Make My Fish

- 120 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026

If you're on the hunt for a true hidden gem in the heart of Harlem, look no further than Make My Fish. This beloved seafood spot has earned a reputation for serving some of the freshest, most flavorful fried fish in New York City. It's a no-frills, cash-only establishment with a deep-rooted community feel, where the focus is squarely on the food. Make My Fish isn't about fancy decor or an elaborate dining experience; it's about delivering authentic, soulful comfort food that keeps people coming back again and again. The menu is a celebration of classic seafood dishes, with an emphasis on perfection—each piece of fish is fried to a crispy, golden-brown exterior while remaining tender and juicy on the inside.

What sets Make My Fish apart is its commitment to quality and a strong sense of community. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, often filled with friendly chatter between the staff and regulars. It's the kind of place where customers feel at home and happy to be there, a testament to the friendly and professional service. While it's known for its seafood, the restaurant also offers a selection of classic sides that are just as popular. From creamy macaroni and cheese to savory collard greens and sweet candied yams, these sides are the perfect complement to the main dishes. This combination of delicious food, generous portions, and a warm, inviting atmosphere makes Make My Fish a true neighborhood treasure and a must-visit for anyone who loves great comfort food.

While the restaurant is a go-to for lunch and dinner, it's also important to note that it's a popular spot, and you may experience a wait, especially during peak hours. However, as many satisfied customers can attest, the wait is well worth it for the high-quality, flavorful food you're about to enjoy. The simple yet effective menu, combined with a focus on doing a few things exceptionally well, has made Make My Fish a reliable and consistent favorite for many in the community. It's a place where you can taste the dedication and passion that goes into every single dish.

Make My Fish is conveniently located at 120 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026, USA. Situated in the lively Central Harlem neighborhood, the restaurant is easily accessible for both locals and those traveling to the area. For those driving, there is both free and paid street parking available nearby, though finding a spot can be typical of New York City. The restaurant is also mindful of accessibility, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance to ensure a welcoming experience for all guests. Its location on West 116th Street makes it a perfect stop for a quick, delicious meal while exploring the historic streets of Harlem or on your way to another destination. This central location in a vibrant part of the city adds to its appeal, cementing its place as a key part of the local dining scene.

Make My Fish offers a simple and efficient service model focused on getting you your food hot and fresh. While it is a cash-only establishment, the quality and speed of service make it a trade-off that is more than worth it. Their services are designed for convenience and to cater to the on-the-go lifestyle of New Yorkers.

• Takeout: As a popular takeout spot, Make My Fish is set up for quick and easy pick-up orders. This is a great option for grabbing a meal to enjoy at home or on the go.
• Delivery: For those who prefer the convenience of home delivery, the restaurant offers this service, ensuring you can enjoy their delicious food without having to leave your location.
• Catering: If you're planning an event or a group meal, Make My Fish also provides catering services, allowing you to share their famous dishes with friends, family, or colleagues.

Make My Fish has built its strong reputation on a few key elements that make it stand out from other seafood spots in the city. These highlights are a big part of why it's considered a local favorite.

• Cash-Only Policy: A unique feature of this establishment is that it is a cash-only business. It’s important to come prepared with cash, but the quality of the food makes it a small consideration for a great meal.
• Perfectly Fried Seafood: The main draw is the exceptional quality of their fried fish and shrimp. Whether it's the Whiting Fish Fillet, Catfish Fillet, or Jumbo Shrimp, customers consistently praise the food for being crispy on the outside and tender and flavorful on the inside.
• Classic Sides: The sides are a key part of the experience, with fan favorites like creamy Macaroni And Cheese, savory Collard Greens, and sweet Candied Yams. These sides are often praised for their homemade taste.
• Community Vibe: The restaurant has a great community feel, with friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere. This sense of belonging is a major factor in why so many customers return regularly.
• Simple and Focused Menu: The menu is straightforward, focusing on what they do best: fried seafood and comfort food sides. This specialization ensures every item is prepared with expertise.
• Desserts: While not listed on the main menu, customers have raved about desserts like their banana pudding and red velvet cake, making it a great place to satisfy a sweet craving.
• Specific Offerings on Fridays: A note for customers is that on Fridays, the restaurant only sells seafood and does not offer chicken. This highlights their dedication to a specific type of cuisine on their busiest day.

For inquiries, to place a takeout order, or to find out more about their menu, you can contact Make My Fish directly using the information provided below. It's the best way to ensure your order is ready when you arrive.

Address: 120 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026, USA

Phone: (917) 388-3138

When you visit Make My Fish, you'll be faced with a menu of delicious choices, but there are a few items that stand out and are highly recommended by regulars. If you're a fan of classic fish and chips, the Catfish And Chips or the Fish And Chips (made with whiting) are excellent choices, offering a crispy exterior and a tender interior. For a combo that lets you try a bit of everything, the Shrimp And Fish Combo Bundle is a fantastic option, providing a satisfying mix of both their famous shrimp and fish. The Shrimp And Grits is a comforting and flavorful dish that has received praise from many. Don't forget to pair your main dish with their renowned sides; the Macaroni And Cheese, Collard Greens, and Candied Yams are all worth trying. For a quick and easy meal, the Catfish Sandwich is a filling and delicious choice. And as noted by a reviewer, the Half And Half beverage is a standout and the perfect drink to accompany your meal. With generous portions and a focus on quality, any choice you make at Make My Fish is likely to be a good one, but starting with these fan favorites will ensure a truly memorable and delicious experience.

Make My Fish

120 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026, USA