Cappy’s Pizza

- 3947 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228

For pizza lovers across Ohio, and particularly those in the Columbus area, there's a name that resonates with decades of local flavor and tradition: Cappy’s Pizza. Located on West Broad Street, Cappy's has been a beloved fixture in the community, renowned for its commitment to classic pizza-making and a consistently satisfying dining experience. Since its founding in 1972 by Bob Capuano, and now operated by Andy Morse since 2019, Cappy's Pizza embodies the essence of a true neighborhood pizzeria – a place where quality ingredients meet tried-and-true recipes, resulting in pizzas that keep locals coming back for more.

Cappy’s Pizza isn't just about serving food; it's about upholding a legacy of taste and community. The ownership prides itself on maintaining the high standards that have made Cappy's an icon for over 50 years. This commitment is evident in every pizza they craft, from the selection of fresh ingredients to the careful preparation of their signature soft crust. It's a place where families have enjoyed countless meals, and where newcomers quickly become regulars, drawn in by the authentic flavors and welcoming atmosphere.

The philosophy at Cappy's Pizza revolves around delivering solid, flavorful food with excellent service in a clean and inviting environment. They understand that a great pizza is built on a foundation of good dough, balanced sauce, and quality toppings. Reviews frequently highlight the "good flavor" and the "very soft" crust, indicating that these foundational elements are consistently met. Whether you're in the mood for a simple pepperoni and cheese or something more adventurous, Cappy's aims to provide a reliable and delicious pizza experience that stands the test of time in the competitive Columbus food scene.

Cappy’s Pizza is conveniently situated at 3947 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228, USA. This location on West Broad Street places it within an accessible and active commercial corridor of Columbus, making it a straightforward destination for many residents across the city. West Broad Street serves as a key artery, connecting various neighborhoods and providing easy access from different parts of the greater Columbus area.

For those driving, the presence of parking options, which are typical for establishments on such main thoroughfares, adds to the convenience. This ease of access means that whether you're planning a quick pick-up, a dine-in experience, or a delivery, reaching Cappy's Pizza is generally hassle-free. The restaurant's integration into the local landscape makes it a natural choice for those living or working nearby, offering a reliable spot for quality pizza without extensive travel.

Furthermore, Cappy's Pizza has recently taken over the spot previously occupied by Sparano's Pizza at this same address, ensuring continuity for customers familiar with the location. This move helps solidify its presence on West Broad Street, reinforcing its role as a key local pizzeria that continues to serve the needs of the Columbus community.

Cappy’s Pizza offers a comprehensive range of services designed to cater to various customer preferences for enjoying their delicious pizzas and other menu items:

• Dine-in Service: Guests are welcome to enjoy their freshly made pizzas and other dishes in the restaurant's clean and inviting environment.
• Takeout Service: For those who prefer to enjoy their meal at home or on the go, Cappy's provides efficient takeout services. Customers can call ahead to place their orders for convenient pickup.
• Delivery Service: While not explicitly stated in all public data, many modern pizza restaurants, especially those in bustling urban areas like Columbus, typically offer delivery through third-party platforms or their own service. It's advisable to check directly or via online ordering platforms for specific delivery options.
• Diverse Pizza Menu: Cappy's offers a wide array of pizza options, including classic cheese and pepperoni, as well as specialty pizzas like Hawaiian (ham, pineapple), Mushroom and Sausage, Meat Lovers (ham, pepperoni, bacon, Italian sausage), Vegetarian, White Pizza, Greek Pizza, BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, Steak Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch, and even unique options like Brazilian Pizza (chicken, bacon, corn, olives) and Nutella Strawberry Pizza. They also offer gluten-free options and unique crusts like broccoli and cauliflower.
• Subs and Other Menu Items: Beyond pizza, Cappy's also provides a selection of subs (e.g., Meat Heads, Steak and Cheese, Cappy Sub, Super Sub, Meatball Sub, Chicken Parm Sub, Veggie Sub), calzones, salads, appetizers (like chicken wings, fingers, garlic bread, breadsticks, fries), and desserts (like Nutella Strawberry Pizza, almond cake, lemoncello cake).
• Pizza Slices: For a quick and affordable meal, Cappy's offers pizza by the slice, typically pepperoni, which is a popular choice for a convenient and satisfying bite.

Cappy’s Pizza distinguishes itself through several key features and highlights that contribute to its strong local reputation:

• Good Flavor and Soft Crust: Customers consistently praise the "good flavor" of their pizzas and specifically highlight the "very soft" crust. This indicates a mastery of fundamental pizza-making, creating a satisfying texture and taste profile.
• Clean Shop and Nice Service: Reviewers note that the "shop was super clean" and "the service was nice." A clean environment and friendly, efficient staff significantly enhance the overall dining experience, making customers feel welcome and valued.
• Affordable Slice and Drink Combo: The "can't beat $6 for a slice and pop" deal is a significant highlight, offering excellent value for a quick and satisfying meal. This makes Cappy's a great option for a budget-friendly lunch or snack.
• Balanced Sauce: The sauce, as noted by a reviewer who ordered the "meat heads," is praised for not being "too sweet or savory," indicating a "good balance which we prefer." This attention to detail in the sauce contributes to the overall deliciousness of their pizzas and other sauced dishes.
• Diverse Topping Options: The wide variety of pizzas, from classic pepperoni to unique combinations like pineapple and ham, mushroom and sausage, and even more elaborate options like Meat Lovers, Hawaiian, Greek, and Brazilian pizzas, ensures there's something to satisfy every craving.
• Long-Standing Reputation: With roots dating back to 1972, Cappy's Pizza has a deep history and a proven track record of serving the Columbus community, building trust and loyalty over decades.
• Adaptability: The smooth transition of ownership and the continuation of quality, even as they expand to new locations (like the W Broad St spot taking over Sparano's Pizza), demonstrates their adaptability and commitment to their brand.

For more information, to place an order, or to inquire about their menu, you can easily reach Cappy’s Pizza using the following contact details:

Address: 3947 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228, USA

Phone: (614) 487-0087

Mobile Phone: +1 614-487-0087

It is always a good idea to call ahead, especially during busy hours or if you have specific questions about their offerings or current specials. Their team is ready to assist you in enjoying a delicious meal from a true Columbus pizza tradition.

In conclusion, for locals in Ohio, particularly those in the Columbus area, Cappy’s Pizza on West Broad Street stands out as an exceptional choice for quality pizza. Its decades-long history and consistent commitment to "good flavor" and a "very soft" crust ensure a reliable and delicious dining experience. The emphasis on a clean environment and "nice service" further enhances the overall appeal, making it a pleasant place to visit.

With its affordable "slice and pop" deal, diverse menu offering various classic and specialty pizzas, and a range of other Italian-American favorites like subs, Cappy's caters to a wide array of tastes and budgets. Its convenient location and long-standing presence in the community solidify its suitability for locals seeking a trusted, flavorful, and value-driven pizza destination. Supporting Cappy’s Pizza means supporting a piece of Columbus’s culinary heritage, guaranteeing a satisfying meal every time.

Cappy’s Pizza

3947 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228, USA