DiCarlo’s Pizza - Westerville Photos










DiCarlo’s Pizza - Westerville Introduce
Welcome to our comprehensive guide on DiCarlo’s Pizza, a name that resonates with many in the Westerville and greater Columbus, Ohio area. This article is designed to give you a detailed and helpful overview of what to expect from this local pizza establishment. Whether you're a long-time resident, a recent transplant, or just passing through, understanding the local food scene is key to feeling at home. DiCarlo’s Pizza is a staple in the region, known for its distinct style that has garnered a loyal following over the years. We'll explore its background, what makes its pizza unique, and all the essential information you need to plan your visit. Our goal is to provide a friendly, factual, and informative resource that helps you make the most of your dining experience. From the moment you walk through the door to the last bite of your pizza, DiCarlo’s offers a taste of local tradition that many have come to love. This isn’t just about food; it's about the community and the shared experiences that bring people together, and local eateries like DiCarlo's are at the heart of that connection. We'll delve into the specifics of their menu, the services they provide, and the overall atmosphere that makes them a part of the Westerville fabric. This content is crafted for the people of Ohio, from their perspective, to provide a trustworthy and thorough guide to one of their local gems.
Situated in the heart of Westerville, Ohio, DiCarlo’s Pizza is conveniently located at 20 S State St #K, Westerville, OH 43081, USA. This prime spot makes it easily accessible for residents and visitors alike. The restaurant is nestled within a vibrant part of town, making it a great stop whether you're running errands, enjoying a day out, or looking for a quick and satisfying meal. Westerville itself is a well-regarded suburb of Columbus, known for its charm and community feel. The accessibility of the location is a significant benefit, as it’s often a short drive from many residential neighborhoods and local businesses. The surrounding area offers a pleasant backdrop for a pizza outing, adding to the overall experience. Whether you choose to dine in or grab your order to go, the central location ensures that getting your pizza is a hassle-free affair. The address is simple to find using GPS, and its presence on a main thoroughfare means you won't have to navigate complicated side streets. The convenience of its location is a key factor in its popularity, as it’s a go-to spot for a quick lunch, an easy dinner, or a meal to share with family and friends. This strategic placement allows DiCarlo’s to serve a broad range of customers, from nearby office workers on their lunch break to families looking for a classic Friday night dinner. Parking is generally available in the vicinity, making the trip even more convenient for those traveling by car. This ease of access is a cornerstone of the local dining experience, and DiCarlo's Pizza - Westerville delivers on that front, making it a simple and reliable choice for the community.
DiCarlo’s Pizza - Westerville offers a variety of services designed to make getting your favorite pizza as easy as possible. Their primary service is, of course, the creation and sale of their signature pizzas, which are made to order with fresh ingredients. They have a straightforward ordering process, and their menu focuses on their specialty, ensuring a consistent and quality product. For those who prefer to enjoy their meal at home or on the go, carry-out service is a popular option. Customers can call ahead to place an order and pick it up at their convenience. This is a great choice for busy families or individuals who want a delicious meal without the hassle of cooking. While specific details on other services like delivery may vary, the focus on carry-out is a key part of their business model. Additionally, their team is trained to handle a high volume of orders efficiently, which means your pizza is ready promptly, maintaining its quality and freshness. They strive to provide a seamless transaction experience, focusing on getting your order right and getting you on your way. The services are designed with the local community in mind, prioritizing speed, convenience, and a straightforward customer experience. This approach helps them maintain their reputation as a reliable and accessible option for pizza lovers in the Westerville area. The simplicity of their service model is part of their charm, allowing them to focus on what they do best: making pizza. The staff is typically ready to assist with any questions you may have about your order, ensuring a smooth and pleasant interaction from start to finish. This focus on customer service is an important part of their community-oriented approach.
DiCarlo's Pizza in Westerville has several features and highlights that set it apart and contribute to its local reputation. These attributes are often what locals cite when explaining why they are loyal customers. The restaurant is known for its distinct style of pizza, which often involves a square-cut crust and a generous layering of cheese. This unique approach to a classic dish is a major highlight and is what many people associate with the DiCarlo’s brand. Another feature is the emphasis on fresh ingredients, which is a key component of any good pizza. The ingredients are carefully chosen to ensure a flavorful and satisfying product every time. The atmosphere inside the restaurant, though sometimes described as no-frills, is often what patrons appreciate—it's a place focused on the food and the company you share it with. This straightforward, community-focused environment is a big draw for many. The staff, for the most part, aims to be friendly and efficient, ensuring a pleasant experience. Furthermore, the establishment is part of a larger regional tradition, and for many, visiting DiCarlo's is a nostalgic experience that reminds them of a classic Ohio pizza style. The consistency of their product is something they strive for, though as with any local business, experiences can vary. They are committed to their craft, and this dedication is often visible in the quality of the final product. The fact that it is a local business, not a large national chain, is also a significant highlight for many residents who prefer to support community enterprises. This local touch gives the place a unique character that can't be replicated by larger corporations. The focus on a specialized menu allows them to perfect their core offerings, making them a go-to spot for those craving a specific type of pizza. Their unique pizza style is a conversation starter and a point of pride for many locals who have grown up with it. The no-fuss approach means the focus remains on the food, and for many, that’s exactly what they are looking for in a local pizzeria.
For those looking to get in touch with DiCarlo’s Pizza in Westerville, here is the essential contact information. The business is located at 20 S State St #K, Westerville, OH 43081, USA. You can easily reach them by phone to place an order or inquire about their menu. The main phone number is (614) 463-0522. Additionally, a mobile phone number is also provided for convenience: +1 614-463-0522. When calling, you can expect to speak with a member of their staff who will be able to assist you with your needs. This direct line of communication is perfect for placing a carry-out order, as it ensures your request is handled promptly and accurately. Having both a landline and a mobile number listed provides flexibility and ensures that customers can always get through. The physical address is a key piece of information for anyone planning to visit the location, whether for pickup or just to stop by. It’s always a good idea to confirm business hours and any specific ordering procedures by calling ahead, especially during peak times. The provided information is all you need to connect with this local business and enjoy their offerings. The straightforward contact details reflect the no-nonsense approach of the restaurant, making it easy for customers to get what they need. This ease of communication is a valuable asset for any local business, fostering a strong connection with the community. Whether you're a first-time caller or a repeat customer, the team at DiCarlo's is ready to take your order and prepare your meal with care.
In conclusion, DiCarlo's Pizza in Westerville is more than just a place to grab a bite; it's a part of the local Ohio community. Its distinctive style of pizza, with its square cuts and focus on flavor, has made it a favorite for many. The restaurant's prime location in the heart of Westerville makes it a convenient and accessible option for residents and visitors alike. It's a spot where you can enjoy a familiar taste that is deeply rooted in local tradition. The straightforward services, with an emphasis on efficient carry-out, cater to the busy lives of people in the area, offering a reliable solution for a quick and satisfying meal. The focus on quality ingredients and a unique preparation method sets it apart from larger chains, giving it a personal touch that is highly valued by locals. This is a place that understands its audience and delivers a product that is both consistent and comforting. For many in Ohio, a visit to DiCarlo’s is a nostalgic experience, and for newcomers, it's an introduction to a beloved local flavor. It’s a testament to the fact that some of the best food is found in small, dedicated local establishments. By supporting DiCarlo’s Pizza, you are not just buying a meal; you are participating in a local tradition and helping to sustain the small businesses that give a community its unique character. Its unpretentious and focused approach to pizza-making is exactly what many people are looking for. It's a place that feels like home, offering a slice of local life with every bite. The friendly staff and efficient service make it a place you can count on. DiCarlo’s Pizza in Westerville is a true local gem, and we hope this guide has provided you with all the information you need to enjoy it to the fullest. Whether for a special occasion or a simple weeknight dinner, it is a great choice for anyone looking for a taste of authentic Ohio pizza. Thank you for reading, and we hope you have a wonderful dining experience.
DiCarlo’s Pizza - Westerville Location
DiCarlo’s Pizza - Westerville
20 S State St #K, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
DiCarlo’s Pizza - Westerville Reviews
Update: I’ve seen the business’s response to my review and want to clarify a few things, since they’ve chosen to respond with personal attacks and misleading statements rather than professionalism.• Both of us went into the shop to place the order. I returned alone to pick it up. We both ate a bite of the pizza and shared the experience, which is why we both felt compelled to leave reviews.• The pizza was greasy, bland, with barely any sauce, and the crust was tough. That’s not a personal attack — it’s honest feedback on the food.• When I asked if they had paper plates, the reply was, “You just eat off the box lid,” said in a way that came across as curt and unwelcoming — not at all as friendly as they’re now claiming.• After two bites, we couldn’t continue eating. I went back in, explained politely that we didn’t enjoy it, and asked if a refund was possible. I was told no, which I respected, but any further attempt to explain my concerns was brushed off.• The claim that I caused a scene, yelled, or made threats is completely false and exaggerated. I told them I’d be leaving a review — which is my right as a paying customer — and I did so.• Saying I should be “recorded and embarrassed online” for giving an honest review is completely inappropriate and unprofessional.I don’t expect every business to offer refunds, but I do expect a basic level of respect and accountability. Attacking a customer for their opinion says far more about how this business handles feedback than anything else.Really disappointing experience. The staff was consistently rude throughout our visit and became even more dismissive when we raised concerns. The pizza was nearly inedible—tasteless, overly greasy, barely any sauce, and the crust was tough and chewy. They don’t accept cash or provide receipts, which was very unprofessional.If you're from out of town, don’t expect basic amenities like paper plates—you’re expected to eat off the pizza box lid. After just two bites, we asked for a refund but were rudely refused because it “cost them money to make.” I understand that, but a good business stands behind its product. When we explained the issue, they insisted they’ve never received a bad review before and showed no interest in making things right.Would not recommend this place to anyone.
Aug 07, 2025 · Hannah KirkendallThis place is very inconsistent. For the price you pay here, I expect my pizza to at least have a normal amount of cheese on it. The dough was also uneven which caused multiple pieces to be undercooked. We also bought 6 pieces with extra cheese and it was still less than the normal amount. I truly feel cheated out of the money I have spent here on "extra cheese" that I never receive. Unfortunately, this is now the 3rd time this has happened, so I don't think we'll be back.
Mar 28, 2025 · Kelsie MastersIf Brandon is working, I’m there. This dude can make pizza. I’m a transplant from the Steubenville, Ohio/Weirton, WV area, where I grew up on DiCarlo’s, and until now, my sons and I have had to drive over two hours to get our fix of Valley pizza. Well, now we don’t have to, cause there are two legit DiCarlo’s franchises right here in our own back yard. And both are very good. We especially like the Westerville location, though, because it’s closer for us, and Brandon is rock solid consistent in making his pies. If you’re from the Ohio Valley and crave a slice of original DiCarlo’s Pizza, this is the closest you’re going to get here in C-Bus. Great pizza. Great location. Great service. Hope it catches on.
Jun 06, 2025 · dswaughLunch at DiCarlo's Pizza in Westerville today and my first experience with "Ohio Valley" style pizza. Did not disappoint.Ordered the Pepperoni and WOW! The pizza is cut into squares and has a crispy texture due to using baking pans.Great sauce with a super fresh flavor to it. The cold provolone cheese on top is a great touch!!I will be back!!
Jan 18, 2023 · My Next Home Columbus - Michael Dalton, REALTORUpdated 07/29/25: The price increase is absolutely outrageous. $3 per slice. The pizzas have been cold, flimsy, chewy and dry lately. It’s still $1.55 in Wheeling for fresh, hot pizza with way more sauce and cheese than Westerville. When Brandon’s there it is absolutely perfect. Otherwise, it’s awful. We used to be weekly regulars. Unfortunately, it’s no longer worth the price.We were so excited when the location opened back up with the new owner. He is extremely friendly every time we go. This is the perfect original Ohio Valley recipe. Perfect crunch, delicious salty/sweet sauce, freshly shredded cheese. I recommend the Ohio Valley way, extra cheese on the side.
Jul 29, 2025 · Sarah Robertson
More Best Restaurants Near Me

15 E College Ave, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

1 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

8 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

7 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

59 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

15 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

10 E Main St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

32 W College Ave, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

Westerville, OH 43081, USA

84 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

41 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

109 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Bites & Banter Posts





