Made in New York Pizza

- 271 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023

Welcome to the vibrant world of New York City pizza! For anyone living in or visiting the city, finding that perfect slice is a journey of its own. Among the countless pizzerias that dot the five boroughs, one name consistently comes up for a true taste of the classic NYC experience: Made in New York Pizza. Nestled on the Upper West Side, this spot has become a go-to for locals and a must-visit for anyone craving an authentic, no-frills, and absolutely delicious pizza.

This guide will walk you through everything you need to know about Made in New York Pizza, from its delicious menu to its convenient location and friendly atmosphere. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch, a late-night bite, or a full pie for the family, this place has something for everyone. It embodies the spirit of a classic New York pizza joint—fast, friendly, and focused on serving up fantastic food. With a reputation built on quality and a loyal local following, it’s a great example of what makes the city's food scene so special. From their traditional cheese pies to their creative specialty options, every item on their menu reflects a commitment to flavor and quality ingredients, ensuring a memorable meal every time.

For a city where pizza is a way of life, Made in New York Pizza holds its own. The aroma of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese fills the air, drawing you in from the street. The experience is everything you’d expect from a neighborhood pizzeria: the friendly staff, the sight of pies spinning in the oven, and the sound of people enjoying their food. It’s a place that feels like home, whether it's your first time or your hundredth. This spot truly captures the essence of a New York City eatery, providing a comfortable and welcoming environment where the focus is simply on great food and good company.

You can find Made in New York Pizza conveniently located at 271 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023, USA. Situated in the heart of the Upper West Side, it's easily accessible whether you're a local resident or just passing through. The location is perfect for a quick stop during a busy day of exploring the neighborhood, or for a casual dinner after work.

The restaurant's accessibility is a key highlight. It features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, making it a welcoming place for everyone. While the seating inside is limited, with some standing tables also available outside, the focus here is on the quality of the food and the speed of service. The location on a bustling avenue means you'll find plenty of paid street parking options nearby, although as with most of NYC, it can sometimes be a bit of a hunt. The proximity to various public transport options also makes it a breeze to get to. The central location in a well-trafficked area ensures that no matter where you are in the neighborhood, a delicious slice is never too far away.

The strategic placement of the pizzeria on Amsterdam Avenue ensures it is a hub of activity, drawing in a steady stream of customers at all hours. This prime spot not only makes it a convenient dining destination but also a part of the local community's daily rhythm. Whether you are grabbing a quick lunch, a post-work slice, or a late-night snack, the location serves as a perfect anchor. This seamless integration into the neighborhood’s fabric is what makes Made in New York Pizza a true local favorite and an essential stop for anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza.

Made in New York Pizza offers a variety of services to make it easy for you to enjoy their food, no matter your preference.

• No-contact delivery: For those who prefer to stay in, you can get their delicious pizza delivered right to your door with a no-contact option for extra peace of mind.
• Delivery: Standard delivery service is also available, ensuring you can enjoy a fresh, hot pizza without leaving the comfort of your home or office.
• Takeout: If you're on the go, their quick and efficient takeout service allows you to pick up your order and be on your way in no time.
• Dine-in: While the space is cozy, there is an option to dine-in and enjoy your meal fresh out of the oven.
• Onsite services: The staff are professional and quick, providing excellent service whether you're grabbing a slice or a full pie.
• Catering: For events, parties, or office lunches, they offer catering services to bring their popular menu items to your gathering.

What makes Made in New York Pizza stand out goes beyond just their food. It’s the combination of their offerings, atmosphere, and a clear focus on the customer experience.

• Classic & Creative Menu: They offer a wide range of options, from classic round pies like the Cheese Pie and Pepperoni Pie to unique specialty pies such as the Vodka Pie, BBQ Chicken Pie, and Street Fair Pie. They also have a selection of square pies, including the classic Grandma Pie and Upside Down Pie.
• Dietary Accommodations: The menu includes a Gluten Free Pie option, making it accessible for those with dietary restrictions.
• Authentic Sides and Desserts: Beyond pizza, you can enjoy delicious sides like Garlic Knots and a Chicken Roll, as well as classic New York desserts like NY Cheesecake and Cannolis.
• Casual, Friendly Atmosphere: The setting is casual and family-friendly, making it a great spot for all ages. They are also known for being LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace, ensuring a welcoming environment for everyone.
• Payment Options: Paying for your meal is easy with multiple options, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Perfect for Any Time: Made in New York Pizza is popular for lunch, dinner, and even offers late-night food for those after-hours cravings. It’s a perfect spot for a quick bite or solo dining.

Ready to grab a slice or order a pie? Here's how you can get in touch with them:

Address: 271 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023, USA
Phone: (646) 449-8556

So, why should you choose Made in New York Pizza? The answer lies in its dedication to serving an authentic, high-quality product in a community-oriented setting. It’s not just about the food; it’s about the entire experience. The pizza itself is everything you'd hope for from a classic New York slice—the crust has the perfect combination of chewiness and crispness, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese is just right.

The consistently positive reviews from locals speak for themselves. One customer called it their "neighborhood go-to for pizza," praising the "friendly staff, quick service, delicious pizza." Another noted that it’s a "good place to grab NY style pizza" with "professional and quick" workers. These testimonials highlight the consistent quality and service that make this pizzeria a trusted spot. The menu variety is also a major draw. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita Pie, a hearty Sausage Pepperoni Pie, or something more unique like the White Spinach Pie, there’s a pizza for every palate. The inclusion of gluten-free options and popular desserts also ensures that no one is left out. The balance of traditional favorites and innovative new creations keeps the menu exciting and gives customers a reason to come back again and again.

Ultimately, Made in New York Pizza is more than just a place to eat; it's a staple of the Upper West Side community. It provides a reliable, delicious, and welcoming experience that embodies the true spirit of a New York City pizzeria. It's a place where quality and comfort meet, making it an excellent choice for anyone in the city looking for a memorable meal. From the moment you walk in, you’re treated like a local, and the food speaks for itself. It’s a perfect example of a local business that gets everything right, from the food to the service, creating a loyal fan base and a reputation for excellence.

Made in New York Pizza

271 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023, USA