Mermaid Oyster Bar Times Square

- 127 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036

Nestled in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, just steps away from the dazzling lights of Broadway, you'll find Mermaid Oyster Bar Times Square, a true gem for seafood lovers. As part of a family of beloved New York seafood restaurants, this location brings a slice of coastal charm and a casually sophisticated atmosphere to one of the city's most bustling neighborhoods. Far from the typical tourist traps, Mermaid Oyster Bar is a reliable and highly-regarded spot that offers a consistent dining experience, blending a lively ambiance with a menu that is both classic and creatively inspired. Whether you're a local on a pre-theater dinner date, a group celebrating a special occasion, or a solo diner looking for a quick bite at the bar, this is a destination that feels both trendy and inviting.

The menu at Mermaid Oyster Bar is a testament to its commitment to fresh, quality ingredients. The raw bar is a major highlight, with a selection of oysters from both the East and West Coasts, as well as platters like the Baby Grand and Grand Platter, which feature a fresh assortment of oysters, clams, and other seafood. The “Nearly Famous” Lobster Roll is a crowd favorite, praised by customers for its generous filling of buttery, well-seasoned lobster and the "amazing" bread that holds it all together. Other standout entrees include the perfectly seared True North Salmon, flavorful Mermaid Fish Tacos, and the hearty 14 oz New York Strip for those who prefer turf over surf. The menu is thoughtfully curated, offering a balance of signature seafood dishes and delicious comfort food options.

Beyond the main courses, the appetizers and small plates are perfect for sharing or enjoying on their own. The New England Clam Chowder, rich with bacon and potatoes, is a must-try, as are the decadent Lobster Knuckles "Escargot Style." For something lighter, the Kale Salad or a starter of Shishito Peppers are excellent choices. The beverage program is equally impressive, with a great selection of cocktails, beer, and wine. The bar offers specialty drinks like the Spicy Margarita and the Lychee & Juliet, and a variety of draft beers, including local favorites like Montauk Wave Chaser IPA. This well-rounded menu ensures that every guest, regardless of their preference, will find something to enjoy.

One of the most appealing aspects of Mermaid Oyster Bar is its lively yet cozy atmosphere. The dining area is often described as dimly lit and intimate, making it an excellent spot for a date night or a casual catch-up with a friend. The bar, which can get packed, is a testament to the restaurant's popularity and provides a great spot to enjoy a drink and some light bites. While some reviews mention that the service, though efficient, may not always be overly warm, the staff's professionalism and the speed at which food is delivered are consistently highlighted as a major plus, especially for theatergoers with a limited timeframe. The restaurant also prides itself on being a space for everyone, drawing a diverse crowd of locals and tourists alike.

While a few reviews have noted that some dishes might feel a bit pricey for the portion, the overall consensus is that the food is high-quality and the experience is reliable. The happy hour, which runs until 5:30 PM, is particularly popular, offering great deals on oysters, mini fish tacos, and a selection of discounted drinks. For anyone seeking a dependable and delicious seafood meal in a location that's often dominated by tourist-oriented eateries, Mermaid Oyster Bar is a refreshing and a very reliable pick. It’s a place that delivers on its promise of fresh, well-prepared seafood in a comfortable and trendy setting, making it a great destination for a variety of occasions.

Location and Accessibility

Mermaid Oyster Bar is conveniently situated at 127 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036, USA. This prime location places it in the heart of the Theater District, making it a perfect spot for pre-show dining or a post-show drink. The restaurant is easily accessible by foot from many Broadway theaters and is just a short walk from major subway lines, including the Times Square-42nd Street station. The establishment is fully committed to accessibility, offering a wheelchair accessible entrance, restroom, and seating, ensuring all guests can dine with ease. While there is no dedicated private lot, paid street parking is available nearby.

Services Offered

• Dine-in with table service for a full, relaxing meal.
• Takeout options for those who prefer to enjoy their food elsewhere.
• Happy hour drinks and small plates specials.
• Accepts reservations, which are highly recommended for dinner, especially on show nights.
• Full bar onsite with a great selection of cocktails, wine, and beer.
• Provides high chairs for guests with children.

Features / Highlights

• Celebrated for its raw bar with a fresh selection of East and West Coast oysters.
• Known for having a great beer selection, great cocktails, and a strong wine list.
• Famous for its "Nearly Famous" Lobster Roll and other standout dishes like the Mermaid Fish Tacos.
• Offers a popular happy hour with discounted oysters and drinks.
• Trendy, casual, and cozy atmosphere, suitable for various occasions, from dates to group dinners.
• Provides fast and efficient service, perfect for pre-theater dining.
• Serves late-night food, catering to a post-show crowd.
• Accommodates a diverse crowd of locals, groups, and tourists.

Contact Information

Address: 127 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036, USA

Phone: (212) 675-9794

What is worth choosing

What makes Mermaid Oyster Bar a truly worthwhile choice is its ability to deliver an authentic and high-quality seafood experience right in the middle of a notoriously tourist-heavy area. The freshness of their seafood, especially the oysters on their raw bar and the lobster in their famous lobster roll, is consistently praised by patrons. The grand platter is an excellent way to start a meal, offering a fresh, clean, and beautifully presented taste of their best offerings. Another key factor is the restaurant's dual nature: it's a perfect spot for a full, seated dinner with delicious entrees, yet it also excels as a casual bar for a quick drink and a few small plates. The happy hour is a fantastic deal, making it possible to enjoy high-quality oysters and drinks at a more accessible price point. The location is an obvious advantage for those visiting or working in the area, particularly for theatergoers looking for a reliable pre-show meal. While the ambiance and service may be more efficient than overtly warm, the focus remains on the food and the speed of service, which is a major benefit in this busy part of town. For a consistent, high-quality seafood meal in a central and trendy setting, Mermaid Oyster Bar is a fantastic and dependable pick.

Mermaid Oyster Bar Times Square

127 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036, USA