Elio's

- 1621 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028

Elio's stands as a true institution in New York City's culinary landscape. Located in the heart of the Upper East Side, this beloved Italian restaurant has been a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike for decades. It's the kind of place that captures the essence of a classic, old-school New York dining experience—from the warm, inviting atmosphere to the impeccable service and, most importantly, the exceptional food. Elio's isn't just about a meal; it's about an event. It's a place where you can relax, feel pampered, and enjoy authentic, well-crafted Italian cuisine in a setting that's both elegant and comfortable. Whether you're planning a romantic dinner, a celebratory meal with family and friends, or a solo dinner at the bar, Elio's provides a perfect backdrop. The restaurant’s enduring popularity is a testament to its commitment to quality, tradition, and a dining experience that feels both luxurious and genuinely welcoming. While the menu offers a wide range of choices, from traditional pasta dishes to standout meat and seafood entrées, the true magic lies in the entire package: the cozy ambiance, the knowledgeable staff, and the feeling that you’ve stepped into a piece of New York’s rich history. From the moment you walk through the door, you are met with a sense of timeless charm that is hard to find elsewhere, making it a place many New Yorkers return to again and again.

The culinary journey at Elio's is rooted in classic Italian techniques and flavors. The menu is a carefully curated selection of antipasti, pastas, and main courses that highlight the best of Italian tradition. Start your meal with a classic antipasto or a serving of roasted peppers and anchovies. The pasta dishes are a highlight, with options ranging from a comforting Spaghetti Sugo Di Carne to a rich Fettuccine Amatriciana. The chefs pay close attention to detail, ensuring each dish is prepared with fresh ingredients and a deep respect for authentic recipes. The restaurant's reputation for classic dishes is well-earned, with standout items like the lasagna, which is often featured as a special, earning rave reviews from customers. While some of the more traditional choices might not be on the regular menu, the daily specials often feature beloved classics, so it's always worth asking your server for recommendations. The main courses offer a variety of options to satisfy any palate, from seafood choices like Zuppa Di Pesce and Grilled Gamberoni to classic meat dishes such as Scaloppine Marsala and Broiled Veal Chop. The wine list at Elio's is particularly impressive, featuring a broad selection of Italian and international wines that perfectly complement the food. The attentive and professional staff are always on hand to help you navigate the extensive list and find the perfect pairing for your meal. The dessert menu, though not as extensive, offers the perfect ending to a memorable meal, with options that are simple, traditional, and delicious. Every aspect of the dining experience, from the first bite to the last sip of coffee, is designed to leave a lasting impression, solidifying Elio's status as a quintessential dining destination in New York City.

Located on the Upper East Side, Elio's is a staple of the neighborhood. The address is 1621 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA. This prime location makes it easily accessible for anyone in the city. The restaurant is situated in a bustling area, surrounded by a mix of residential buildings and other local businesses, giving it a true neighborhood feel. Whether you’re coming from a nearby office, a hotel, or one of the many cultural institutions in the area, getting to Elio's is straightforward. For those using public transportation, the restaurant is conveniently located near bus routes and a short walk from the subway. The Second Avenue subway line (Q train) has a stop at 86th Street, which is just a few blocks away. The 4, 5, and 6 trains at 86th Street and Lexington Avenue are also within walking distance, making it a convenient destination from various parts of the city. For those driving, street parking can be challenging, as is typical in this part of Manhattan, but there are several parking garages nearby. The restaurant’s location is also known for its walkability, allowing for a pleasant stroll before or after your meal to explore the surrounding area. The entrance and seating are wheelchair accessible, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a meal here comfortably. The central, yet classic neighborhood location contributes significantly to the overall experience, making Elio's feel like a hidden gem that’s right in plain sight. It's a place where you can feel connected to the vibrant energy of the city while enjoying a quiet, intimate dining experience. The accessibility of the location, combined with the timeless charm of the restaurant itself, makes it a destination that is both easy to get to and difficult to forget.

