One if by Land, Two if by Sea

- 17 Barrow St, New York, NY 10014

For New Yorkers seeking a dining experience that transcends a simple meal, a place that is as much about the atmosphere as it is about the food, One if by Land, Two if by Sea stands as an iconic and unparalleled destination. Often cited as the most romantic restaurant in New York City, this establishment is more than just a place to eat; it is a journey into history, elegance, and pure enchantment. It’s a place where the hustle of Manhattan disappears, replaced by the soft glow of candlelight and the gentle melodies of a baby grand piano.

The restaurant is housed in a land-marked carriage house built in 1767, once owned by Aaron Burr, the third Vice President of the United States. This rich history permeates every corner of the venue, from the original brick fireplaces to the hand-made horseshoes and antique bottles that serve as reminders of its past. The decor is nothing short of breathtaking, with grand chandeliers, floor-to-ceiling windows, and a private garden that adds to the feeling of a hidden, secret world. It’s no wonder that this has become the go-to spot for special occasions, with more marriage proposals taking place here than any other restaurant in the city.

The culinary experience at One if by Land, Two if by Sea is as refined as its setting. The menu is a testament to classic American cuisine, elevated with modern techniques and the finest ingredients. The restaurant offers a Three-Course Prix Fixe menu, along with a seasonal Chef's Tasting Menu, ensuring a curated and exceptional dining journey. Every dish is crafted with an artist's touch, both beautiful to behold and exquisite in flavor. The dining experience is complemented by a thoughtful wine list, a full bar, and a selection of cocktails, ensuring that every element of your meal is perfect.

From the moment you step off the cobblestone streets of the West Village and into the historic building, you are greeted with a warmth and professionalism that is both rare and refreshing. The service is often described as "flawless," with a staff that is not only attentive but also genuinely kind and knowledgeable. It is this combination of stunning ambiance, exquisite food, and impeccable service that solidifies One if by Land, Two if by Sea's reputation as a truly magical dining destination.

One if by Land, Two if by Sea is discreetly located at 17 Barrow St, New York, NY 10014, USA, on a quiet, charming street that feels worlds away from the city's noise. The West Village neighborhood itself adds to the experience, with its historic charm and romantic feel. The restaurant's location is easily accessible by various subway lines, making it a convenient destination for a romantic evening out, no matter where you are in the city.

For those driving, an unaffiliated parking garage, "Sheridan Square Parking," is located across the street. While the building is a historic landmark, it offers modern accommodations for its guests. According to public information, the facilities are wheelchair accessible, making it a welcoming space for all. Due to its popularity as a premier dining and event venue, reservations are essential for dining and can be made by contacting the restaurant directly.

One if by Land, Two if by Sea provides a suite of services that cater to its clientele's high expectations for fine dining and special events.

• Dine-in: The primary service, offering an unforgettable multi-course dining experience in a historic and romantic setting.
• Private Dining & Events: The restaurant can be booked for special events, including weddings, anniversaries, and corporate functions, accommodating up to 130 seated guests.
• Reservations: Guests are encouraged to make reservations, as the restaurant's exclusive and sought-after nature means it is often booked well in advance.
• Entertainment: Live piano music is a nightly feature, creating an elegant and soothing backdrop for your meal.
• Bar & Lounge: A separate bar and lounge area is available for those who wish to enjoy cocktails, a lighter menu, or a pre-dinner drink.

This restaurant is celebrated for a number of features that contribute to its legendary status.

• Iconic Romantic Setting: Renowned for its candlelit tables, brick fireplaces, and live piano music, it is consistently named one of the most romantic restaurants in the world.
• Historic Location: Housed in a land-marked 18th-century carriage house, the venue itself is a destination with a rich history connected to Aaron Burr.
• Exquisite Cuisine: Known for its classic American menu, including the famously divine Beef Wellington, and a seasonal Chef's Tasting Menu.
• Flawless Service: The staff is celebrated for being warm, attentive, and knowledgeable, providing a personalized and memorable experience.
• Accommodates Special Events: A premier venue for weddings, engagements, and anniversaries, with options for private dining and full buyouts.
• Grand Decor: The stunning interior, with its elegant chandeliers, baby grand piano, and lush garden views, creates a truly enchanting atmosphere.
• Live Piano Music: A permanent fixture, the live piano music adds to the restaurant’s timeless and romantic ambiance, performed nightly.

For reservations or inquiries about private events, you can reach One if by Land, Two if by Sea at:

Address: 17 Barrow St, New York, NY 10014, USA
Phone: (212) 255-8649

For anyone considering a visit to One if by Land, Two if by Sea, the question isn't just about what to order, but what experience you're seeking. The restaurant is a destination for a reason, and there are several elements that make it an unparalleled choice for a special occasion.

First and foremost, the Beef Wellington is legendary. It is consistently praised as "divine" and "one of the best," a classic dish that the restaurant has perfected. It's a must-try for any first-time visitor. The prix-fixe and tasting menus are carefully curated to provide a full and balanced culinary journey, and they are the best way to experience the breadth of the chef's talents. The wine pairings, guided by a knowledgeable sommelier like Kirk, can elevate the entire meal, adding a layer of sophistication and depth.

However, what truly makes this restaurant worth choosing is its ability to create a sense of magic. The atmosphere, with its flickering candlelight and live piano music, is what you're paying for, and it delivers on every level. Customer reviews highlight how the setting makes you feel "as if the city had disappeared for a night." The discreet location on a quiet, cobblestone street adds to the feeling of "discovering a secret."

The service is another key component. The staff's warmth and attentiveness, with specific mentions of waiters like Michael and bread servers like Nicky, demonstrate a genuine commitment to making guests feel special. They go "above and beyond" to ensure every detail is handled with care. This personal touch is what transforms a fine dining experience into a truly cherished memory.

Finally, One if by Land, Two if by Sea is a destination for life's most significant moments. From proposals to anniversaries and birthdays, the restaurant's reputation for celebrating love and special occasions is well-earned. The private tables, especially those with a view of the garden, offer a secluded and romantic setting that is hard to find anywhere else in New York City. Choosing to dine here is not just about a meal; it's about investing in an experience that is timeless, elegant, and full of love.

One if by Land, Two if by Sea

17 Barrow St, New York, NY 10014, USA