Emmett's on Grove: A Slice of Chicago's Tavern-Style Pizza in NYC

Emmett's on Grove Introduce

In a city famous for its classic New York-style slices, Emmett's on Grove offers a unique and delightful departure. Located in the heart of the historic West Village, this restaurant brings a taste of Chicago to the Big Apple, specializing in authentic tavern-style thin-crust pizza. Emmett's on Grove isn’t just about pizza; it's a Midwestern-inspired supper club that blends a casual, trendy atmosphere with an elevated dining experience, making it a standout destination in a neighborhood known for its incredible food scene.

Stepping inside, you'll find a space that feels both modern and nostalgic, with great art and 20th-century memorabilia creating a welcoming and stylish environment. The restaurant is a sister location to the original Emmett's in Soho, which is known for its deep-dish pizza, but Emmett's on Grove focuses on the equally beloved thin-crust, square-cut pies. This focus on a niche, yet incredibly popular, style of pizza gives it a special place in the NYC food landscape. It’s a place that appeals to both groups looking for a fun night out and solo diners seeking a fantastic meal, offering a comfortable and engaging setting for all. The commitment to quality and a unique menu has quickly made Emmett's on Grove a local favorite.

Emmett's on Grove is perfectly situated at 39 Grove Street, New York, NY 10014, USA. This location places it squarely in the vibrant and picturesque West Village, a neighborhood famous for its charming tree-lined streets, historic architecture, and bustling cultural scene. Being on Grove Street adds to its allure, making it a great destination for a pre-theater dinner or a meal after a day of exploring the area's many boutiques and landmarks.

Accessibility is a key feature of the restaurant, ensuring a welcoming experience for all guests. Emmett's on Grove provides a wheelchair-accessible entrance, as well as a wheelchair-accessible restroom and seating. This inclusive design is a major benefit. For those traveling by public transportation, the restaurant is conveniently located near several subway lines and bus stops, making it easy to reach from any part of the city. While street parking is available, as is common in the West Village, it can be competitive. Planning to use public transport or a ride-share service is often the easiest option. The restaurant's charming facade and location in a historic building also make it easy to spot and a pleasant place to arrive at.

Emmett's on Grove provides a comprehensive array of services and dining options to cater to a wide range of customer preferences.

Service Options: The restaurant offers a variety of ways to enjoy their food. You can choose to dine in and enjoy the full experience, or opt for the convenience of takeout. For those who prefer to stay home, delivery service is also available, bringing their delicious pizzas and other dishes right to your door.
Dining Options: Emmett's is a great choice for various meal times. They serve brunch, lunch, and dinner, with a menu that transitions smoothly from midday comfort food to more substantial evening fare. The dining experience is enhanced by table service and comfortable seating. The restaurant also has a bar onsite, making it a perfect spot for pre-dinner drinks or a late-night bite.
Offerings: The menu is far more extensive than just pizza. In addition to their famous tavern-style pies, they offer a wide selection of small plates, comfort food, and hearty mains like Chicken Parmesan and Baby Back Ribs. The drink menu is equally impressive, featuring a great beer selection, a well-curated wine list, and expertly crafted cocktails. They also offer happy hour food and drinks, as well as late-night options for those seeking a post-event meal. High chairs are available for younger diners, making it a family-friendly spot.

Several features and highlights make Emmett's on Grove a truly special place to visit in the West Village.

Exceptional Service: Customer reviews consistently highlight the incredible staff and service. From the warm welcome by the hostess to the attentive and friendly servers, the staff's dedication to making the experience "next level" is a major draw. The relaxed and unhurried pacing of the meal is also frequently praised.
Unique Pizza Style: While New York is the capital of the classic slice, Emmett's stands out by championing the Chicago tavern-style thin-crust pizza, cut into shareable squares. This unique offering provides a refreshing alternative and has quickly gained a loyal following.
Great Cocktails and Beverages: The bar is a key feature, with a well-curated selection of beers, a thoughtful wine list, and a cocktail menu that receives rave reviews. Patrons praise the quality of the drinks, from a classic martini to their more unique creations.
Trendy and Cozy Atmosphere: The restaurant's ambiance is a perfect mix of casual and trendy. The decor, with its vintage memorabilia and reclaimed materials, creates a visually interesting and comfortable space. The natural light from the skylight in the rear dining room adds to the inviting atmosphere.
Accepts Reservations: For a popular spot, the ability to make a reservation is a significant convenience. While walk-ins are welcome, especially at the bar, securing a dinner reservation is highly recommended to ensure you get a table.

For those looking to visit Emmett's on Grove or make a reservation, here is the essential contact information:

Address: 39 Grove St, New York, NY 10014, USA

Phone: (646) 370-3858

What makes Emmett's on Grove a truly worthwhile choice? It's the harmonious combination of its unique food, standout service, and inviting ambiance. The menu is a highlight, with appetizers like the Crispy Olives and Emmett's Meatballs receiving high praise for their flavor and quality. The Hot Girl pizza, with its perfect blend of pepperoni, jalapeño, and Mike's Hot Honey, has achieved a near-legendary status among customers. It's a testament to the restaurant's ability to create a menu that is both creative and satisfying. The mains, like the perfectly cooked Baby Back Ribs and Chicken Parmesan, also prove that Emmett's is a full-service eatery that excels beyond just its pizza.

The service is, without a doubt, a significant reason for its popularity. As multiple reviewers noted, the staff goes above and beyond to make the dining experience a special one. This level of attentiveness, combined with the relaxed pacing of the meal, makes you feel like a valued guest rather than just another customer. It is this human touch that elevates a good meal to a great one.

Lastly, the atmosphere itself is a key selling point. The trendy yet comfortable setting, with its cool art and vintage finds, makes it a fun and memorable place to be. It’s perfect for a wide range of occasions, from a laid-back solo lunch to a lively group dinner. For anyone in New York City looking for a pizza experience that is different from the usual, or simply an outstanding meal in a fantastic setting, Emmett's on Grove is a destination that delivers on all fronts. It’s a place that’s not just serving food, but creating a complete, "next level" experience that you’ll want to return to again and again.

Emmett's on Grove Menu

Snacks
House Chips $6.00
Crispy Olives $6.00

Apps
Arugula Salad $13.00
Caesar Salad $14.00
Emmett's Meatballs $14.00
Classic Shrimp Cocktail $14.00
Burrata $14.00
House Focaccia $6.00

Pastas
Spaghetti & Meatballs $25.00
Pappardelle Bolognese $25.00

Sides
Hand Cut Fries $7.00
Pan Fried Broccoli $8.00
Sauteed Escarole $8.00
Twice Baked Potato $10.00

Pizzas
Hot Papi $28.00
Hot Girl $27.00

Mains
Baby Back Ribs with Sides $27.00
Chicken Parmesan $28.00
Chicken Milanese $23.00
House Burger & Fries $21.00

Cocktails
Classic Martini $16.00
Classic Negroni $16.00
Mezclado $16.00
La Cura $15.00
Mai Tai $16.00
Grapefruit Spritz $14.00

Emmett's on Grove Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great wine list

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Happy hour food
Hard liquor
Late-night food
Small plates
Wine

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy

Crowd
Groups
Tourists

Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
High chairs

Emmett's on Grove Photos

Emmett's on Grove Location

Emmett's on Grove

New York New York County New York Grove Street

39 Grove St, New York, NY 10014, USA

Emmett's on Grove Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 297 user reviews.

martinichicken parmmeatballscaesar saladbartenderdeep dishbrunchtavern stylepigs in a blanketsleep

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

The hostess, Hannah, was fantastic and made our whole visit something beyond our expectations. She greeted us warmly as we all walked in and made sure our table was ready, since we already had a reservation. She made sure our server was also attentive and came right to our table. She is the coolest hostess I've ever met.We had two servers who were also both truly attentive, friendly, prompt, and accurate. The pacing of the meal was relaxed, not rushed, and not delayed.The service and staff here make the experience "next level."We ordered the pigs in a blanket, Greek salad, and meatballs for appetizers. Each was outstanding and perfect for sharing. The pigs in a blanket are larger than what you would expect and the wrap was flaky and seeded. Dipped in the mustard, it was better than any wedding I've ever attended (and that's no joke as they are always the first thing to deplete at weddings for a good reason). The meatballs were an unexpected hit. They were very well cooked, but not dry at all. The sauce was flavorful and not overwhelming, so the meatball itself was the focus of the bite. The Greek salad didn't actually include salad, which was perfect, so the fresh tomato, the ideal "baby bear" feta - not too hard, not too soft, the onion, and the cucumber were the focus. The dressing was lightly applied so as to not be overwhelming.The pizza came out before the pasta. The pizza is Chicago-style, so it is thin crust and cut into single-bite squares, and excellent for sharing. The "Hot girl" pizza was the hit. I can tolerate a lot of spice, and this was spicy. I loved it. Pepperoni, jalapeño, and Mike's Hot Honey. It was legit. The other half was Mona Lisa, which was nice, but not in the class of "Hot Girl."The pappardelle bolognese had the right amount of sauce and was prepared perfectly al dente. The noodles were super long and it was like a pasta clown car when you try to serve it. The noddle just kept on coming and eventually had to be cut. The Cacio e Pepe also was a hit with the group, but not my thing. It's more like an "al fredo."The surprise at the end was the key lime pie which had a very strong lime flavor and ridiculously crumbly and chewy crust, topped with a light whipped cream that didn't drown the pie like some do. The pie center had a perfect texture that was creamy and thick, but not viscous at all.The atmosphere was very trendy with great art strewn throughout and 20th century memorabilia also scattered around, like an old 7-up sign or the rotating Schlitz globe. The Globe is apropos as it is mounted outside the restrooms - just in case you need to take a "Schlitz," I guess. There is great natural light in the rear dining room from a skylight and a display of wine racks in the wall. The bar had a well-curated selection for all levels of palates.I had an IPA on tap with the meal and it was a perfect pairing with the spicy pizza.Overall, this is one of my favorite restaurants now, between the service, the ambiance, and the food, Emmet's on Grove is a "must-see" if you're anywhere in NYC.
June 15 · Cory Notrica
Hands down, the best pizza and burgers in town! The service was amazing, and the food was out of this world. If you visit New York, make sure to have lunch or dinner here. This is the best pizza I’ve ever had!
August 17 · Aaron Goldsmith
Was able to walk in Saturday 3pm still pretty crowded! Vibes were good, back room was super loud. Took about 35 minutes to get one pizza which was annoying because the pizza was only tepid. everyone in the room was waiting for their pizzas so maybe they had a backlog or change in shift. Pizza was good though, could’ve been warmer and crunchier.
May 10 · H L
Quality and unique presentation of the pizza, pasta and chicken parm. Great service. Celebrated my wife’s birthday and the staff made it special.
July 28 · Peter Tse
The pepperoni and jalapeño pizza hits so hard. Also don’t sleep on their salad. The pizzas with a lot of veggies or sausage can sag a bit too fast and makes it not-as-good as the other ones. Great service but space is a bit too crowded.
May 24 · Francisco F