Strictly Pizza in Pelham: A Modern Take on a NY Classic

Strictly Pizza Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For those on the hunt for a truly exceptional slice of New York pizza, Strictly Pizza in Pelham is an absolute gem. This pizzeria, located on the historic Boston Post Road, has quickly become a local favorite, known for its commitment to quality, a clean and modern aesthetic, and an incredibly friendly staff. Unlike many traditional pizzerias, Strictly Pizza stands out with a bright, welcoming atmosphere that makes it a perfect spot for both a quick bite and a relaxed meal. The name says it all: their focus is on mastering the art of the pie, offering a menu that is, as the name suggests, "strictly" about pizza, along with a few carefully chosen complementary items like calzones and garlic knots.

The owners, a local family, wanted to create a space that was different from a typical pizzeria, and they succeeded. The interior boasts a clean, marble aesthetic, and the team takes great pride in using fresh ingredients to create a truly delicious product. Their expertise is evident, with the staff having at least 20 years of experience in the pizzeria business. This dedication to craftsmanship and a customer-first approach has earned them rave reviews, with patrons praising everything from the taste of their food to the warmth of the service. Whether you're grabbing a single slice or a full pie for the family, you can be confident that you're getting a top-notch product.

---

Location and Accessibility

Strictly Pizza is conveniently located at 4400 Boston Post Rd, Pelham, NY 10803, USA. Situated right on a major thoroughfare, it is easy to find and access from various parts of Westchester County and beyond. The location is particularly convenient for drivers, as the restaurant offers a free parking lot and on-site parking. This is a significant advantage in a busy area, allowing customers to easily stop by for a quick slice or a takeout order without the stress of finding a spot.

The pizzeria is also highly accessible to people with mobility challenges. It features a wheelchair accessible entrance, a wheelchair accessible parking lot, a wheelchair accessible restroom, and wheelchair accessible seating. This thoughtful design ensures that every customer can enjoy a comfortable and convenient dining experience. The combination of a prime location and inclusive amenities makes Strictly Pizza a welcoming destination for everyone in the community.

---

Services Offered

Curbside pickup: For a fast and convenient way to get your order, you can arrange for curbside pickup.
Takeout: Place your order and pick it up to enjoy at home, work, or wherever you like.
Dine-in: Settle into the ultra-clean and modern dining area for a casual and cozy meal.

---

Features / Highlights

Fast Service: Customers praise the staff for their quick and efficient service.
Modern and Clean Vibe: The restaurant's aesthetic is noted for being "ultra-clean" and "modern," offering a different feel from a traditional pizzeria.
Dedicated to Pizza: The menu is focused entirely on pizza and related items like calzones, ensuring that what they do, they do well.
Wide Variety of Slices and Pies: The menu includes both classic favorites like the Cheese Slice and Pepperoni Pie, as well as unique creations like the Chicken Scarpariello Pie and Shrimp Scampi Pie.
Gluten-Free Options: A 12" Gluten Free Cheese Pizza is available, catering to those with dietary restrictions.
Beverages, Rolls, and Desserts: In addition to pizza, they offer a selection of soda, water, rolls, calzones, and desserts like Zeppoli and Nutella Pizza.
Good for Kids: The casual and friendly environment makes it a great spot for families with children.

---

Contact Information

Address: 4400 Boston Post Rd, Pelham, NY 10803, USA

Phone: (914) 738-0024

---

What is worth choosing

What makes Strictly Pizza truly stand out is its unwavering commitment to quality and its focus on a singular product. While many pizzerias try to do a little bit of everything, Strictly Pizza has chosen to "wear one hat and wear it well," and the results are undeniable. The pizza itself is consistently described as "delicious" and "fantastic" by customers, with the crust and sauce receiving particular praise. The variety of both slices and full pies ensures that there's always something to try, whether you're a purist or looking for a more adventurous flavor combination. A customer review highlighted the "delicious" garlic knots and the perfectly flavored hot marinara, proving that the attention to detail extends beyond just the main pies.

The menu is a testament to the kitchen's creativity and skill. Beyond the classics, unique options like the Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Pie and the Chicken & Vodka Sauce Slice offer a gourmet twist on traditional favorites. The Grandma Pie and Sicilian Pie are also available for those who prefer a thicker, more rustic crust. The fact that the restaurant offers a Gluten Free Cheese Pizza is a thoughtful touch that broadens its appeal to a wider audience.

Beyond the food, the overall experience at Strictly Pizza is what keeps people coming back. The staff is consistently described as "super friendly" and "awesome," making every visit a pleasant one. The "ultra-clean" and "modern" aesthetic creates a comfortable and inviting space that feels a cut above your typical local pizzeria. For New Yorkers in the Pelham area, Strictly Pizza is more than just a place to get a quick bite; it's a reliable, high-quality local business that delivers on its promise of great food and a welcoming atmosphere. As one review enthusiastically states, "You won’t be disappointed in a bit."

Strictly Pizza Menu

Slice
Pepperoni Slice $5.75
Savory pepperoni on a classic slice, perfect for a quick and satisfying bite.
Chicken & Bacon Slice $6.50
Savory chicken and bacon slice, perfect for a quick bite or a satisfying meal.
Chicken & Vodka Sauce Slice $6.50
Savor a slice topped with chicken and creamy vodka sauce for a unique twist on classic pizza flavors.
Margherita Slice $6.00
Classic slice with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil for a simple yet delicious taste.
Chicken Scarp $7.00
Savory chicken with a blend of spices, perfect for a quick and satisfying bite.
Sicilian $5.25
Thick, square pizza slice with a crispy crust, topped with rich tomato sauce and melted cheese.
Cheese Slice $5.00
Classic cheese slice with a generous layer of melted cheese on a crispy crust.
White Slice $5.25
Creamy mozzarella and ricotta on a crispy crust, topped with a hint of garlic and herbs.
Upside Down Slice $5.25
A unique pizza slice with toppings baked beneath The Crust for a delightful twist on classic flavors.
Chicken Parm Slice $6.50
Crispy chicken topped with marinara and melted cheese on a pizza slice for a savory delight.
Grandma Slice $5.25
Square slice topped with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and herbs for a classic, comforting taste.
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Slice $7.00
Savor a slice topped with savory sausage and broccoli rabe, offering a delightful blend of flavors.
Buffalo Slice $6.50
Savory slice topped with Buffalo sauce, perfect for a spicy kick in every bite.
Veggie Slice $7.00
Vegetarian. A delicious slice topped with fresh veggies, perfect for a light and satisfying meal.

Pinwheels
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Pinwheel $8.00
Savory pinwheels with sausage and broccoli rabe, perfect for a flavorful bite.
Pepperoni Pinwheel $7.00
Savory pinwheels filled with pepperoni, perfect for a quick and delicious bite.
Spinach Pinwheel $7.00
Savory pinwheels filled with fresh spinach, perfect for a delightful snack or appetizer.

Pizza
Chicken & Vodka Sauce Pie $42.00
Tender chicken enveloped in a creamy vodka sauce, baked to perfection in a flaky pie crust.
Cheese Pie $28.00
Golden, flaky crust filled with rich, melted cheese for a savory delight.
Veggie Pie $42.00
Vegetarian. A delightful pie filled with fresh veggies, perfect for a wholesome and satisfying meal.
Shrimp Scampi Pie $44.00
Shrimp, garlic, olive oil, fresh parsley, lemon zest, and mozzarella cheese on a savory crust.
BBQ Chicken Pie $37.00
Savory chicken pie topped with barbecue sauce, offering a delightful twist on classic flavors.
Pasta Pie $34.00
Layer of ziti , mozzarella, and ricotta cheese baked into a hearty pie. Don’t forget to add vodka sauce or marinara sauce in the modify section.
Chicken Scarpariello Pie $42.00
Savory pizza topped with chicken, peppers, and onions, offering a delightful blend of flavors.
Chicken & Bacon Pie $37.00
Savory pie filled with tender chicken and crispy bacon, wrapped in a flaky crust for a hearty delight.
Grandpa Pie $38.00
Savory pie topped with pesto, offering a delightful twist on classic flavors.
Grilled Chicken Primavera Pie $42.00
Topped with grilled chicken, zucchini , and broccoli on a cheesy base.
12” Gluten Free Cheese Pizza $19.00
Gluten free.
Grandma Pie $36.00
A classic square pizza with a thick, airy crust, topped with tangy tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
Hot Mami Pie $42.00
Pepperoni pie with a sweet and spicy twist, drizzled with hot honey for a bald flavor.
Big Papi Pie $42.00
Crispy cheese pie with jalapeños, bacon, tomato, and basil. They don’t call it big Papi for nothing.
Buffalo Pie $37.00
Savory pizza topped with spicy Buffalo sauce, perfect for a bold flavor experience. Please let us know if you prefer a ranch drizzle or a blue cheese drizzle in the notes section at check out.
Margherita Pie $34.00
Classic pizza with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil for a simple yet delicious taste.
White Pie $32.00
Creamy pizza topped with mozzarella, ricotta, and garlic, offering a rich, cheesy delight.
Sicilian Pie $32.00
Savory Sicilian pie topped with rich tomato sauce, mozzarella, and a blend of Italian herbs.
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Pie $42.00
Savory pie with sausage and broccoli rabe, offering a delightful blend of flavors in every bite.
Trio Pie $40.00
Square pie topped with tomato, pesto, vodka sauce, and mozzarella for a delightful flavor trio.
Pepperoni Pie $32.00
Crispy pizza topped with savory pepperoni for a classic, mouthwatering experience.
Upside Down Pie $32.00
A unique twist on pizza with layers of savory toppings baked to perfection in a pie form.
Chicken Parm Pie $37.00
Savory pizza topped with crispy chicken, rich tomato sauce, and melted cheese for a delightful twist.

