Cull & Pistol

- 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011

For New Yorkers who appreciate the simple luxury of fresh, perfectly prepared seafood, finding a go-to spot is essential. Cull & Pistol, a standout seafood restaurant located within the bustling Chelsea Market, is a true gem in the city's culinary scene. It’s not just a restaurant; it’s a direct connection to the ocean, brought to you by the team behind The Lobster Place, one of New York's most trusted seafood markets. This unique relationship ensures that everything on the menu, from the raw bar selections to the grilled fish, is of the highest quality and freshness. The name itself, "Cull & Pistol," is a nod to a lobster with one or two missing claws, a term affectionately used in the lobster trade, signaling a deep and authentic connection to the seafood world.

Cull & Pistol provides a dining experience that is both casual and refined. The atmosphere is cozy and trendy, making it an ideal place to escape the market's hustle and bustle. The menu is a thoughtful and creative showcase of the day's fresh catch, with an emphasis on sustainability and craftsmanship. Whether you're craving classic New England clam chowder, an authentic lobster roll, or a more adventurous dish like grilled Spanish octopus, the kitchen's dedication to flavor and quality shines through. The restaurant is a haven for seafood enthusiasts and a delightful surprise for anyone simply looking for a fantastic meal in a friendly and welcoming environment.

Beyond the food, Cull & Pistol's mission is rooted in community and quality. As a veteran-owned business, it brings a sense of integrity and purpose to its operations. The restaurant is known for its exceptional hospitality and attentive staff who are knowledgeable about the menu and happy to make recommendations. It's a place that has managed to build a loyal following among locals, who recognize its consistent delivery of great food, service, and atmosphere. This blend of authentic cuisine, a polished dining experience, and a welcoming vibe makes Cull & Pistol a must-visit destination for anyone in New York City with a love for seafood.

Cull & Pistol is conveniently located at 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, USA, right in the heart of Chelsea Market. This prime location makes it incredibly accessible for locals and tourists alike. Situated near major subway lines and bus routes, getting to the restaurant is a breeze, whether you’re coming from Midtown, Downtown, or anywhere else in the city. The entrance is a part of the vibrant Chelsea Market concourse, making it a perfect stop after a walk on the High Line or a day of shopping in the Meatpacking District.

The restaurant has made a strong commitment to accessibility, ensuring that everyone can enjoy its offerings comfortably. It features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, wheelchair-accessible seating, and even a wheelchair-accessible restroom. This inclusive approach to its physical space, combined with its welcoming atmosphere, makes Cull & Pistol a place where all diners feel at home. The central location and ease of access contribute significantly to its popularity, allowing it to serve a diverse and dynamic crowd that includes families, couples, and solo diners.

Cull & Pistol provides a range of services designed to offer a flexible and high-quality dining experience for all its patrons. The restaurant focuses on providing excellent hospitality, whether you're sitting down for a full meal or grabbing a quick bite.

Here are the services you can expect:

• Dine-in: Enjoy a full-service, sit-down meal with table service in the restaurant's cozy and trendy setting. Reservations are highly recommended, especially for dinner, as the restaurant is known to have a wait.

• Takeout: For those on the go, Cull & Pistol offers a convenient takeout option, allowing you to enjoy their fresh seafood at home or on a nearby park bench.

• Catering: For larger events or private parties, the restaurant also provides catering services, bringing its renowned seafood to your special occasion.

• Reservations: To ensure you get a table during peak times, Cull & Pistol accepts reservations. It’s a good idea to book ahead, as it’s a popular spot for both lunch and dinner.

These services highlight the restaurant's dedication to accommodating different dining styles and needs, from a casual quick lunch to a planned celebratory dinner.

Cull & Pistol is celebrated for a number of key features that set it apart in New York City's competitive dining scene. These highlights are what make the restaurant a favorite among locals and a must-visit for tourists.

Key highlights of Cull & Pistol include:

• Great Wine List and Cocktails: The restaurant boasts an impressive beverage program. The wine list is carefully curated to pair perfectly with seafood, and the cocktail menu features creative and well-balanced drinks like the "Pickled Mary" and "Spicy Tropical Mezcalita."

• Excellent Beer Selection: In addition to wine and cocktails, Cull & Pistol has a great selection of local craft beers on draft and in cans, offering something for every beer lover.

• Fresh, High-Quality Seafood: As a sister business to The Lobster Place, the seafood is guaranteed to be exceptionally fresh and of the highest quality. This is a core part of the restaurant's identity and a primary reason for its popularity.

• Happy Hour Specials: A major draw for the after-work crowd is the happy hour, which often features half-priced oysters and other specials. This makes a taste of luxury more accessible and is a popular reason for the restaurant to be bustling.

• Welcoming Atmosphere: The restaurant is known for being casual, cozy, and trendy. It’s also recognized as LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safe space, fostering an inclusive and welcoming environment for all.

• Fast Service: Despite being a busy and popular spot, the service is often noted as fast and efficient, ensuring a pleasant dining experience even during peak hours.

• Veteran-Owned Business: Cull & Pistol is identified as veteran-owned, which adds a layer of community support and pride for patrons who value supporting such establishments.

These features collectively create a compelling reason to visit, offering a high-quality food and drink experience in a positive and professional environment.

To plan your visit or get in touch with the restaurant, here is the essential contact information:

• Address: 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, USA

• Phone: (646) 568-1223

Whether you're calling to make a reservation or simply want to know the day's special, the staff is ready to assist you. The provided phone number is the best way to get direct information about the restaurant’s menu and availability.

Choosing what to order at Cull & Pistol can be a delightful dilemma, given the extensive and high-quality menu. However, there are a few items that consistently stand out and come highly recommended by regulars and critics alike, making them excellent choices for a first-time visitor or a returning fan.

The raw bar is a great place to start. Many reviewers, including local patrons, rave about the oysters. One customer review notes that they are "some of the best oysters in the city," particularly praising the "higher salinity" varieties and the restaurant's homemade vinegar, which is a perfect pairing. The oyster sampler is a great way to explore the diverse selection, which changes regularly based on what's fresh and available from the market next door. This direct-from-market freshness is a key selling point and a major reason why the raw bar is such a popular choice.

Beyond the raw bar, the New England Clam Chowder is a must-try. A reviewer specifically mentioned it as a dish they would "order again," describing it as "creamy, tasty, and full of crabmeat." The fact that it's "not too salty" highlights the kitchen's focus on balanced, well-rounded flavors. It's a comforting classic done exceptionally well, a perfect dish to warm up on a chilly New York day.

Another item worth choosing is the grilled octopus. One reviewer praised it for being "very tender" with a "smokey charred outside," demonstrating the skilled preparation that goes into each dish. The lobster rolls, both hot and cold, are also a top choice. Known for their generous, meaty portions and served with perfectly seasoned fries, they are a luxurious and satisfying meal that epitomizes classic New England seafood. For a truly unique experience, don't miss the Banana Pudding for dessert. A reviewer called it a "pleasant surprise," loving the "crispy caramel layer" and "well balanced" flavor, a clear indication that the restaurant’s talent extends beyond savory dishes.

Finally, the daily "Catch of the Day" is always an amazing choice, according to a regular customer. This option leverages the direct access to The Lobster Place's fresh inventory, ensuring that you're getting the best and freshest seafood available that day. This commitment to fresh, simple, and expertly prepared food is ultimately what makes Cull & Pistol an exceptional choice for any seafood lover in New York.

Cull & Pistol

75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, USA