Luigi's Pizza

- 5370 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026

For anyone in Hilliard, Ohio, who appreciates a good, local pizza place with a rich history and a menu full of classic Italian favorites, Luigi's Pizza is a name that often comes up. Since 1955, Luigi's has been a staple in the community, and its reputation as "Hilliard's original pizza place" is well-deserved. This family-owned restaurant has been serving up high-quality, flavorful food for generations, earning a special place in the hearts of many Central Ohio residents. It's the kind of place where you can find not just a great pizza, but a full-fledged Italian dining experience, complete with fresh salads, hearty pasta dishes, and even authentic desserts. The dedication to consistency and quality has made Luigi's a go-to spot for both quick weeknight dinners and larger gatherings.

This article will take you on a journey through what makes Luigi's Pizza a beloved local institution. We'll explore their menu, which goes beyond just pizza to include subs, salads, and dinner entrees that are sure to satisfy. We'll also highlight the convenience of their modern ordering system and the consistently praised service that makes every visit a pleasant one. Customer reviews paint a picture of a place that is not only reliable but also capable of delivering exceptional quality, whether you’re picking up a single pizza or catering a party for a crowd. The unique flavor of their thin-crust pizza, often compared to other local favorites, gives it a distinct identity that sets it apart. So, whether you're a long-time fan or a curious newcomer, this guide will provide you with all the essential information you need to understand why Luigi's Pizza remains a cornerstone of the Hilliard dining scene.

Luigi's Pizza is situated in a convenient and easily accessible location for residents of Hilliard and the surrounding areas. The address is 5370 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA. This location places it in a well-traveled area, making it simple to find for both locals and visitors. The restaurant is located approximately 1.8 miles west of I-270, at the corner of Cemetery Road and Lattimer Street. Its proximity to major roadways ensures that it's a practical choice for a quick pickup on the way home or a destination for a dine-in meal. The area provides a good amount of parking, which is a major convenience for customers, especially during busy times. Being close to downtown Hilliard, as noted by a customer, also adds to its appeal, as it's part of the local community's hub of activity. The accessibility of the location is a crucial part of its success, as it makes it easy for families, professionals, and students to stop by and get a high-quality, freshly made meal without a lot of hassle. This ease of access is a key part of what makes Luigi's so suitable for the local lifestyle.

Luigi's Pizza offers a comprehensive menu that caters to a wide range of tastes, making it a great choice for individuals and groups alike. Here is an overview of the services and menu items they provide:

• Pizza Variety: The core of the menu is, of course, the pizza. They offer both original thin and thick crust options in various sizes, from personal to X-Large. A popular choice is the thin-crust pizza, which a customer review notes has a similar taste to Grandad's Pizza, a familiar local flavor that many Ohioans appreciate. The menu also features specialty pizzas like Chicken BBQ and Deluxe, in addition to the classic cheese and pepperoni.
• Pasta and Italian Dinners: Beyond pizza, Luigi's has a full menu of Italian dinner classics. They serve dishes like spaghetti with homemade meatballs, cheese manicotti, and homemade lasagna. Each of these dinners is often served with a regular tossed salad and a breadstick, offering a complete and satisfying meal.
• Delicious Subs and Salads: For those craving something other than pizza or pasta, the restaurant offers a selection of subs, including Italian, super, and vegetarian options. The salads are also a highlight, with a tossed salad that is praised for its "very fair size/portion" by one customer. They also offer a family-sized salad for larger groups.
• Desserts: A unique and much-loved aspect of their menu is the inclusion of authentic Italian desserts. The cannolis, in particular, are a standout, with a customer remarking that they were "pretty good" and compared them favorably to cannolis they had enjoyed in Boston. This shows a commitment to providing a full, high-quality dining experience from start to finish. They also offer other treats like a pizza brownie and pizza cookie.
• Online Ordering and Pickup: Luigi's offers a simple and straightforward online ordering system, which a customer found to be very convenient. The food is often ready "almost exactly when they said it would be," indicating a high level of efficiency and organization. This service is essential for locals with busy schedules.

Luigi's Pizza has several key features and highlights that have contributed to its long-standing success and popularity within the Hilliard community. These are the elements that make it stand out from other options:

• Hilliard's Original Pizza Place: With a history dating back to 1955, Luigi's is not just a pizza shop; it's a piece of local history. This long-standing presence gives it an authentic feel and a sense of tradition that chain restaurants simply cannot replicate. It's a testament to their consistent quality and community support over the decades.
• High-Quality Food: Reviews consistently mention the high quality of the food. From the "very good" thin-crust pizza to the "fresh salad" and the "pretty good" cannolis, the restaurant's commitment to using good ingredients and preparing them well is a recurring theme. The quality of their food is a primary reason for their strong recommendations.
• Exceptional Service for Parties and Events: Luigi's has proven its ability to handle large orders with speed and efficiency. A customer's experience of a party with 22 people where "all of the food was ready on time" and the staff was "fast and efficient" is a major highlight. This shows that they are a reliable choice for catering and large family gatherings, a huge plus for locals planning events.
• Unique Dessert Options: The cannoli is a definite highlight. Offering an authentic Italian dessert that is hard to find elsewhere in Central Ohio is a unique selling point. This small detail adds a lot to the overall dining experience and makes the restaurant feel more special and authentic.
• Strong Local Recognition: The fact that the thin-crust pizza is compared to "Grandad's Pizza," another local favorite, shows that Luigi's has a distinct and recognizable flavor profile that is part of the local food culture. This kind of recognition is a mark of a truly successful local business.
• Positive Customer Feedback: The overwhelmingly positive feedback, with customers "strongly" recommending the place and even ordering food to take home for their families, speaks volumes about the quality of both the food and the service. This word-of-mouth praise is the best kind of promotion a local business can get.

For those interested in trying Luigi's Pizza, all the necessary contact information is provided for your convenience. The physical address is 5370 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA. This is the place to visit for dine-in or to pick up your order. For placing an order, checking on a pickup, or for any general inquiries, you can reach them by phone at (614) 876-6712. The mobile phone number is also provided as +1 614-876-6712. Having this direct line of contact is a great asset for locals, as it allows for easy communication and helps streamline the ordering process. The combination of a convenient location and accessible contact information makes Luigi's Pizza an easy choice for a delicious and hassle-free meal.

In conclusion, Luigi's Pizza is more than just a pizza restaurant; it is a Hilliard institution that has been serving the local community with pride for decades. Its suitability for locals comes from a perfect blend of high-quality, classic Italian food, a convenient location, and a deep-seated commitment to customer satisfaction. The consistently good reviews, which highlight everything from the delicious thin-crust pizza and fresh salads to the unique cannolis and the fast service for large parties, prove that Luigi's is a reliable and cherished part of the local dining scene. Whether you're a family looking for a dependable dinner option, a group of friends wanting to order in, or a person planning a party, Luigi's Pizza has the menu, the service, and the tradition to meet your needs. It's a place that perfectly embodies the spirit of a great local business, offering a taste of tradition and a whole lot of flavor to the Hilliard community.

Luigi's Pizza

5370 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA