Moonstruck Eatery: A Timeless Diner Experience in Midtown

Moonstruck Eatery Introduce

Moonstruck Eatery, located at 250 E 58th St, is a quintessential New York diner, embodying the city’s timeless charm and offering a taste of classic American comfort food. This isn't just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a neighborhood staple that has perfected the art of serving a diverse and delicious menu around the clock. For New Yorkers, a diner is more than just a restaurant—it's a reliable sanctuary for any meal, at any time of day or night. Moonstruck Eatery fulfills this role perfectly, providing a cozy and casual atmosphere that is both welcoming and familiar. The menu is a comprehensive testament to the diner concept, offering everything from hearty breakfast plates to full-scale New American entrees, ensuring that every craving can be satisfied under one roof. It is the kind of place that is perfect for a solo diner looking for a quick, comforting meal or a group of friends gathering for a laid-back breakfast or late-night bite.

What sets Moonstruck Eatery apart is its ability to maintain high quality across such a vast menu. While many diners might spread themselves too thin, Moonstruck is celebrated for its consistently good food, earning praise for dishes as varied as its salmon burger and its classic beef gyro. The dessert case is a major highlight, with reviews specifically calling out the "best hot chocolate and pie in NYC hands down," and even a special mention of the "amazing" raspberry lemonade. The service is also a key feature, often described as "friendly and accommodating." This combination of high-quality food, fast service, and a welcoming atmosphere makes Moonstruck Eatery a beloved spot for both locals and tourists. It's a place where you feel immediately comfortable, and the variety ensures that you can come back again and again to try something new without ever being disappointed.

Situated at 250 E 58th St, New York, NY 10022, Moonstruck Eatery benefits from its prime location in the Midtown East neighborhood. It is easily accessible from all parts of the city, making it a convenient destination for a wide range of patrons. The restaurant is a short walk from major subway lines, including the 4, 5, 6, N, Q, R, and W trains, which makes it an ideal spot for a pre-theater dinner, a post-work meal, or a weekend brunch. Its proximity to landmarks such as the Queensboro Bridge, Bloomingdale's, and the offices around Lexington and Third Avenues ensures a steady flow of customers throughout the day.

The accessibility extends to a variety of service options, including no-contact delivery and standard delivery, which are essential for a city that thrives on convenience. For those who prefer to dine in, the restaurant offers a cozy and comfortable space with ample seating. The location is also noted for being wheelchair accessible, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and seating, which is a significant amenity for a New York restaurant. The blend of a central, highly-accessible location with practical service options makes Moonstruck Eatery a reliable and easy choice for anyone in the area looking for a great meal.

Services Offered:

No-contact delivery: A convenient and safe option for getting your favorite comfort food delivered.
Delivery: A reliable way to have a wide variety of meals brought to your home or office.
Takeout: Perfect for a quick and satisfying meal on the go.
Dine-in: Enjoy a full, sit-down meal in a cozy and classic diner setting.
Table Service: Guests can expect friendly and accommodating table service for a relaxed dining experience.

Features / Highlights:

Vast Menu Selection: From classic diner fare like omelettes and burgers to New American entrees and a full list of desserts, the menu offers something for every taste and craving.
All-Day Dining: Serving breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner, Moonstruck Eatery is a reliable spot for a meal at any time of day, including late-night.
Great Dessert Highlight: The dessert menu, particularly the pies and hot chocolate, is a major highlight and a strong draw for customers.
Fast and Friendly Service: The restaurant is known for its efficient service and accommodating staff, making for a pleasant dining experience.
Casual and Cozy Atmosphere: The vibe is relaxed and inviting, perfect for a no-fuss meal and comfortable for all types of groups, from solo diners to families.
Kid-Friendly Amenities: With high chairs and a menu that appeals to children, Moonstruck Eatery is a great choice for family dining.

Contact Information:

Address: 250 E 58th St, New York, NY 10022, USA

Phone: (212) 752-1711

What is worth choosing:

Choosing Moonstruck Eatery is a decision for a classic, no-fail New York dining experience. The primary reason to visit is its ability to serve a wide-ranging menu with a level of quality and consistency that is rare for a diner. Whether you're in the mood for a savory egg dish, a hearty burger, or a rich slice of cheesecake, Moonstruck delivers. The customer reviews, which highlight the quality of the food and the friendliness of the staff, are a testament to this fact. For a city dweller, having a go-to diner that you can count on for a good meal is invaluable, and Moonstruck Eatery has clearly earned this reputation.

Beyond the food, the overall experience is what makes it a standout choice. The atmosphere is authentically cozy and unpretentious, providing a comfortable escape from the frenetic energy of Midtown. The fact that it is popular for solo dining speaks to its welcoming nature. Its fast service is a huge bonus, ensuring that even on a tight schedule, you can enjoy a full, delicious meal. The combination of its reliable food, excellent service, and ideal location makes Moonstruck Eatery a truly worthy choice. It’s a place that feels like a cherished local secret, even as it sits in the middle of one of the world's busiest cities. It's a place where you can find a piece of classic New York, and that in itself is a reason to choose it.

Moonstruck Eatery Menu

Soups
Beef Barley Soup $6.00
Chicken Orzo Soup $6.00
Minestrone Soup $6.00
Bowl Of Chili $9.00
Yankee Bean Soup $6.00
Chicken Noodle Soup $6.00
Chicken & Rice $6.00
Split Pea Soup $6.00
Lentil Soup $6.00
Cream Of Turkey Soup $6.00
Chicken Pasta Soup $6.00
Chicken Rice Soup $6.00
Matzah Ball Soup $6.50
Manhattan Clam Chowder $6.00
Onion Soup Gratinee $7.00

Breakfast
Low Fat Yogurt Parfait $12.00
Fage yogurt, granola, honey, fresh fruit.
ILLY Cappuccino $5.50
Hot or iced.
Decaf $3.00
Tea $3.00
Fruit Salad $7.00
Assorted Juices $3.50
Fresh squeezed orange, apple, tomato, grapefruit, pineapple, cranberry.
ILLY Latte $5.50
Hot or iced.
Bagel Special $20.00
lox / cream cheese / lettuce / tomatoes onions / olives / cucumbers / capers
ILLY Double Espresso $5.00
Hot Chocolate $3.25
Oatmeal $6.00
Made to order. Add fruit for additional cost.
Coffee $3.00
Cold Brew $4.00
Seasonal Berries $7.00

Shakes
Vanilla Shake $8.00
Strawberry Shake $8.00
Strawberry Chocolate Chip Shake $9.00
Strawberry / crushed chocolate chips
Banana Chocolate Shake $9.00
Banana and chocolate ice cream.
Cookie & Cream Shake $9.00
Vanilla crushed Oreos.
Chocolate Shake $8.00
M&M's Shake $9.00
Vanilla /chocolate syrup / crushed m & m's
Reese's Shake $9.00
Vanilla / chocolate syrup / peanut butter cups

Entrees
Oven Roasted Chicken $28.00
Half roasted chicken, potato or rice and choice of vegetable. Served with soup or mixed greens.
Sesame Teriyaki Salmon $32.00
Rice, sauteed broccoli and carrots. Served with soup or mixed greens.
Skirt Steak 16 Oz. $32.00
Served with potato or rice and choice of vegetable. Served with soup or mixed greens.
Canadian Grilled Salmon $32.00
Served with potato or rice and choice of vegetable. Served with soup or mixed greens.
Chicken Parmigiana $28.00
Panko chicken cutlet, spaghetti and marinara sauce. Served with soup or mixed greens.
Chicken Francaise $28.00
Sauteed chicken, dill butter wine sauce, rice or potato and choice of vegetable. Served with soup or mixed greens.
Shrimp Scampi $30.00
Served with soup or mixed greens.
Filet Picatta $28.00
Sauteed filet, dill wine sauce, capers, mushrooms, potato or rice and choice of vegetable. Served with soup or mixed greens.
T-Bone Steak 16 Oz. $33.00
Served with potato or rice and choice of vegetable. Served with soup or mixed greens.
Garlic Chicken $28.00
Sauteed chicken, fresh garlic, mushrooms, rice or potato and choice of vegetable. Served with soup or mixed greens.
Chicken Mexicana $28.00
Sauteed chicken, poblano chili peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, served with potato or rice and choice of vegetable. Served with soup or mixed greens.

Desserts
New York Sundae $10.00
Ice cream / caramelized walnuts / whipped cream / chocolate syrup. Add banana for additional cost.
Manhattan Truffle $8.00
Vanilla and chocolate ice cream / cherry and almond center enrobed in chocolate
Amaretto Truffle $8.00
Amaretto ice cream /rolled in almonds and chocolate
Brownie Lava Cake $8.00
Fried Oreos $10.00
Carrot Cake $8.00
Cookies & Cream Truffle $8.00
Enrobed in dark chocolate
Assorted Fruit Pies $7.00
Chocolate Mousse $8.00
New York Cheese Cake $8.00
Homemade Rice Pudding $7.00
Tiramisu $8.00
Two Scoops Of Ice Cream $6.00

Beverages
Bottled Water $2.50
Snapple $3.00
Strawberry Lemonade $5.00
Soda $3.00
Iced Tea $4.00
Pellegrino $4.00
16.9oz Pellegrino water.
Raspberry Lemonade $5.00
Chocolate Milk $5.00
Arnold Palmer $5.00
Milk $5.00
Fresh Lemonade $5.00

Pasta
Three-Cheese Pasta $21.00
Romano / mozzarella / gruyere
Capellini $21.00
Sauteed fresh vegetables / olive oil / garlic
Northwest $22.00
Sautéed mushrooms / onions peppers / andouille sausage / garlic
Calamari Fra Diavolo $23.00
Olive oil / garlic / chili sauce cherry tomatoes
Alfredo $21.00
Cream sauce / romano cheese
A La Vodka $21.00
Vodka sauce
Bolognese $23.00
Homemade meat sauce
Five-Cheese Ravioli $21.00
Mixed cheeses

Appetizers
Guacamole & Chips $14.00
Bacon Cheese Fries $11.00
Buffalo Chicken Fingers $13.00
House Made Buffalo Wings $14.00
Truffle Fries $9.00
Truffle oil and parmesan cheese.
Fiesta Nachos $16.00
Tortilla chips, housemade chili, jalapeno peppers, cheddar cheese, diced lettuce and tomatoes.
Greek Fries $10.00
Crumbled feta and oregano.
Mac & Cheese $13.00
Grand Fried Calamari $16.00
Served with marinara sauce.
Panko Chicken Fingers $13.00
Mozzarella Sticks $13.00
Served with marinara sauce.

Salads
Salmon Nicoise Salad $24.00
Arugula, artichoke hearts, cherry tomatoes, olives, capers, red onions, salmon and honey mustard vinaigrette.
Crispy Chicken Salad $22.00
Arugula, sliced mandarins, toasted almonds, dried cranberries and mango vinaigrette.
Greek Salad $19.00
Mixed greens, cucumber, tomatoes, red onion, mixed peppers, grape leaves, olives and feta cheese.
Caprese Salad $15.00
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, olives and capers.
Baby Spinach Salad $18.00
Baby spinach, bacon, goat cheese, dried cranberries and walnuts.
Quinoa Salad $16.00
Quinoa, cherry tomato, scallions, parsley, roasted red peppers and lemon dressing.
Red Beet Salad $19.00
Baby arugula, fried goat cheese, toasted pumpkin seeds, citrus vinaigrette and balsamic drizzle.
Arugula Salad $17.00
Arugula, radicchio, red onion, tomatoes and roasted peppers.
Cobb Salad $19.00
Mixed greens, avocado, bacon, tomatoes, cucumber, egg, bleu cheese and granny smith apple.
Fandango Salad $19.00
Mixed greens, walnuts, roasted peppers, dried cranberries, bleu cheese, granny smith apple and raspberry vinaigrette.
Baby Kale Salad $18.00
Baby kale, parmesan, dried cranberries, raisins, almonds and honey mustard vinaigrette.
House Salad $16.00
Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumber, olives, peppers and onions.
Caesar Salad $17.00
Romaine or baby kale, garlic roasted croutons, creamy Caesar dressing and Romano cheese.

Specialty Sandwiches
New York Cheese Steak Sandwich $22.00
Skirt steak, cheddar cheese, caramelized onions and mixed peppers. Served with French fries or mixed greens.
Willshire Sandwich $20.00
Grilled chicken, avocado, bacon and muenster cheese. Served with French fries or mixed greens.
Bbq Pork Sandwich $20.00
Fresh roasted pork, smothered in Bbq sauce, topped with coleslaw and garlic toasted bun. Served with French fries or mixed greens.
Cuban Sandwich $20.00
Fresh roasted pork, ham, swiss, pickles and mustard. Served with French fries or mixed greens.
Greek Sandwich $20.00
Grilled chicken, mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, green peppers and feta cheese.
California Sandwich $20.00
Grilled chicken, mixed greens, avocado, bacon, red onion and blue cheese.
Caesar Sandwich $20.00
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, garlic roasted croutons, Romano cheese and creamy Caesar dressing. Served with French fries or mixed greens.
Lord Johns Sandwich $20.00
Grilled chicken, mozzarella, grilled onions, mushrooms and peppers. Served with French fries or mixed greens.
Chicken Pesto Sandwich $20.00
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, arugula and pesto sauce. Served with French fries or mixed greens.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich $20.00
Panko chicken cutlet, bacon, tomato, iceberg lettuce, buffalo sauce and bleu cheese. Served with French fries or mixed greens.
Veggie Sandwich $18.00
Grilled zucchini, portobello mushrooms, avocado and caramelized onions. Served with French fries or mixed greens.

