Lucille's: An Authentic Pizza & More Spot in New York

Lucille's. Introduce

Welcome, New Yorkers, to a true neighborhood gem that's more than just a pizza spot. Lucille's, nestled on Macombs Place in Harlem, offers a unique and authentic dining experience that combines the best of classic pizza with a diverse menu of Italian-American comfort food. This restaurant, identified as both Latino-owned and women-owned, provides a cozy and casual atmosphere that is perfect for a variety of occasions. Whether you're a local craving a delicious slice, a tourist exploring the area near Yankee Stadium, or a group looking for a laid-back place to enjoy a meal, Lucille's has you covered. The place is known for its excellent service and its lively vibe, which is often enhanced by live music, making it a destination in its own right.

Lucille's is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a full-fledged dining destination. While the pizza is a clear highlight, the menu extends to include a variety of other delicious offerings. From hearty Italian dishes like Vodka Ravioli and Baked Ziti to American classics like the Fried Chicken Sandwich and Shrimp & Grits, there's a wide array of choices to satisfy any craving. The restaurant also caters to different dietary needs with a great selection of vegan and vegetarian options, including a dedicated Vegan Squares menu. This versatility, combined with a full bar offering beer, wine, cocktails, and hard liquor, makes it an ideal spot for lunch, dinner, happy hour, or a late-night meal.

The atmosphere at Lucille's is a significant part of its appeal. It strikes a perfect balance between casual and cozy, making it a comfortable place to relax and enjoy your food. Many a New Yorker has found it to be a favorite, praising the authentic flavors and the friendly environment. The restaurant is family-friendly and also noted as being a welcoming space for the LGBTQ+ community, including being a transgender safe space. This commitment to inclusivity, along with amenities like free Wi-Fi and a gender-neutral restroom, further enhances its reputation as a welcoming hub for the community. Lucille's is not just a place to eat; it's a place to connect and feel at home.

For those who prefer to dine at home, Lucille's also offers a unique "Bake-At-Home" menu, allowing you to enjoy their famous squares fresh from your own oven. This innovative service shows their dedication to providing convenience and quality in every way. The combination of a fantastic menu, a great atmosphere, and a variety of service options makes Lucille's a standout choice in New York City's vibrant food scene.

Lucille's is conveniently located at 26 Macombs Pl, New York, NY 10039, USA. Situated in Harlem, near the Harlem River and Yankee Stadium, its location makes it a great spot for a pre- or post-game meal or a destination for those exploring the area. The restaurant is easily accessible by public transportation, being a short walk from the 145th Street subway station. For those who prefer to drive, there is free street parking available nearby, which is a significant convenience in the city.

Accessibility is also a key feature, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance ensuring that all customers can comfortably enter and enjoy their dining experience. The presence of outdoor seating provides a pleasant option for dining on a nice day, and a review from a real customer mentions that there are "benches outside in nice weather." This adds to the laid-back and accommodating nature of the establishment. The fact that the restaurant is also dog-friendly is a wonderful bonus for pet owners in the neighborhood.

Lucille's offers a variety of services to accommodate the needs of its diverse clientele, making it a highly convenient dining option.

Outdoor Seating: Enjoy your meal on the patio, especially on a warm day. The outdoor space is also dog-friendly.
No-Contact Delivery & Delivery: For those nights in, you can get your favorite pizza and comfort food delivered safely to your home.
Takeout: A great option for a quick meal on the go, allowing you to grab your order and head out.
Dine-in: Experience the cozy and casual atmosphere firsthand by dining inside the restaurant.
Onsite Services & Counter Service: The restaurant provides various onsite services and counter service for a streamlined and efficient experience.
Catering: While the menu mentions some options for parties, the restaurant is well-equipped to handle larger orders for events.

Lucille's is known for several key features and highlights that set it apart in the bustling New York dining scene.

Authentic Pizza & Varied Menu: The restaurant is celebrated for its authentic pizzas, including 18-inch pies, 12-inch pies, and 12x9-inch squares. The menu also includes a full dinner selection, with everything from Fried Chicken to Shrimp & Grits.
Fast Service & Live Music: Patrons consistently highlight the quick service and the lively atmosphere, which is often enhanced by live music, making for an enjoyable and engaging visit.
Vegan & Vegetarian Options: The menu is inclusive, with a dedicated section for vegan squares and other vegetarian dishes, ensuring a satisfying meal for everyone.
Full Bar: With a selection of beer, cocktails, wine, and hard liquor, Lucille's is a great spot for happy hour or a night out.
Latino- & Women-Owned: As an independently owned business with these identifiers, it’s a great place to support a local, diverse establishment.
Convenient Payment Options: The restaurant accepts credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and easy.
Bake-At-Home Squares: This unique offering allows customers to enjoy the fresh taste of Lucille's pizza at their own convenience.

For more information, to place an order, or to make a reservation, you can contact Lucille's at the following details.

Address: 26 Macombs Pl, New York, NY 10039, USA

Phone: (646) 370-4270

What makes Lucille's truly worth choosing is its ability to deliver an authentic, high-quality experience that extends far beyond a simple slice of pizza. The reviews from real customers provide a compelling argument for a visit. One customer notes that it's an "authentic pizza spot" and praises the "excellent sausage!" Another review calls it "one of my favorite pizza spots in Harlem" and highlights the delicious Margherita and the "best" garlic knots they've had in a while. These personal accounts of satisfaction speak to the consistent quality of the food.

The versatility of Lucille's is another key factor. While it offers a convenient "grab and go" option for those in a hurry, it also provides a comfortable dine-in experience for those who want to linger. A review clarifies this perfectly, stating that while it's a "small place" for grab and go, you can also "order pizza at Lucille’s next door and have a sit in experience." This hints at a larger, co-located dining space that provides the full restaurant experience, which is a significant advantage. This dual-purpose setup caters to every need, from a quick bite to a leisurely dinner.

The extensive menu is also a major draw. Beyond the incredible pizzas, the inclusion of comfort food classics, happy hour specials, and a full bar means you can come for any occasion. The fact that the restaurant is women- and Latino-owned also makes it a great choice to support a local business with a strong community identity. Ultimately, Lucille's is more than just a pizza joint; it’s a welcoming, authentic, and high-quality establishment that offers a wide range of services and delicious food in the heart of Harlem. It's a place that delivers on its promises and is a true gem in the New York food scene.

Lucille's. Menu

Pies 18-inch
Classic Pie -18" $24.00
Fresh marinara, Grande mozzarella, and aged Parmesan on our NY-style crust. 18-inch, 8-slice pie.
Margherita Pie -18" $28.00
Lucille’s signature Grandma sauce, house-made mozzarella, fresh basil, evoo, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 18-inch, 8-slice pie.
Vodka Sauce Pie -18" $28.00
Rich house-made vodka sauce, house-made mozzarella, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 18-inch, 8-slice pie.
MVP Pie -18" $30.00
Marinara, vodka, and pesto sauces, fresh house-made mozzarella, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 18-inch, 8-slice pie.
Bianca Pie - 18" $28.00
Homemade fresh mozzarella, creamy ricotta, aged Parmesan, and EVOO on our NY-style crust. 18-inch, 8-slice pie.

Pies 12-inch
Classic Pie - 12" $20.00
Fresh marinara, Grande mozzarella, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.
Margherita Pie - 12" $21.00
Lucille’s signature Grandma sauce, house-made mozzarella, fresh basil, evoo, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.
MVP Pie - 12" $23.00
Marinara, vodka, and pesto sauces, house-made mozzarella, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.
Bianca Pie - 12" $22.00
House-made mozzarella, creamy ricotta, aged parmesan, and evoo on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.
Vodka Sauce Pie - 12" $22.00
Rich house-made vodka sauce, fresh house-made mozzarella, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.
Rabe & Sausage Pie - 12" $24.00
Broccoli rabe, sweet Italian fennel sausage, creamy béchamel, fresh homemade mozzarella, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.
Veggie Pesto Pie -12" $24.00
Pesto, house-made mozzarella, heirloom cherry tomatoes, black olives, roasted red peppers, and evoo on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.
Artichoke Pie - 12" $22.00
Artichoke, house-made mozzarella, creamy spinach sauce, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.
Supreme Pie - 12" $27.00
Loaded with crispy charred pepperoni cups, Grande mozzarella, spicy garlic Grandma sauce and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.
Meatball & Burrata Pie - 12" $27.00
Beef meatballs, spicy arrabbiata tomato sauce, creamy burrata spread, fresh basil, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. (No pork) 12-inch, 6-slice pie.
Arthur Ave Pie - 12" $24.00
Sweet Italian sausage, house-made mozzarella, roasted red peppers, pepperoncini, onions, aged parmesan, and evoo on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie
Buffalo Chicken Pie - 12" $24.00
Crispy fried chicken, marinara, Grande mozzarella, hot sauce, blue cheese, and scallions on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.

Squares 12x9-inch
Grandma Square $20.00
Lucille’s signature Grandma sauce, house-made mozzarella, evoo, aged parmesan, and fresh basil on our thin sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
Vodka Square $22.00
Lucille’s lush vodka sauce, fresh house-made mozzarella, and aged parmesan on our thin sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
Supreme Square $28.00
Loaded with charred pepperoni cups, Grande mozzarella, spicy garlic marinara sauce, and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
Rabe & Sausage Square $24.00
Broccoli rabe, sweet Italian fennel sausage, creamy house-made béchamel, house-made mozzarella and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
MVP Square $23.00
Marinara, vodka, and pesto sauces, house-made mozzarella, and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
Buffalo Chicken Square $24.00
Fried chicken, marinara, Grande mozzarella, hot sauce, blue cheese, and scallions on our thin sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
Aritichoke Square $22.00
Artichokes, fresh house-made mozzarella, creamy spinach sauce, and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
Meatballs & Burrata Square $27.00
All-beef meatballs (no pork), spicy arrabbiata grandma sauce, creamy burrata spread, fresh basil, and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
Veggie Pesto Square $22.00
Pesto, house-made mozzarella, heirloom cherry tomatoes, black olives, roasted red peppers, and evoo on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
Bianca Square $22.00
Lucille’s house-made mozzarella, creamy ricotta, aged Parmesan, and evoo on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
Arthur Ave Square $25.00
Sweet Italian sausage, house-made mozzarella, red peppers, pepperoncini, onions, aged parmesan, and evoo on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Vegan Squares 12x9-inch
Vegan Grandma $22.00
Lucille's signature Grandma sauce, Daiya vegan mozzarella, evoo, and fresh basil on our sheet pan crust vegan square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
Vegan Marinara $16.00
Lucille's signature Grandma tomato sauce, roasted garlic, and parsley on our sheet pan crust vegan square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.
Vegan Veggie Pesto $25.00
Pesto, Daiya vegan mozzarella, heirloom cherry tomatoes, black olives, red peppers, and evoo on our sheet pan crust vegan square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Lucille's Dinner Menu
Fried Brussel Sprouts $14.00
Sriracha honey'd fried Brussel sprouts!
Hummus $13.00
Homemade hummus with a side of carrots, cucumber and homemade vegan flatbread
Chicken Nugz $12.00
guava glaze, chia seeds, pickled onions, citrus aioli.
French Fries $10.00
Old bay & Salt tossed French Fries.
Heirlooms & Burrata $15.00
Heirloom cherry tomatoes, Burrata cheese, Pesto, Balsamic glaze and crostini.
Power Green Salad $15.00
Spinach, Kale, Broccoli, Carrots, Cranberry, Pumpkin Seed, Almonds, Quinoa, Lemon Vinaigrette.
Kale Caesar $13.00
kale, garlic croutons, caesar dressing, parmesan
Mac & Cheese $16.00
Cavatelli pasta, three-cheese béchamel blend, aged parmesan, toasted breadcrumbs.
Vodka Ravioli $18.00
Handmade ricotta-filled ravioli tossed in our house-made rich vodka sauce and finished with aged Parmesan.
Baked Ziti $17.00
Handmade rigatoni baked with house-made vodka sauce, creamy burrata, aged Parmesan, and fresh parsley.
Fried Chicken Sandwich $17.00
Fried chicken, sriracha honey, red cabbage slaw, dill pickles, black pepper aioli in a brioche bun.
Cubano Sandwich $16.00
Slow-roasted pernil, smoked ham, pickles, provolone, and mustard pressed in-between sourdough bread. Served with your choice of salad or chips.
Salmon Burger $20.00
Salmon Burger, avocado, frisée, pickled red onions and chipotle aioli in a brioche bun.
Shrimp & Grits $23.00
Creamy white corn grits, old bay shrimp(x4), chili oil, scallions

