • The Gallery at The CarlyleThe Gallery at The Carlyle2.0 (9 reviews)

    35 E 76th St, New York, NY 10075, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Trending Bites & Banter Posts