Blue Mountain Heights Introduce
Blue Mountain Heights: More Than Just a Coffee Shop, It's a Cultural Hub
In a city where every block seems to have a new cafe or a specialized restaurant, finding a place that truly stands out is a rare pleasure. Blue Mountain Heights, located in the heart of New York City, defies simple categorization. It's a unique establishment that expertly blends the cozy, inviting atmosphere of a neighborhood coffee shop with the vibrant, soulful flavors of a full-fledged Caribbean restaurant. The name itself is a nod to its dual identity, promising high-quality coffee—specifically, the world-renowned Blue Mountain variety—and an elevated dining experience.
This is a place where you can start your day with a perfectly brewed cup of coffee and a fresh pastry, and end it with a delicious, comforting Caribbean meal. The atmosphere is a key part of the experience. It's described by patrons as casual, cozy, and trendy, creating a welcoming space that feels like a home away from home. The addition of a fireplace adds a touch of warmth and charm, making it an ideal spot to relax, work, or catch up with friends, no matter the season. The presence of live music and a lively sports scene also contributes to a dynamic and engaging environment, ensuring there’s always something happening.
What truly sets Blue Mountain Heights apart is its ability to seamlessly transition from a morning cafe to a lively dinner spot. The dual menu, which includes both a cafe section and a full restaurant menu, caters to every time of day and every kind of craving. From a simple bagel with cream cheese or a croissant in the morning to a hearty Oxtail meal or a delicious Rasta Pasta in the evening, the culinary offerings are as diverse as New York City itself. This versatility makes it a popular choice for a variety of occasions, whether you're looking for a quick bite, a satisfying lunch, or a full-on dinner experience.
Blue Mountain Heights is more than just a place to eat and drink; it's a social destination. It's a place where families can feel at home, groups can gather for a great time, and tourists can get a genuine taste of Caribbean culture and hospitality. The combination of great food, an excellent beverage selection, and a vibrant atmosphere makes it a must-visit for anyone in the New York area. It's a testament to the city's rich and diverse culture, all wrapped up in one welcoming and delicious package.
Location and Accessibility
Blue Mountain Heights is conveniently situated at 499 W 158th St, New York, NY 10032, USA, placing it in the bustling West Harlem neighborhood. The location is easily accessible for both locals and those visiting the area. Its proximity to major transportation routes makes it a straightforward destination for anyone traveling by subway or bus. For those with mobility needs, the restaurant is committed to accessibility, offering a wheelchair accessible entrance and seating. This ensures that all guests can comfortably enjoy their dining experience. The neighborhood itself is vibrant and welcoming, making Blue Mountain Heights a convenient and inviting spot to visit.
Services Offered
Blue Mountain Heights provides a comprehensive range of services to cater to every customer's needs, from dining in to enjoying a meal at home. The services include:
Dine-in: Experience the full ambiance of the restaurant with a cozy seat, table service, and the vibrant atmosphere, complete with a bar onsite.
Takeout: For those on the go, the restaurant offers a convenient takeout service, allowing you to enjoy your favorite dishes wherever you are.
Delivery: Stay in and have your meal delivered right to your doorstep, with options available for both food and beverages.
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch & Dinner: The restaurant serves a full menu throughout the day, ensuring you can get a delicious meal at any time.
Dessert: Be sure to save room for dessert to end your meal on a sweet note.
Accepts Reservations: For those planning ahead, the restaurant accepts reservations, making it a great option for group dinners or special occasions.
Features and Highlights
Blue Mountain Heights is rich with features that make it a compelling choice for dining and social gatherings. Some of its most notable highlights include:
Authentic Jamaican & Caribbean Cuisine: The menu is a tribute to authentic Caribbean flavors, featuring classic dishes like Jerk Chicken, Oxtail, and Brown Stew Chicken. The "Rasta Pasta" is a highly-praised customer favorite.
Full-Service Bar & Happy Hour: The restaurant boasts a great selection of beers, cocktails, hard liquors, and wines, with a lively happy hour offering discounted drinks and food like Rum Punch and discounted Tacos and Empanadas.
Unique Coffee Offerings: As a cafe, it serves a variety of coffee drinks, including the famous Blue Mountain Coffee, known for its smooth and rich flavor. The availability of drip coffee, espresso, and lattes caters to all coffee lovers.
Vibrant Atmosphere: The ambiance is a major draw, with a cozy and trendy vibe, complemented by a fireplace, live music, and a sports-friendly environment. It's a fantastic spot for groups and families.
Fast Service: Customers often note the fast and efficient service, making it a great option for a quick bite or when you're on a tight schedule.
Versatile Menu: Beyond the main dishes, the menu offers a wide range of options, including vegetarian choices, comfort food, quick bites, and small plates, ensuring there's something for everyone.
Wi-Fi and Amenities: Free Wi-Fi, a bar onsite, and clean restrooms provide all the necessary amenities for a comfortable and convenient visit.
Contact Information
To make a reservation, place a takeout order, or simply learn more, you can contact Blue Mountain Heights using the information below:
Address: 499 W 158th St, New York, NY 10032, USA
Phone: (646) 998-5905
What Is Worth Choosing
Choosing Blue Mountain Heights for your next meal is a decision to embrace a truly multi-faceted dining experience. The most compelling reason to visit is the unique fusion of a Caribbean restaurant and a coffee shop. This dual identity means you get the best of both worlds: a place for a quick coffee break and a spot for a leisurely, flavorful meal. The authenticity of the food is a major draw; dishes like the Oxtail and Jerk Chicken are prepared with care, delivering a taste of the islands that feels both genuine and delicious. The fact that a "Chef takes you back home," as one customer review suggests, speaks volumes about the quality and authenticity of the cooking.
The atmosphere is a key component of the appeal. It’s a place that fosters great vibes and a feeling of being at home. The presence of live music adds a layer of cultural richness that few other establishments can match. Whether you're a fan of soothing reggae or a lively band, the music enhances the overall experience. The happy hour is also a significant highlight, offering excellent value on a range of drinks and popular appetizers, making it a great spot for a post-work outing or a casual get-together.
While some customer reviews mention inconsistencies in service, the overall sentiment points to a spot with great food, a welcoming environment, and a dedicated kitchen. The convenience of being able to make reservations and the availability of both delivery and takeout options further add to its appeal. For anyone in New York looking for a place that offers more than just food—a place with culture, great drinks, and a vibrant atmosphere—Blue Mountain Heights is a destination that truly stands out.
Blue Mountain Heights Vibe
CAFE Drinks
- Blue Mountain Coffee $4.50
Jamaican Grown and Roasted Coffee, Blue Mountain Coffee brand
- Drip Coffee (small) $2.00
Coffee Labs Medium Roast
- Drip Coffee (large) $2.50
Coffee Labs Medium Roast
- Espresso Shot $1.50
Coffee Labs Espresso Roast
- Double Espresso $2.00
Coffee Labs Espresso Roast
- Latte/Capuccino/Mocha (small) $4.00
Coffee Labs Espresso Roast
- Latte/Capuccino/Mocha (large) $4.50
Coffee Labs Espresso Roast
- Americano (small) $3.00
Coffee Labs Espresso Roast
- Americano (large) $3.50
Coffee Labs Espresso Roast
- Red/Black Eye (small) $4.00
Coffee Labs Espresso Roast
- Red/Black Eye (Large) $4.50
Coffee Labs Espresso Roast
- Tea (small) $1.50
variety
- Tea (large) $2.00
variety
- Hot Cocoa $3.00
Ghiradelli
- Peppermint Hot Cocoa $3.75
Ghiradelli
- Oral's Carrot Juice $6.00
Fresh Squeezed Carrot Juice and Condensed Milk
- Flavour shot $0.75
Vanilla, Sugar Free Vanilla, Hazelnut, Peppermint
CAFE Food
- Cornmeal Porridge $3.00
Made in house on select days
- Gluten Free Chocolate Banana Bread $4.00
Hamilton's Bakery
- donut $2.00
Hamilton's Bakery
- Banana Walnut bread $2.50
Hamilton's Bakery
- Assorted Muffins $3.50
Hamilton's Bakery
- Croissant $2.50
Hamilton's Bakery
- Rasta Cakes $0.50
Hamilton's Bakery
- Bagels (Plain, Everything, raisin, Cheddar) $2.00
Bo's Bagels (125th)
- Cream Cheese (plain or veggie) $1.50
Bo's Bagels (made fresh)
- Grape Jam $1.00
- fruit $1.00
RESTAURANT Appetizers
- Taco $5.00
chicken, or +$2 for shrimp
- Empanada $6.00
chicken, cheese or +$2 for shrimp
- Wings $8.00
Jerk, Fried, BBQ, Henny
- Saltfish Fritters $5.00
- Pepper Shrimp $8.00
- Soup $7.00
*select days
RESTAURANT Entrees
- Jerk Chicken $13.00
Served with choice of 2 sides (Mac n cheese slight up-charge)
- Oxtail $18.00
Served with choice of 2 sides (Mac n cheese slight up-charge)
- Brown Stew Chicken $12.00
Served with choice of 2 sides (Mac n cheese slight up-charge)
- Curry Chicken $12.00
Served with choice of 2 sides (Mac n cheese slight up-charge)
- Wings Meal (Henny, Jerk, BBQ, Fried) $13.00
Served with choice of 2 sides (Mac n cheese slight up-charge)
- Rasta Pasta $13.00
chicken +$3, shrimp +$5, oxtail +$10, salmon +10
- Chicken Tenders & Fries $13.00
- Chicken & Waffles $14.00
- Steam Veggie Plate $10.00
RESTAURANT Seafood
- Crablegs Meal $35.00
- Whole Snapper $23.00
steamed, escovitch, brown stew
- Salmon Meal $25.00
Jerk, garlic, grilled, henny, escovitch
- Shrimp Meal $16.00
curry, jerk, fried, garlic, grilled
RESTAURANT Sides
- Rice & Peas (Rice & beans) $3.00
- white rice $3.00
- sweet plantain $3.00
- french fries $4.00
- festival $4.00
- Mac & Cheese $6.00
or +3 up-charge when selecting as a meal side
- Cheese Fries $6.00
or +3 up-charge when selecting as a meal side
- steamed veg $5.00
RESTAURANT Deserts
- Cheesecake $8.00
pistachio, triple treat, henny (+$2)
RESTAURANT Happy Hour
- Rum Punch $6.00
- Beer Bottles $3.00
Heineken, Red Stripe, Guinness, Modelo
- Margaritas $6.00
Passion Fruit, Guava, coconut, strawberry, traditional
- Wine $4.00
- Long Island $6.00
- Well Drinks $6.00
- Well Shots $4.00
- Wings $5.00
jerk, BBQ, Henny, Fried
- Empanada $3.00
chicken, cheese
- taco $3.00
chicken
- shrimp & Fries basket $9.00
Blue Mountain Heights Details
Service options
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Fast service
- Fireplace
- Great cocktails
- Live music
- Sports
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Happy hour drinks
- Happy hour food
- Hard liquor
- Late-night food
- Quick bite
- Small plates
- Vegetarian options
- Wine
Dining options
- Breakfast
- Brunch
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Bar onsite
- Restroom
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Trendy
Crowd
- Family-friendly
- Groups
- Tourists
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Blue Mountain Heights Photos
Blue Mountain Heights Location
Blue Mountain Heights
499 W 158th St, New York, NY 10032, USA
Blue Mountain Heights Reviews
oxtailchefpricesbartenderrum punchspicyrasta pastaatmospheremusicshrimp
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Arrived 7:30 pm 4/22/24 . Was greeted & sat at the bar by a young pretty female. It was 6 of us . Spot was empty ( it’s Monday ). Unsure if it’s usually busy any other day. The girl was on FT - facetime the entire time we were there . We ordered drinks I had a rum punch rate that a 5/10 could’ve been WAY better. The food was 7/10 for me I loved the oxtail Rasta pasta . It was suppose to be mild but the oxtails were a bit spicy ( not too much ). It was only one chef n the back. The bartender/waitress was all over the place like it wasn’t that kind of day for her to be working. One of the people I was with ordered fried shrimp which came out after we were all half way done eating smh . She didn’t even set out any utensils to our food came. Definitely the type of spot u eat in and dnt order on Uber eats it’s fresher that way. Quiet in the wall spot I will say ( NO HOOKAH ).
April 23 · Sariah GMy Family and I had such a wonderful time dinning for father's day. Very clean,Live Band very soothing, therapeutic Island vibes down to service server phenomenal, Chef takes you back home,The beauty you can see him preparing your meal.If you have not been back home ,I'm talking about vacation mode very tasty, elegant .The place is welcoming. Definitely brought me back home .Great vibes. All smiles, Owner great vibes. Wishing you Guys more blessings and prosperity!!!!Usually I eat half of my food. My family and I ate our entire meal. The drinks Island vibes!!!!
June 16 · Phillisia DolphyDO NOT ORDER FROM HERE ! I ordered through Uber eats and when I got my food let me tell you the chicken had so much f&$king hair on it ! Literally inedible. Blue mountain cafe should literally be ashamed not only did you not examine your chicken you also failed to clean it ! I will never order from here again. As you can see from the pictures how long , thick and disgustingly dirty the chicken is you shouldn’t be ordering from here either. Y’all give Jamaican restaurants a bad name.
February 22 · K On TopFound this restaurant randomly and was so happy we stopped by! Didn't even realize there was a Jamaican restaurant in the heights! Had the Rasta pasta and it was amazing! Shout out to reeka, drinks were on point! Loved the rum punch. Excellent customer service, def will return
August 06 · Shalandra BrownThe waitress Ice was really nice but they gave me these two baby brown stew pieces of chicken. Highly disappointed. For $20 should have been more. Always wanted to try their food and did. There are several other places in Harlem where you get more food
July 13 · Antonio Javar
More Best Restaurants Near Me

1969 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA

2002 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA

1954 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA

1944 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA

2017 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA

2021 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA

2023 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA

2023 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA

2038 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA

2048 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA

3780 Broadway, New York, NY 10032, USA

3802 Broadway, New York, NY 10032, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Bites & Banter Posts





