West Side Pie

- 684 12th Ave, New York, NY 10019

In a city famous for its pizza, standing out can be a real challenge. Yet, West Side Pie has quietly become a beloved institution for locals in the Midtown area, earning a reputation for serving up authentic, high-quality New York-style pizza. Tucked away on 12th Avenue, this no-frills pizzeria is a testament to the idea that great food and friendly service are the most important ingredients for a successful restaurant. It's the kind of place you stumble upon and instantly feel like a regular, a true neighborhood gem that keeps people coming back for more. Whether you're a local on your lunch break or a tourist exploring the West Side, West Side Pie offers a comforting and delicious experience that captures the essence of classic New York pizza culture.

The atmosphere at West Side Pie is refreshingly casual and unpretentious. It's a place where you can walk in and immediately feel at ease. The focus here is on the food, not on a flashy ambiance, which is a big part of its charm. Customers consistently praise the quality of the products used, noting that the difference is noticeable compared to other places in the area. The menu offers all the "ol' faithfuls" you'd expect, from a classic cheese pie to a variety of specialty pizzas. One review from a loyal customer highlights the consistent quality, stating they "come here everyday for lunch with my colleagues" and that the "pizza is awesome." This kind of repeated patronage from local workers is a strong indicator of a restaurant's value and reliability. The friendly service, mentioned by a visitor who was given "a great tip on sight seeing the city," adds a personal touch that makes a visit to West Side Pie feel special.

West Side Pie is located at 684 12th Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA. This places it on the western edge of Manhattan, a stone's throw from the Hudson River and key attractions like the Intrepid Sea, Air & Space Museum. Its location makes it a convenient stop for those visiting the Intrepid Museum or the nearby piers. The area is also home to many businesses and residential buildings, making it a reliable lunch spot for locals.

While a little off the main public transit routes, the restaurant is easily accessible by foot from the Hell's Kitchen and Midtown neighborhoods. For those with cars, West Side Pie offers both Curbside pickup and a Drive-through, a rare and highly convenient feature for a New York City eatery. These services make it easy for customers to get their order without having to find parking, which is an amenity that is highly valued by New Yorkers. The restaurant is also designed to be accessible, with features such as wheelchair-accessible entrances, and a welcoming environment that is suitable for solo diners, families, and groups.

West Side Pie offers a variety of services and a menu that caters to different needs and cravings.

• Service Options: The restaurant provides a range of convenient options, including Dine-in with seating and Counter service for those who want a quick meal. For those on the go, Takeout, Curbside pickup, and even a Drive-through are available, which are rare and very welcome services in the city.

• Dining Options: The menu is perfect for Lunch and Dinner. They offer a variety of pizza pies, calzones, and other classic comfort foods. The availability of pizza "by the slice" makes it an ideal spot for a quick bite. They also offer Catering services, making it a great option for events and office lunches.

• Offerings: The menu is centered on comfort food, with a focus on quick and satisfying bites. The core of the menu is pizza, with a variety of classic and specialty pies. They also offer popular sides like Garlic Knots, Mozzarella Sticks, and Chicken Wings. The availability of a Round 12" Gluten Free pie is a great feature for those with dietary restrictions.

• Payments: A variety of payment methods are accepted for a seamless checkout experience, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

• Family and Pets: The establishment is family-friendly and considered "good for kids." They also allow dogs outside, which is a nice perk for pet owners.

The features and highlights of West Side Pie are what truly make it stand out.

• Quality Ingredients: Customers consistently praise the quality of the ingredients used in the pizzas. This focus on premium products ensures a better flavor and a more authentic taste compared to competitors.

• Excellent Side Dishes: Beyond the pizza, West Side Pie is known for its delicious sides. The "fried zeppoles are to die for!" according to one customer, and another praised the "fried cheese calzone" and "chicken wings."

• Friendly Service: The service is a consistent highlight. One customer noted that the staff member (possibly the owner) was "extremely friendly" and even offered helpful advice on sightseeing. This kind of personal touch is a major draw.

• Classic New York-style Pizza: The restaurant's pizzas, sold both as full pies and "by the slice," are a quintessential representation of the New York-style. Thin crust, perfectly balanced sauce and cheese, and just the right amount of grease make for a perfect foldable slice.

• Convenient Services: The inclusion of a Drive-through, Curbside pickup, and Takeout options sets West Side Pie apart, providing a level of convenience that is highly valued in New York City.

For direct inquiries or to place an order, you can contact West Side Pie using the details below.

Address: 684 12th Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA

Phone: (347) 605-0178

Mobile Phone: +1 347-605-0178

What is truly worth choosing at West Side Pie is its dedication to quality and a classic, authentic experience. While some restaurants rely on gimmicks, West Side Pie succeeds by doing the basics exceptionally well. A customer who stopped by after visiting the Intrepid Museum noted that "Everything was awesome—the pizza, sauces and service." This holistic praise speaks volumes about the consistency and quality of the entire dining experience. A local who eats there daily with colleagues is a testament to the reliability and value. The fried zeppoles, described as "to die for," are a perfect example of how the restaurant excels even in its side dishes, turning a simple dessert into a memorable highlight. For anyone looking for a no-nonsense, high-quality, and delicious slice of pizza with a side of friendly, local service, West Side Pie is a must-visit. It's a place that proves the old-school New York pizzeria is alive and well, serving up a slice of tradition with every order.

West Side Pie

684 12th Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA