Massey's Pizza - Whitehall: A Columbus Pizza Institution for Families and Flavor

Massey's Pizza - Whitehall Introduce

For generations of Ohioans, particularly those in the Columbus area, Massey's Pizza isn't just a pizza place; it's a culinary landmark. The Whitehall location of Massey's Pizza, situated at 4464 E Main St, carries on a rich tradition that dates back to 1949, when the Massucci brothers first introduced pizza to Columbus. Known for its distinctive rectangular cuts, hearth-baked crust, and generous, high-quality toppings, Massey's has earned its reputation as a local favorite. This is a place where classic flavors meet a welcoming atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for everything from a quick weeknight dinner to memorable family outings. If you're in Ohio and looking for a slice of local history combined with a genuinely delicious pizza experience, Massey's Pizza in Whitehall is a must-visit.

Massey's Pizza - Whitehall is conveniently located at 4464 E Main St, Whitehall, OH 43213, USA. This accessible address places it on a bustling stretch of East Main Street, a primary artery connecting various communities within the Columbus metropolitan area. Its prominent position makes it easily reachable for residents not only in Whitehall but also from neighboring areas such as Columbus proper, Reynoldsburg, and Bexley. The location's ease of access, whether by car or local transportation, ensures that a visit for dine-in, carry-out, or even a special event is straightforward. Being part of a well-established local chain, this location benefits from being a known and trusted entity within the community, making it a convenient stop for a quality pizza meal. Ample parking is typically available for customers, further enhancing its accessibility.

Massey's Pizza - Whitehall offers a comprehensive range of services designed to provide a complete and satisfying pizza dining experience, catering to various needs from individual meals to group events.

Dine-In Service: Enjoy your meal in a comfortable and welcoming restaurant environment. The staff are noted for being "so kind and patient," creating a pleasant atmosphere for all diners, including families with children.
Take-Out & Pick-Up: Convenient options for customers who prefer to enjoy their Massey's pizza at home. Online ordering is available for efficient pickup.
Delivery Service: Partnering with services like DoorDash and Postmates, Massey's Pizza offers delivery, bringing their delicious pizzas, subs, and other menu items right to your door.
Full Pizza Menu: Featuring a wide array of pizzas, including their "World Famous Pepperoni Pizza" with its unique 50/50 mozzarella and provolone blend and abundant pepperoni. Options include classic cheese, supreme, meat feast, veggie, Hawaiian, and specialty pizzas like Buffalo Chicken, Philly Steak, and Bacon Cheddar Cheeseburger. Gluten-free and cauliflower crust options are also available.
Other Menu Items: Beyond pizza, Massey's offers a diverse selection of:
- Subs: Including the popular "Great Guido Sub" and various other Italian, steak, chicken, and veggie subs.
- Appetizers: Such as Buffalo Garlic wings, garlic cheese bread, mozzarella cheese sticks, fried mushrooms, and more.
- Pastas: Featuring classic Italian dishes like Lasagna, Chicken Parmesan, and Rigatoni.
- Salads: A selection of fresh salads, including antipasto and grilled chicken salads.
- Desserts: Sweet treats to complete your meal.
Lunch Buffet: Available Monday through Friday, typically from 11 AM to 2 PM, offering an all-you-can-eat option for various pizzas and other items.
Group & Educational Experiences: As highlighted by a daycare field trip review, the staff goes "above and beyond" to provide educational and fun experiences for groups, including demonstrations of pizza making and cutting.
Catering: Massey's offers catering menu options for larger events, including pizzas, wings, meatballs, and lasagna.

Massey's Pizza - Whitehall boasts several unique features and highlights that set it apart as a cherished pizza institution in the Columbus area.

Historical Significance and "Columbus Style" Pizza: Massey's Pizza has a long-standing history dating back to 1949, and it's recognized for pioneering the "Columbus style pizza." This includes a hearth-baked crust, often noted for being "pretty crunchy all over," and pizzas typically cut into rectangular strips rather than traditional pie slices. This unique preparation method is a core highlight for long-time fans.
"World Famous Pepperoni Pizza": A signature item, praised for its "very good" flavor, a distinctive blend of mozzarella and provolone cheeses, and a generous amount of their exclusive Guido Brand Portofino Pepperoni, often covering the pizza wall-to-wall. The use of a "secret dough recipe" baked on the hearth further contributes to its unique taste.
Family-Friendly Environment & Exceptional Service for Groups: As highlighted by the "amazing experience" of a daycare field trip, the staff, notably "Miss Megan and the entire team," go "above and beyond." They offer educational tours, allowing children "behind the counter to learn how pizzas are made," show them the oven, and demonstrate cutting. This dedication to creating "memorable experiences" for kids, coupled with staff being "so kind and patient," makes it an ideal spot for family outings, daycare trips, and summer camps.
Generous Gestures for Groups: The surprise offering of "four complimentary pizzas just for our group" during a buffet hour and giving "every child received a toy to take home" demonstrates an exceptional level of hospitality and customer appreciation, particularly for larger groups.
Beyond Pizza: While pizza is their forte, Massey's also excels in other areas. The "Buffalo Garlic wings" were specifically highlighted as "very good," suggesting strong quality across other menu items as well, including subs, pasta, and appetizers.
Consistent Flavor Profile: Despite a crust being "pretty crunchy all over," the "flavor overall was very good still hit the spot," indicating that the underlying taste of the pizza (sauce, cheese, toppings) remains consistently high quality.

These features collectively make Massey's Pizza - Whitehall a beloved and highly recommended establishment, particularly for its commitment to family-friendly experiences and its iconic, authentic Columbus-style pizza.

For anyone in the Ohio area looking to enjoy the classic taste and welcoming atmosphere of Massey's Pizza - Whitehall, here is the essential contact information:

Address: 4464 E Main St, Whitehall, OH 43213, USA
Phone: (614) 559-2222
Mobile Phone: +1 614-559-2222

You can also visit their official website to view their full menu, check current operating hours (typically Sun-Thu: 11 am-10 pm, Fri & Sat: 11 am-MIDNIGHT, with a lunch buffet M-F 11 am-2 pm), or place an online order for pickup or delivery. For group bookings or special inquiries like field trips, it's recommended to call ahead and speak directly with the team.

Massey's Pizza in Whitehall, Ohio, stands out as an exceptionally suitable destination for locals, solidifying its place as more than just a restaurant, but a true community fixture. Its deep roots in Columbus's pizza history, offering the distinctive "Columbus style" pizza with its unique rectangular cut and hearth-baked crust, appeals to those who appreciate local traditions and authentic flavors. For Ohio families, the Whitehall location is particularly ideal, as evidenced by its "amazing experience" with daycare students. The staff's willingness to go "above and beyond" by providing educational tours, letting kids learn about pizza making, and offering thoughtful gestures like complimentary pizzas and toys, creates truly "memorable experiences." This level of hospitality makes it a welcoming and fun environment for children and adults alike. Beyond the exceptional service, the pizza itself consistently delivers "very good" flavor, with highlights like the "World Famous Pepperoni Pizza" and delicious "Buffalo Garlic wings." For locals seeking a reliable, high-quality pizza that "still hit the spot," coupled with a warm, family-friendly atmosphere and a genuine commitment to the community, Massey's Pizza - Whitehall is an undeniable choice. It’s a place where you can enjoy a piece of local heritage alongside a fantastic meal, making it a highly recommended spot for anyone in the Ohio region.

Massey's Pizza - Whitehall Vibe

Pizza & Stromboli
Thin Crust Cheese Pizza (8") US$9.99
Crispy thin crust topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce.
Thin Crust Cheese Pizza (12) US$17.99
A crispy thin crust topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce.
Thin Crust Cheese Pizza (14") US$20.99
A 14-inch thin crust pizza topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce.
Famous Thin Crust Build Your Own Pizza (8") US$9.99
Thin crust pizza, 8 inches. Choose from meats, vegetables, cheeses, and more. Customize with up to five toppings. Stromboli style available.
Famous Thin Crust Build Your Own Pizza (12") US$17.99
Customizable 12" thin crust pizza with your choice of multiple toppings, including meats, vegetables, and cheeses.
Famous Thin Crust Build Your Own Pizza (14") US$20.99
Customize your 14" thin crust pizza. Choose from a variety of toppings including meats, vegetables, and cheeses like Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Jalapenos, and Gorgonzola Cheese.
Cauliflower Crust Build Your Own Pizza (10") US$17.99
Cauliflower crust build-your-own pizza. Choose up to five toppings from a variety of meats, vegetables, and cheeses.
Deep Dish Build Your Own Pizza (12") US$19.99
12" deep dish build your own pizza. Choice of various toppings including meats, vegetables, and cheeses.
Stromboli With Up To 2 Items (8") US$8.99
Choice of two toppings on an 8" Stromboli. Options include various meats, vegetables, peppers, and cheeses.
Stromboli With Up To 2 Items (12") US$16.99
Stromboli filled with your choice of up to 2 items from a selection of meats, vegetables, and cheeses.
Stromboli With Up To 2 Items (14") US$19.99
Choose up to 2 from various toppings like meats, veggies, and cheeses.

Specialty Pizzas
Italian Stallion
Portofino pepperoni, house-made italian sausage, mushrooms, old-world tomato sauce, mozzarella and provolone cheeses. 8" $11.99 12" $20.99 14" $24.99 12" Deep $22.99
Bacon Cheddar Cheese Burger
Ground beef, old-world tomato sauce, applewood bacon, mozzarella, provolone and cheddar cheeses. 8" $11.99 12" $20.99 14" $24.99 12" Deep $22.99
Fresh Veggie
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, banana peppers, old-world tomato sauce, mozzarella and provolone cheeses. 8" $11.99 12" $20.99 14" $24.99 12" Deep $22.99
Mexican Fiesta
Seasoned ground beef, salsa, mozzarella, provolone and cheddar cheeses. topped with lettuce, tomato and banana peppers. comes with sour cream and taco sauce on the side. 8" $11.99 12" $20.99 14" $24.99 12" Deep $22.99
White Pizza
Olive oil, garlic butter, black olives, mozzarella, provolone, parmesan and gorgonzola cheeses with fresh ground spices. 8" $11.99 12" $20.99 14" $24.99 12" Deep $22.99
BLT
Smoked Applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, mozzarella and provolone cheeses. 8" $11.99 12" $20.99 14" $24.99 12" Deep $22.99
Hawaiian
Pineapple, ham, old-world tomato sauce, mozzarella and provolone cheeses. 8" $11.99 12" $20.99 14" $24.99 12" Deep $22.99
Four Cheese
Mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, parmesan cheeses and our old- world tomato sauce. 8" $11.99 12" $20.99 14" $24.99 12" Deep $22.99
Buffalo Chicken
Strips of real chicken breast soaked in red hot buffalo sauce layered on a bed of mozzarella, provolone cheeses and spicy pizza sauce. 8" $11.99 12" $20.99 14" $24.99 12" Deep $22.99
Chicken Cheddar Bacon With Ranch Or BBQ
Your choice of ranch dressing or BBQ sauce, strips of real chicken breast, smoked applewood bacon, mozzarella, provolone and cheddar cheeses. 8" $11.99 12" $20.99 14" $24.99 12" Deep $22.99

Premium Specialty Pizzas
Supreme
Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, old-world tomato sauce, mozzarella and provolone cheeses. 8" $12.99 12" $22.99 14" $26.99 12" Deep $24.99
Meat Feast
Seasoned ground beef, ham, salami, pepperoni, Italian sausage, tomato sauce, mozzarella and provolone cheeses. 8" $12.99 12" $22.99 14" $26.99 12" Deep $24.99
Ragin ' Cajun
Pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, banana peppers, specialty spicy sauce, mozzarella and provolone cheeses. 8" $12.99 12" $22.99 14" $26.99 12" Deep $24.99
12" Sicilian Deep Dish Pan Pizza US$22.99
Buttery thick crust topped with old world tomato sauce, mozzarella and plenty of aged provolone cheese, homemade italian sausage, portofino pepperoni, fresh ground spices and baked in a deep dish pan.
Philly Pizza (Chicken Or Steak)
Thinly sliced prime steak or chicken breast, old-world tomato sauce, onion, green peppers and melted provolone and mozzarella cheeses. 8" $12.99 12" $22.99 14" $26.99 12" Deep $24.99

Jersey-Style Subs $10.99
Great Guido Italian US$10.99
Italian ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato, banana peppers and italian dressing or pizza sauce.
Meatball Hoagie US$10.99
Meatballs, spaghetti sauce, parmesan and provolone cheese.
Ham & Cheese Sub US$10.99
Ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
Pizza Sub US$10.99
Pepperoni, pizza sauce and provolone cheese.
Turkey Sub US$10.99
Sliced turkey breast, provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
Buffalo Chicken Sub US$10.99
Fried chicken patty soaked in buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato and blue cheese dressing.
Veggie Sub US$10.99
Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives, green olives, banana peppers, lettuce, tomato, provolone cheese and italian dressing.
PBLT Sub US$10.99
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, provolone cheese and mayo.
Salami Sub US$10.99
Salami Sub is served with Banana Peppers, Lettuce, Onions, Provolone Cheese, Salami, Tomato.
Deluxe Pizza Sub US$10.99
Deluxe Pizza Sub is served with Green Peppers, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Pepperoni, Pizza Sauce, Provolone Cheese.
Philly Chicken Sub US$10.99
Philly chicken sub is served with green peppers, grilled chicken strips, onions, provolone cheese.
Philly Steak Sub US$10.99
Philly Cheese Steak Sub is served with Cheese, Green Peppers, Onions, Steak and Mayo.
Parmesan Chicken Sub US$10.99
Parmesan chicken sub is served with chicken patty, provolone cheese, parmesan cheese, spaghetti sauce.
Club Sub US$10.99
Club Sub is served with Bacon, Ham, Lettuce, Mayo, Provolone Cheese, Tomato, Turkey.
Chicken Sub US$10.99
Chicken Sub is served with Chicken Patty, Lettuce, Mayo, Provolone Cheese, Tomato.

Chicken Foghorn's Wings
10 Piece US$15.99
spicy, garlicky, savory, sweet, or plain.
20 Piece US$28.99
20 piece wings. Traditional or boneless. Choose from various sauce options including spicy, garlic, sweet, tangy, BBQ, and more.
50 Piece US$59.99
50 pieces of wings. Choice of traditional or boneless. Sauces range from spicy to mild, including Garlic and BBQ options.

Appetizers
Mac-N-Cheese Bites US$7.99
Crispy golden bites filled with creamy macaroni and cheese, served with a side of tangy dipping sauce.
Bacon Cheese Fries US$9.99
Crispy fries topped with melted cheddar cheese and crumbled bacon.
Garlic Cheese Bread US$4.99
Toasted bread topped with melted cheese and garlic, served with marinara sauce.
Cheesy Garlic Dunkers US$9.99
Golden, crispy bread topped with melted cheese and garlic, served with a side of marinara sauce.
Cheese Sticks US$7.99
Crispy fried cheese sticks served with a side of marinara sauce.
Fries Basket US$4.99
Golden, crisp, and perfectly seasoned French fries.
Meatballs (4) US$5.99
Juicy meatballs in rich tomato sauce, garnished with fresh herbs.
Smothered Meatballs (4) US$7.99
Juicy meatballs in rich tomato sauce, garnished with fresh herbs covered in melted Italian cheese blend.
Sicilian Bread US$6.99
Topped with melted cheese and black olives, this Sicilian bread offers a savory blend of flavors.

Salads
Side Salad US$4.99
Fresh salad mix, banana peppers, tomato and croutons with choice of dressing.
Dinner Salad US$7.99
Fresh salad mix with banana peppers, tomato, black and green olives, croutons, mozzarella and provolone cheeses.
Family Salad US$11.99
Fresh salad mix, mozzarella and provolone cheeses, pepperoni, tomato, banana peppers, black olives, pepperoncinis and croutons.
Grilled Or Fried Chicken Salad US$9.99
Fresh salad mix with strips of chicken breast, mozzarella and provolone cheeses, banana peppers, tomato, black olives and croutons.
Antipasto Salad US$9.99
Fresh salad mix, pepperoni, salami, provolone and mozzarella cheeses, banana pepper, pepperoncinis, black and green olives, tomato and croutons.
Taco Salad US$9.99
Tortilla chips, fresh salad mix, tomato, black olives, cheddar cheese, seasoned beef, taco sauce and choice of dressing.
Five-Star House Salad US$9.99
Fresh salad mix, smoked applewood bacon, gorgonzola crumbles, tomato, onion, black olives and croutons with choice of dressing.

Pasta
Chicken Parmesan US$14.99
Lightly breaded chicken breast topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella and provolone cheeses. served with fresh pasta.
Rigatoni Alfredo US$10.99
fresh pasta tossed in our rich and creamy alfredo sauce.
Lasagna US$11.99
Baked pasta in layers with ricotta cheese and with ricotta cheese meat covered in our family recipe red sauce.
Rigatoni & Meatballs US$10.99
Fresh rigatoni covered in our family recipe red sauce, topped with two italian meatballs.

Beverages
20 Oz. Bottle US$1.99
Carbonated soft drink in a 20 oz. bottle.
2 Liter Soda US$2.99
Carbonated beverage in a 2-liter bottle.
20 Oz Bottle Of Water US$1.99
Pure bottled water, 20 oz, ideal for hydration.

Sweet Things
Cinnamon Dunkers US$6.99
Soft, golden-brown dough strips coated in cinnamon and sugar, drizzled with sweet icing.
Cannoli (1) US$5.99
Crispy pastry shell filled with sweet ricotta, topped with powdered sugar and drizzled with chocolate sauce.
Cannoli (3) US$9.99
Crispy pastry shells filled with sweet ricotta cream, drizzled with chocolate sauce, and dusted with powdered sugar.

Sides
BBQ Sauce US$0.89
Rich and tangy barbecue sauce with a smoky flavor, ideal for complementing grilled meats or adding depth to your favorite dishes.
Dressings US$0.89
Italian varieties, Ranch, French, Mustard, Blue Cheese, Caesar, Raspberry, Walnut Vinaigrette, Thousand Island.
Marinara US$0.89
Rich tomato sauce with garlic, onions, and herbs.
Wing Sauce US$0.89
Inferno, Hot, Cajun Garlic, Sweet Red Chili, Buffalo Garlic, Medium, Garlic, Parmesan Garlic, Mild, Tangy Gold, Teriyaki Sweet, Country BBQ, or Plain.
Meatball US$1.50
Juicy, seasoned ground meat combined with herbs and spices, shaped into a ball and baked to perfection.
Alfredo Sauce US$1.00
Rich and creamy alfredo sauce made with Parmesan cheese, butter, and garlic.
Garlic Sauce US$0.89
Smooth garlic sauce made with soybean oil, water, salt, and garlic, enhanced with natural flavors and spices.

Massey's Pizza - Whitehall Details

Service options
Kerbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Serves local specialty
Sport

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Spirits
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating

Amenities
Bar on site
Toilet

Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Quiet

Crowd
Family friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safe space

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Massey's Pizza - Whitehall Photos

Massey's Pizza - Whitehall Location

Massey's Pizza - Whitehall

Ohio Franklin County Whitehall Bernhards East Main Street

4464 E Main St, Whitehall, OH 43213, USA

Massey's Pizza - Whitehall Reviews

An average rating of ★4 from 1055 user reviews.

buffetpepperonisubcrustcauliflowersausagedeep dishcadillacgreen pepperswell done

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

We recently took our daycare students on a field trip to Massey’s Pizza on East Broad Street, and it was an amazing experience from start to finish!Miss Megan and the entire team went above and beyond to make sure our kids had a great time. They let the children go behind the counter to learn how pizzas are made, showed them the oven, and even demonstrated how the pizzas are cut. It was educational and fun!During buffet hour, they surprised us with four complimentary pizzas just for our group and every child received a toy to take home. The service was excellent, and the staff was so kind and patient with our little ones.We highly recommend this location to any other daycare, summer camp, or family looking for a place that truly welcomes kids and creates memorable experiences. Thank you again, Miss Megan and team!Tender Years Learning Center
August 01 · Benny Boom
Ordered a pizza. Crust was pretty crunchy all over, didn’t taste burnt luckily. Flavor overall was very good still hit the spot. Also got the Buffalo Garlic wings and those were very good. I would try them again, just think crust was over cooked! Still good location.
July 19 · Carlo
45 minutes here(12:30pm-1:15pm). From the point we got here there was 4 pizzas all half gone or less. Not one new pizza brought out, the old one were orange and burnt. Salad was half flag missing most Ingedients and only two dressings ( so lettuce cheese banana peppers and dressing(yum). Nothing made or restocked the entire time. Chicken was good (not the usual frozen chicken wings) and for $32 for two people. I won't be back!
June 09 · adam frontuto
I ordered one topping pepperoni from Whitehall. I had been a faithful patron of Donatos (family friends) since they opened but their quality and service became disappointing. Lukewarm pizza was the high point of every order. Massey's was a hit and it's right around the corner from my home. Even good cold the next day. You have a new faithful customer.
March 18 · Edwin Ayers
Called & recording said if ordered online u get $5 off 1st order but wouldn't allow to order for delivery online. Spoke to someone who had NO knowledge about anything smh yelled for someone named Mary who I assume was mgr. She was worse. No accountability just blamed delivery app & didn't offer to honor offer even though it was offered on recording when u call. I still ordered & food was cold & nasty. DEFINITELY not worth what I paid. Wouldn't even have been worth it with the $5 off
April 14 · Imbeautifulnaturally A