Brunch & Snack Chat
Brunch & Snack ChatBites & BanterBest Restaurants Near Me
Ohio

Brunch & Snack ChatBest Restaurants Near MeNew YorkNew York CountyNew YorkBest Restaurants in 1st AvenueMaya Mexican Grill
Maya Mexican Grill ico

Maya Mexican Grill
- 1586 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028

Mexican restaurant ★4.0 (15)·$10–20

1586 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

4.0
Had a great first time at Maya Mexican grill. The food tasted fresh and the staff was very nice. Portion sizes are good for the price! A great addition to the neighborhood. - Carley Miller
Maya Mexican Grill Overview Intro Menu Detail Photos Location Reviews
$10–20 per person Reported by 15 people$1–10$10–20$20–30

Maya Mexican Grill Introduce

In a city where delicious food can be found on every block, sometimes what truly stands out is a place that combines quality, convenience, and genuine value. Maya Mexican Grill, a new and welcome addition to the Upper East Side, is doing just that. It's quickly earning a reputation as a go-to spot for fresh, flavorful Mexican food in a fast-casual setting. This isn't just another Mexican restaurant; it's a place that prides itself on offering a superior experience, from the taste of its food to the warmth of its staff. For New Yorkers seeking a satisfying and reliable meal that feels a step above the usual, Maya Mexican Grill is a perfect choice.

The menu at Maya Mexican Grill is a celebration of classic Mexican flavors with a modern twist. While it offers familiar favorites like burritos and quesadillas, it truly shines with its specialty items, particularly the popular Birria Tacos and the customizable bowls. Customers rave about the freshness of the ingredients, a key factor that elevates the dining experience. The focus on big, bold flavors and generous portion sizes is another major highlight, ensuring that you leave feeling full and happy. This commitment to both quality and quantity makes it a favorite among those who appreciate a meal that is as satisfying as it is delicious.

The atmosphere of the restaurant is designed to be casual and welcoming, making it a great spot for a quick lunch or a laid-back dinner. The staff is consistently praised by customers for being "very nice" and providing "lovely" service. This friendly approach creates a positive and comfortable environment that encourages return visits. It’s the kind of place where you can grab a meal on your own, bring the family for a casual dinner, or get catering for your next event. The overall vibe is one of community and hospitality, which is a key ingredient in any successful neighborhood eatery.

For those in the Upper East Side, Maya Mexican Grill is a breath of fresh air. It’s a place that takes a well-loved cuisine and executes it with care and a focus on the customer, promising a great meal every time you visit. It has quickly established itself as a valuable addition to the neighborhood's culinary landscape, and it's well worth exploring for anyone in the area.


Location and Accessibility

Maya Mexican Grill is located at 1586 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA. Its position on the Upper East Side makes it highly accessible to both local residents and visitors to the area. The restaurant is situated on a major avenue, ensuring it is easy to spot and get to, whether you're walking or using public transportation.

The location is well-served by New York City's extensive public transit network. The 86th Street subway station, serving the 4, 5, and 6 lines, is a short walk away, and numerous bus routes operate along 1st Avenue and nearby streets. This makes it a convenient stop for a quick lunch on the go or a relaxed dinner after a day of work or sightseeing. The easy accessibility contributes significantly to its appeal as a go-to spot for a satisfying meal.

The restaurant is designed for easy entry, with a focus on being a convenient food destination. While specific accessibility details are not provided, the general setup of a fast-casual spot on a main street is typically welcoming and easy to navigate. The focus is on getting customers in and out efficiently, making it a practical choice for those with busy schedules. Its presence in a high-traffic residential and commercial area means it's a natural fit for the daily routines of many New Yorkers.


Services Offered

Maya Mexican Grill provides a range of services designed for maximum convenience and flexibility, catering to the needs of a modern, fast-paced city.

  • Dine-in Service: You can enjoy your meal in the casual and comfortable dining space. It's a great option for a quick, sit-down meal.
  • Takeout and Delivery: For those on the go or who prefer to eat at home, Maya Mexican Grill offers both takeout and delivery options, ensuring you can enjoy their fresh food wherever you are.
  • Lunch and Dinner: The restaurant is a popular spot for both lunch and dinner, making it a reliable choice for a meal at any time of day.
  • Catering: Maya Mexican Grill offers catering services, making it a perfect solution for feeding a large group at a party or event with fresh, delicious Mexican food.
  • Kids' Menu: The availability of a dedicated kids' menu, with options like Kid's Quesadillas and Tacos, makes it a family-friendly destination, which is a great asset in a residential neighborhood.

Features / Highlights

Several key features make Maya Mexican Grill a standout choice and a "great addition to the neighborhood."

  • The Birria Tacos: This is a major highlight. The birria offerings, including both tacos and quesadillas, are a strong draw for customers. The flavor and quality of the birria are what set the restaurant apart from many of its competitors.
  • Generous Portion Sizes: Customers consistently praise the restaurant for its "huge portions." This provides excellent value for the price, ensuring that every meal is both delicious and filling.
  • Fresh and High-Quality Ingredients: Reviews highlight the "super fresh ingredients," which is a key factor in the superior taste of the food. This commitment to quality is what makes it a "Chipotle upgrade" for many.
  • Friendly and Welcoming Staff: The staff is repeatedly mentioned for being "very nice" and "lovely." The positive and accommodating service creates a warm atmosphere that enhances the entire dining experience.
  • Diverse Menu: While known for its tacos and bowls, the menu also includes other classics like quesadillas, nachos, and desserts like churros and tiramisu. The "Make your own" option allows for a high degree of customization, catering to individual preferences.

Contact Information

For more information, to place an order, or to inquire about catering, you can contact Maya Mexican Grill at the following:

Address: 1586 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

Phone: (212) 470-5283


What is Worth Choosing

When you're deciding where to eat in New York, what makes Maya Mexican Grill a destination worth choosing? It's the perfect combination of quality, value, and a genuinely pleasant experience. The most compelling reason to visit is the food itself. Unlike many fast-casual spots, Maya Mexican Grill stands out for its freshness and the authenticity of its flavors. The Birria Tacos, in particular, are a must-try, offering a rich and flavorful experience that has quickly become a favorite among local customers. The menu is also highly customizable, allowing you to build your own bowl or burrito, which means you can create the perfect meal to suit your taste and dietary needs, including excellent vegan and protein options.

The generous portion sizes are another significant reason to choose Maya Mexican Grill. In a city where you often pay a premium for small portions, receiving a "huge" and satisfying meal is a major plus. This makes it an excellent value for your money, especially for a quick lunch or a casual dinner. The variety on the menu, from appetizers like Guacamole & Chips to desserts like Tres Leches and Churros, means you can enjoy a full meal from start to finish. The availability of a kids' menu also makes it a stress-free option for families, ensuring there's something everyone will enjoy.

The service is another key factor. The friendly and "lovely" staff create a welcoming environment that enhances the entire dining experience. This level of hospitality, combined with the freshness of the food, gives the restaurant a strong edge over its competitors. It feels like a place that truly cares about its customers and the quality of the food it serves. This attention to detail is what makes it feel like an "upgrade" from other fast-casual chains.

In short, Maya Mexican Grill is worth choosing because it delivers a superior fast-casual experience. It provides high-quality, fresh, and delicious Mexican food with generous portions and excellent service. It’s a reliable, friendly, and satisfying choice for anyone in the Upper East Side neighborhood looking for a great meal without the wait or the fuss of a full-service restaurant. It's a true gem that is quickly becoming a beloved staple in the community.

Maya Mexican Grill Menu

  • Popular Maya Bowl

  • Red Bowl $11.99

    White rice, pinto beans, grilled chicken, pico de gallo, spanich, corn, lettuce, cheese, creamy cilantro, lime sauce.

  • Protein Bowl $14.99

    Cilantro, white rice, fajita veggies, grilled chicken, steak, mexican corn, lettuce, spicy salsa, cilantro salsa.

  • Maya Bowl $12.99

    Cilantro rice, maya chicken, queso, guacamole, pico de gallo, shredded cheese, lettuce, chipotle maya.

  • Vegan Bowl $12.99

    Tofu, lettuce, brown rice, black beans, fajita veggies, mexican corn, pico de gallo, guacamole, cilantro salsa.

  • Birria Quesadilla

  • Steak Birria Quesadilla $15.99

    Melted cheese and tender steak in a folded tortilla with onions and cilantro. served with a side of rich birria consommé for dipping.

  • Chicken Birria Quesadilla $13.99

    Melted cheese with seasoned chicken and birria sauce inside a folded tortilla.

  • Drinks

  • Jarritos $2.99
  • Soda Can $1.50
  • Water Bottle $1.50
  • Birria Tacos

  • 2 Pieces Birria Tacos $15.98
  • 3 Pieces Birria Tacos $17.98
  • Make your own

  • 3 Piece Birria Tacos $12.99
  • Crispy Quesadilla $12.49
  • Maya Burrito $11.99
  • 2 Piece Birria Tacos $11.99
  • Mexican Bowl $11.99
  • Salad Bowl $10.99
  • Kids' Menu

  • Kid's Quesadillas $10.98
  • Kid's Tacos $10.98

    2 pieces crispy soft.

  • Kid's Burritos $10.98

    1 protein.

  • Birria Pie

  • Chicken Birria Pie $26.99
  • Steak Birria Pie $29.99
  • Menu

  • Nachos Bowl $11.99
  • Guacamole $4.99
  • Churros $3.99
  • Guacamole & Chips $6.99
  • 3 Pieces Birria Tacos $17.98
  • Burrito $12.99
  • Salad Bowl $10.99
  • Chips & Queso $6.99
  • 3 Soft Tacos $12.99
  • Chicken & Cheese Quesadilla $10.99

    With Sour Cream and Salsa on the side.

  • Tiramisu $5.99

    Layers of coffee-soaked ladyfingers, mascarpone cheese, and cocoa powder.

  • Dessert Tres Leches $5.99

    Soft sponge cake soaked in three types of milk, topped with whipped cream and drizzled with caramel sauce.

  • Loaded Fries $10.99
  • Nachos $2.99
  • Quesadilla $12.99
  • 2 Soft Tacos $10.99
  • Fries $4.99
  • 2 Pieces Birria Tacos $15.98
  • Maya Bowl $12.99

    Rice with choice of white, brown, or mexican rice, fajita veggies or beans, and protein options including chicken, beef, shrimp, tofu, or cauliflower.

Maya Mexican Grill Details

  • Service options

  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • Dining options

  • Lunch
  • Catering
  • Children

  • Kids' menu

Maya Mexican Grill Photos

Maya Mexican Grill Picture 1Maya Mexican Grill Picture 2Maya Mexican Grill Picture 3Maya Mexican Grill Picture 4Maya Mexican Grill Picture 5Maya Mexican Grill Picture 6Maya Mexican Grill Picture 7Maya Mexican Grill Picture 8Maya Mexican Grill Picture 9Maya Mexican Grill Picture 10

Maya Mexican Grill Location

Maya Mexican Grill

1586 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

Maya Mexican Grill Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 36 user reviews.

pricechipotleburritobowlfast casualpickled onionsbirriasteakquesadillasalsa

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More Best Restaurants Near Me

  • Zabb PuTawnZabb PuTawn4.0 (417 reviews)

    1584 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • AOC EastAOC East4.0 (373 reviews)

    1590 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • La Mia PizzaLa Mia Pizza3.0 (423 reviews)

    1580 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • Le Pain QuotidienLe Pain Quotidien3.0 (202 reviews)

    1592 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • QUATORZEQUATORZE4.0 (210 reviews)

    1578 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • Horn's Hook TavernHorn's Hook Tavern4.0 (195 reviews)

    1589 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • Felice 83Felice 834.0 (632 reviews)

    1593 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • Botte UESBotte UES4.0 (316 reviews)

    1606 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • Goal Omakase SushiGoal Omakase Sushi4.0 (81 reviews)

    349 E 82nd St, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • Gino's PizzaGino's Pizza4.0 (282 reviews)

    345 E 83rd St, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • Nica TrattoriaNica Trattoria4.0 (217 reviews)

    354 E 84th St, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • Gracie Mews DinerGracie Mews Diner4.0 (1039 reviews)

    1550 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Trending Bites & Banter Posts