Made In New York Pizza: Authentic Pizza on Broadway

Made In New York Pizza Introduce

In a city where pizza is a way of life, standing out from the crowd is no small feat. Made In New York Pizza has managed to do just that, quickly establishing itself as a premier destination for authentic New York pizza. Located on the bustling Broadway, this pizzeria is more than just a place to grab a slice; it’s a celebration of quality ingredients and classic techniques. Its reputation for fantastic pizza is built on a foundation of genuine passion for the craft, drawing in passersby with its irresistible aroma and converting them into loyal patrons with every bite. The restaurant offers a wide range of options, from a simple cheese slice to specialty pies and traditional Italian sides, making it a perfect spot for any time of day or night.

The quality of the pizza at Made In New York Pizza is a recurring theme in customer reviews. One reviewer, drawn in by the aroma, was delighted to have a fresh pie made just for them and found the end result to be "incredible, fantastic pizza." This attention to freshness and quality is a major differentiator. Another review, from a long-time local, points out that the "pizza scene from 92 to 106 on Broadway has hit an all time high" and credits Made In New York Pizza for being a key part of this improvement. The use of "better ingredients" and "friendly staff" sets it apart from older, more "average to poor" neighborhood joints. The spicy pepperoni squares are even compared favorably to the famous Prince Street version, a high compliment in the world of New York pizza.

The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, a perfect fit for a New York pizza spot. The space, though not large, is well-utilized, with "a decent amount of tables" and "plenty of counter space at the window to stand up and eat your crispy slice." The restaurant has become a go-to spot for late-night food, saving locals from the previously limited options. This convenience, combined with the high quality of the food and the friendly staff, makes Made In New York Pizza a beloved addition to the neighborhood. The fact that they once handed out free slices to the neighborhood is a testament to their community-oriented approach, winning over hearts and stomachs from the very beginning.

---

Made In New York Pizza is conveniently located at

2563 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, USA

. Its prime spot on Broadway, between 96th and 97th Streets, makes it incredibly accessible for locals and tourists alike. The restaurant is just "steps away from the 1/2/3 trains at the ninety sixth street station," a major subway hub that connects to a vast part of the city. Additionally, it is convenient to several bus lines, including the MTA 104, M7, and M96, making it an easy destination regardless of your mode of transport.

The restaurant’s location and accessibility are a significant part of its appeal. It is situated in a bustling part of the Upper West Side, a neighborhood known for its vibrant energy and constant flow of people. This busy environment makes the convenience of a delicious, quick, and late-night food spot even more valuable. For those who enjoy walking, it's a perfect stop to grab a bite while exploring the area. While there's no information on dedicated parking, the excellent public transportation options make it unnecessary for most New Yorkers.

---

Made In New York Pizza offers a variety of services to ensure that their delicious food is accessible to everyone.

Dine-in: The restaurant has a casual dining space with tables and counter space where patrons can enjoy their pizza.
Takeout: A great option for a quick bite on the go, allowing you to pick up your order and eat it at your convenience.
Delivery: For those who prefer to eat at home, the restaurant offers reliable delivery services, including a no-contact delivery option for safety.
Curbside Pickup: This service provides a quick and efficient way to retrieve your order without having to go inside.
Catering: Made In New York Pizza offers catering services, making it a perfect choice for parties, office lunches, or other large gatherings.

---

Made In New York Pizza is known for several key features and highlights that contribute to its strong reputation.

Authentic New York Pizza: The restaurant is praised for its high-quality, delicious, and authentic New York style pizza.
Late-Night Hours: It is a favorite spot for late-night food, staying open late to serve customers after a long night out.
High-Quality Ingredients: Reviewers mention that the restaurant uses "better ingredients," which differentiates it from its competitors.
Variety of Pizzas: The menu includes a wide range of pies, including classic round pies, square pies like the Spicy Pepperoni and Grandma Pie, and a Gluten Free Pie.
Friendly Staff: Customers have consistently praised the staff for being friendly and attentive.
Mexican Soda: The availability of Mexican Coke is a unique highlight that adds to the authentic vibe and differentiates it from other pizzerias.
Great Sides: The menu includes popular sides like Garlic Knots and a classic Chicken Roll, perfect for rounding out a meal.

---

For more information or to place an order, you can contact Made In New York Pizza using the details below.

Address:

2563 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, USA

Phone: (917) 261-4660

---

What is worth choosing?

For any New Yorker on the hunt for a truly great slice of pizza, Made In New York Pizza is a top-tier choice. The most compelling reason to visit is the quality of the pizza itself. The consistent praise for its fresh, flavorful pies and high-quality ingredients sets it apart from many other neighborhood pizzerias. The variety on the menu is another major selling point; whether you're in the mood for a classic Plain Cheese Pie, a spicy Spicy Pepperoni Square, or even a Gluten Free Pie, you'll find a delicious option. The fact that the staff is willing to make a fresh pie on demand, as one customer mentioned, speaks to their dedication to customer satisfaction.

Beyond the food, the convenience and atmosphere make it a fantastic choice for any occasion. Its late-night hours fill a significant gap in the neighborhood's dining scene, providing a delicious alternative to fast-food chains. The casual, walk-in friendly vibe is perfectly suited for a quick lunch, a solo dinner, or a simple get-together with friends. The location is unbeatable, with easy access to multiple public transportation options, making it a great last stop after a long day in the city. The availability of catering also makes it a strong contender for office events or parties.

In conclusion, Made In New York Pizza is a genuine and high-quality establishment that lives up to its name. It is not just another pizza joint; it’s a place that takes pride in its craft and provides a genuinely authentic and delicious experience. The positive reviews from loyal locals and the consistent praise for its quality and friendly service make it a reliable and highly recommended choice for anyone in the New York area craving a truly great slice of pizza. It's a testament to the fact that with passion and good ingredients, a classic can always be improved upon.

Made In New York Pizza Food & drink

Sides/Salads/Desserts
Calzone $9.36
House Salad $10.40
Cannoli $8.32
Cheese Cake $8.65
Pepperoni Wheel $5.20
Caesar Salad $9.36
Chopped romaine lettuce, crunchy croutons, and pecorino romano with caesar dressing.
Garlic Knots $4.16
Chicken Roll $9.36

Drinks
Bottle Soda $3.38
Glass Soda $4.16
Gold Peak $3.38
Mexican Soda $3.90
Dasani Water $2.60
Vitamin Water $3.64
Power $3.64
Poland Spring $2.60
Smart Water $3.38

Whole Round Pizza
BBQ Chicken - Pie $38.48
Mozzarella cheese, breaded chicken marinated in sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce.
Custom Whole Pie $28.08
Margherita - Pie $33.28
Plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, fresh garlic, basil and EVOO.
Sausage - Pie $33.28
California tomatoes, mozzarella, oregano, sausage
White Spinach - Pie $38.48
A four cheese blend, chopped spinach, fresh garlic EVOO.
Plain Cheese - Pie $28.08
California tomatoes, mozzarella, oregano
Sausage Jalapeno - Pie $38.48
California tomatoes, mozzarella, sausage, oregano, jalepeno
Pepperoni - Pie $33.28
California tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano, pepperoni.
Pepperoni Sausage - Pie $38.48
California tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano, pepperoni, sausage
Buffalo Chicken - Pie $38.48
Mozzarella cheese, breaded chicken marinated in frank's red hot sauce
Gluten Free Pie $19.76
Mushroom - Pie $33.28
California tomatoes, mozzarella, oregano, mushrooms
Yo Paulie $38.48
Margherita (Stracciatella) - Pie $41.60
Tomatoes, pecorino, post oven stracciatella, basil, EVOO.
Vodka - Pie $33.28
Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, vodka sauce, basil, EVOO.

Misc. Sauce/Dressing
$1.00 Sauce/Dressing $1.04
Italian $1.04
Ranch $1.04
Marinara $1.04

Whole Square Pizza
Veggie - Pie $38.48
Slow cooked tomato sauce, mozzarella, oregano, mushroom, red peppers, white onions.
Upside Down - Pie $33.28
Slow cooked tomato sauce, mozzarella, sicilian oregano, pecorino romano.
Grandma - Pie $33.28
Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, seasoned plum tomatoes and fresh garlic
Spicy Pepperoni - Pie $38.48
Slow cooked tomato sauce, mozzarella, spicy pepperoni cups.
Classic Sicilian - Pie $33.28
Slow cooked tomato sauce, mozzarella, sicilian oregano, pecorino romano.
White - Pie $38.48
A four cheese blend, basil, EVOO.
Eggplant - Pie $38.48
Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, seasoned plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, charred eggplant, basil, EVOO.

Made In New York Pizza Details

Service options
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Dining options
Catering

Made In New York Pizza Photos

Made In New York Pizza Location

Made In New York Pizza

New York New York County New York Broadway

2563 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, USA

Made In New York Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★3.7 from 23 user reviews.

pricetrainmexican cokebroadwayslicescostovenpepperoni

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I was walking passed this place on Broadway, and the aroma hit me and pulled me in. After much discussion I decided to get a pie with 50%/50% split on the toppings. I would've been happy with the two half pies already on display, but when the oven guy said he'd make a new pie for me fresh, I was so glad he did. The end result was incredible, fantastic pizza. A little pricey, I thought, but then when I saw and tasted the pie, it was worth every penny.Conveniently located on Broadway between 96 and 97, and convenient to the MTA 104 bus as well as the M7, M96 and others. Plus it's just steps just steps away from the 1/2/3 trains at the ninety sixth street station.
July 08 · Brian
Within 6 months, the pizza scene from 92 to 106 on Broadway has hit an all time high of quality options. If you’ve lived within this border long enough, you know how average to poor it used to be.All the new spots are better than our old neighborhood pizza joints but that’s not saying much.M. I. N. Y. uses better ingredients, friendly staff and Mexican Coke to differentiate itself from the herd, ya nerds. No beef Pattie’s here, Bruno, strictly: slices & garlic knots. Their pepperoni squares remind me of Prince Street’s version, maybe even better ?I happened to walk by when they first opened and they were handing out a free slice to everyone in the neighborhood.A standard cheese slice is a solid 8.2 , if you know - you know.Decent amount of tables considering the small space. Plenty of counter space at the window to stand up and eat your crispy slice.Zero freelance door openers right now or $1 Joes when you coming or going, which is surprising considering the location.They’re open late. And by that, I mean they were still open after a long night post work on a Friday kind of late. The kind of nights where the only option used to be after you got off the train was McDonald’s or the Mexican food truck. Not anymore.
April 17 · Yür MůmzŶ
This place is legit! I poo pooed this place at first for being gentrified and fake? I went in and ate my words!!!! It is the perfect representation NYC slice, almost the best I’ve ever had in NYC- up with the older greats and holes in the wall pizza giants. The pizza crust has the best crunch, and you will eat the ends! Pair this with Mexican coca cola and you’re all set for a perfect pizza experience. Hope this grand opening quality lasts years to come!!
May 04 · Cézanne Bies
The Home of the Which Piece of Left Over Pizza do you want heated up?We went here to try another NYC pizza place. Meh. Not a great experience and the slices cost just as much as the other places ($6 for a margarita slice). The regular cheese slice came out of the oven soggy. … like immediately tried to eat it . The pizzas are all just sitting there and most of them 90%-100% still there.There was a place in Tucson called grandma Tony’s. It was a giant .. GIANT… cheese slice that you would add topping and they would run it through a salamander… that’s what this place seems like it’s trying to be but with all of the choices already made, regular size and not great.We only ate about 40% and then left for another place. Unheard of for us.Atmosphere: it’s a pizza place. Exactly what you’d expect.Service: the people there seem nice enough.
July 28 · Salvador Krk
Like others, I was skeptical that this pizza would be very good, mainly because the name is so generic. I absolutely loved it though! The crust is super thin and crispy, and the toppings are plentiful and taste super fresh. It didn’t seem as greasy as other places either. Honestly this might be my new go-to place for pizza.
May 09 · Mary W