The professional and attentive staff at Elio's are a crucial part of the restaurant's charm. The service is often described as good, with a genuine desire to make your dining experience memorable. The team is known for its eagerness to cater to guests' needs, though some have noted they can be a bit over-eager at times. The staff’s professionalism is evident in their knowledge of the menu, their ability to make recommendations, and their overall attentiveness. However, some guests have mentioned issues with the staff's transparency, particularly regarding the pricing of by-the-glass wines. It is always a good idea to confirm prices before ordering to avoid any unexpected surprises. Despite these occasional critiques, the service generally contributes positively to the overall experience, with the staff working to create a welcoming and comfortable environment for every guest. The restaurant's reservation policy is a key part of the experience, as reservations are highly recommended, especially for dinner. This ensures that you have a table waiting for you, although it's worth noting that the restaurant is popular and can have a wait. The dining atmosphere is cozy, romantic, and upscale, making it a great choice for special occasions. The interior features a classic bar onsite, and the seating options include both table service and outdoor seating, weather permitting. The restaurant is also equipped with a restroom and provides high chairs for children. All of these amenities and services are designed to ensure that guests have a pleasant and comfortable visit. Elio’s accepts various payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions convenient and easy. The combination of classic amenities, a professional team, and a warm atmosphere makes Elio’s a standout choice for a quintessential New York dining experience.

Services Offered

• Dine-in: A full-service dining experience with table service.
• Takeout: Guests can order food to enjoy at home.
• Outdoor seating: A great option for enjoying a meal on a pleasant day.
• Reservations: Reservations are accepted and highly recommended for dinner.
• High chairs: The restaurant is family-friendly and provides high chairs for children.
• Table service: Professional and attentive service throughout your meal.
• Payments: Accepts a wide range of payment methods including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features and Highlights

• Great cocktails: A well-regarded selection of cocktails to start your evening.
• Great coffee: The perfect way to end a meal.
• Great wine list: An extensive list of sparkling, white, and red wines from Italy and around the world.
• Cozy and romantic atmosphere: Ideal for a quiet dinner or a special occasion.
• Upscale and trendy vibe: A sophisticated setting that feels modern yet classic.
• Wheelchair accessible: The entrance and seating are accessible for all guests.
• Comfort food: Classic Italian dishes that feel both comforting and refined.
• Bar onsite: A full bar serving a wide variety of drinks.
• Popular for groups and solo diners: A versatile atmosphere suitable for various occasions.

Contact Information

• Address: 1621 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA
• Phone: (212) 772-2242

What Is Worth Choosing

Choosing Elio's means opting for a quintessential New York Italian dining experience. It's a place that transcends fleeting trends to offer something timeless and deeply satisfying. The main reason to visit is for the authentic, no-frills Italian cuisine, prepared with a respect for tradition. The menu, while perhaps not as expansive with "traditional choices" as some might expect, excels in its quality and execution of classic dishes. The fact that the lasagna is a lauded special tells you everything you need to know about their commitment to a high standard of cooking. The true highlight of Elio's is the atmosphere. It's an "old school" New York Italian restaurant that feels both cozy and upscale, a rare balance to strike. The romantic and trendy setting makes it perfect for a date night or a special celebration, while the high-quality food ensures that the experience is worth the price. The extensive and well-curated wine list is another major draw, offering perfect pairings for every dish. While some experiences may vary, particularly regarding transparency on pricing, the overall consensus is that Elio's delivers a solid and memorable meal. It is a place for those who appreciate a classic approach to dining—a place where the focus is on good food, good wine, and a great atmosphere. For anyone in New York looking for a taste of timeless Italian elegance and a dining experience that feels genuinely special, Elio's is a truly excellent choice that holds its own among the city's many culinary options. It represents a piece of the city's history and a tradition of fine dining that is well worth experiencing.

Elio's

1621 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA