Sexton’s Pizza

- 5460 Franklin St, Hilliard, OH 43026

For pizza aficionados across Ohio, and especially those in the Hilliard area, a name that consistently comes up in discussions about exceptional pizza is Sexton’s Pizza. Located in Hilliard, this establishment has quickly garnered a reputation, even from prominent pizza reviewers, for serving pies that are often described as “the best pizza I've ever had.” This article aims to provide a comprehensive look at what makes Sexton’s Pizza a must-visit destination for anyone in the Ohio region seeking a truly elevated pizza experience, from its unique offerings to its convenient location and the overall ambiance that keeps locals returning for more.

Sexton’s Pizza isn't just about crafting a good pizza; it's about perfecting the art. Their philosophy revolves around meticulous attention to detail, starting with their dough. Unlike many commercial pizzerias, Sexton’s makes every batch of dough by hand and allows it to rise for two days, contributing to that distinctive airy and perfectly textured crust that patrons rave about. This dedication to traditional methods and quality ingredients is evident in every bite, setting their pizzas apart in a crowded culinary landscape. Whether you prefer the classic crispness of a New York-style slice or the rich, flavorful depth of a Detroit-inspired Motown deep dish, Sexton’s delivers an experience that is both authentic and unforgettable.

The buzz around Sexton’s Pizza isn't just word-of-mouth; it's been solidified by high praise from influential critics, notably receiving an impressive 8.1 rating from Dave Portnoy’s “One Bite Pizza Reviews” series. This accolade has catapulted Sexton’s into the spotlight, validating their commitment to creating top-tier pizza. What makes their pies truly stand out, as noted by enthusiastic customers, are elements like the “perfectly charred” crust, a lightness that makes the pizza unique, and an explosion of flavor from their “excellent sauce” and “unreal toppings.” This unwavering focus on quality, combined with an inviting atmosphere, makes Sexton’s Pizza more than just a meal; it's a culinary journey that locals are proud to have in their backyard. The dedication to quality is so strong that they occasionally sell out, a testament to the high demand for their artisanal creations.

Sexton’s Pizza is conveniently located at 5460 Franklin St, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA. This address places it firmly within the heart of Hilliard, making it highly accessible for residents not only in Hilliard itself but also for those in surrounding communities across the wider Columbus metropolitan area. Franklin Street is a well-known thoroughfare, ensuring that finding the restaurant is straightforward for most visitors, whether they are driving from a nearby neighborhood or making a special trip from further afield.

For patrons arriving by car, the location generally offers accessible parking options in the vicinity, which is a practical consideration for any popular local eatery. This ease of parking contributes to a stress-free visit, allowing customers to focus on the delicious pizza awaiting them. While specific public transportation routes would need to be checked for individual accessibility, for the majority of Ohioans, personal vehicles remain the most common mode of transport, and Sexton’s Pizza's location is ideally suited for vehicular access. Its central placement in Hilliard enhances its appeal as a convenient and desirable dining destination for anyone in the region craving high-quality pizza.

Services Offered:

• Dine-in Service: Enjoy your pizza in their great atmosphere.
• Takeout Service: Order your favorite pizzas for convenient pickup.
• Online Ordering: Place orders directly through their website or third-party delivery platforms for pickup.
• Delivery Service: Available through platforms like Uber Eats, DoorDash, and Postmates, extending their reach to various parts of Columbus and surrounding areas.
• Two Pizza Styles: Offers both 16-inch NY style (8 triangular slices) and Motown deep dish (8 square slices).
• Build Your Own Pizza: Customize your pie with a variety of toppings and choice of crust.
• Specialty Pizzas: A curated selection of unique and popular pre-designed pizzas.
• Salads and Sides: Includes large salads suitable for sharing and delicious sides like garlic parm fries.
• Desserts: Offers a selection of cupcakes in flavors like Chocolate Peanut Butter, Cookies n Creme, Birthday Cake, and Red Velvet.
• Beverages: Provides a selection of sodas and possibly other drinks.
• Accepts Online Payments: Payment is typically handled via online ordering platforms for delivery and pickup.

Features / Highlights:

• Acclaimed Pizza Quality: Widely considered among the best, if not the best, pizza in Ohio, receiving high praise from customers and a notable 8.1 rating from Dave Portnoy's "One Bite Pizza Reviews."
• Handmade, Two-Day Fermented Dough: A key differentiator, contributing to an incredibly airy and perfectly crispy crust.
• Distinctive Crust Styles: Offers authentic NY style (thin and crispy) and Motown deep dish (thick, light, and perfectly charred) pizzas, catering to different preferences.
• Unique and High-Quality Toppings: Features "unreal toppings" and quality ingredients like Ezzo pepperoni, candied bacon, fresh mozzarella, and house-made sauces.
• Signature Pizzas: Popular specialty pies include "Kevin Bacon" (candied bacon and pepperoni), "MIKE!" (7/11 ground tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, cup and burn pepperoni, Mike's hot honey), and "East Village Pepperoni."
• Perfect Charring: Pizzas are noted for being "charred perfectly" without being burnt, adding to their unique flavor.
• Great Atmosphere: Customers frequently praise the pleasant dining environment within the restaurant.
• Popular Sides: Offers delicious garlic parm fries and sizable salads.
• High Demand: Known to sell out of pizza, indicating high popularity and fresh production.
• Vegan Options: Offers an "I'M VEGAN" pizza with Follow Your Heart Mozzarella Cheese and Beyond Vegan Sausage Crumble.

Sexton’s Pizza in Hilliard is an exceptionally suitable dining destination for locals across Ohio, particularly those in the Columbus metropolitan area, for several compelling reasons. Foremost among them is the unparalleled quality of their pizza. In a state with numerous pizza options, Sexton’s has consistently risen to the top, earning widespread acclaim and even national recognition for its perfectly crafted pies. Ohioans who truly appreciate artisanal pizza, with its perfectly charred crusts, unique lightness, and burst of fresh, high-quality flavors, will find Sexton’s to be a revelation. The choice between a classic NY style or a robust Motown deep dish ensures there's a perfect pie for every preference.

Beyond the exceptional food, the overall experience at Sexton’s Pizza resonates deeply with local values. The commitment to handmade dough, fresh ingredients, and a quality-over-quantity approach speaks to a genuine passion for their craft that Ohioans appreciate. The "great atmosphere" within the restaurant fosters a welcoming environment, making it an ideal spot for family dinners, gatherings with friends, or simply enjoying a top-tier meal in a comfortable setting. The fact that they occasionally sell out of pizzas isn't a drawback; it's a testament to their dedication to freshness and high demand, encouraging locals to plan ahead for a truly rewarding culinary treat.

Furthermore, its accessible location on Franklin Street in Hilliard makes it a convenient choice for a wide range of local residents. The ease of access, combined with the availability of online ordering and delivery services through major platforms, means that enjoying Sexton's acclaimed pizza is simpler than ever. For locals seeking not just a meal, but a culinary experience that consistently delivers on taste, quality, and an authentic passion for pizza, Sexton’s Pizza in Hilliard is undoubtedly a cherished local gem and a destination that lives up to its extraordinary reputation.

Sexton’s Pizza

5460 Franklin St, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA