Made in New York Pizza

- 512 7th Ave, New York, NY 10018

For New Yorkers, a perfect slice of pizza isn’t just a meal—it’s a way of life. It’s the foldable, cheesy, saucy, and slightly greasy joy that fuels the city. Made in New York Pizza, with its prime location in Midtown, lives up to its name by offering a truly authentic New York pizza experience. This isn't your average pizza joint; it’s a place that honors the city's rich pizza tradition while also innovating with new and exciting toppings and styles. Whether you're a local on your lunch break, a tourist looking for that quintessential New York moment, or a hungry group after a long day of sightseeing, Made in New York Pizza is a must-visit destination. The atmosphere is casual and relaxed, making it the perfect spot for a quick bite or a satisfying sit-down meal.

The moment you walk in, the aroma of fresh dough, bubbling cheese, and savory toppings lets you know you're in the right place. The restaurant offers a wide variety of pizza options, from the classic cheese and pepperoni to more inventive creations like the "Yo Paulie Pie." They understand that a great pizza starts with great ingredients, and their commitment to using fresh, quality components is evident in every bite. With a selection of round pies, square pies, and an extensive list of slices available at all times, there's always something to satisfy any craving. The service is consistently friendly and fast, and the prices are very fair, especially for the heart of Manhattan. It's a place that captures the essence of what makes New York pizza famous worldwide—its delicious simplicity, its perfect texture, and its undeniable character.

Made in New York Pizza is conveniently located at 512 7th Ave, New York, NY 10018, USA, placing it right in the heart of Midtown Manhattan. This prime spot makes it easily accessible to anyone working or visiting the bustling Garment District and Times Square area. It's just a stone's throw away from major transit hubs, including multiple subway lines and bus stops, so getting there is a breeze no matter where you are in the city. The central location also means it’s a perfect pit stop for a quick lunch or dinner before catching a Broadway show. While parking in this area can be difficult, paid street parking is available, and for those using a mobility device, the restaurant features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that it is welcoming to all guests.

Made in New York Pizza provides a range of services to cater to the fast-paced life of New York and the needs of its customers. From a quick slice to a full pie for a party, their service options are designed for convenience. The services available include:

• Dine-in: There are a few seats available inside and a couple of tables outside, offering a casual spot to enjoy your pizza hot and fresh.
• Takeout: A popular choice for people on the go, allowing you to grab your slice or pie and be on your way.
• Delivery: The restaurant offers delivery, so you can enjoy their delicious pizza from the comfort of your home, office, or hotel.
• Catering: For larger events, they offer catering services, including full trays of salads and garlic knots, making it easy to feed a crowd.
• Grab-and-Go Slices: The most iconic service is the availability of a wide variety of slices, perfect for a quick and satisfying bite.

What makes Made in New York Pizza a standout among the city's countless pizzerias is its dedication to classic techniques and diverse offerings. The restaurant’s features create a distinct experience that keeps both locals and tourists coming back. Some of the most notable highlights include:

• Authentic NY-Style Pizza: The pizza features a perfectly soft, chewy, and foldable dough with a good crust, which many customers describe as having the perfect texture.
• Diverse Menu: From classic round pies and hefty Sicilian squares to thin Grandma pies, the menu offers a rich variety of pizza styles to choose from.
• Extensive Slice Selection: The counter is always stocked with a wide range of slices, from traditional Pepperoni and Cheese to the more unique Spicy Pepperoni and Vodka-Roni, allowing you to try different flavors.
• Vegetarian and Vegan-Friendly Options: The menu includes multiple vegetarian options, and they offer a dedicated Vegan Cheese Pie and a Vegan Pie with no cheese, catering to a diverse clientele.
• High-Quality Ingredients: Customers consistently praise the fresh ingredients, from the flavorful sauce to the perfect blend of cheeses.
• Fast and Friendly Service: The staff is known for being friendly and efficient, ensuring that you get your delicious pizza quickly, which is a major plus in a busy area.
• Reasonable Prices: For a Midtown location, the prices are considered very fair, offering great value for the portion sizes and quality of the food.
• Kids' Menu & Options: With a selection of simple, classic pies and slices, it’s a good spot for families with kids.

To place an order, inquire about catering, or for any other information, you can contact Made in New York Pizza at the following:

Address: 512 7th Ave, New York, NY 10018, USA

Phone: (646) 370-6488

With such a broad menu, deciding what to order at Made in New York Pizza can be a delightful challenge. However, based on the customer feedback and menu highlights, a few items stand out. The Spicy Pepperoni Slice is a definite winner for those who can handle the heat, praised for its perfect crust, soft dough, and delicious sauce. For a more classic choice, the Cheese Pie and Pepperoni Pie are fantastic introductions to their high-quality ingredients and classic New York style. The Vodka Slice and Drunken Grandma Slice are also highly recommended for their rich and creamy vodka sauce, which is a fan favorite.

Beyond the round pies and slices, the square pizzas are also worth trying. The Upside Down Square Slice offers a unique experience with the sauce on top of the cheese, and the Classic Sicilian Slice is a satisfyingly thick and savory option. Don't forget to grab some of their side items; while the garlic knots may be "ok" according to one review, many find them to be a perfect addition to their meal, especially with a side of their delicious Marinara sauce. The portion sizes are generous, often big enough for leftovers, which provides excellent value. Overall, the combination of delicious, fresh pizza, fair prices, and the classic New York atmosphere makes Made in New York Pizza a place that truly lives up to its name and is well worth choosing for your next pizza fix.

Made in New York Pizza

512 7th Ave, New York, NY 10018, USA