Pi Bakerie: Authentic Greek Bakery and Cafe in New York City

Pi Bakerie Introduce

If you're looking to find a genuine taste of Greece right in the heart of New York City, look no further than Pi Bakerie. Tucked away on Broome Street, this charming spot is a local gem that has been winning over New Yorkers with its authentic Greek flavors, fresh-baked goods, and welcoming atmosphere. It's not just a bakery; it's a cozy cafe and restaurant that serves up everything from savory pies and hearty lunch specials to an array of delectable desserts and excellent coffee. Whether you're a long-time fan of Mediterranean cuisine or just curious to try something new, Pi Bakerie offers a culinary escape that will transport your taste buds straight to the Aegean.

The name itself, "Pi," is a nod to the traditional Greek pies that are a cornerstone of their menu. This is a place where you can find those classic, home-cooked-style dishes that feel both comforting and wonderfully unique. From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with the irresistible aromas of freshly baked goods and brewed coffee, setting the stage for a delightful dining experience. It's a place that feels like a warm hug, perfect for a quick breakfast on the go, a leisurely lunch, or even a catering order for a special event.

The menu is extensive and thoughtfully curated, showcasing the rich variety of Greek cuisine. Breakfast options are a great way to start your day, featuring items like savory spinach croissants, sweet baklava croissants, and traditional Greek yogurt with toppings. Lunchtime brings a selection of savory "Pi's" (pies), including the classic Moussaka Pi, Pastitsio Pi, and the vegetarian-friendly Green Harvest Pi. But what truly stands out is the quality and authenticity of every dish. Everything is made with care, using traditional recipes that have been passed down through generations. This is what sets Pi Bakerie apart—it’s not just food; it’s a piece of Greek culinary heritage.

Location and Accessibility

Pi Bakerie is conveniently located at 512 Broome St, New York, NY 10013, USA. Its location in Lower Manhattan makes it easily accessible for both locals and visitors exploring the area. The neighborhood is vibrant and bustling, with many shops and attractions nearby, making Pi Bakerie an ideal stop for a quick bite or a relaxing break. The restaurant is committed to ensuring a comfortable experience for all guests, offering a wheelchair-accessible toilet.

Services Offered

Pi Bakerie provides a wide range of services to meet the needs of its diverse clientele, ensuring everyone can enjoy their delicious offerings in the way that suits them best. The following are available:

Dine-in: Enjoy a casual and cozy meal right inside the cafe. The atmosphere is relaxed and friendly, making it a great spot for a solo dining experience or a get-together with friends and family.
Takeaway and Kerbside Pickup: For those in a hurry, you can easily place an order for takeaway or opt for convenient kerbside pickup.
Delivery: Pi Bakerie offers delivery services, including a no-contact option, so you can have their delicious food brought right to your door.
Catering: Perfect for corporate events, parties, or family gatherings, their catering menu offers a wide variety of platters, from a Mediterranean Dip Platter to a Fresh Greek Yogurt Bar and even assorted savory pies. Their large catering options, such as the Greek Mezze Platter or the Morning Wake-Up Breakfast Platter, make hosting an event a breeze. They have a range of options for every occasion.
On-site Services: The team at Pi Bakerie is dedicated to providing excellent service whether you're dining in or ordering ahead.

Features and Highlights

What makes Pi Bakerie a standout destination in New York City is its commitment to quality and the overall experience it offers. The following features are what guests love most:

Fast Service: Customers consistently praise the fast and efficient service, making it a great option for a quick and satisfying meal, especially during a busy workday lunch.
Great Coffee: The coffee is a major highlight, with a variety of hot and cold beverages like the authentic Greek Coffee, Freddo Cappuccino, and a strong Devocion House Blend. It’s the perfect companion for a fresh pastry or a meal.
Delicious Desserts: From the award-winning oversized chocolate cookie to classic Greek pastries like Baklava, Galaktoboureko, and the citrusy Orange “Portokalopita” Pi, the desserts are a true delight. They are often described by customers as being exceptionally moist, flavorful, and true to traditional recipes.
Varied Menu: The menu offers a wide variety of options, including healthy choices, vegetarian dishes, and organic dishes, ensuring there's something for everyone. Whether you’re in the mood for a light salad, a hearty savory pie, or small plates like the Sampler Plate for 2, you will find something you love. They also offer a salad bar and a great selection of comfort food.
Atmosphere: The ambiance is described as casual, cozy, and trendy, creating a welcoming and relaxed environment. It's a great spot for a casual get-together with friends or a quiet moment to yourself.
Dietary Accommodations: Pi Bakerie is popular for its vegetarian options and provides a variety of healthy dishes and comfort food. While not exclusively a health food spot, the use of organic ingredients and fresh produce makes it a fantastic place to find balanced and delicious meals. They also have a popular Gluten-Free Chocolate Pi.

Contact Information

Ready to plan your visit or place an order? Here is the contact information you'll need:

Address: 512 Broome St, New York, NY 10013, USA
Phone: (212) 226-2701

What Is Worth Choosing

Pi Bakerie stands out for its authenticity and quality, offering a true taste of Greece in the city that never sleeps. It's not just a restaurant; it's an experience that feels personal and genuine. Here’s why it’s a must-visit:

The authenticity is the main reason to choose Pi Bakerie. Many visitors, especially those who have traveled to Greece, praise the food for being exactly like what they experienced abroad. The commitment to traditional recipes, from the flaky phyllo of the savory pies to the rich, moist texture of the desserts, ensures that every bite is a little piece of Greek heritage.

Their menu is incredibly diverse, catering to different dining times and preferences. From a refreshing Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice and a breakfast croissant to a hearty Moussaka Pi for lunch, the options are plentiful. The catering menu is particularly impressive, offering large-format dishes like the Traditional Salad Bar or a Mediterranean Antipasti Platter that can make any event special. The availability of alcohol, including beer and wine, also makes it a great spot to unwind after a long day.

Finally, the atmosphere and service make it a place you’ll want to return to. The staff is friendly and warm, and the space is comfortable and inviting. Whether you’re grabbing a coffee to go or sitting down for a full meal, you feel welcomed and cared for. For a genuine, delicious, and heartwarming taste of Greece right here in New York City, Pi Bakerie is the definitive choice.

Pi Bakerie Menu

Breakfast Items
Ham & Cheese Croissants US$5.95
Sour Cherry With Baklava Yogurt US$7.50
Fresh Greek yogurt, imported sour cherry preserve, and baklava.
Spinach Croissant US$5.75
Croissant filled with spinach and feta
Chocolate Croissant US$5.45
Almond Croissant US$5.55
Baklava Croissants US$5.25
Fresh baked croissant with baklava filling.
Mozzarella Di Bufala Croissant Sandwich US$8.95
Fresh mozzarella di bufala tomatoes, fresh basil and Cretan extra virgin olive oil.
Salami And Cheese Croissant Sandwich US$8.95
Salami, kasseri cheese, arugula and Kalamata extra virgin olive oil.
Veggie Frittata Pi. US$14.25
Greek omelette.
Plain Croissant US$5.10
Nutrition Bar US$5.00
Sunflower seeds, quick oats, almonds, walnuts, and 70% dark chocolate.
Breakfast Box US$11.00
croissant, assorted cookies and 7oz fresh squeezed orange juice.
Plain Greek Yogurt Add Topping US$6.55
Two scoops of our fresh Greek yogurt.
Fig & Cheese Croissant US$5.25
Fig and Feta cheese

Hot Beverages
Cortado US$4.00
Devocion House Blend US$3.55
Nescafe US$4.25
Chocolate US$4.75
Matcha US$5.95
Caffe Latte US$5.25
Chai Latte US$4.00
Macchiato US$4.25
Greek Coffee US$4.00
Espresso US$4.25
Herbal Tea US$4.25
Organic, Chamomile Citrus , Tropical Green Tea , Jasmine and Greek Mountain Tea
Cappuccino US$4.75

Salads & Dips
Bulgur "Pligouri" Salad Small US$6.50
Traditional Greek bulgur, arugula, scallions, grape tomatoes, fresh lemon, and EVOO.
Briam Small US$7.50
A Greek version of ratatouille. Includes baked eggplant, zucchini, green bell peppers, and fresh garden herbs in a light tomato suace.
Tarama US$3.75
Fish Roe Dip
Eggplant "Melitzanosalata" Dip US$4.20
Baked eggplant, fresh parsley, roasted red bell peppers, garlic, Greek red win vinegar, and EVOO. Served with baked pita chips.
Watermelon Salad US$5.50
Organic Black Eyed Bean "Mavromatika" Salad Small US$7.00
Roasted red bell peppers, scallions, parsley, olives, red win vinegar, and EVOO.
Greek Village "Horiatiki" Salad Small US$6.50
Beefsteak tomatoes, cucumbers, green olives, feta cheese, oregano and EVOO.
Mixed Salad Large US$10.50
Mix of any salads in one large bowl.
Dip Trio US$11.00
A combination of each of our signature dips. Served with baked pita chips.
Mediterranean Lentil Salad Small US$6.50
Imported greek lentils, roasted red peppers, carrots, kalamata olives, greek red wine, and EVOO.
Green “Prasini” Salad Small US$6.50
Romaine, scallions, dill, red wine vinegar, and EVOO.
Spicy Feta "Tirokafteri" Dip US$4.20
Spicy greek Feta Dip
Hummus Dip US$4.20
Chick peas, garlic, tahini, and lemon. Served with baked pita chips.
Tzatziki Dip US$4.20
Greek yogurt, garlic, cucumbers, and dill. Served with baked pita chips.
Hand Rolled Grape Leaves "Dolmadakia" US$1.25
Rice, fresh herbs, fresh lemon, and EVOO.
Lentil Salad Small US$6.50
Roasted red bell peppers, shredded carrots, olives, red wine vinegar, and EVOO.

Catering
Fresh Greek Yogurt Bar US$85.00
Selection of real Greek yogurt with strawberries, blackberries, organic honey and granola toppings. Serves ten.
Mediterranean Dip Platter US$45.00
A selection of our signature dips, including tzatziki, hummus, and eggplant dip accompanied by pita chips and crudite.
Apple Pi US$85.00
Mediterranean Dip Trio US$100.00
Tzatziki (cucumber-yogurt dip), hummus, and eggplant dip accompanied by pita chips Serves up to 10.
Stuffed Peppers With Beef US$120.00
Tray with 6 Stuffed peppers with beef and rice . Comes with oven done potatoes.
Mediterranean Antipasti Platter US$135.00
Pita bread and a combination of Mediterranean delights including tzatziki, hummus, "melkitzanosalata" eggplant dip, dolmadakia, mini spnach pies and Greek traditional meatballs. Serves ten.
Greek Mezze Platter US$85.00
Olives ,cherry tomatoes , Feta cheese, Dolmades, Tzatziki dip, hummus dip and Pita chips for 8 to 10 people
Coffee Box US$45.00
Please request milk if needed. There is not charge for regular milk. There is a small charge for Almond and Oat milk.
Desserts & Sweet Pies US$80.00
Sour cherry and baklava yogurt parfait. Serves ten.
Walnut Pi Box US$40.00
6 slices of walnut Pi
Galaktoboureko Pi US$40.00
Galaktoboureko Pi. milk custard Pi box with 6 slices
Gluten-Free Chocolate Pi US$85.00
Gluten-Free 12'' chocolate Pi
Mini Assorted Baklava US$70.00
has 25 pieces of mini assorted baklava on tray.
Baklava Box US$48.00
20 pieces of mini baklava. options ,walnut, almond,.pistachio ,chocolate, coconut or mixed assortment
Anthoulas Rice Pudding US$70.00
Serves ten.
9" Galaktoboureko, Baklava, Walnut Pie Or Orange Pi US$45.00
choice of baklava ,Walnut Pie ,Orange Pie
Mushroom Pi's US$85.00
Portabella mushroom, organic brown rice, scallions, light cream, homemade phyllo. 6 pies per order
Stuffed Peppers With Rice US$100.00
Tray of 6 peppers stuffed with rice . Served with oven done potatoes
Orange Juice 64oz US$42.00
Freshly squeezed Florida orange juice .
Sides US$60.00
Traditional Savory Pi For 6 US$96.00
moussaka , pastitsio ,
Koulouri Sandwich Platter US$110.00
An assortment of our koulouri sandwiches cut in quarters. Served with kalamata olives on a platter. Serves ten.
Mixed Cookie Platter US$100.00
Serves up to 10.
Orange Pi Box US$40.00
6 slices of orange Pi
Mini Pi Platter US$100.00
Spanakopita, tiropitakaria, mini painerli, and bougatsa. Serves up to 12 .
Morning Wake-Up Breakfast Platter US$110.00
Buogatsa, plain, chocolate, almond, ham, and cheese croissants. Serves ten.
Green Harvest, Zucchini & Chicken Pi US$78.00
For 6 people
Fruit Platter US$78.00
Grapes ,black berries ,Blue berries, strawberries cantaloupe and honeydew melon . feeds 10
Greek Frittata US$120.00
Greek imported feta, baby spinach, cherry tomatoes and free range eggs, along with our prasini salad. Serves 12-15
Traditional Salad Bar US$80.00
80 oz bowl

Appetizer Pi's
Mini Spanakopita Pi US$2.00
Hand-stretched phyllo dough. Add extra one piece or three pieces for an additional charge.
Greek Salad Painerli US$8.95
Hand-stretched phyllo dough stuffed with calzone pi and imported kasseri and Kephalotiri cheese topped with feta ,tomato, onion and olives
Painerli Pi US$8.75
Hand-stretched phyllo dough stuffed with `Greek calzone made with ham, kasseri, and kephalotiri cheese.
Mini Tiropita Pi US$2.00
Hand-stretched phyllo dough. Add extra one piece or three pieces for an additional charge.
Spanakopita Pi US$8.25
Hand-stretched phyllo dough stuffed with fresh spinach, imported feta cheese, and Greek herbs.
Mini Painerli Pi US$3.25
Hand-stretched phyllo dough stuffed with Greek calzone made with tomatoes, kasserie, and kephalotiri cheese.
Mini Ham Painerli Pi US$3.50
Hand-stretched phyllo dough stuffed with `Greek calzone made with ham, kasseri, and kephalotiri cheese.
Tiropita Pi US$8.25
Hand-stretched phyllo dough stuffed with imported feta cheese and Greek herbs.
Sampler Plate For 2 US$25.00
2 dolmadakia (hand rolled grape leaveswithrice fresh herbs ) 2 mini cheese pi 2 mini spinach pi 2 mini Painerli Pi Dip Trio .A combination of each of our signature dips. Served with baked pita chips.
Ham Painerli Pi US$8.95
Hand-stretched phyllo dough stuffed with `Greek calzone made with ham, kasseri, and kephalotiri cheese.

Koulouri Sandwiches
Salmon Koulouri US$11.50
Organic acme nova scotia salmon, arugula, dill, cream cheese, and kalamata EVOO. With Greek sesame encrusted koulouri bread, made fresh every morning in house, and served with kalamata olives.
Salami Koulouri US$9.25
Soppressata salami, kasseri cheese, fresh arugula, and kalamata EVOO. With Greek sesame encrusted koulouri bread, made fresh every morning in house, and served with kalamata olives.
Plain Koulouri US$2.95
Mozzarella Di Bufala Koulouri US$8.95
Fresh mozzarella di bufala, tomatoes, fresh basil, and cretan EVOO. With Greek sesame encrusted koulouri bread, made fresh every morning in house, and served with kalamata olives.
Yogurt Koulouri US$6.95
Greek yogurt, cucumbers, sea salt, and kalamata evooo. With Greek sesame encrusted koulouri bread, made fresh every morning in house, and served with kalamata olives.

Lunch items
Moussaka Pi US$18.50
Baked eggplant, ground beef in a caramelized tomato sauce, topped with a light béchamel sauce and kasseri cheese.
Mustard Chicken US$17.25
Mustard chicken with choice of sides.
Green Harvest Pi "Hortopita US$15.95
Fresh spinach, kale, leeks, feta cheese, fresh Greek herbs, homemade phyllo.
Zucchini Pi "Kolokithopita" US$15.95
Shredded zucchini, feta, kephalotiri, kasseri, cheese, eggs, and fresh Greek herbs.
Chicken & Vegetable Pi "Kotopita US$16.75
Chicken breast, leeks, scallions, carrots, kasseri cheese, celery, homemade phyllo.
Mushroom Truffle Pi "Manitaropita" US$14.95
Portabella mushroom, organic brown rice, scallions, light cream, homemade phyllo.
Pastitsio Pi US$18.50
Penne, ground beef in a light caramelized tomato sauce, topped with a light béchamel sauce and kasseri cheese.

Savory Pi's
Chicken & Vegetable Pi "Kotopita" US$13.50
Chicken breast, leeks, scallions, carrots, cheese, and celery in a home-made phyllo dough.
Zucchini Pi "Kolokithopita" US$12.50
Imported Greek feta, kephalotiri, kasseri cheese, creamy Greek yogurt, eggs, and fresh Greek herbs.
Mushroom Truffle Pi "Manitaropita" US$11.50
Portabella mushroom, organic brown rice, scallions, and light cream in a home-made phyllo dough.
Moussaka Pi US$15.90
Ground sirloin beef, baked eggplant, and potato, caramelized onion, fresh tomato sauce topped with kasseri cheese, and a light bechamel sauce.
Pastitisio Pi US$15.90
Greek-style lasagna, ground beef, Greek pasta, tomato sauce, and bechamel.
Green Harvest Pi "Hortopita" US$13.50
Fresh spinach, kale, leeks, imported Greek feta cheese, and fresh herbs in a home-made phyllo dough.

Homemade Greek Soups
Lentil Soup US$9.95
Flakes with sauteed onions, carrots and celery in a light tomato and lentil broth. Served with baked pita chips.
Chicken Lemon “Avgolemono “ Soup US$9.95
Pureed carrots and celery in a broth with chicken breast and orzo in lemon-egg sauce. Served with baked pita chips.

Lunch specials
Moussaka Pi US$21.95
Baked eggplant, ground beef and potatoes in a caramelized tomato sauce, topped with a light béchamel sauce and kasseri cheese ,served with side Salad
Greek Mezzo Platter US$28.00
Olives ,cherry tomatoes , Feta cheese, Dolmades, Tzatziki dip, hummus dip and Pita chips for 2 or 4 people
Green Harvest Pi "Hortopita US$19.50
Fresh spinach, kale, leeks, feta cheese, fresh Greek herbs, homemade phyllo .Served with side Salad
Mustard Chicken Combo US$18.75
3 slices of chicken with rice and or Briami with Salad
Mushroom Truffle Pi "Manitaropita" With Side Salad US$18.95
Portabella mushroom, organic brown rice, scallions, light cream, homemade phyllo. with side salad
Zucchini Pi "Kolokithopita" US$19.50
Shredded zucchini, feta, kephalotiri, kasseri, cheese, eggs, and fresh Greek herbswith Salad
Chicken & Vegetable Pi "Kotopita US$19.75
Chicken breast, leeks, scallions, carrots, kasseri cheese, celery, homemade phyllo with Salad
Sampler Platter For Two US$25.00
Dip Trio .A combination of each of our signature dips. Served with baked pita chips. 2 mini spinach pi 1 large Painerli Pi cut in 2 2 mini cheese pi 2 dolmadakia (hand rolled grape leaves with rice fresh herbs )
Pastitsio Pi US$21.95
Penne, ground beef in a light caramelized tomato sauce, topped with a light béchamel sauce and kasseri cheese .served with Salad

