Bexley Pizza Plus

- 2651 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209

For pizza aficionados across Ohio, particularly those in the heart of the state, Bexley Pizza Plus stands as a significant landmark in the local culinary landscape. Located conveniently at 2651 E Main St in Columbus, this establishment has carved out a reputation, with many proclaiming it to offer "the best pizza in central Ohio hands down." While individual tastes and experiences can always vary, Bexley Pizza Plus aims to deliver a memorable pizza experience through its diverse menu, quality ingredients, and welcoming atmosphere.

Bexley Pizza Plus prides itself on crafting pizzas that truly resonate with its loyal customer base. A standout feature, as highlighted by glowing reviews, is their specialty pizzas. The "carbonara pizza and white pizza are chef's kiss," according to one enthusiastic patron, indicating a mastery of both traditional and more innovative flavor combinations. The inclusion of "mini pepperonis" also seems to be a delightful detail that sets their pizzas apart, appealing to those who appreciate nuanced textures and flavors. Beyond their celebrated pies, the establishment offers a comfortable dining atmosphere with ample seating and a selection of drinks, making it suitable for both a quick bite and a more relaxed meal. While one review described an "underwhelming" visit, citing unremarkable pizza and indifferent service, the prevailing sentiment from many customers points to a positive and satisfying experience, emphasizing their dedication to quality ingredients, including fresh dough made daily, 100% real cheese, fresh-cut veggies, and homemade sauce.

Bexley Pizza Plus is conveniently situated at 2651 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209, USA. This prime location places it directly on East Main Street, a bustling and easily navigable thoroughfare that forms a vital link between various parts of Columbus and its charming suburb, Bexley. The restaurant's position on such a prominent road ensures excellent visibility and straightforward access for local residents, whether they are coming from the heart of Bexley, other Columbus neighborhoods, or even farther afield in Central Ohio.

For those traveling by car, Bexley Pizza Plus typically offers ample parking nearby, making it convenient for customers who wish to dine in or pick up their orders. The strategic placement on a main road also means that the pizzeria is often well-served by local public transportation routes, providing an accessible option for patrons who prefer not to drive. This combination of a central, desirable location within a vibrant community and practical accessibility makes Bexley Pizza Plus a hassle-free destination for anyone in Ohio looking for quality pizza and Italian-American fare.

Bexley Pizza Plus offers a comprehensive array of services designed to provide convenience and a satisfying experience for all its customers.

• Dine-In Service: The restaurant provides a comfortable and inviting dining atmosphere with plenty of seating, making it suitable for families, friends, or individuals who wish to enjoy their meal on-site.
• Carryout/Pickup: Customers can place orders for pickup, allowing them to quickly collect their freshly prepared pizza and other menu items to enjoy at home or elsewhere.
• Delivery Service: Bexley Pizza Plus offers local delivery to areas including Bexley, Berwick, and Eastmoor, with a stated delivery minimum and charge. They also partner with third-party delivery platforms such as Uber Eats and DoorDash, expanding their reach for convenient home delivery.
• Create Your Own Pizza: Patrons have the option to build their custom pizza, choosing from a variety of crusts (traditional or thin), red or garlic white sauce, and an extensive selection of over 40 toppings. These toppings include various meats (pepperoni, mini pepperoni, chunky sausage, bacon, shaved steak, chicken, ground beef, ham, salami, anchovies), cheeses (provolone, mozzarella, swiss, colby, shaved parmesan, romano, feta, asiago), and fresh vegetables (artichoke hearts, black olives, green olives, broccoli, spinach, mushrooms, peppers, onions, tomatoes, basil, pineapple).
• Specialty Red and White Pizzas: The menu features 22 signature specialty pizzas, including popular choices like Maximum Pep (two types of pepperoni), Six Cheese, Margherita, All American, Hawaiian, Carbonara, and Mexican. White pizzas offer unique combinations like Chicken Broccoli, Steak Portabella, and Philly Steak.
• Extensive Menu Beyond Pizza: In addition to pizzas, Bexley Pizza Plus offers a wide selection of oven-baked subs (e.g., Italian, Super Italian, Club, Steak & Cheese, Meatball, Chicken Parmesan), fresh salads (Caesar, Greek, Chef, Deluxe Chef), and sides like garlic bread with cheese, cookies, and cheesecake.
• Freshly Prepared Ingredients: They emphasize the use of fresh dough made daily, 100% real cheese, fresh-cut veggies, and homemade sauce, ensuring high-quality and flavorful dishes.

Bexley Pizza Plus distinguishes itself with several key features and highlights that contribute to its strong reputation among locals in Central Ohio.

• "Best Pizza in Central Ohio" Claim: Many customers enthusiastically declare Bexley Pizza Plus to have the "best pizza in central Ohio hands down," a powerful endorsement that speaks to the quality and unique appeal of their pies.
• Exceptional Specialty Pizzas: The Carbonara pizza and White pizza are specifically highlighted as "chef's kiss," indicating these are must-try items for new visitors. The diverse range of 22 signature specialty pizzas caters to a wide array of tastes.
• Distinctive Mini Pepperonis: The inclusion of "mini pepperonis" is a small but notable detail that sets their pizzas apart, offering a unique texture and flavor distribution that patrons enjoy.
• Quality Ingredients: The pizzeria prides itself on using only the best ingredients: fresh dough made in multiple batches daily (never refrigerated or frozen), a 100% real cheese blend of mozzarella and provolone, fresh-cut vegetables, and homemade sauce from vine-ripened tomatoes. This commitment to quality is a significant highlight.
• Methodical Grid-Style Cut: Their pizza is reportedly cut in a "methodical grid-style," which is a unique feature that appeals to both crust lovers and those who prefer less crust, ensuring a good balance in every slice.
• Comfortable Dining Atmosphere: The establishment offers a "nice dining atmosphere" with "plenty of seating and choice of drinks," providing a comfortable and casual environment for a relaxed meal.
• Customization Options: With over 40 available toppings and options for traditional or thin crust, customers have extensive control to create their ideal pizza.

To experience the renowned pizzas and other offerings at Bexley Pizza Plus, or to place an order, here is their contact information:

Address: 2651 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209, USA

Phone: (614) 237-3305

Mobile Phone: +1 614-237-3305

For residents across Ohio, particularly in the Columbus and Bexley communities, Bexley Pizza Plus is an exceptionally suitable dining destination for several compelling reasons. Foremost is its widespread reputation among many as delivering "the best pizza in central Ohio." This high praise, especially for their specialty pies like the Carbonara and White pizza, speaks to a commitment to quality and flavor that resonates deeply with local palates. The unique detail of mini pepperonis further enhances the experience, offering a distinctive touch that sets their pizzas apart.

Beyond the celebrated pizza, the restaurant offers a comprehensive menu that extends to a wide variety of subs and fresh salads, ensuring that there’s something to satisfy diverse cravings within a single visit. This versatility makes it an ideal spot for family dinners, casual outings with friends, or even a solo meal. The comfortable dining atmosphere, coupled with choices of drinks, provides a welcoming environment that encourages patrons to linger and enjoy their experience.

Finally, its convenient and accessible location on East Main Street makes it an easy choice for both pick-up and local delivery, integrating seamlessly into the busy lives of Ohioans. While occasional varied feedback exists, the strong positive sentiment and features like their fresh daily dough, homemade sauce, and dedication to fresh ingredients solidify Bexley Pizza Plus as a reliable and highly recommended local pizzeria that truly caters to the tastes and needs of the Ohio community.

Bexley Pizza Plus

2651 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209, USA