Jersey Mike's Subs

- 4664 Cemetery Road, Kroger Plaza at, Leap Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026

For anyone in the Ohio region craving an authentic, East Coast-style sub sandwich, Jersey Mike's Subs in Hilliard has long been a go-to destination. Known for their commitment to freshly sliced meats and cheeses, premium ingredients, and a dedication to customer satisfaction, Jersey Mike's offers a distinct sub experience that stands out from typical sandwich shops. While the Hilliard location has seen some changes in recent times, its core offering of delicious, made-to-order subs continues to draw in hungry locals seeking a quality meal. This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of what makes this particular Jersey Mike's a significant part of the Hilliard food scene for Ohio residents.

Jersey Mike's Subs has built its reputation on the concept of "A Sub Above," emphasizing the use of high-quality ingredients and a meticulous preparation process. Each sub is made to order, with meats and cheeses sliced fresh right in front of the customer, ensuring peak freshness and flavor. The Hilliard location, like others in the franchise, adheres to this standard, providing a taste that many Ohioans have come to love and expect. The authenticity of their subs, often served "Mike's Way" with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, olive oil blend, red wine vinegar, and spices, delivers a classic flavor profile that transports you straight to the Jersey Shore. Despite some recent adjustments in staffing and a fresh remodel in early 2025, the foundation of fresh ingredients and made-to-order goodness remains central to their appeal for the local Ohio community.

The Jersey Mike's Subs in Hilliard, Ohio, is conveniently situated for easy access by residents throughout the area. You can find this popular sandwich shop at:

4664 Cemetery Road, Kroger Plaza at, Leap Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA

Located within the Kroger Plaza, this spot offers excellent accessibility for those in Hilliard and surrounding Columbus suburbs. Its position within a well-known shopping center means that customers can easily combine their sub run with other errands, making it a highly practical choice for busy Ohioans. The plaza typically provides ample parking, ensuring a smooth and stress-free visit whether you're picking up a quick lunch or ordering for the whole family. The intersection of Cemetery Road and Leap Road is a major thoroughfare, making it simple to get to from various parts of Hilliard and beyond. This strategic placement ensures that Jersey Mike's is a readily available option for delicious subs, whether you're coming from work, school, or home, truly integrating itself into the local Ohio community's daily life.

Jersey Mike's Subs in Hilliard offers a variety of services designed to provide convenience and satisfaction to its Ohio customers.

• Dine-In Service: Customers can enjoy their freshly made subs in the recently remodeled, bright, and clean dining area.
• Takeout/Carryout: Ideal for those on the go, orders can be placed in-store or by phone for quick pickup.
• Online Ordering: For maximum convenience, customers can order their favorite subs through the Jersey Mike's website or mobile app, allowing for customized orders and scheduled pickups.
• Delivery Services: Partnering with popular third-party delivery platforms, Jersey Mike's in Hilliard makes it easy for locals to have their subs delivered directly to their homes or workplaces.
• Catering: For events, office lunches, or larger gatherings, Jersey Mike's offers catering options including sub trays, boxed lunches, and more, providing a convenient solution for feeding a crowd.
• Customizable Subs: Customers have full control over their sub creations, choosing from a wide array of meats, cheeses, fresh vegetables, and their signature "Mike's Way" dressings.
• Hot and Cold Subs: A diverse menu includes both classic cold subs and a selection of grilled hot subs like cheesesteaks, catering to various preferences.

Jersey Mike's Subs in Hilliard boasts several features and highlights that contribute to its appeal for Ohio residents.

• Fresh Sliced Meats and Cheeses: This is a cornerstone of the Jersey Mike's experience. All meats and cheeses are sliced fresh for each order, right in front of the customer, ensuring unparalleled quality and taste that differentiates them from many competitors.
• "Mike's Way" Preparation: A signature feature is the option to have your sub prepared "Mike's Way," which includes fresh onions, crisp lettuce, ripe tomatoes, a special blend of olive oil and red wine vinegar, and spices. This classic preparation enhances the flavors and provides a truly authentic experience.
• Quality Ingredients: Beyond the fresh-sliced items, Jersey Mike's emphasizes high-quality ingredients across its menu, from the bread baked in-store to fresh vegetables and signature sauces.
• Recent Remodel: The Hilliard location underwent a remodel in early 2025, resulting in a refreshed and modern interior that enhances the dining and ordering experience, making it a more pleasant environment for customers.
• Diverse Menu: Offering both cold and hot subs, including popular options like the #7 Turkey and Provolone, #13 The Original Italian, and various cheesesteaks, there’s a wide selection to satisfy different tastes and cravings.
• Community Involvement: Jersey Mike's as a brand is known for its strong community involvement and charitable initiatives, which often resonate positively with local customers who appreciate businesses giving back.
• Efficient Service (Typically): While recent customer feedback has noted some adjustments, Jersey Mike's aims for efficient and friendly service, particularly when fully staffed and trained, striving to deliver quick and accurate orders.

For orders, inquiries, or more information about Jersey Mike's Subs in Hilliard, OH, you can use the following contact details:

Address: 4664 Cemetery Road, Kroger Plaza at, Leap Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA

Phone: (614) 876-8700

Mobile Phone: +1 614-876-8700

For Ohioans seeking a quality sub sandwich experience, Jersey Mike's Subs in Hilliard remains a suitable and appealing choice. Despite recent changes, the fundamental commitment to freshly sliced, high-quality ingredients and the signature "Mike's Way" preparation continues to offer a distinct and flavorful product that sets it apart. The convenient location within the Kroger Plaza on Cemetery Road ensures easy accessibility for residents across Hilliard and surrounding areas, making it a practical stop for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or catering for events. The option for online ordering and third-party delivery further enhances its convenience, aligning perfectly with the busy lifestyles of many Ohio locals.

While recent customer reviews indicate some challenges with staffing transitions and portion consistency following the 2025 remodel, the potential for Jersey Mike's to rectify these issues and return to its historical level of excellence is significant. The brand's established reputation for quality and its proactive efforts in refreshing locations suggest a commitment to improving the customer experience. For those in Ohio who value fresh ingredients and a customizable menu that offers both classic and hot sub options, Jersey Mike's in Hilliard presents a strong contender. The fresh, modern interior also provides a pleasant environment for dining in. Ultimately, for residents who appreciate a hearty, flavorful sub made with care, Jersey Mike's Subs in Hilliard offers a compelling choice within the local food landscape, making it a place worth visiting and supporting as it continues to evolve.

Jersey Mike's Subs

4664 Cemetery Road, Kroger Plaza at, Leap Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA