Peggy's Introduce
For residents of Ohio, especially those in the Reynoldsburg area, discovering a local gem that consistently delivers on taste and provides a genuine culinary experience is always a treat. Peggy's, nestled in Reynoldsburg, has carved out a unique space in the local dining scene, earning a reputation for its authentic soul food. This article aims to provide a comprehensive look at what makes Peggy's a noteworthy destination for anyone in Ohio seeking a taste of true Southern comfort. From its savory dishes to its location and unique attributes, we'll explore why Peggy's has become a talking point among local food enthusiasts.
Peggy's isn't just another restaurant; it's a place where traditional recipes and hearty portions come together to create a memorable meal. The essence of soul food lies in its rich flavors, comforting textures, and the feeling of home-cooked goodness, and Peggy's embodies all of these characteristics. Whether you're a long-time fan of soul food or new to its delights, the menu offers an inviting array of options that are both familiar and exciting. This establishment is a testament to the enduring appeal of classic American comfort food, prepared with care and served with a distinctive touch that keeps locals coming back for more.
The culinary philosophy at Peggy's revolves around delivering robust, authentic flavors that speak to the heart of soul food tradition. Dishes are prepared with attention to detail, ensuring that each bite is packed with the rich, savory tastes that patrons expect. While the atmosphere may be casual, the food is certainly not. It’s the kind of place where the aromas from the kitchen alone are enough to whet your appetite, promising a meal that is both satisfying and deeply flavorful. For anyone in the Ohio region looking to explore the vibrant world of soul food, or simply craving a truly delicious and comforting meal, Peggy's in Reynoldsburg stands out as a must-visit. Its dedication to time-honored recipes and generous servings makes it a cherished part of the local dining landscape.
Peggy's is conveniently situated at 2435 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA. This location places it within a readily accessible part of Reynoldsburg, making it an easy destination for many residents throughout the surrounding Ohio communities. Brice Road is a well-trafficked route, ensuring that finding the restaurant is typically straightforward, whether you're coming from nearby neighborhoods or a bit further afield. For those traveling by car, the area around Peggy's generally offers accessible parking solutions, contributing to a hassle-free visit. Its placement within a commercial stretch of Reynoldsburg means it’s often near other local businesses and amenities, making it a convenient stop for a meal as part of a day out or an easy choice for a dedicated dining trip. For most Ohioans, driving remains the primary method of transport, and Peggy's location is well-suited for vehicular access, allowing locals to comfortably reach the restaurant for dine-in or takeout options. The ease of access helps establish Peggy's as a convenient and reliable choice for a hearty meal in Reynoldsburg.
Services Offered:
- Dine-in Service: Guests can enjoy their authentic soul food meals in the restaurant's casual setting.
- Takeout Service: Convenient option for those who wish to enjoy Peggy's delicious food from the comfort of their home.
- Delivery Service: Peggy's offers delivery, allowing customers throughout the local Ohio area to have their favorite dishes brought directly to them.
- Catering Options: While not explicitly detailed as a primary service, many establishments specializing in comfort food may offer catering for local events and gatherings; it is advisable to inquire directly.
- Family-Friendly Environment: The casual and comforting nature of the food makes Peggy's a suitable dining spot for families.
- Lunch and Dinner Service: Open for both lunch and dinner, accommodating various dining schedules.
- Alcohol Offerings: The establishment provides alcoholic beverages, including beer, wine, and cocktails, to complement meals.
- Accepts Reservations: Customers have the option to make reservations, which can be particularly helpful during peak hours.
Features / Highlights:
- Authentic Soul Food Cuisine: Peggy's is celebrated for its genuine and flavorful soul food dishes, offering a true taste of Southern comfort.
- Highly-Praised Mac and Cheese: Numerous patrons rave about the deliciousness of the macaroni and cheese, often cited as a must-try side.
- Flavorful Fried Fish: The fried fish is consistently highlighted as a winner, praised for its excellent taste and preparation.
- Spicy and Flavorful Dirty Rice: The dirty rice stands out for its rich flavor and a pleasant level of spice, earning high recommendations.
- Delicious Candied Yams and Collard Greens: These classic soul food sides are frequently mentioned for their authentic taste and quality.
- Variety of Meat Options: Beyond fish, the menu includes options like lamb chops (noted for unique "lollipop style"), and possibly chicken, offering diverse choices.
- Blackened Shrimp Pasta with Spinach Sauce: A unique and delicious offering that provides a different culinary experience, as highlighted by a satisfied customer.
- Comforting Desserts: Cheesecake is among the dessert options that customers enjoy.
- Friendly Service (Variable): While some reviews indicate areas for improvement in initial reception, others praise specific staff members, such as Quitia, for being very friendly and helpful.
Peggy's in Reynoldsburg is truly an excellent choice for locals across Ohio, particularly those seeking an authentic and satisfying soul food experience. The primary reason for its suitability lies in the consistently high quality and genuine flavors of its dishes. For Ohioans who appreciate home-style cooking and rich, comforting flavors, Peggy's delivers on all fronts. The renowned mac and cheese, the perfectly fried fish, and the flavorful dirty rice are just a few examples of the culinary highlights that make this establishment a standout. When you're craving that specific taste of well-prepared soul food, Peggy's provides a reliable and deeply satisfying option.
