Prime Catch

- 140 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036

In the vibrant and bustling heart of Midtown, where the lights of Broadway meet the energy of Times Square, lies a dining destination that offers a classic and comforting experience: Prime Catch. This restaurant promises more than just a meal; it provides a blend of a classic steakhouse, a fresh seafood eatery, and a cozy Italian trattoria, all wrapped in a trendy, romantic, and comfortable setting.

Prime Catch is a place designed for a variety of occasions. Whether you're a local seeking a new favorite spot, a tourist looking for an authentic New York dining experience, or a couple celebrating a special evening, the restaurant’s atmosphere and diverse menu are tailored to impress. With a welcoming bar, a great wine list, and the option for live music, it is an ideal location to relax and indulge in a memorable meal.

Prime Catch is centrally located at 140 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036, USA. This prime address places it perfectly in the Theater District, making it an excellent choice for a pre-show dinner. Its proximity to Times Square ensures it is easily accessible by a multitude of public transportation options, including various subway lines and buses that stop within a few blocks.

The restaurant has also made a conscious effort to ensure it is accessible to all. It features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, restroom, and seating, providing a comfortable and accommodating dining experience for everyone. The option for outdoor seating, with its unique sliding glass windows that let in fresh air, adds to the appeal, although it is worth noting that cigarette smoke from passersby can be a minor inconvenience. Overall, its central and accessible location makes Prime Catch a convenient and popular dining spot for both planned celebrations and spontaneous meals.

Prime Catch provides a wide array of services to cater to its diverse clientele, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable experience.

• Dine-in: The primary service is the full dining experience, offering a choice of cozy indoor seating or a trendy outdoor space. With table service, guests can enjoy a leisurely meal, whether it's for a romantic dinner or a group outing.

• Reservations: As a popular destination, especially for dinner, the restaurant accepts reservations and even recommends them. This helps ensure a table is ready for you, saving time and stress.

• Curbside Pickup and Delivery: For those who prefer to eat at home, Prime Catch offers both delivery and curbside pickup. This is a great option for a high-quality meal without the hassle of dining out.

• Takeout: Takeout is available for guests on the go, allowing them to enjoy their favorite dishes from Prime Catch wherever they are.

• Bar Onsite: The restaurant features a well-stocked bar with a great selection of beers, cocktails, and a thoughtful wine list, making it an ideal spot for a drink before your meal or a casual evening out.

Prime Catch is more than just a steakhouse; it's a multi-faceted dining establishment with several notable features.

• Diverse Culinary Offerings: The menu is a highlight, offering not only a selection of steaks and chops but also a substantial seafood and Italian section. This variety ensures that everyone in a group can find something they love, from a classic Bone-In Ribeye to a Whole Grilled Branzino or even a Chicken Parmesan.

• Great Drink Selection: With a focus on quality, the restaurant boasts a great beer selection, a fantastic wine list, and a cocktail menu. This makes it a great spot for a celebratory drink or for pairing the perfect wine with your meal.

• Romantic and Cozy Atmosphere: The ambiance is often described as cozy, romantic, and trendy. The presence of a fireplace adds a warm and intimate touch, making it a wonderful setting for a date night or a special occasion.

• Live Music: Live music is a significant feature that elevates the dining experience, adding to the romantic and vibrant atmosphere. This makes Prime Catch a destination for both great food and quality entertainment.

• Accessibility and Amenities: With features like a bar onsite, Wi-Fi, and a restroom, the restaurant is well-equipped for comfort. It is also good for kids, with high chairs available, making it a suitable choice for families.

For inquiries or to make a reservation, you can reach Prime Catch at the following contact points:

• Address: 140 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036, USA

• Phone: (646) 609-6113

While some experiences can vary, a number of dishes at Prime Catch are praised by diners. The menu offers a wide variety, so there's a lot to choose from beyond the classic steak.

The Chicken Parmesan with pasta is a standout, with one customer calling it "so delicious" and giving it a perfect score. Similarly, the Calamari has been noted for its tender texture and perfect breading, making it a great appetizer. The Mashed Potatoes are described as "silky smooth," and the Shrimp & Lobster Avocado is a popular choice for a fresh start to a meal.

As for the main courses, while steak can be inconsistent, other dishes are worth considering. The Veal Chop Milanese and Chicken Milanese are solid options from the entrée menu. The seafood selection also offers promising dishes; the Whole Grilled Branzino is praised as one of the best outside of Italy by one reviewer. The Prime Catch Seafood Pasta is another luxurious choice. For dessert, the selections have been noted as "phenomenal" and "delicious," so be sure to save room for a sweet finish.

Given the varying feedback on steaks, it's worth considering other menu items that have received consistent praise. However, if you are a steak lover, the Bone-In Ribeye and Bone-In NY Strip are signature choices. Be sure to communicate your preferences clearly to the server for the best experience. The wine and cocktail list is also a major draw, so pairing your meal with a great drink is a must. Overall, Prime Catch offers a compelling dining experience with a focus on Italian and seafood dishes that can make for a very enjoyable evening.

Prime Catch

140 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036, USA