Madison Street Pizza

- 223 Madison St, New York, NY 10002

In a city where pizza is not just food but a way of life, Madison Street Pizza has established itself as a true neighborhood gem. Located in a low-key, unassuming spot, it's the kind of place that locals know and love for its excellent, no-fuss approach to a classic New York staple. This is a pizza shop that prides itself on delivering high-quality, delicious pies with a perfect crust texture—a detail that every true pizza connoisseur appreciates. It's not about extravagant toppings or a complex menu; it’s about perfecting the basics and doing them exceptionally well. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, making it a comfortable place to pop in for a quick slice or to sit down and enjoy a full pie with family and friends. For New Yorkers looking for that authentic, top-tier pizza experience that feels both familiar and special, Madison Street Pizza is a must-visit destination.

The spirit of Madison Street Pizza is rooted in its dedication to a great product and even better service. As a women-owned business, it brings a unique and personal touch to its operation. Customers consistently rave about the friendly and welcoming nature of the owners and staff, describing the place as an adorable "mom and pop" shop. This personal connection is a significant part of the experience, as one reviewer mentioned, with a kind owner even throwing in a free garlic bread on a first visit. This kind of hospitality fosters a sense of community and makes every customer feel valued. Beyond the standard cheese and pepperoni, the menu offers a solid selection of pies, including specialty options like the Four Cheese, Meat Lover Pie, and Valeriana Pizza. The buffalo chicken slice is another popular item that has earned a loyal following among regulars. The commitment to quality ingredients and a great crust ensures that whether you're grabbing a single slice or an entire pie, you're getting a top-notch meal that is worth every bite.

Madison Street Pizza is conveniently located at 223 Madison St, New York, NY 10002, USA. Nestled in a vibrant and accessible neighborhood, it's a convenient spot for a quick bite or a planned meal. The location is easy to find and is well-integrated into the local community, making it a frequent stop for residents and those working nearby. While specific accessibility details are not fully provided, the ground-level entrance typical of many New York pizza shops suggests it is easily approachable for most patrons. For those who live or work in the area, it's the perfect place to grab lunch or dinner without a long commute. The fact that it's a "lowkey spot" also adds to its charm, offering a relaxed alternative to some of the more high-traffic dining establishments in the city. Its location on Madison Street makes it a staple of the Lower East Side, contributing to the rich tapestry of local eateries that define the city's culinary landscape.

Services Offered:

• Curbside pickup: A convenient service that allows customers to get their order quickly and easily.
• No-contact delivery: Ensures a safe and hassle-free way to have your food delivered.
• Delivery: A reliable option for enjoying Madison Street Pizza's offerings from the comfort of your home or office.
• Takeout: Perfect for grabbing a slice or a full pie on the go.
• Dine-in: A casual space is available for those who wish to sit and enjoy their meal in the shop.

Features / Highlights:

• Excellent Crust Texture: The pizza is celebrated for its perfectly textured crust, a key indicator of a high-quality New York-style pie.
• Women-Owned Business: Identifies as a women-owned establishment, contributing to the diversity of local businesses.
• Family-Friendly & Good for Kids: The casual atmosphere and classic menu make it a great spot for families.
• Friendly and Welcoming Staff: The team is consistently praised for their warm and inviting nature, enhancing the dining experience.
• Comfort Food: The menu is centered on classic, satisfying comfort food that is perfect for any occasion.
• Debit Cards & NFC Mobile Payments Accepted: Offers a variety of convenient payment options.

Contact Information:

• Address: 223 Madison St, New York, NY 10002, USA
• Phone: (917) 675-6006

What is worth choosing?

Choosing Madison Street Pizza is a decision to support a true local gem that prioritizes quality and community. The garlic knots, which one customer said are now one of their favorite things on the menu, are a perfect example of how a simple item can be executed to perfection. The pizzas themselves are the main event, with the 18" pies providing ample portions for a family or a group of friends. The classic Cheese and Pepperoni are a must-try for any first-timer, as they showcase the perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and that exceptional crust. For those with a more adventurous palate, the Valeriana Pizza, with its array of fresh vegetables, offers a vibrant and delicious vegetarian option. The Meat Lover Pie is a hearty choice for those craving a savory and filling meal. What truly sets Madison Street Pizza apart, however, is the feeling you get when you walk through the door. It's the type of place where the owners remember your face and a simple meal feels like a treat. The combination of high-quality, flavorful food, excellent service, and a warm, inviting atmosphere makes it a standout. In a city where pizza is ubiquitous, finding a place that feels this authentic and special is a rare find. Madison Street Pizza is not just a place to grab a quick slice; it’s a local institution that embodies the heart and soul of a New York neighborhood, and that's what makes it truly worth choosing.

Madison Street Pizza

223 Madison St, New York, NY 10002, USA