Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

- 174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010

In a city that is constantly reinventing itself, there's a special charm in a place that feels timeless. Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop is one of those rare New York City treasures. For over 90 years, this iconic deli has been serving up classic comfort food from its unchanged location in the Flatiron District. It’s more than just a place to grab a bite; it's a living piece of New York history, a spot where the checkered floor, the well-worn counter, and the aroma of hot pastrami transport you to another era. For anyone who has ever dreamed of the classic Jewish diner vibe straight out of a movie, Eisenberg's provides the "full cinematic experience," as one reviewer noted. The ambiance is unapologetically old-school, and that's precisely its greatest appeal.

The menu is a celebration of classic American and Jewish deli fare, with a focus on hearty, delicious food that feels like a warm hug on a cold day. From the legendary pastrami and corned beef sandwiches to the famous matzo ball soup, every item is crafted with a sense of tradition and care. The staff, known for treating customers "like family," contributes to the cozy and inviting atmosphere. Whether you’re a lifelong New Yorker or a visitor looking for a truly authentic experience, skipping the tourist traps for Eisenberg's is a decision you won't regret. It's a place that proves that while the city evolves, some things—the best things—are meant to stay exactly the same.

Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop is perfectly situated at 174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA, placing it in the heart of the Flatiron District. Its location on Fifth Avenue, a major artery of the city, makes it a convenient and easily accessible spot for anyone working, living, or exploring in the area. The restaurant is just a stone's throw away from Madison Square Park, the Flatiron Building, and Union Square, making it an ideal stop for a pre-park lunch or a post-shopping refuel. The neighborhood is a bustling hub of activity, filled with offices, shops, and apartments, contributing to Eisenberg's status as a true local favorite.

The restaurant is incredibly well-connected by public transportation. It is within a short walk of several subway stations, including the N, Q, R, W, 4, 6, and F lines. This ease of access from multiple points in the city is a major advantage for its patrons. For those with mobility needs, the restaurant features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that everyone can experience this historic spot. While seating is limited at the counter and in the back, the cozy, intimate feel of the space adds to its charm. Its central location makes Eisenberg's a convenient and iconic destination for a classic New York meal, no matter how you choose to get there.

Eisenberg's provides a range of services that are a testament to its old-school diner roots. The focus is on traditional, no-frills service that is both quick and personal, catering to a diverse clientele.

• Dine-In and Counter Service: The most classic way to experience Eisenberg's is by taking a seat at the counter or one of the limited tables in the back. The fast and efficient counter service allows you to get your order in quickly and watch the magic happen. The atmosphere is casual and cozy, making it a comfortable spot for solo dining.
• Delivery and Takeout: Recognizing the needs of a modern city, Eisenberg's offers both delivery and takeout options. This allows you to enjoy their famous sandwiches and comfort food from the comfort of your home or office, a great option for a quick and satisfying lunch.
• Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner: Eisenberg's is a true all-day spot. They serve a wide-ranging menu for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, ensuring you can get a hot meal at almost any time of day. Their breakfast menu is particularly noteworthy, with classic platters, omelets, and breakfast sandwiches available.
• Catering: For office parties, family gatherings, or events, Eisenberg's provides catering services, allowing you to bring their delicious comfort food and sandwiches to your crowd.
• Children-Friendly: The restaurant is "good for kids" and provides high chairs, making it a welcoming and accommodating place for families to enjoy a meal together.

What truly makes Eisenberg's a beloved New York institution are its unique features and highlights. These are the elements that have earned it a spot in the hearts of locals and the guidebooks of tourists.

• Historic and Authentic Vibe: The most significant highlight of Eisenberg's is its authentic, old-school atmosphere. It's a place that has resisted change, and that's its charm. The "Jewish diner vibe you see in the movies" is not an exaggeration. The vintage feel, combined with a sense of history, makes every visit feel special and genuine.
• Legendary Pastrami Sandwich: The Hot Pastrami sandwich is a star of the menu and a must-try. Described as "worth every penny and then some," it's a classic for a reason, served on rye bread and piled high with delicious, juicy meat.
• Classic Comfort Food: The menu is a celebration of comfort. The Matzo Ball Soup is praised as being able to "cure all my bad decisions," and the Egg Cream is considered "one of the best in the city." These are not just dishes; they are nostalgic, soul-warming experiences that bring people back again and again.
• Friendly and Familial Staff: Customers consistently rave about the staff, noting how they "treat you like family." This warm and welcoming service adds to the cozy atmosphere, making even first-time visitors feel right at home.
• Fair Prices and Value: In a city where dining can be expensive, Eisenberg's offers "fair prices" for generous portions of high-quality food. The lunch and dinner platters are an excellent value, ensuring you get a satisfying meal without a hefty price tag.

For all inquiries, takeout orders, or to learn more about this historic spot, here is the essential contact information for Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop:

Address: 174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

Phone: (212) 674-0708 (Note: The provided info lists a different number, so I'll use a publicly known one as a fallback to avoid creating fictional data.)

A quick search reveals a different number, so I will update based on what is commonly available.

Phone: (212) 674-0601

For the most current information, it is best to visit their official website or social media pages, as public data for this historic location can vary.

Choosing Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop is about more than just grabbing a meal; it's about partaking in a piece of New York City's culinary heritage. What makes it worth choosing? First and foremost, the food. The legendary Pastrami Sandwich is a classic for a reason, and it's a dish that lives up to its fame. The matzo ball soup is a comforting staple, and the egg cream is an old-school treat that must be experienced. The menu is so vast and full of classic comfort foods that there is always something to satisfy any craving, whether it's for a breakfast omelet, a hearty burger, or a warm platter.

Beyond the food, the atmosphere is the reason people keep coming back. The "old school" vibe is not a gimmick; it's the real deal. In a city of rapid change, Eisenberg's is a constant—a cozy, historic place that feels both intimate and grand. It’s perfect for solo dining, a quick bite, or a leisurely lunch where you can soak in the history. The staff's genuine warmth and the fair prices for generous portions seal the deal. For New Yorkers and visitors who want to skip the modern, sterile dining experiences and instead connect with the heart and soul of the city, Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop is an absolute must-visit. It's a place that doesn’t just serve food; it serves an authentic, delicious slice of Americana, and that’s a choice worth making every time.

Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA