Magdy’s

- 245 Park Ave, New York, NY 10167

For nearly three decades, Magdy’s has been a beloved fixture of the Midtown dining scene. More than just a simple restaurant, it's a true New York City institution, a testament to the idea that great food, generous portions, and friendly service can withstand the test of time. Magdy's specializes in a style of American comfort food that takes inspiration from classic Middle Eastern and street food flavors, particularly its famous "over rice" platters. The restaurant has garnered a loyal following of locals who appreciate its commitment to delivering a high-quality, filling meal without the high-end price tag. The atmosphere is casual and unpretentious, reflecting the no-nonsense approach to great food that has made it a success for so long.

Magdy’s is perfectly situated at 245 Park Avenue, placing it right in the heart of one of Manhattan's busiest and most iconic business districts. This location is ideal for the working crowd, offering a convenient and reliable lunch or dinner option for those in the area. Its proximity to major corporate offices and landmarks makes it a go-to spot for a quick bite. The restaurant’s popularity among locals is a clear indicator of its consistent quality and value. For those driving, paid street parking is available, which is a common feature in this bustling part of the city.

Magdy’s has streamlined its services to focus on efficiency and speed, ensuring that hungry customers get their food without a long wait, which is crucial in a neighborhood defined by its fast pace.

Services Offered

• Takeout: Magdy's is a master of the grab-and-go model. The takeout service is fast and efficient, making it the perfect choice for busy individuals on a lunch break or anyone looking for a quick and easy dinner to take home.
• Dine-in: The restaurant offers a casual dine-in experience for those who prefer to sit and enjoy their meal. The atmosphere is relaxed and comfortable, inviting you to take a brief pause from the city’s hustle.

Magdy's has built its reputation on a few key features that its customers consistently praise, highlighting its core strengths in quality, value, and service.

Features / Highlights

• Fast and Friendly Service: A standout feature is the "friendly and fast service." This efficiency is a critical part of the Magdy’s experience, ensuring that even during peak hours, the line moves quickly and you get your food without unnecessary delay.
• Generous Portions and Great Value: Customers consistently note the "good portion of food" and the "huge tin of food for around 10 bucks." The affordability, especially for a Midtown location, is a major draw. The "Recession Special" is an $8 tag that is appreciated in a high-cost area.
• Flavorful, Non-Greasy Food: A reviewer highlighted that the food is "not salty nor greasy," which is a significant plus for comfort food. This suggests a focus on balanced flavors rather than relying on excess oil or salt.
• Classic Over Rice Platters: The menu’s platters, especially the "Over Rice" options, are a signature offering. Diners can choose from favorites like "Chicken," "Lamb Gyro," or a combo, served with a base of rice and vegetables.
• Diverse Sandwiches and Platters: The menu also includes a variety of sandwiches and platters, such as the "Philly Steak" and "Grilled Chicken," catering to different tastes and cravings.
• Long-Standing Reputation: The restaurant has been in the same location for "28 years," which as one review pointed out, "gets it right all the time." This long history is a powerful testament to its consistent quality and local appeal.

Contact Information

Address: 245 Park Ave, New York, NY 10167, USA

Phone: (718) 755-2630

What is worth choosing

When you're in the bustling Midtown area and in need of a quick, satisfying meal that won't break the bank, Magdy's stands out as an exceptional choice. It's a place that has perfected a simple formula and continues to deliver on its promise of great food and great value.

The number one reason to choose Magdy’s is the unparalleled value for money. In a neighborhood where a quick lunch can easily cost upwards of $15 or $20, Magdy’s offers a "huge tin of food for around 10 bucks," as noted by a customer. This affordability, combined with the generous portions, makes it an absolute steal. The “$8 tag in midtown” is a detail that speaks volumes to those who live and work in the area, offering a rare sense of financial relief without compromising on the amount of food you receive.

Beyond the price, the quality of the food is a major draw. While not "fancy," the flavors are consistently good and, as a reviewer pointed out, the food is not overly "salty nor greasy." This balance makes the comfort food feel both satisfying and well-prepared. The "over rice" platters, a staple of the menu, are a must-try. Whether you opt for the chicken, lamb gyro, or a combo, you're guaranteed a filling and flavorful meal that has earned the loyalty of countless locals over the years. The existence of a dedicated local crowd is one of the strongest indicators of a restaurant’s true worth.

Lastly, the efficiency and speed of service are perfectly suited to the New York lifestyle. For anyone on a tight schedule, the ability to get a delicious and hot meal quickly is a huge benefit. Magdy’s has been "getting it right all the time" for over two decades, which is a rare feat in the city’s ever-changing culinary scene. This long-standing success is a testament to its reliability and consistent quality, making it a dependable choice for lunch or dinner. When you’re looking for a tried-and-true, no-frills meal that delivers on both taste and value, Magdy’s is a destination you can count on.

Magdy’s

245 Park Ave, New York, NY 10167, USA