Brunch & Snack Chat
Brunch & Snack ChatBites & BanterBest Restaurants Near Me
Ohio

Brunch & Snack ChatBest Restaurants Near MeNew YorkNew York CountyNew YorkBest Restaurants in Amsterdam AvenueMi Casita
Mi Casita ico

Mi Casita
- 1484 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031

Mexican restaurant, Delivery Restaurant ★3.0 (13)·$10–20

1484 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

3.0
12$ 8/10 Tinga Tostadas(3); Ingredients were freshly cut and and portion was enough to fill me up. A bit disappointing that the tostadas seem to be the Guerrero ones from the supermarket or those that you buy for 2$ where as other authentic mexican restaurants have them home madeI had a good time here! I stayed for a while due to La Rosa de Guadalupe playing lol and the good environment🌮Back to FOOD, I also had a carnitas Taco🌮Being mexican, I'd say the tortilla was little undercooked to the point of breaking by the last bite, 30 seconds would of made it just the way I like it. If youre not Mexican you probably wont mind🤷‍♂️But! Ingredients were VERY freshBeing that I didnt ask for crispy tortilla, I wont hurt the Tacos grading but I'll give it a 10/10Server was friendly and fast! - David H
Mi Casita Overview Intro Vibe Detail Photos Location Reviews
$10–20 per person Reported by 13 people$1–10$10–20$20–30

Mi Casita Introduce

In the vibrant heart of New York City, where a world of cuisines converges, finding a spot that offers truly authentic and soulful Mexican food can feel like a quest. Thankfully, for residents and visitors alike, there's a cozy and welcoming gem that has been serving up the real deal: Mi Casita. Located in a bustling and easily accessible part of the city, this restaurant stands out by delivering a taste of home-cooked Mexican flavors with every dish. It's not just a place to eat; it's a place to experience the warmth and tradition of Mexican culinary art. From flavorful breakfast options to hearty dinners and late-night quick bites, Mi Casita has become a go-to spot for those craving genuine, fresh, and delicious Mexican fare. Whether you're a local looking for your new favorite spot or a tourist wanting to step away from the usual dining scene, Mi Casita offers a friendly and flavorful escape.

What sets Mi Casita apart is its dedication to freshness and authenticity. The menu is a testament to the rich and diverse flavors of Mexico, featuring classic dishes prepared with care and precision. The casual and cozy atmosphere makes it an ideal setting for any occasion—whether it's a quick lunch, a relaxed dinner with friends, or a solo dining experience where you can savor every bite. Patrons often describe the place as a "mom and pop shop," a description that perfectly captures its unpretentious, homey feel and the personal touch that goes into every meal. The fast service and friendly staff only add to the inviting atmosphere, making you feel like you're part of the family from the moment you walk in. For those in New York seeking comfort food that tastes like it was made with love, Mi Casita is the answer.


Mi Casita is conveniently situated at 1484 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA. Its prime location makes it a breeze to get to from many parts of the city. Located in a well-trafficked area, the restaurant is easily accessible by various modes of public transportation, including subways and buses, making it a great choice for both locals and those traveling from different boroughs. For those who prefer to drive, there are options for street parking in the vicinity, though it's always wise to check for availability, especially during peak hours. The restaurant is also designed with accessibility in mind, featuring wheelchair-accessible seating to ensure that everyone can enjoy a comfortable dining experience. Whether you're passing through or making a special trip, finding your way to Mi Casita is straightforward, and the delicious food that awaits is well worth the journey.


Mi Casita offers a comprehensive range of services designed to cater to every customer's needs, whether they're dining in, grabbing food to go, or enjoying a meal at home. The restaurant provides a variety of convenient options to make your experience as smooth as possible.

  • No-contact delivery: For those who prefer to stay in, Mi Casita offers safe and convenient no-contact delivery, bringing their delicious food directly to your doorstep.
  • Delivery: Standard delivery service is also available, ensuring you can enjoy your favorite dishes from the comfort of your home.
  • Takeout: If you're on the go, you can easily place an order for takeout and pick it up at your convenience.
  • Dine-in: The cozy and casual atmosphere of the restaurant is perfect for enjoying a meal right there. With table service and ample seating, you can relax and savor your food at your own pace.
  • Reservations: Mi Casita accepts reservations, which is particularly helpful for groups or for securing a table during busy times.
  • Payment Options: The restaurant accepts a variety of payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and hassle-free.