Jumbo Wings
Buffalo Hot Wings 8pc $16.00
Jumbo wings, tossed in spicy hot Buffalo sauce, topped with scallions, and served with a side of ranch. 8 pieces.
Sweet BBQ Wings 8pc $16.00
Jumbo sweet BBQ wings, tossed in a smoky-sweet barbecue sauce, topped with scallions, and served with a side of ranch. 8 pieces.

Add ons
Garlic Knots 6pc $5.50
Sourdough folded, rolled, and knotted with roasted garlic and spices, baked golden brown, then tossed in garlic sauce and Parmesan. Served with a side of homemade marinara. 6 pieces.
Riceballs 3pc $11.00
Fried rice balls (arancini) made with shallots, prosciutto, mozzarella, white wine, peas, and carrots. Breaded and fried crispy on the outside, soft and creamy on the inside. Served with a side of fresh marinara. 3 pieces
Mozzarella Sticks 3pc $11.00
Homemade mozzarella, hand-breaded and fried until golden and crispy, served with a side of Lucille’s marinara. 3 pieces.
Classic Lasagna $16.00
Lucille’s signature Grandma sauce layered with creamy ricotta, homemade mozzarella, and aged parmesan, all layered between our handmade pasta sheets. 1 serving (16oz).
Lasagna Bolognese $19.00
Lucille’s bolognese (pork & beef) layered with creamy ricotta, homemade mozzarella, and aged Parmesan, all between our handmade pasta sheets. 1 serving (16oz).

House Desserts
Maraschino Cannoli 1pc $6.00
Mascarpone and ricotta whipped with vanilla, chocolate chips, dehydrated maraschino cherries, orange zest, and cinnamon, lightly dusted with powdered sugar, and piped into our crisp cannoli cookies. 1 piece per order.
Lucille's Tiramisu $12.00
A classic Italian dessert featuring layers of coffee & Kahlúa-soaked ladyfingers, Luxardo creamed mascarpone, finished with a dusting of cocoa powder. 16oz.
Cadillac Cheesecake $12.00
Lucille’s signature cheesecake features a rich and creamy blend of ricotta, mascarpone, and cream cheese, baked to perfection on a homemade graham cracker crust. Served with a blueberry compote. 12oz.

Bake-At-Home Squares!
Grandma Square (Bake At Home) $19.00
Lucille’s signature Grandma sauce, homemade mozzarella, EVOO, aged parmesan, and fresh basil on our thin sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, sealed fresh and ready to bake at home. Cooking instructions available at pizzabylucilles.com
Vodka Square (Bake At Home) $21.00
Lucille’s rich vodka sauce, fresh homemade mozzarella, and aged Parmesan on our thin sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, sealed fresh and ready to bake at home. Cooking instructions available at pizzabylucilles.com
Roni Cup Square (Bake At Home) $24.00
Lucille's signature Grandma sauce, homemade mozzarella, crispy pepperoni cups, and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, sealed fresh and ready to bake at home. Cooking instructions available at pizzabylucilles.com
MVP Square (Bake At Home) $22.00
Lucille’s marinara, vodka, and pesto sauces come together with fresh House-made mozzarella and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, sealed fresh and ready to bake at home. Cooking instructions available at pizzabylucilles.com
Artichoke Square (Bake At Home) $21.00
Lucille’s Artichoke Square features tender artichokes, fresh homemade mozzarella, creamy spinach sauce, and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, sealed fresh and ready to bake at home. Cooking instructions available at pizzabylucilles.com
Vegan Marinara (Bake At Home) $17.00
Lucille's signature Grandma tomato sauce, roasted garlic, and parsley on our sheet pan crust vegan square (no cheese). 12x9-inch, sealed fresh and ready to bake at home. Cooking instructions available at pizzabylucilles.com
Vegan Grandma (Bake At Home) $22.00
Lucille's signature Grandma sauce, Daiya vegan mozzarella, evoo, and fresh basil on our sheet pan crust vegan square. 12x9-inch, sealed fresh and ready to bake at home. Cooking instructions available at pizzabylucilles.com

Drinks
Can Soda $3.00
Bottled Water $2.00
Leaf Tea 1/2 Lemonade $5.00

Lucille's. Details

From the business
Identifies as Latino-owned
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Outdoor seating
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Live music

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour food
Hard liquor
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegan options
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy

Crowd
Family-friendly
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safespace

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
Kids' menu

Parking
Free street parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed

Lucille's. Photos

Lucille's. Location

Lucille's.

New York New York County New York Macombs Place

26 Macombs Pl, New York, NY 10039, USA

Lucille's. Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 268 user reviews.

pricepiepepperonisausagegarlic knotsareamargheritavodkamarinarapizza by the slice

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Authentic pizza spot about 12 minutes walk from yankee stadium. Not any seating but benches outside in nice weather. Lots of options - Sicilian, traditional and some excellent sausage!
June 12 · Jeremy Hess
One of my favorite pizza spots in Harlem. I usually get the Margherita and its always delish. I recently had the garlic knots and they were the best I've had in a while.Its a small place. Grab and go. But you can also order pizza at Lucille’s next door and have a sit in experience.
January 29 · Katherine Acosta
Edit: After having had an e-mail exchange with the owner, Alexander, it's clear to me how much this place cares about their customers. I look forward to continuing to order from you guys in the future, thanks again._______________________________________________________________I’ll gladly change this review if I ever hear back from Lucille’s but after calling the night this happened and calling back a couple days later, leaving my number and never hearing from the manager Alex, I feel like this is my only option.I’ve ordered from here a number of times and it’s pricy but I have largely been satisfied. A couple weeks ago I ordered a pepperoni pie directly from the Lucille’s website that, once you include tax and tip came to about $35. When it arrived it was a mini pizza, 11 inches across. I essentially paid $35 for what amounted to two slices of pizza.I specifically order directly from Lucille’s so that you guys don’t get screwed by third party apps and now this is making me wish I hadn’t. There’s nowhere on the website that would indicate to me how small this pizza is. Very disappointing experience that is now compounded by getting no response when I complained.
March 21 · Adam Mamawala
I ordered a margarita pizza for a picnic from Lucille’s and was an amazing idea! Everybody liked. The pizza was really nice, the ingredients are very tasty. I usually buy pizza from this place and always is good!
July 31 · Miriam Villacañas
Not only was the ravioli I ordered flavorless but I was truly shocked by the serving size of about 8 pieces I received for a $30 delivery. I am giving three stars because I ordered cheesecake as well, which was delicious.
March 15 · Michelle Lesperance