Pizza Fenice

- 304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803

For pizza lovers in New York, the search for the perfect slice is a never-ending quest, but for those in Westchester County, Pizza Fenice in Pelham is a formidable contender. Located on Fifth Avenue, this pizzeria has quickly established itself as a must-visit spot, earning a reputation for its fantastic flavors and consistent quality. What sets Pizza Fenice apart is its dedication to perfecting various styles of pizza, from the classic New York slice to the increasingly popular Detroit-style deep-dish pies. The restaurant's commitment to culinary excellence is evident in every bite, delivering a delicious experience that justifies every dollar spent.

Pizza Fenice is more than just a place to grab a quick slice; it’s a destination for a truly satisfying meal. The atmosphere is casual, cozy, and trendy, making it a comfortable spot for a solo diner or a small group. Whether you're craving a traditional slice, a hearty calzone, or one of their inventive specialty pizzas, the menu offers a wide variety of options that are both familiar and exciting. This article will guide you through what makes Pizza Fenice a top-tier choice for New Yorkers, covering its convenient location, diverse service options, unique menu highlights, and the specific dishes that have garnered rave reviews from satisfied customers.

Pizza Fenice is conveniently situated at 304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803. This address places it in the heart of Pelham, a charming town in Westchester County. The location is easily accessible for residents and visitors alike, making it a central spot for a quick lunch or a dinner pickup. Its placement on Fifth Avenue ensures it is easy to find, whether you are a local or just passing through.

When it comes to parking, the restaurant offers paid street parking nearby, which is a common and convenient option in this area. For those with mobility needs, the restaurant has a wheelchair accessible entrance, making it a welcoming place for all customers. While the seating is described as limited—comfortably seating two people or three people tightly—it provides a cozy spot for a quick bite. This intimate setting encourages a focus on the delicious food and casual dining experience.

Pizza Fenice provides a variety of services to accommodate the preferences and schedules of its customers.

• Curbside Pickup: This convenient service allows you to get your order without having to leave your car, perfect for a fast and efficient pickup.

• Delivery: For those who prefer to enjoy their pizza at home, the restaurant offers a reliable delivery service, bringing their delicious food right to your doorstep.

• Takeout: Takeout is a popular option, with many slices ready to go in front for those in a hurry. You can grab your favorite slice or a whole pie to enjoy elsewhere.

• Dine-in: The cozy indoor seating is available for a relaxed meal. It’s an ideal setting for a casual lunch or dinner with a friend or two.

Pizza Fenice has several key features that make it a standout choice for pizza enthusiasts in the New York area.

• High-Quality Pizza: The restaurant is known for its exceptional flavors and consistent quality, with one reviewer calling it a "top 3 contender for best pizza in Westchester County."

• Variety of Pizza Styles: They excel in more than just one type of pizza. Their menu includes NY slices, Sicilian slices, Grandma's slices, and, most notably, Detroit-style pizzas, which are highly praised by customers.

• Inventive Menu Items: Beyond the traditional pizzas, the menu features a wide array of "Not So Traditional Pizzas," with unique names and creative toppings like The Angry Drunk Bird and The Pastrami Reuben, showcasing their innovative spirit.

• Reasonable Prices: The prices are considered reasonable for the high level of deliciousness and quality, making it a great value for the money.

• Friendly and Casual Atmosphere: The ambiance is relaxed and comfortable, making it a great spot for solo dining or a small gathering. It's also family-friendly and a good spot for kids.

• Vegetarian Options: The menu includes a variety of vegetarian options, such as the Veggie Slice and Eggplant Parm Roll, ensuring that there's something for everyone.

To place an order or get more information, here is the contact information for Pizza Fenice.

• Address: 304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, USA

• Phone: (914) 633-3332

The menu at Pizza Fenice is extensive, offering a delicious dilemma of what to choose. However, based on customer reviews and menu highlights, a few items are an absolute must-try. The Detroit-style pizzas are a clear standout. One customer was "absolutely blown away" by it, noting the "cheesy, crunchy goodness" and the great flavor of the sauce. If you're looking for a deep-dish square pie, the Detroit Red or Detroit Bandiera are excellent choices.

For those who prefer a classic New York slice, the Plain Slice and the Sicilian Slice are fantastic choices, known for their traditional preparation and satisfying flavors. The Grandma's Slice and Grandma Vodka Slice are also highly recommended for their rich, hearty sauces.

Beyond the pizzas, the menu features a variety of other worthwhile items. The rolls and stromboli, such as the Chicken Roll and Meatball Parm Roll, are great for a handheld, satisfying meal. The panzerotti, a fried pizza pocket, is another unique item that's perfect for a quick bite, with options like the Prosciutto Cotto & Fresh Mozzarella Panzerotti. For an appetizer or side dish, the Arancini (fried risotto balls) and the Homemade Meatballs are excellent choices. The restaurant’s commitment to quality is evident in every item, from the sauce to the toppings. Whether you're a long-time resident or just visiting, a visit to Pizza Fenice to try their lauded Detroit-style pies or a classic New York slice is a choice you won't regret.

Pizza Fenice

304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, USA