Pies & Pints Worthington, OH: Gourmet Pizza & Craft Beer in Central Ohio

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Photos

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Picture 1

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Picture 2

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Picture 3

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Picture 4

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Picture 5

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Picture 6

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Picture 7

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Picture 8

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Picture 9

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Picture 10

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Introduce

For residents and visitors in the Columbus, Ohio, region with a discerning palate for pizza and a keen interest in craft beer, Pies & Pints in Worthington stands out as a culinary gem. This isn't your average pizza joint; it's a destination that has earned a reputation for crafting "gourmet pizza" with innovative and delicious flavor combinations, perfectly complemented by an extensive selection of local and regional brews. Pies & Pints offers a vibrant and lively atmosphere, making it a popular spot for everything from a casual weeknight dinner to a celebratory gathering with friends.

What truly sets Pies & Pints apart is its commitment to elevating the pizza experience. Their menu features a diverse array of "unusual and delicious-looking combinations," moving beyond traditional toppings to create truly memorable pies. Beyond the exceptional pizza, the restaurant also offers a tempting selection of appetizers, salads, and sandwiches, ensuring there's something to satisfy every craving. Paired with a rotating tap list featuring a wide variety of craft beers, ciders, and even non-alcoholic options, Pies & Pints delivers a comprehensive and enjoyable dining experience for the Ohio community. The friendly and helpful staff contribute significantly to the positive ambiance, even during busy periods.

Pies & Pints is conveniently located at 7227 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085, USA. This prime address places it within the Shops at Worthington Place (formerly Worthington Square Mall), a well-known retail and dining hub on the northern edge of Ohio's capital. Its strategic positioning in Worthington makes it highly accessible for residents not only within the immediate community but also for those coming from neighboring areas such as Dublin, Powell, Lewis Center, and Westerville.

The accessibility of this location is a significant advantage for patrons. It is situated in the southwest quadrant of I-270 and Route 23, approximately ten minutes north of downtown Columbus, and a short drive from popular attractions like the Columbus Zoo. This means easy access for those commuting or simply looking for a quality dining experience outside of the downtown hustle. Ample parking is readily available due to its mall location, removing any concerns about finding a spot. Whether you're planning a dedicated trip for a gourmet pizza experience or looking for a convenient stop after shopping, Pies & Pints Worthington offers straightforward access and a pleasant environment for locals. They also boast a year-round patio for those who enjoy outdoor dining, weather permitting.

Services Offered:

Dine-in Service: Enjoy your meal in a lively, bar-like atmosphere.
Takeout and Carryout: Convenient options for picking up orders to enjoy at home.
Online Ordering: Available through various platforms for easy remote ordering.
Catering: Offers a selection of menu items for events and gatherings.
Lunch and Dinner Service: Open daily from late morning to evening.
Full Bar Service: Features a vast selection of craft beers on tap, as well as wines and other beverages.
Happy Hour: Provides specials on select pints and appetizers.
Year-Round Patio Dining: Offers an outdoor seating option, with garage doors that open in warmer months to connect indoor and outdoor spaces.

Features / Highlights:

Gourmet Pizza Creations: Known for unique and inventive pizza combinations, moving beyond traditional toppings. Popular pies include the Gouda pizza, Grape & Gorgonzola, Street Corn, and Thai Pie.
Extensive Craft Beer Selection: Boasts a wide, rotating tap list featuring local Ohio breweries (like Columbus Bodhi, Fat Head's, Jackie O's) and national/international craft beers, expertly curated to pair with their pizzas.
Quality Ingredients: Emphasizes fresh, locally-sourced ingredients, with pies hand-stretched and baked directly on a stone hearth.
Diverse Menu Beyond Pizza: Offers a range of appetizers (e.g., Char-Grilled Hot Wings, Pizza Skins, Pork & Pepper Nachos), fresh salads (Greek, Antipasto, Spinach), and sandwiches (Steak & Cheese, Marinated Grilled Chicken, Cuban Pulled Pork, Italian Hero).
Accommodating Dietary Needs: Provides gluten-free crust options (including cauliflower crust) and vegan cheese (Daiya brand), making it suitable for various dietary restrictions.
Friendly and Helpful Staff: Customers consistently praise the attentiveness and welcoming nature of the service team.
Lively Atmosphere: The restaurant maintains a vibrant, energetic, and sometimes bustling environment, perfect for a dynamic dining experience.
Signature Dishes: Specific items like the Gouda pizza and Steak Sub are highly recommended by loyal customers.
Brunch Offerings: Available on Saturdays and Sundays from 11:00 AM – 3:00 PM, featuring items like the Brunch Pie.

Contact Information:

Address: 7227 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085, USA

Phone: (614) 885-7437

Mobile Phone: +1 614-885-7437

Hours: Sunday - Thursday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM; Friday & Saturday: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM. (Note: The website states these are the earliest closing times, implying they may stay open later.)

Pies & Pints in Worthington, OH, is exceptionally suitable for locals in the Ohio region who are seeking a distinctive and high-quality pizza and dining experience. While some customers note that the food can be "VERY expensive," they also acknowledge that the quality and unique offerings, such as their "most gourmet pizza," often justify the price. The "Gouda pizza" is a particularly highlighted favorite, alongside delicious sandwiches like the steak sub. This suggests that for those willing to "spare some change for fancy pizza," Pies & Pints delivers on its promise of an elevated culinary adventure.

Furthermore, the welcoming environment and the consistently "friendly and helpful" staff enhance the overall experience, even when the interior might feel "a little chaotic" with different waiting areas. The expansive craft beer selection is another major draw, offering local beer enthusiasts a chance to explore a wide range of brews. The availability of gluten-free and vegan options also makes it an inclusive choice for various dietary needs, ensuring that more members of the community can enjoy their offerings.

In conclusion, for Ohioans who appreciate creative, high-quality pizza and a diverse craft beer menu in a lively setting, Pies & Pints in Worthington is a highly recommended destination. Its unique flavors, commitment to fresh ingredients, and dedication to offering a memorable experience make it a valuable asset to the local dining scene, solidifying its reputation as a go-to spot for an elevated pizza and beer outing.

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Location

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH

Ohio Franklin County Worthington Worthington Place North High Street

7227 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085, USA

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Reviews

Pies and pints make probably the most gourmet pizza that I have had. Their menu has many unusual and delicious-looking combinations, but I always go back to getting the Gouda pizza because of how good it is. I tried their steak sub this time and it was also delicious. The food is VERY expensive, but the restaurant posted a video of the kitchen which seems justifiable. I still come here infrequently due to cheaper options being around. The staff was very friendly and helpful inside. It is a little chaotic inside, with people waiting to be seated at the host stand while others wait next to them for pickup orders at the bar. If you’re able to spare some change for fancy pizza, I highly recommend this place.
Mar 31, 2025 · P Reviews
I really enjoy this place but there is something missing in the overall environment of the place. Service was great, she was attentive and consistent. Food was great. And the atmosphere feels like a bar but not really. It's just missing something to make it 5 stars.
Mar 17, 2025 · Stephen Kalicki (Seadweller43)
The food is always good here. Of course we have a specialty pizza. It was awesome. The beer selection is phenomenal, actually too many to choose from! The atmosphere is very loud and it is difficult to have conversations. If you sit outside, it is much better.
Jun 21, 2025 · Lou Bernard
First time visit and I was in the afternoon lull of a late lunch and had the place almost to my self. I always like to try a specialty pie when I am at a new pizza place - to see what they’re good at. When I asked the server what to best ones were, he casually mentioned that if I ordered a large I could half-and-half two specialties… color me SOLD! I was leaning toward the Italian, but worried that was too basic and he has strongly urged for the chicken Gouda. With this last bit of information in place I did both as halves! I was overly pleased with both. The Italian does not have traditional sauce, but Italian dressing. And it was zesty. I was in love, and it is always the banana papers that make a pizza for me anyway. So a double whammy - but with good meats. The chicken Gouda was Smokey and flavorful - and a smooth, perfect contrast to the zip on the other side of the pizza.Fair warning. I could not eat an entire large. In fact I could only eat 4 of the 8 slices. This crust, their cheese blend and the drizzle sauces on top DO NOT reheat well in a microwave. If that is all you have available at your workplace, leave it at home for oven or air fryer prep. That might go better.
Sep 09, 2024 · David Trisel
Excellent service with great food. We came in on a Saturday evening right before close. The manager was super attentive and the food was excellent. Went back the next day for lunch and sat at the bar. The bartender, Alex, was such a nice guy. Highly recommend this restaurant for the great food and staff.
Jul 02, 2025 · Jan Whitus