Beverages
2 Liter Soda $6.00
Soda Can $3.00
Refreshing soda in a convenient can, perfect for pairing with your favorite pizza.
Bottled Water $2.00
Soda Bottle $4.00

Garlic Knots
6 Garlic Knots $4.00
Cheesy garlic knots with basil, perfect for a savory snack or side.

Dessert
Nutella Pizza $24.00
Sweet pizza topped with creamy Nutella, perfect for a delightful dessert treat.
Zeppoli (3) $5.50
Light, airy Italian pastries dusted with powdered sugar, perfect for a sweet treat.

Rolls
Sausage & Peppers Roll $11.00
Savor the classic combo of sausage and peppers, wrapped in a roll for a hearty, flavorful bite.
Broccoli Rabe & Grilled Chicken Roll $13.00
Grilled chicken paired with broccoli rabe for a savory roll experience.
Chicken & Parm Roll $11.00
Chicken and Parmesan rolled together for a savory delight.

Calzone
Cheese Calzone $9.50
Savory calzone filled with melted cheese, perfect for a cheesy delight in every bite.
Chicken Calzone $13.00
Savory calzone filled with tender chicken, perfect for a hearty meal.

Sauces
Extra Marinara Sauce $1.50
One Garlic Sauce $1.50
Freshly made rich and creamy garlic sauce, perfect for enhancing your favorite dishes with a savory kick.

Strictly Pizza Details

Service options
Curbside pickup
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Comfort food
Quick bite
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Locals

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Free parking lot
On-site parking
Parking

Strictly Pizza Photos

Strictly Pizza Location

Strictly Pizza

New York Westchester County Pelham Manor Boston Post Road

4400 Boston Post Rd, Pelham, NY 10803, USA

Strictly Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★4.9 from 121 user reviews.

garlic knotspiegarlic saucetoppingspepperonimarinara saucemargaritashrimp scampigrandma slicefoodie

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

What a great find on Boston Road! Ultra-clean, modern, and the staff were super friendly. We grabbed a plain pizza slice and a chicken parm slice, plus garlic knots with hot marinara, and everything tasted fantastic. The vibe is cozy and welcoming, and we’re already planning our next visit to try more options. Highly recommend Strickly Pizza if you’re in the Bronx.
August 15 · Rosie Cruz-Gutierrez
This place deserves 5 Stars. Everything was top notch. The pizza, calzones, garlic knots and zeppoles were delicious some of the best we’ve had in a while. The staff were very friendly (an extra plus, Arsenal fans). The prices are more than reasonable. The place clean and bright. We’ll definitely be back for more. So if you are looking for some awesome food, stop on by and give them a try. You won’t be disappointed in a bit.
April 18 · Eddie S.
One week after opening, I enjoyed a Margherita slice that could win a contest. The crust was crisp, soft inside, not burned. The flavor of the tomato sauce was excellent: natural, not sweetened, no hard burn from acidic tomatoes. Truly worth the price to get a pizza that is not just pizza "from the corner".The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful. The place is nice, clean, and stands out from your usual pizzeria. I tried Margherita, chicken scarpariello, shrimp scampi, chicken bacon, grandma's, zeppolis, and have not been disappointed at all.Still one of the best pizzas out there.
August 13 · Marc Boris Dombrowa
Toppings are always fresh, and you can tell they really care about quality. Whether it’s a classic pepperoni or a more creative specialty pie, every slice hits the spot. Fast, friendly service and a cozy vibe make it even better. Highly recommend for any pizza lover!
April 05 · Gabriel Zaro
This establishment is beyond beautiful, the staff is amazing and super friendly. Their patience is unmatched and the slices are fresh. They even sell some retail gear here. We visited on Monday afternoon, we waited about 4 minutes for our pizzas, paid and sat at their back tables. We ordered 2 pepperoni slices, and a mushroom pizza. It is a special topping which I highly recommend. The garlic butter dipping sauce is delectable! Try it if you visit. The decor is gorgeous and you wouldn’t even think twice aboutComing back because it doesn’t feel like your traditional pizza establishment. Their prices were super affordable for our party of 4 and were totally worth it.
May 12 · Esthepany Francisco