Furthermore, the convenience of its Reynoldsburg location on Brice Road makes it highly accessible for a wide range of residents. Whether you're planning a dine-in meal with family or friends, or simply need a quick takeout order after a busy day, Peggy's is easy to get to. The availability of delivery services also means that the deliciousness of Peggy's can be enjoyed in the comfort of your own home, making it an ideal choice for a cozy night in. This blend of authentic cuisine and practical accessibility truly caters to the lifestyle of Ohio locals.
While some feedback points to varying service experiences, the overwhelming consensus revolves around the food being exceptionally good and worth the visit. For many locals, the quality of the meal takes precedence, and Peggy's consistently impresses on that front. It's the kind of place you recommend to a friend looking for "the good stuff," a spot that feels like a culinary secret worth sharing. In essence, Peggy's offers a taste of tradition and comfort that resonates deeply within the local community, establishing itself as a cherished dining destination in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, and a must-try for anyone in the region with a love for authentic soul food.
Peggy's Menu
Fish Platters
- Red Snapper US$23.95
- Orange Roughy US$23.95
- Catfish US$18.95
- Whiting US$18.95
- Perch US$18.95
Signature Entrees
- Smothered Porkchops US$18.95
- Garlic & Rosemary Grilled Lambchops US$29.95
- Blackened Shrimp & Grits US$17.95
- Blackened Salmon & Rice US$22.95
Specialty Seafood
- Red Snapper US$25.95
- Orange Roughy US$25.95
- Catfish US$24.95
- Whiting US$19.95
- Perch US$19.95
Pasta
- Blackened Shrimp Pasta US$24.95
- Blackened Salmon Pasta US$24.95
- Orange Roughy Pasta US$24.95
Sides
- Baked Mac And Cheese US$7.00
- Candied Yams US$6.00
- Vegetarian Baked Beans US$6.00
- Cheese Grits US$6.00
- Collard Greens US$6.00
- White Rice US$6.00
- Cajun Dirty Rice US$6.00
- Fries US$6.00
- Fried Okra US$6.00
- Cornbread US$2.95
Beverages
- Coffee
- Tea
- Orange Juice
- Milk
- Pepsi Products
- Apple Juice
Sandwiches & Sliders
- Blackened Chicken Sandwich US$12.95
- Buffalo Chicken Slider US$14.95
- Veggie Burger US$12.95
- Cheeseburger US$14.95
- Fish Sliders US$12.95
- Grilled Cheese US$10.95
- Turkey Club US$12.95
Chicken Or Fish Baskets W/Fries
- Perch Basket US$14.95
- Wing Dings Basket US$14.95
- Catfish Basket US$14.95
- Whiting Basket US$14.95
- Whole Wings Basket US$16.95
- Orange Roughy Basket US$19.95
- Red Snapper Basket US$19.95
Peggy's
- Smothered Pork Chops W/ White Rice US$18.95
- Catfish With Creamy Creole Sauce Over Rice US$24.95
- Grilled Lamb Chops W/ Creamy Spinach Sauce Over Rice
- Blackened Shrimp & Grits W/ Creamy Cajun Sauce US$17.90
- Blackened Salmon Pasta US$24.95
- 6 Wing Dings W/ Fries US$15.95
- 5 Whole Wings W/ Fries US$16.95
- 2 Perch W/ Fries US$14.95
- 2 Whiting W/ Fries US$14.95
- Orange Roughy W/ Fries US$19.95
- Catfish W/Fries US$18.95
- Red Snapper W/Fries US$19.95
Drinks
- Pepsi Products US$3.99
- Freshed Squeezed Lai's Lemon
Dinner & Entrees
- Smothered Pork Chops With White Rice US$14.99
- Smothered Chicken With White Rice US$14.99
- Smoked Bbq Ribs With Fries US$16.99
- Smoked Beef Ribs With Fries US$24.00
- Red Snapper With Creamy Creole Sauce Over White Rice
- Catfish With Creamy Creole Sauce Over White Rice US$13.95
- Garlic & Rosemary Grilled Lamb Chops US$28.95
- Blackened Shrimp & Grits US$14.95
- Chicken & Waffles US$13.95
- Blackened Salmon Pasta US$22.99
- Smoked Brisket Gravy Over Biscuits US$11.99
- Cajun Shrimp And Grits US$14.95
- 6 Fried Chicken Wing Dings With Fries US$14.00
- 6 Fried Chicken Wing Dings With 2 Sides US$18.00
- 5 Fried Whole Wings With Fries US$15.50
- 5 Fried Whole Wings With 2 Sides US$19.50
- 2 Perch With Fries US$13.00
- 2 Perch With 2 Sides US$16.00
- 2 Whiting With Fries US$13.00
- 2 Whiting With 2 Sides US$16.00
- Orange Roughy With Fries US$18.00
- Orange Roughy With 2 Sides US$24.00
- Spaghetti US$6.99
Combos
- 3 Wing Dings/2 Fish US$15.50
- 3 Wing Dings/2 Fish US$21.00
- 3 Whole Wings/2 Ash US$16.50
- 3 Whole Wings /2 Fish US$23.50
Lunch Menu
- Peggy's Grilled Burger
- Cheeseburger
- Pulled Pork
- Turkey Club
- Vegetarian Burger US$8.95
- Blackened Chicken Sandwich US$12.99
- 6pc Fried Chicken Wing Dings W/Fries US$14.00
- 5pc Fried Whole Wings W/Fries
- 2pc Perch & Fries US$12.99
- 2pc Perch W/2 Sides US$16.00
- 2pc Whiting & Fries
- Orange Roughly & Fries
Others
- Peggy's Grilled Burger US$13.99
- Pulled Pork US$7.99
- Vegetarian Burger US$8.95
- 6pc Fried Chicken Wing Dings W/Fries
- 5pc Fried Whole Wings W/Fries
- 2pc Perch & Fries
- 2pc Perch W/2 Sides
- 2pc Whiting & Fries
- Orange Roughly & Fries US$18.00
- Orange Roughly W/2 Sides
- Mac&Chez
- Cheeseburger+ Fries US$14.95
- Blackened Chicken Sandwich + Fries US$12.95
- Fish Sliders + Fries US$12.95
- Buffalo Chicken Sandwich + Fries US$14.95
- 6 Piece Wing Dings + Fries US$15.95
- 5 Piece Whole Wings + Fries US$16.95
- 3 Wing Dings/2 Pc Fish/Fries US$16.95
- 3 Whole Wings/2 Pc Of Fish/Fries US$17.95
- Yams
- 3 Whole Wings/2 Pc Of Fish/ Fries +2 Sides US$17.95
Peggy's Details
From the business
- Identifies as Black-owned
Service options
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
- Delivery
Highlights
- Fast service
- Live music
- Serves local specialty
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
- Small plates
- Spirits
- Wine
Dining options
- Breakfast
- Brunch
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Dessert
- Seating
Amenities
- Bar on site
- Toilet
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cosy
Crowd
- Family friendly
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safe space
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- Kids' menu
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
- On-site parking
- Parking
Peggy's Photos










Peggy's Location
Peggy's
2435 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA
Peggy's Reviews
mac and cheesegreenssoul foodwingsdirty ricecatfishsweet potatoesorange roughyshrimp and gritscornbread
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1The food is very good. If you are looking for authentic soul food, this is it! Try the mac n cheese and greens. The dirty rice is spicy and flavorful. The fried fish is a winner. However, the chicken was a 2.5. Lamb chops are "lollipop style" but were a bit salty and dry. The food overall is worth the trip, the service needs improvement. Staff isn't friendly, nor do they make you feel welcomed. The food is worth making the trip for but don't expect a warm reception when you get there. Pictured: fried fish (great) sweet potatoes (canned, but a good taste), greens, corn bread muffins (crumbly texture), lamb chops, dirty rice(very good, a little spicy), cheesecake cake, macaroni and cheese (delicious). Give this one a try!
June 09 · Honest ReviewThe food is delicious. My Mom and I had the same fish platters. Orange Roughy with Mac & cheese, collard greens, fried okra, Cajun dirty rice and candied yams as sides. I also wanted to try the Blackened Shrimp pasta with the spinach sauce to share with my Mom and sisters at the table. Everything was delicious. Quitia, our waitress was very friendly and helpful. Our service was great. I'm looking forward to visiting this restaurant again.
March 23 · Theodore PalmerThis is a great place to visit and revisit! The food was hot and fresh. The service was great. It was so good, my friend went alone and invited us back the very next day! It is moderately priced, the portions are great and the cuisine is excellent. I can’t wait to go back and try more of this delicious menu.
March 17 · Lisa AlstonCame for dinner with my family. There was a wait to be seated but, there were quite a bit of people inside! It did take a while to take orders but again, it was busy inside so I didn’t mind. The food was excellent! The chicken and mac and cheese were perfectly seasoned. The food was fresh and hot! I can’t wait to go back and try breakfast and lunch!
March 23 · Paige CaldwellFirst timer here and everything from customer service to the food was top tier. Good job peeps. I went for brunch and MIMOSAS x2(the bartender did her thing) I will be back for dinner service soon because them greens baby, was fire.
June 28 · Teresa Hamilton
More Best Restaurants Near Me

2045 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

2160 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

6068 Channingway Blvd, Columbus, OH 43232, USA

1921 Channingway Center Dr, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

1928 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

1926 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

1898 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

6201 E Livingston Ave, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

Brice Rd and, E Livingston Ave, Columbus, OH 43068, USA

6184 E Livingston Ave, Columbus, OH 43232, USA

6065 E Livingston Ave, Columbus, OH 43232, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Bites & Banter Posts