Mi Casita is celebrated for a number of features and highlights that contribute to its outstanding reputation. From the quality of the food to the overall dining experience, there are many reasons why this spot has become a local favorite.

  • Fast Service: One of the most frequently praised aspects of Mi Casita is its efficient and friendly service. Despite the small, family-run feel, the staff works quickly to get your food to you without compromising on quality.
  • Authentic Mexican Dishes: The menu is packed with traditional Mexican dishes that taste like they were prepared in a family kitchen. From classic tacos and burritos to more elaborate plates like Mole Rojo de Pollo and Chile Relleno de Queso, the food is authentic and flavorful.
  • Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner: Mi Casita is a great option for any meal of the day. The restaurant is popular for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, offering a wide array of options to suit your craving at any time.
  • Solo Dining: The casual and welcoming atmosphere makes it a perfect place for solo diners to enjoy a great meal without any fuss.
  • Healthy Options and Quick Bites: The menu includes healthy choices like various salads and grilled chicken, alongside quick bite items for when you need a fast and satisfying meal.
  • Full Bar with Cocktails and Wine: Mi Casita offers a selection of alcoholic beverages, including cocktails and wine, to complement your meal. There's even happy hour food to make your evening even better.
  • Family-Friendly: The restaurant is good for kids, offering a kids' menu and high chairs to accommodate families of all sizes.

For inquiries, reservations, or to place an order, you can contact Mi Casita using the following information:

Address: 1484 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

Phone: (212) 234-3331

Mobile Phone: +1 212-234-3331


Choosing Mi Casita isn't just about grabbing a meal; it's about indulging in a culinary experience that is both authentic and deeply satisfying. When you're in New York and looking for a place that delivers on taste, value, and atmosphere, here's why Mi Casita is an excellent choice. One of the restaurant's biggest strengths is its commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients. As noted by a customer, the ingredients for dishes like the Tostadas and Tacos are "freshly cut" and taste vibrant. This dedication to freshness is evident in every dish, from the crisp vegetables in the salads to the perfectly seasoned meats in the tacos and burritos.

The variety on the menu is another major draw. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty breakfast of Huevos Rancheros, a classic lunch of Enchiladas, or a dinner of a traditional Mexican plate like Carne Asada, there's something to please every palate. The extensive options ensure that you can return multiple times and still have new dishes to discover. Another standout feature is the authentic flavor profile. As one patron, who is Mexican, remarked, the food tastes like a "mom and pop shop" and "tastes authentic." While they might offer a few helpful suggestions to improve, the overall sentiment is that the food is genuine and true to its roots. This is a huge plus for anyone looking to avoid Tex-Mex and enjoy the real flavors of Mexico.

The atmosphere at Mi Casita is relaxed and inviting, described as both casual and cozy. It's a place where you can feel comfortable whether you're dining alone or with a group. The friendly and fast service, which has been praised by many, contributes significantly to the positive experience. The staff makes you feel welcome, and their efficiency ensures that you're not waiting long for your food, even when the restaurant is busy. This makes it an ideal spot for a quick lunch break or a satisfying dinner after a long day.

Finally, Mi Casita offers great value. The portion sizes are generous, providing enough to fill you up without an exorbitant price tag. This combination of fresh, authentic food, excellent service, and fair prices makes Mi Casita a truly worthwhile choice for anyone in New York. It’s a testament to the idea that some of the best culinary experiences come from small, family-run businesses that put their heart and soul into every dish they serve.

Mi Casita Vibe

  • Desayunos

    Served with rice, beans and corn tortillas.

  • Omelette con Pimiento Verde, Rojo, Tomate, Cebolla y Chorizo $6.50

    Omelette served with green pepper, red pepper, tomato, onion and chorizo.

  • Huevos y Jamon con Papas Fritas $6.50

    Eggs and ham with French fries.

  • Huevos con Tocino y Papas Fritas $6.50

    Eggs with bacon and French fries.

  • Huevos con Salchicha y Papas $6.50

    Eggs with sausage and fries.

  • Huevos en Salsa Verde $6.00

    Scrambled eggs with red sauce.

  • Huevos en Salsa Roja $6.00

    Scrambled eggs with green sauce.

  • Huevos a la Mexicana $6.50

    Scrambled eggs with tomatoes, onion and jalapeno.

  • Huevos al Gusto $6.00

    Egg any style, with yellow American cheese, ham or chorizo.

  • Huevos con Cecina $7.50

    Eggs any style with salted beef.

  • Huevos Rancheros $7.50

    Two eggs sunny side up with guacamole, pico de gallo, y queso blanco on a lightly fried corn tortilla.

  • Salad (Ensalada)

    All salads are with olive oil.

  • Ensalada De La Casa (House Salad) $7.50

    Served with lettuce, onions, peppers, tomatoes, carrots and avocado.

  • Ensalad De Pollo Asado (Grilled Chicken Salad) $10.00

    With lettuce, onions, peppers, tomatoes, carrots.

  • Pollo Asado Ensalada (Grilled Chicken Breast Salad) $10.50
  • Ensalada de Camaron (Shrimp Salad) $14.00
  • Ensalada con Bistec (Steak Salad) $11.00
  • Enchiladas

    3 soft corn tortilla rolled stuffed with meal and green mole sauce topped with cotija cheese and sour cream. Served with rice and beans.

  • Enchiladas Rojas con Pollo $11.00

    Enchiladas with red sauce with chicken.

  • Enchiladas Verde con Pollo $11.00

    Enchiladas with green sauce with chicken.

  • Enchiladas Rojas con Puerco $11.00

    Enchiladas with red sauce with pork.

  • Enchiladas Verde con Puerco $11.00

    Enchiladas with green sauce with pork.

  • Enchiladas Rojas con Bistec $11.50

    Enchiladas with red sauce and steak.

  • Enchiladas Verdes con Bistec $11.50

    Enchiladas with green sauce and steak.

  • Enchiladas de Camaron $15.00

    Shrimp enchiladas.

  • Enchilada de Cecina $13.00

    Enchiladas with salted beef.

  • Enchiladas Rojas (Plain) $9.00
  • Enchiladas Rojas (Plain) $9.00
  • Tacos

    Corn tortilla stuffed with onions, cilantro, tomatoes and your choice of meat.

  • Al Pastor Taco $3.00

    Pork marinated with pineapple and onions.

  • Pollo (Chicken) Taco $3.00
  • Vegetales Taco $3.00
  • Carne Enchilada (Spicy Pork Meat) Taco $3.00
  • Chorizo (Mexican Sausage) Taco $3.00
  • Carnitas (Shredded Pork) Taco $3.00
  • Cecina (Salted Beef) Taco $3.00
  • Bistec (Steak) Taco $3.00
  • Lengua (Beef Tongue) Taco $3.50
  • Typical Mexican Dishes

    Served with rice, beans and corn tortilla and hot sauce. Extras (Optional - Choose up to 5): Extra Creme (Sour Cream) - $0.50, Extra Guacamole - $1.50, Pico de Gallo - $0.50, Salsa Verde (Green Sauce) - $1, Salsa Roja (Red Sauce) - $1.

  • Mole Rojo de Pollo $11.95

    Dark or white meat chicken with sweet and spicy ancho and poblano chili.

  • Molo Verde de Pollo $11.95

    Dark or white meat chicken with sweet and spicy ancho and tomatillo.

  • Mole Rojo de Puerco $11.95

    Pork with sweet and spicy ancho and poblano chili.

  • Molo Verde de Puerco $11.95

    Pork with sweet and spicy ancho and tomatillo.

  • Pipian de Pollo $11.50

    Pumpkin seed sauce with dark or white meat chicken.

  • Pipian de Puerco $11.50

    A thick and spicy guajillo chili sauce with chicken.

  • Chile ajo de Pureco $11.50

    A thick and spicy guajillo chili sauce with pork.

  • Chili ajo de Pollo $11.50

    A thick and spicy guajillo chili sauce with chicken.

  • MIlanese de Pollo $11.00

    Breaded breast of chicken milanese served with rice, beans and a corn tortilla.

  • Bistec a la Mexicana $12.50

    Mexican style steak with onion, tomatoes and sliced jalapenos.

  • Carne Asada (Pounded Grilled Steak) $12.50
  • Bistec Encebollado $12.50

    Pounded grilled steak.

