Bartolo's Contemporary Mexican Cuisine

- 714 11th Ave, New York, NY 10019

In a city as vast and culinarily diverse as New York, finding a Mexican restaurant that stands out from the crowd can be a challenge. But for those in the know, Bartolo's Contemporary Mexican Cuisine is a true hidden gem. Located on a quiet stretch in Hell's Kitchen, this restaurant is praised for elevating Mexican food beyond the typical and commercial, offering authentic, flavorful, and simply wonderful dishes. It’s a place that foodies and critics alike compare to Michelin-starred restaurants, yet it maintains a warm, inviting, and casual atmosphere. Bartolo's is the kind of spot that’s perfect for a wide range of occasions, from a laid-back dinner with friends to a special celebration. This article will provide a comprehensive guide to what makes Bartolo's a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a top-tier Mexican dining experience in New York City.

Bartolo's has quickly established itself as a great addition to both the neighborhood and the broader NYC food scene. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, providing a comfortable setting that is both casual and elegant. The restaurant is family-friendly and welcoming to all, with a notable commitment to being an LGBTQ+ friendly and transgender-safe space, which adds to its inclusive charm. The crowd is a mix of locals who appreciate its quality and those who have traveled to experience its unique menu. The fast and attentive service is a highlight, with staff members being described as personable and dedicated, ensuring every guest feels well taken care of. This combination of a sophisticated menu and a relaxed, friendly environment is what sets Bartolo's apart from other Mexican restaurants in the city.

The culinary philosophy at Bartolo's focuses on authentic, high-quality Mexican flavors with a contemporary twist. The dishes are designed to be a true representation of Mexican cuisine, made without cutting corners or using "syrup alternatives" in their drinks. The chefs at Bartolo’s use their expertise to create dishes that are both classic and innovative, from the exquisite tuna appetizer to the authentic tamarind margarita. The menu is not just about the food but also about a commitment to a full sensory experience that is "high up there" with some of the best restaurants in the world. It’s a place where every bite tells a story and where a simple meal can feel like a culinary adventure. The focus on authenticity and quality is a significant draw for anyone looking for a truly memorable Mexican dining experience.

Bartolo's is conveniently located at 714 11th Ave, New York, NY 10019, placing it in the vibrant neighborhood of Hell's Kitchen. This area is known for its diverse culinary scene and its proximity to the Theater District, making Bartolo's an excellent choice for a meal before or after a show. The restaurant’s location is easily accessible by various forms of public transportation, including several subway lines and bus routes. For those driving, paid street parking is available in the vicinity, though it's always wise to be prepared for the typical New York parking challenges.

The restaurant is designed with accessibility in mind, providing a comfortable experience for all guests. It features both a wheelchair-accessible restroom and seating, ensuring that people with mobility needs can dine with ease. The atmosphere, while sophisticated, remains casual and welcoming, making it a great spot for various crowds and occasions. The option to make reservations is a valuable service that helps guests plan their visit and avoid potential wait times, especially during popular dinner hours. This combination of a central location and thoughtful amenities makes Bartolo's a convenient and accommodating dining destination in the city.

• Dine-in: The primary service at Bartolo's is the dine-in experience. With its warm and inviting atmosphere, it's the perfect place to sit down and enjoy a full meal. The restaurant offers seating and counter service, providing a comfortable environment for both solo diners and groups. The attentive table service is a recurring highlight in customer reviews, ensuring a pleasant and relaxed dining experience.

• Takeout: For those who prefer to enjoy their meal at home or on the go, Bartolo's offers a takeout service. You can place your order and pick it up at your convenience, making it a great option for a quick bite without the wait. Curbside pickup is also available, adding to the convenience for customers.

• Catering: While the provided information doesn’t specify a full catering menu, the restaurant’s offerings of appetizers, entrees, and sides are well-suited for catering events. The ability to bring the authentic and flavorful dishes of Bartolo's to your party or gathering is a great benefit for those planning a special event.

• Reservations: Bartolo's accepts reservations, which is a key service given its popularity. It is recommended to book a table in advance, especially for dinner, to ensure a spot and avoid any potential wait. This service allows for better planning and a more seamless dining experience.

• Authentic and High-Quality Cuisine: Customers rave about the authenticity and quality of the food. Unlike "commercial" Mexican food, the dishes at Bartolo's are described as being "authentic, flavorful, simply wonderful." The restaurant's use of real, high-quality ingredients, like in their **tamarind margarita** which is not made with "syrup alternatives," is a major highlight.

• Great Cocktails: The drink menu is a significant feature, with customers praising the quality of the cocktails. The **Spicy Cucumber Margarita** and **Pomegranate Picante** are just a couple of the unique and delicious options available. The bar onsite is an excellent amenity for those looking to enjoy a drink with their meal.

• Welcoming and Inclusive Atmosphere: Bartolo's is noted for its friendly, casual, and warm environment. Its status as an LGBTQ+ friendly and transgender-safe space highlights its commitment to being a welcoming place for everyone. The crowd is described as family-friendly, and the restaurant is considered "good for kids," making it a versatile option for various groups.

• Fast and Attentive Service: Despite the high quality of the food, the service is consistently praised for being fast and attentive. This efficiency ensures a great dining experience, whether you are on a tight schedule for a show or just want a quick and delicious meal.

• Address: 714 11th Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA

• Phone: (917) 475-1118

Navigating the menu at Bartolo's Contemporary Mexican Cuisine is an exciting journey through innovative and classic flavors. For a first-timer, there are several dishes that come highly recommended by those who have experienced the magic of this kitchen. For starters, the **Atún Tostaditas** is a must-try appetizer. One customer described the tuna appetizer as "exquisite," a testament to its high quality and memorable taste. The **Guacamole With Guajillo Chips** is another excellent choice, offering a fresh take on a classic. The chips, made in-house, are a noteworthy detail that contributes to the authenticity and flavor of the dish.

When it comes to the main entrees, the options are plentiful and diverse. The **Quesadilla De Pollo Y Tres Quesos** is a safe and delicious bet for a satisfying meal. For those looking for a more adventurous dish, the **Mixiote De Borrego** and **Carne En Tamarindo** are excellent choices that showcase the kitchen's creative flair and commitment to rich, authentic flavors. If you're a seafood lover, the **Branzino Al Pastor** and **Salmon Jarocho** are worth considering. These dishes highlight the restaurant's ability to seamlessly blend traditional Mexican spices with a variety of proteins. And for those looking for a classic, a simple side of **Tacos** or **Steak Asada Tacos** will not disappoint.

No meal at Bartolo's would be complete without trying one of their celebrated drinks and desserts. The **Tamarind Margarita** is highly praised for being "authentic, delicious," and not made with artificial syrups. The **Spicy Cucumber Margarita** is another great choice for a unique and refreshing drink. For dessert, the **Tres Leches Mezcal** and **Pastel De Chocolate** are excellent ways to end your meal on a sweet note. With options like **Fried Sweet Corn Bread** and **Sweet Corn Tamal** on the side menu, you can create a perfectly balanced and flavorful meal. The overall consensus is that the food is a step above the rest, and the entire staff is personable and attentive, making your entire dining experience a memorable one. Bartolo's is a true gem in the NYC food scene, and it’s a place you will definitely want to come back to.

Bartolo's Contemporary Mexican Cuisine

714 11th Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA