Your Local Papa Johns Pizza: Quality Pizza and Convenient Service in Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Papa Johns Pizza Photos

Papa Johns Pizza Introduce

For residents of Reynoldsburg and the wider Ohio region, Papa Johns Pizza at 7061 E Main St has long been a familiar name for pizza delivery and carryout. As a well-known national franchise, this location aims to provide a consistent and convenient experience for those craving pizza, breadsticks, wings, and more. With a brand commitment to using "Better Ingredients," the store offers a wide variety of pizzas with different crust options, from the classic Original to the New York Style, catering to a diverse range of preferences within the community. Whether you're looking for a quick dinner after a long day or a feast for a family movie night, this Papa Johns location provides a menu that is both extensive and easily accessible, making it a reliable option for many local households.

The menu at Papa Johns is a central part of its appeal. Beyond the standard cheese and pepperoni pizzas, this location offers a wide array of specialty pizzas, such as The Works, The Meats, and the BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza. For those who enjoy a bit of a kick, options like the Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza are available. The menu also includes a variety of crusts, including the popular Epic Stuffed Crust and the Garlic 5-Cheese Crust, which provides customers with a wealth of choices to customize their meal. Complementing the pizza are numerous side dishes like garlic knots, cheesesticks, and a selection of wings in various flavors. Dessert options, such as the Double Chocolate Chip Brownie and Cinnamon Pull Aparts, are also on hand to complete the meal. This extensive selection is a key reason why many in Reynoldsburg turn to Papa Johns for their pizza needs, as it provides something for everyone in the family.

While a few customer reviews have expressed disappointment with the quality of food, noting issues with bland crust and undercooked items, other feedback, especially from those using third-party delivery services, indicates a more positive experience with items like pepperoni pizza being rated highly. The mixed feedback suggests that while some experiences may vary, the restaurant is a go-to for many locals. The service for in-store pickup is generally described as fine, focusing on efficiency, which is what many customers expect from a fast-food establishment. This location’s brand is built on convenience and a well-known product, and for many, it successfully delivers on this promise. The sheer volume of orders and the wide availability of the menu through various channels indicate that despite some critical feedback, the restaurant remains a popular choice.

The Papa Johns Pizza at 7061 E Main St is very well-located within Reynoldsburg, Ohio. Positioned on a major thoroughfare, East Main Street, the restaurant is easily accessible for people traveling by car. This location is part of a commercial area, which typically means that parking is available and easy to navigate. Its central placement makes it a convenient stop for a quick carryout order on the way home from work or for those looking to pick up a pizza before heading to a local event. The address is straightforward to find using GPS, and its presence on a main road ensures that it is a familiar and easy-to-reach destination for many in the Reynoldsburg community and surrounding neighborhoods.

The restaurant's services are designed for maximum convenience and accessibility. Papa Johns at this location is open late, with carryout and delivery hours extending well into the evening, making it a great option for late-night cravings or last-minute dinner plans.

Delivery Service: Papa Johns is well-known for its delivery, and this location offers this service to the local area. Customers can place an order online or by phone and have their pizza delivered right to their door, which is a significant convenience.
Carryout: For those who live or work nearby, carryout is a quick and efficient option. Ordering ahead of time allows customers to simply pick up their meal without the wait.
Online and App Ordering: The restaurant offers a seamless online and mobile app ordering experience, allowing customers to customize their pizzas, apply deals, and pay in advance. This streamlines the process and is a preferred method for many modern diners.
Catering: Papa Johns provides catering for large groups, making it a suitable option for parties, office lunches, and other events. They offer "Group Suggestions" and customizable large orders to feed a crowd easily.

Key features and highlights of this particular Papa Johns location and its brand.

Variety of Crusts and Toppings: The menu's extensive options, including different crust styles and a wide range of toppings, allow for a highly customizable dining experience that caters to all tastes.
Famous Sides and Desserts: Beyond pizza, the restaurant offers popular sides like cheesesticks and garlic knots, as well as classic desserts, ensuring a full-course meal is available.
Promotional Deals: Papa Johns is known for its frequent coupons and deals, providing customers with affordable ways to enjoy their menu, especially for families and larger groups.
Convenient Hours: With hours extending late into the night, the restaurant serves as a reliable option for those with unconventional schedules or late-night cravings.
Established Brand: Being part of a well-known chain, this location benefits from a familiar menu and a reputation for providing a consistent, recognizable product.

For those who wish to order or get more information, here is the essential contact information for this Papa Johns location.

Address: 7061 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

Phone: (614) 751-8000

Mobile Phone: +1 614-751-8000

It is always recommended to use their official website or app for the latest deals and menu information, or to call them directly to confirm specific hours and services.

For locals in the Ohio region, particularly in Reynoldsburg, this Papa Johns location is a suitable choice for a few key reasons. It offers a consistent and familiar product that many people have come to enjoy. The variety on the menu ensures that it can satisfy a wide range of tastes, from traditional pepperoni lovers to those seeking a specialty pizza or even just a side of wings. The services, especially the robust delivery and online ordering systems, are built for modern convenience, making it incredibly easy to get a meal without leaving the house. While individual experiences may vary, the brand's established presence and the location's operational efficiency make it a practical and reliable option for a quick, affordable, and customizable meal. For those in the area looking for a hassle-free pizza night, this Papa Johns remains a go-to option.

Papa Johns Pizza Location

Papa Johns Pizza

Ohio Franklin County Reynoldsburg East Main Street

7061 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

Papa Johns Pizza Reviews

The food is just not good. The pizza crust is akin to cardboard. I had to recut the slices because the precuts were surface level. The sauce and cheese flavor just falls flat leaving you with such disappointment after expecting a rich, decadent, and savory bite. The pizza crust is stiff and bland. The garlic knots were burnt on the outside and undercooked inside leaving me with a mouth full of dough-I am hoping I don't get sick-but I'm guessing they were cooked too fast which is why the outside was burnt while the inside was nearly raw. The service for in-store pick up was fine, albeit meaningless because of the quality of the food. The only tolerable part of the meal was the marinara that came with the garlic knots. Their pizza and garlic knots looks nothing like advertised, which might be acceptable, if the food was good to eat. This was a waste of a cheat meal. Oh, and I requested light cheese and that was not provided.
May 26, 2025 · Brittany
Dear Papa Johns Franchise Owner,Please shut down.Without provocation, I've received 2 redemption coupons based on the pizza I ordered and received. It didn't stop at the pizza either, instead I've had to wait 2hrs before receiving my order. Although the photo I have shared does not tell the whole story, it is nonetheless NOT what I ordered. I asked for lite cheese and against my wishes, I received the normal amount and what even seems to be excessive amount of cheese. I requested my pizza to be well done and wouldn't you know it, the pizza arrived as a normal bake.I'm not sure why this location seems to fall short every single time but, I can't imagine a world where the quality of pizza you've come to normalize will lead to success.P.S.Please, shut it down.
Apr 29, 2025 · LaAnder Harris
I don't order order pizza I'm gluten-free but every great now and then I crave normal food. So I ordered from the closest one that delivered, the app said it would be here between 5:45 and 5:56. The app on the computer let's you track your pizza my pizza was still backing at 5:56 so I called and the animated voice said my pizza would arrive at 7:02. At 7:18 I call the manager he answered Hospitality, I asked what time my pizza would arrive and he hung up. But it did arrive a few minutes later. Papa John's makes you put you tip on the credit card order which is great everyone should tip your delivery person. And that means the people that delivers your sofa, washer,dryer and. Anything else you have delivered to your house. They work very hard for less than they deserve. Come on buy their lunch 10 bucks each. There are lots of nice people out there, if you can't find one be one.
Aug 05, 2025 · tina staton
What the heck is this? This is what we got w an order of stuffed crust dough. No, this is not thin crust. Hell, even for thin crust this would be thin. Donatos is thicker than this and this is regular dough! Oh no… 🥴
Jun 09, 2025 · Matthew Koch
terrible quality. dough is thin and hard in some spots, some slices are like 40% crust because the sauce and toppings are not distributed evenly. insane that this is the standard. here's a photo for comparison. what it's supposed to look like vs what i got.
Feb 25, 2025 · Sean