  • Chuletas de Puerco al Gusto $12.50

    Grilled or sauteed pork chops with mole sauce or green salsa.

  • Pechuga a la Mexicana $12.50

    Con salsa de tomate, arroz y frijoles. Chicken with tomato sauce, rice and beans.

  • Chile Relleno de Queso $11.00

    Cheese stuffed poblano pepper with rice, beans and corn tortillas.

  • Pollo a la Parmellana $12.00

    Con salsa de tomate, arroz y frijoles. Chicken with tomato sauce, rice and beans.

  • Pollo Chipotle $13.00

    Pollo blando (pechuga) y salsa picante. Tender chicken breast and hot sauce.

  • Hamburguesas (Hamburgers)

  • Cheeseburger $4.50
  • Cheeseburger Superior $6.50

    Served with French fries and salad.

  • Cheeseburger Al Estilo Mexicano $7.00

    Served with French fries, salad and jalapenos.

  • Tostadas - Fried Corn Tortilla

    3 crispy flat corn tortilla layered with beans, onions, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, sour cream. Extras: Extra Creme (Sour Cream) - $0.50, Extra Guacamole - $1.50, Pico de Gallo - $0.50, Salsa Verde (Green Sauce) - $1, Salsa Roja (Red Sauce) - $1.

  • Tostada sin Carne $8.00

    Without meat.

  • Vegetales (Veggie) Tostada $10.50
  • Pollo (Chicken) Tostada $10.50
  • Tinga De Pollo Tostada $10.50

    Shredded chicken in a chipotle tomato and onion sauce.

  • Carnitas (Shredded Pork) Tostada $10.50
  • Chorizo (Mexican Sausage) Tostada $10.50
  • Cecina (Salted Beef) Tostada $12.00
  • Al Pastor Tostada $12.00

    Pork marinated with pineapple and onions.

  • Bistec (Steak) Tostada $12.00
  • Tortas - Mexican Sandwich

    All sandwiches served with beans, tomatoes, lettuce, onions, avocado, quesso cheddar and pickle.

  • MIlanesa de Pollo Torta $7.50

    Breaded chicken breast.

  • Pollo Asado Torta $7.50

    Grilled chicken.

  • Tinga de Pollo Torta $7.50

    Shredded chicken in a chipotle tomato and onion sauce.

  • Carnitas Torta $7.50

    Shredded pork.

  • Cecina Torta $7.00

    Salted beef.

  • Chorizo y Huevo Torta $7.50

    Mexican sausage and scrambled eggs.

  • Carne Enchilada Torta $7.50

    Spicy pork meat.

  • Queso Fundido Y Jamon Torta $7.50

    Melted mozzarella cheese and ham.

  • Steak and Cheese Torta $7.50

    Served with mozzarella cheese.

  • Burritos

    Soft flour tortilla rolled and stuffed with rice, beans, lettuce, sour cream, mozzarella cheese, guacamole and choice of meat. Extra Creme (Sour Cream) - $0.50, Extra Guacamole - $1.50, Pico de Gallo - $0.50, Salsa Verde (Green Sauce) - $1, Salsa Roja (Red Sauce) - $1.

  • Bistec (Steak) Burrito (12") $9.95
  • Pollo a la Brasa (Grilled Chicken Breast) Burrito (12") $9.95
  • Carnitas Burrito (12") $8.95

    Shredded pork.

  • Camaron (Shrimp) Burrito (12") $12.00
  • Queso Fundido (Melted Cheese) Burrito (12") $8.50
  • Pollo Con Mole Burrito (12") $11.50

    Spicy chicken with red mole sauce.

  • Camaron (Shrimp) Burrito (12") $12.00
  • Vegetariano Burrito (12") $9.50
  • Tinga Burrito (12") $8.50

    Shredded chicken in tomato and onion chipotle sauce.

  • Burrito de Huevo Revuelto (12") $8.50

    Scrambled eggs burrito.

  • Camaron (Shrimp) Burrito (12") $12.00
  • Vegetariano Burrito (12") $9.50
  • Tinga Burrito (12") $8.50

    Shredded chicken in tomato and onion chipotle sauce.

  • Burrito de Huevo Revuelto (12") $8.50

    Scrambled eggs burrito.

  • Burrito Al Pastor (12") $10.00

    Pork marinated meat with pineapple and onions.

  • Pollo (Chicken) Burrito (10") $6.50
  • Chorizo (Sausage) Burrito (10") $6.50
  • Bistec (Steak) Burrito (10") $6.50
  • Carnitas (Shredded Pork) Burrito (10") $6.50
  • Vegetariano (Vegetarian) Burrito (10") $6.50
  • Carne Enchilada y Al Pastor Burrito (10") $6.50

    Spicy meat and roasted pork.

  • Side Orders

  • Papas Fritas (French Fries) $3.00
  • Guacamole with Chips $8.00
  • Tortilla Chips and Salsa $3.50
  • Chile en Vinagre (Pickled Jalapenos) (8oz) $2.00
  • Crema (Sour Cream) (8oz) $2.00
  • Arroz (Yellow Rice) (32 oz) $8.00
  • Frijol (Black Beans) (32 oz) $10.00
  • Salsa Verde (Green Sauce) $3.00
  • Salsa Roja (Red Sauce) $3.00
  • Arroz (Yellow Rice) (8 oz) $2.50
  • Frijol (Black Beans) (8 oz) $2.50
  • Dessert

  • Flan (Homemade) $3.50
  • Cheese Cake $4.00
  • Bebidas (Drinks)

  • Horchata $3.50
  • Seltzer $2.00
  • Sidral $2.00

    Mexican apple soda.

  • Sodas $1.25

    Choice of Coke, Diet Coke, Gingerale or Sprite.

  • Bottled Water $2.00
  • Jamaica $3.50
  • Sangria $2.00
  • Jarritos $2.00

    Choice of pineapple, grapefruit, tamarind or mandarin.

  • Jumex (Mexican Juice) $2.00
  • Sour Cream (8 oz) $2.00

Mi Casita Details

  • Service options

  • No-contact delivery
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • Highlights

  • Fast service
  • Popular for

  • Breakfast
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining
  • Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Offerings

  • Alcohol
  • Cocktails
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
  • Happy hour food
  • Healthy options
  • Quick bite
  • Wine
  • Dining options

  • Breakfast
  • Brunch
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Dessert
  • Seating
  • Table service
  • Amenities

  • Restroom
  • Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Cozy
  • Trendy
  • Crowd

  • Locals
  • Tourists
  • Planning

  • Accepts reservations
  • Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards
  • Children

  • Good for kids
  • High chairs
  • Kids' menu

Mi Casita Photos

Mi Casita Picture 1Mi Casita Picture 2Mi Casita Picture 3Mi Casita Picture 4Mi Casita Picture 5Mi Casita Picture 6Mi Casita Picture 7Mi Casita Picture 8Mi Casita Picture 9Mi Casita Picture 10

Mi Casita Location

Mi Casita

1484 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

Mi Casita Reviews

An average rating of ★3.6 from 123 user reviews.

pricetacosbeanstortillatostadasdeliveryhometortasteaksalsa

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More Best Restaurants Near Me

  • La Casita Taqueria RestaurantLa Casita Taqueria Restaurant4.0 (24 reviews)

    1484 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

  • MakanaMakana3.0 (63 reviews)

    1502 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

  • Kennedy Chicken & BurgersKennedy Chicken & Burgers4.0 (6 reviews)

    1502 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

  • RAIRAIKEN UPTOWNRAIRAIKEN UPTOWN4.0 (214 reviews)

    1467 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10027, USA

  • Sushi SushiSushi Sushi4.0 (325 reviews)

    1504 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

  • TORI-BIENTORI-BIEN4.0 (47 reviews)

    1467 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10027, USA

  • American RestaurantAmerican Restaurant4.0 (14 reviews)

    1465 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10027, USA

  • Uptown WingzUptown Wingz4.0 (48 reviews)

    1461 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10027, USA

  • Ten DragonTen Dragon3.0 (64 reviews)

    1516 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

  • Amsterdam SushiAmsterdam Sushi3.0 (177 reviews)

    1518 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

  • Los PanchitosLos Panchitos4.0 (12 reviews)

    482 W 135th St, New York, NY 10031, USA

  • Fork & KeyFork & Key4.0 (44 reviews)

    1453 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10027, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Trending Bites & Banter Posts