Milano Pizza Shop

- 2255 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029

In a city famous for its pizza, Milano Pizza Shop holds its own as a cherished local establishment in East Harlem. It's the kind of unpretentious, straightforward pizzeria that defines the classic New York slice experience. Serving a wide variety of Italian-American comfort food, from classic round pies to hearty hero sandwiches and pasta dishes, Milano Pizza Shop has become a go-to for a quick, satisfying meal. The place has a relaxed, casual vibe that makes it popular with a diverse crowd, including college students and tourists, all seeking a taste of authentic New York.

While a few delivery-related hiccups have been mentioned in customer reviews, the overall consensus for in-store dining and the quality of the food remains overwhelmingly positive. Customers consistently praise the fresh ingredients, the perfect balance of flavors, and the friendly nature of the staff. It's a place that seems to focus on doing one thing exceptionally well: providing delicious, no-frills food that feels like a true neighborhood gem. This article will provide a comprehensive guide to Milano Pizza Shop, covering everything from its location and accessibility to its menu highlights and what makes it a local institution.

Milano Pizza Shop is conveniently located at 2255 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029. This address places it firmly in the East Harlem area, a vibrant and bustling neighborhood. The location on a major avenue makes it easily reachable by public transportation, with bus stops and subway stations a short walk away. This accessibility is a key factor for a spot that serves a lot of walk-in and takeout customers.

The shop is designed for efficiency and ease of access. It features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, making it a welcoming spot for all diners. While the atmosphere is described as casual and sometimes a bit trendy, the primary focus is on quick service, which is perfect for a quick lunch or dinner on the go. The establishment's setup, with its focus on counter service and a small dining area, is typical of many classic New York pizzerias.

Milano Pizza Shop provides several services to accommodate its customers' needs, ensuring that a great meal is always within reach.

• Delivery: The shop offers delivery, which is a popular option for locals who want to enjoy a fresh meal at home or at the office.
• Takeout: For those on the move, takeout is a primary service, allowing customers to quickly grab their order from the counter and be on their way.
• Dine-in: Milano Pizza Shop has seating available for those who prefer to eat on-site and soak in the casual, welcoming atmosphere.
• Catering: The restaurant also provides catering services for larger events or parties. Customers can order trays of their favorite dishes, from lasagna and baked ziti to chicken parmigiana, making it a perfect choice for feeding a crowd.

These services, from quick slices to full catering trays, highlight the shop's versatility and commitment to serving the community in various capacities.

Milano Pizza Shop is more than just a place to grab a slice; it has several key features that contribute to its "hidden gem" reputation.

• Authentic New York Pizza: The star of the show is, of course, the pizza. The shop is celebrated for its classic Italian pies, with a perfect balance of crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and gooey cheese.
• Quality Ingredients: A key highlight mentioned in customer reviews is the use of good, fresh ingredients. This commitment to quality is evident in the taste of both the pizzas and the other menu items.
• Diverse Menu: Beyond pizza, the menu is extensive, offering a full range of Italian-American comfort food. From classic hero sandwiches like Chicken Parmigiana and Meatball Parmigiana to hearty pasta dishes like Lasagna and Baked Ziti, there's something to satisfy every craving.
• Cash-Only Policy: A distinctive feature of this establishment is that it is a cash-only business. While this may be a slight inconvenience for some, it is a common practice in many authentic, no-frills New York establishments and adds to its old-school charm.
• Friendly and Efficient Staff: Many customers praise the staff for their friendliness and fast service. This positive interaction enhances the dining experience and makes the shop feel like a genuine neighborhood spot.
• Catering Services: The availability of catering trays for a variety of popular dishes makes this a go-to spot for parties, family gatherings, or office lunches.

These highlights collectively contribute to the shop's reputation as a reliable and high-quality local pizzeria.

For placing an order, confirming operating hours, or any other inquiries, you can reach out to Milano Pizza Shop using the following contact information.

Address: 2255 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA

Phone: (212) 996-5141

These contact details make it easy for customers to connect with the restaurant directly.

The menu at Milano Pizza Shop is full of delicious options, but a few items stand out based on customer feedback and general popularity. The most essential choice is, without a doubt, a classic slice of pizza. Whether you opt for a Regular Slice or a Sicilian Slice, you can expect a perfectly prepared piece that embodies the essence of New York pizza. One reviewer even called the pizza "the best" they've ever had, with a "perfect balance of crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and gooey cheese." The Chicken Cutlet Slice is another popular choice, praised for its generous toppings and fresh ingredients.

Beyond the pizza, the hot hero sandwiches are a major draw. The Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana sandwich is a common order, although some customer experiences with delivery have been mixed on this particular item. However, when made in-house, it's often a fresh and satisfying choice. For those looking for a different hero, the Meatball Parmigiana or Eggplant Parmigiana are classic Italian choices that showcase the quality of the ingredients and the flavorful sauce.

For a full meal, the pasta dishes are a great option. The Lasagna and Baked Ziti are hearty and comforting choices, perfect for a sit-down meal. And for a perfect side or snack, the Garlic Knots are a must-try. They are a classic addition to any order and can be enjoyed on their own or with a side of sauce.

While one customer had a negative experience with a specific delivery order, the other reviews highlight the consistent quality of the food, especially when it's fresh and hot. The phrase "hidden gem that absolutely delivers on flavor and service" sums up the overall sentiment of many patrons who appreciate the straightforward, high-quality food and friendly service that Milano Pizza Shop provides.

Milano Pizza Shop

2255 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA