Miss Nellie's

- 321 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036

In the heart of New York's iconic Theater District, where the energy of Broadway lights and bustling crowds fills the air, lies a true hidden gem: Miss Nellie's. This American restaurant offers more than just a meal; it provides a distinctive, speakeasy-style experience that captivates you from the moment you step inside. With its "wow" factor decor, dim lighting, and eclectic decorations, the space creates a cozy, romantic, and trendy atmosphere that feels like a sophisticated escape from the city's fast pace.

Named after the pioneering journalist Nellie Bly, the restaurant embodies a spirit of adventure and innovation, reflected in both its ambiance and its menu. Miss Nellie's serves up inventive takes on classic American dishes, blending traditional comfort food with a modern flair. The menu is diverse, offering everything from hearty brunch plates and delicious main courses to a tempting array of small plates and raw bar selections. The culinary journey is complemented by a carefully crafted cocktail list that nods to classic concoctions while incorporating new, bold flavors.

Miss Nellie's is a versatile spot that appeals to a wide variety of diners. Whether you're a local looking for a new brunch favorite, a couple seeking a romantic date night spot, or a group of friends planning a pre-show dinner, this place has something for everyone. Its reputation for "delicious food" and "attentive" staff ensures that every visit is a pleasant one, and the overall ambiance makes it a perfect destination for both quiet conversations and festive gatherings.

This article will delve into what makes Miss Nellie's a standout American restaurant in New York City, covering its prime location, convenient services, and a detailed look at its most appealing features.

---

## Location and Accessibility

Miss Nellie's is ideally situated at 321 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036, USA. This location places it squarely in the middle of the Theater District, making it a highly convenient spot for anyone seeing a show on Broadway. The surrounding area is vibrant and full of activity, offering a true New York City experience.

Accessibility is a key advantage of the restaurant. It's just a short walk from the Times Square-42nd Street subway station, a major transportation hub for numerous lines, including the 1, 2, 3, N, Q, R, W, A, C, E, and 7 trains. This easy access makes it a breeze to get to from anywhere in the city.

The restaurant itself is designed to be welcoming to all. It offers wheelchair-accessible seating, ensuring a comfortable experience for guests with mobility needs. The ambiance is described as casual, cozy, romantic, and trendy, with dim lighting that creates an intimate and funky vibe. This setting, combined with its friendly and attentive staff, makes it a perfect place for groups, solo diners, and those looking for a special outing.

Parking in the area consists of paid parking lots and paid street parking, which can be challenging to find, especially during peak hours. Given its central location and proximity to public transit, it is often more convenient to travel without a personal vehicle.

---

## Services Offered

Miss Nellie's provides a focused and high-quality dining experience. The main service options are centered around a relaxed and comfortable on-site visit.

• Dine-in: The primary service is dine-in, which allows guests to fully immerse themselves in the unique atmosphere. The restaurant offers both table service and seating at the bar onsite.

• Reservations: Miss Nellie's accepts reservations, and they are highly recommended, especially for dinner, to ensure you can secure a table and avoid a wait. This is particularly helpful for those planning a pre-theater meal.

• Private Dining Room: For special occasions or larger groups, the restaurant offers a private dining room. This provides a more exclusive and intimate setting for celebrations or gatherings.

• Diverse Dining Options: The restaurant serves brunch, lunch, and dinner, with a menu that transitions smoothly between these times. They also have a dessert menu to round out your meal.

• Late-Night Food and Drinks: With a bar onsite and a menu of small plates and comfort food, Miss Nellie's is an excellent spot for late-night food and drinks after a show or a long day.

---

## Features and Highlights

What makes Miss Nellie's a memorable destination are its distinctive features that set it apart from other American restaurants in the area.

• Speakeasy Vibe and Decor: The first thing many customers notice is the ambiance. The "speakeasy vibe," "dim lighting," and "eclectic decorations" create a "fun, funky" and "cozy" atmosphere. This unique setting is a major draw for both locals and tourists looking for a special night out.

• Great Cocktails and Bar Selection: The bar is a highlight, offering a great selection of beers, cocktails, and wines. While the menu lists unique "House Elixirs" and a variety of martinis, the full bar ensures that "they can make the classics" as well. Happy hour drinks and food are also available, making it a great spot for an after-work gathering.

• Fast and Attentive Service: Despite its popularity, Miss Nellie's is known for its "fast service" and "attentive" staff. One reviewer noted that when they were running late for a show, the restaurant "pushed back our reservation time no problem which was so nice," showcasing their commitment to customer service.

• Inventive Menu: The menu offers a mix of classic American dishes and creative twists. Items like **Bloody Mary Deviled Eggs**, **Smoked Ribeye Benny**, and **Caviar Lobster Rolls** demonstrate the kitchen's innovative approach to comfort food.

• Proximity to Broadway: The location is perfect for theater-goers. As a reviewer mentioned, it's a "perfect place to go for dinner before a show!" The ability to get seated quickly and have food and drinks served fast makes it an ideal choice for those with a tight schedule.

---

## Contact Information

To plan your visit or make a reservation at Miss Nellie's, you can use the contact details below:

• Address: 321 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036, USA

• Phone: (646) 360-3012

---

## What is Worth Choosing

When considering a meal at Miss Nellie's, there are many elements that make it a compelling choice for a memorable New York dining experience. The restaurant's appeal extends beyond just the food, encompassing its unique ambiance, excellent service, and strategic location.

The most significant reason to choose Miss Nellie's is its overall atmosphere. The "lovely atmosphere" and "speakeasy vibe" make it a standout destination. This unique setting is what turns a simple dinner into a special event. It's a place that feels both romantic and fun, perfect for various occasions. The ability to push back a reservation for a delayed guest shows a high level of attentiveness that is highly valued in the city.

From the menu, there are several standout items worth considering. For a classic American comfort food experience, the **Chicken & Waffles** and the **Smashburger** are excellent choices. The brunch menu, in particular, seems to be a hit with locals. The "delicious" food is a consistent theme in positive reviews, with great portions for the price. While some reviewers found certain items like the lobster rolls and eggplant chips to be a bit salty or overpowering, this is often a matter of personal taste. The **Spicy Chicken Sandwich** is also a popular and satisfying choice.

The drinks are also a major reason to visit. The "unusual cocktails" and the presence of a "full bar" mean you can find something for every palate. Whether you're in the mood for a unique house elixir like the **Fogg & Fancies** or a classic martini, the options are plentiful. The happy hour is an excellent opportunity to sample some of these drinks at a great price.

In summary, Miss Nellie's is a top choice for those seeking a restaurant that offers more than just food. It’s an immersive experience with a fantastic ambiance, reliable service, and a menu that blends familiarity with creativity. For a pre-theater dinner or a special date night, Miss Nellie's delivers on its promise of a memorable and enjoyable outing.

Miss Nellie's

321 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036, USA