Desserts
Baklava US$7.00
All time Greek favorite, prepared with stacked crispy phyllo filled with almonds and walnuts drizzled with an aromatic honey syrup.
Walnut “Karidopita” Pi US$6.95
A mouth watering greek recipe consisting of chopped walnuts, cinnamon, nutmeg, and cognac in a honey syrup.
Mini Baklava Assorted Flavors US$13.00
Chocolate ,pistachio or walnut . Half pound . if you would like a specific flavor please request in order
Melomakarona Cookie US$12.50
Per half pound Baked in-house
Six" Freshly Baked Apple Tart US$10.00
Crowned with Granny Smith apples and glazed with apricot jam.
Athena's Wedding Cookie US$12.25
per half pound Baked in-house
Our #1 Award Winning Oversized White And Milk Chocolate Cookie US$5.00
Mosaiko US$3.00
Chocolate ganache, petit beurre cookie, vanilla extract. Soft and creamy with a crunchy bite.
Cool Custard "Galaktoboureko" Pi US$7.15
Made with layers of golden brown crispy phyllo, filled with creamy custard, and soaked in honey syrup.
Galaktoboureko 9inch US$48.00
9 inch galaktoboureko Pi
Vasilopita Large 2.5lbs US$47.00
Anthoula's Rice Pudding US$6.50
This old fashioned comforting treat is amde iwth rice, creamy milk, vanilla, and orange zest dusted with cinnamon.
Trigona US$4.00
Crispy buttery phyllo triangle soaked in honey syrup and filled with rich creamy custard.
Apple "Milopita" Pi US$7.95
A moist dessert filled with juicy fresh Granny apples, scented with cinnamon, and baked in a homemade Greek cookie crust.
Portokalopita 9 Inch US$48.00
9 inch portokalopita Pi
Vasilopita 1.5lbs US$36.00
Greek New Years Cake
Almond Pound Cake US$7.50
Tender and buttery. This pound cake is always a winner.
9" Walnut Pi US$45.00
Orange, cognac and semolina made in a 9" tray .ships in cake box .Great gift idea for the holidays
“Bougatsa Pi” Warm Milk Pi US$7.75
Hand-rolled phyllo pastry dough stuffed with sweet custard cream, dusted with cinnamon and confectioners sugar.
Tsoureki Braided 2lbs US$34.00
Sweet bread . Greek Easter Bread 2Lbs.
9" Orange Pi US$45.00
Orange, phyllo dough and fresh Greek yogurt made in a 9" tray and sent in cake box. Great gift idea for the holidays.
9" Baklava US$45.00
Traditional Greek baklava layers of crispy phyllo dough with nuts with an organic Greek honey. made in 9" tray. Great gift idea for the holidays.
Traditional Mediterranean Confections US$12.25
Select the combination of your choice. Half pound.
Gluten-Free Chocolate "Sokolatopita" Pi US$8.50
This smooth and silky chocolate cake is made with semi sweet chocolate and cocoa powder. Definitely a chocolate lovers delight.
Orange “Portokalopita” Pi US$6.95
A deliciously different cake and a must try! Prepared with Greek yogurt, fresh orange juice, orange zest, shredded baked phyllo, and EVOO soaked in an aromatic honey and cinnamon syrup.

Cold Beverages
Saratoga Spring Water US$3.50
Devocion Cold Brew Coffee US$4.50
Freddo Espresso US$4.75
Iced Americano US$4.25
Iced Chocolate US$4.00
Iced Frappe US$4.65
Iced Matcha US$5.95
Iced Decaf Coffee US$3.50
Green John US$7.75
Fresh baby spinach, kale, celery, green apples, lemon
Iced Tea US$4.25
12oz
Freddo Cappuccino US$5.50
Mexican Coke US$3.75
The same great taste made with only pure cane sugar and served in a bottle.
Matcha Mint Lemonade US$6.15
Iced Matcha US$5.95
Diet Coke US$3.75
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Mint Lemonade US$5.95
Mastiqua Water US$4.85
greek wellness water
Saratoga Sparkling Water US$3.50
Iced Latte US$4.75
Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice US$7.15
12oz
Doctors Advice US$7.75
Carrots, green apples, red apples, ginger,
Cold Brew Coffee US$4.00
Cold Brew Coffee US$4.50
Iced Matcha Latte US$6.00
Mixed Berry Smoothie US$5.95

Pi Bakerie Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Kerbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great coffee
Great dessert

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Coffee
Comfort food
Healthy options
Organic dishes
Quick bite
Salad bar
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Trendy

Crowd
Family friendly
LGBTQ+ friendly
Locals
Transgender safe space

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Pi Bakerie Photos

Pi Bakerie Location

Pi Bakerie

New York New York County New York Broome Street

512 Broome St, New York, NY 10013, USA

Pi Bakerie Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 884 user reviews.

baklavabakerypiecafesavorygreek yogurtspanakopitacherrybagelmatcha

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

After returning from a soul-stirring vacation in Greece, I found myself yearning for the rich, savory simplicity of authentic Mediterranean flavors—especially those found in Greek desserts, where tradition meets indulgence. Enter Pi Bakerie, an unassuming jewel tucked away in Lower Manhattan that transported me instantly back to the sun-drenched streets of Athens and the island charm of Santorini.Among the many delights, it was their Greek orange cake that truly stole the show. Moist, fragrant, and flawlessly balanced between citrus and sweetness, it is a masterclass in restraint and richness. The texture speaks of careful craftsmanship, and every bite evokes the warmth of a home-baked Greek classic elevated by artisanal finesse.The pricing? Entirely justified by the quality. The service? Impeccable—attentive yet unintrusive, delivered with a warmth that mirrors the hospitality of the Aegean. The ambiance is a love letter to Hellenic culinary heritage: comforting, elegant, and quietly transporting.Pi Bakerie is more than a bakery—it is a curated experience of Greek flavors brought lovingly to New York. A rare, underrated treasure that deserves both applause and repeat visits. A standing ovation to the team for preserving and sharing such scrumptious authenticity.P.S. This is not a paid endorsement—just the heartfelt praise of a very satisfied sweet-toothed New Yorker .
June 26 · Lenny (Lenny)
Excellent cafe with a variety of home cooked style food! Tasty bakery and coffee, plus delicious baklava. Loved stuffed pepper, it’s a common dish enjoyed in Eastern Europe, so I felt happy to eat my familiar cuisine.
February 06 · J D
Randomly visited this place and was pleasantly surprised! We tried their in-house desserts, and they were absolutely delicious,fresh, flavorful, and perfectly sweet. If you're in the area, I highly recommend stopping by and treating yourself. You won’t regret it!
May 06 · Pranay reddy
2" thick slab of bechamel with a 1" sliver of moussaka below, for $18.50, served at the counter on a paper tray. Go get your own plastic utensils over there. Side salad? Ha, that would be another $8. And we suggest you tip us for standing in line and getting your own utensils and drink at 20-25%. I'm getting truly sick of trying to eat out in NYC... (The moussaka below the top 1.5" of bechamel was pretty tasty).
May 16 · Magnus Westergren
I order lunch from Pi almost everyday!! My number one in soho for coffee, snacks, and lunch. I can’t recommend more!My dad came to visit me for the weekend and I had to stop here with him one day- he was so impressed too. Super tasty stuff and great options if you’re health conscious!Lentil soup is outstanding :)Thank you Pi!!!
August 25 · lily woodrow