Pisillo Italian Panini

- 97 Nassau St, New York, NY 10038

For any New Yorker seeking an authentic taste of Italy without leaving the city, Pisillo Italian Panini is an absolute must-visit. Nestled on Nassau Street in the Financial District, this spot isn’t your average sandwich shop. It’s an Italian deli that prides itself on delivering an authentic experience, from the high-quality, imported ingredients to the exceptional hospitality. As many locals and tourists alike have discovered, the paninis here are not just sandwiches—they are a work of art, bursting with fresh flavors and generous portions.

The atmosphere at Pisillo is casual and trendy, with a distinct old-school, Italian feel. The walls are covered with signs and memorabilia, and the music often makes you feel as though you've been transported to a small cafe in Italy. It's a place that attracts a diverse crowd, from nearby office workers grabbing a quick lunch to university students and tourists from all over. The staff, often described as "amazing" and "exceptional," adds to the welcoming and friendly environment, making every visit a pleasant one. While the space is small and can get busy, the fast and efficient service ensures you won't be waiting long for your culinary masterpiece.

Pisillo Italian Panini is conveniently located at 97 Nassau Street, New York, NY 10038. Its position in the heart of the Financial District makes it a prime destination for a midday meal. The area is well-connected by numerous subway lines and bus routes, making it easily accessible from all corners of the city. For those who choose to drive, paid street parking is available, though it can be competitive during peak hours. The restaurant is also designed with accessibility in mind, featuring a wheelchair-accessible entrance to ensure everyone can enjoy their delicious offerings.

The vibrant neighborhood surrounding the restaurant is a mix of historical sites, office buildings, and retail shops, making Pisillo a great stop before or after exploring the area. Its location is a significant part of its appeal, drawing in a steady stream of satisfied customers who are often amazed by the quality of the food and the speed of the service, a rare combination in such a busy urban environment. It's a genuine slice of Italy tucked away in one of New York's most famous neighborhoods.

Pisillo Italian Panini offers a variety of services to accommodate all diners, whether you have time to sit and savor your meal or need to grab and go.

• Dine-in: The restaurant has counter service and some seating available for those who want to enjoy their panini in the lively atmosphere. It's a great choice for solo dining or a quick, casual lunch with friends.

• Takeaway: Given the fast-paced nature of the area, many customers opt for takeaway. The paninis are well-packaged, making them easy to enjoy on the go. The generous size of each panini means they can even be shared for a less-messy, on-the-go experience.

• Delivery: Pisillo provides both regular and no-contact delivery options, bringing their incredible sandwiches right to your home or office. This is a perfect solution for a business lunch or a cozy night in when you’re craving a taste of Italy.

• Counter Service: The counter service model contributes to the fast and efficient experience. Customers can quickly place their order, and the paninis are prepared with impressive speed, a highlight that many reviews praise.

What truly sets Pisillo Italian Panini apart from other sandwich spots in the city is the dedication to quality and authenticity.

• Authentic Italian Paninis: The menu features over 30 different paninis, each named after an Italian city, such as the "Roma," "Milano," and "Napoli." They are made with imported Italian meats, cheeses, and vegetables, and served on outstanding, fresh-baked bread that is crispy on the outside and soft inside. Unlike some places, they serve what many call a hero, not a flat-pressed panini, which allows them to pack a huge amount of fresh ingredients inside.

• Generous Portions: The paninis are famously large and incredibly filling. Many customers note that one sandwich is often enough for two people, offering incredible value for the price. The "Pisillo Panini" in particular is a customer favorite, combining prosciutto di parma, porchetta, buffalo mozzarella, and roasted peppers for a truly epic meal.

• Fresh and High-Quality Ingredients: Reviews consistently highlight the freshness of the ingredients. From the perfectly fresh mozzarella to the flavorful roasted peppers and prosciutto, every component is chosen for its quality. The sauces and spreads, while sometimes a bit messy, are noted for their incredible flavor that complements the fillings perfectly.

• Vegetarian Options: Pisillo offers a dedicated "Vegetarian Panini" with sun-dried tomatoes, roasted peppers, artichokes, and arugula, as well as other options like the "Ancona" and "Campobasso" paninis, ensuring that vegetarian diners have plenty of delicious choices.

• Desserts and Sides: In addition to the main attraction, the menu includes a variety of classic Italian sides and desserts, such as sfogliatelle, cannoli, and various biscotti and tarts. These are perfect for finishing off your meal with a sweet, authentic treat.

• Cash Only Policy: A key feature to note is that Pisillo is a cash-only establishment. However, they have an ATM inside for the convenience of their customers, so you can easily get cash if needed.

For more information or to plan your visit, you can reach out to Pisillo Italian Panini.

Address: 97 Nassau St, New York, NY 10038, USA
Phone: (212) 227-3104

For a New Yorker, choosing a sandwich can be a serious decision, and Pisillo Italian Panini makes that choice an easy one. What makes this place truly worth it is the commitment to authentic, high-quality Italian ingredients and the sheer size of their creations. When you order a panini here, you are not just getting a simple sandwich; you are getting a meal so substantial and flavorful that it could easily serve two. The value for the price is exceptional, especially given the prime location and the quality of ingredients, many of which are imported directly from Italy.

The dining experience itself is a major draw. The fast service and the genuinely friendly, hospitable staff create a welcoming environment that makes every visit a pleasure. They have mastered the art of providing a quick bite that feels anything but rushed. The diverse crowd of locals and visitors speaks volumes about the widespread appeal of their food. Whether you're a student, a professional, or a tourist exploring downtown, you’ll find that Pisillo feels like a part of the community.

The unique menu, with paninis named after Italian cities, invites you to try something new each time. The "Pisillo Panini" is often recommended as a perfect starting point, but you can't go wrong with any of their meat or vegetarian options. The bread, which is a major highlight, is a crucial part of the experience, serving as the perfect vessel for the incredible fillings. The generous amounts of fresh mozzarella, high-quality prosciutto, and other delicious ingredients ensure every bite is a flavor explosion. While the sauces can be a little messy, they are part of the fun and the overall deliciousness. In a city where quick food can often mean a compromise on quality, Pisillo Italian Panini stands out as a place that delivers an authentic, satisfying, and truly memorable meal.

Pisillo Italian Panini

97 Nassau St, New York, NY 10038, USA