Sides
Fresh Cut French Fries $7.00
Sweet Potato Fries $8.00
Baked Potato $5.00
White or sweet.
Rice $6.00
Vegetable $8.00
Sauteed or steamed.
Mashed Potato & Gravy $6.00
Onion Rings $8.00
Waffle Fries $8.00

Breakfast Sides
Bagel With Cream Cheese $4.00
Herb Roasted Potatoes $6.00
Turkey Sausage $7.00
Sausage $7.00
Turkey Bacon $7.00
Ham $7.00
Bacon $7.00

Eggs
Eggs Benedict $19.00
Add smoked salmon for an additional cost.
Omelettes $10.00
Add bacon / ham / sausage / turkey sausage / turkey bacon / Canadian bacon / spinach / onions / avocado / broccoli / mushrooms / tomatoes / pepper jack / bleu / feta / American / mozzarella / Swiss / cheddar / gruyere for additional cost.
Steak & Eggs $24.00
10 oz angus skirt steak.
Norway Omelette $21.00
Smoked salmon / scallions / spinach / cream cheese.
The Breakfast Wrap $17.00
Scrambled eggs / bacon / chili / onions / cheddar mix.
Two Eggs $10.00
Add bacon / ham / sausage / turkey sausage / turkey bacon / Canadian bacon for additional cost.
Avocado Toast $19.00
Multigrain toast/avocado spread / red chili flakes / diced tomato / two eggs / bacon. Add smoked salmon for an additional cost.
The Western Quesadilla $17.00
Scrambled eggs / ham / peppers / onions / cheddar mix.

Burgers
Patty Melt $16.00
Grilled cheese, burger and sautéed onions.
Turkey Burger $14.00
Fried ground turkey and fresh herbs.
Wyoming Burger $16.00
Haystack onions, Bbq sauce, bacon and provolone.
Chicken Burger $14.00
Fresh ground chicken, fresh mozzarella, fresh herbs and sun-dried tomato pesto aioli.
Hawaiian Burger $16.00
Grilled pineapple, gruyere cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion and teriyaki glaze.
Signature Burger $16.00
Provolone, arugula, avocado and truffle mayo.
New Yorker Burger $16.00
Fried egg, bacon and American cheese.
Classic Burger $13.00
Lettuce, tomato and red onion.
Salmon Burger $17.00
Fresh ground salmon, avocado, grilled tomato, caramelized onions and cilantro aioli.

Egg Sandwich
2 Eggs Sandwich $5.00

The Classics
Chicken Quesadilla $24.00
Grilled chicken, cheddar mix, jalapenos and French fries.
B.L.T $10.00
Beef Gyro $20.00
Pita bread, Greek salad and French fries.
Fresh Roasted Turkey $11.00
Grilled Chicken Sandwich $12.00
Chicken Salad $11.00
Tuna Salad $11.00
Reuben $20.00
Corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese, rye bread and French fries.
Rustic Grilled Cheese $9.00
Chicken Parm $20.00
Panko cutlet, mozzarella cheese, housemade marinara and French fries.
Turkey Club $20.00
Fresh roasted turkey, lettuce, tomato, bacon, mayo and fresh cut French fries.
Chicken Souvlaki $22.00
Pita bread, Greek salad and French fries.
Homemade Spinach Pie $20.00
Served with tossed or Greek salad.
Grilled Chicken Club $20.00
Grilled chicken, American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.

Griddle
Peanut Butter Banana Pancakes $17.00
Includes coffee or tea and juice.
French Toast $13.00
Add two eggs / bacon / ham / sausage / turkey sausage / turkey bacon / canadian bacon for additional charges.
Nutella French Toast & Berries $18.00
Includes coffee or tea and juice.
Banana Chocolate Chip Pancakes $17.00
Includes coffee or tea and juice.
Nutella Smores Waffle $17.00
Nutella, crushed graham crackers and roasted marshmallows.
Buttermilk Pancakes $13.00
Breakfast Of Kings $19.00
Choice of French toast, waffles or pancakes, two eggs, bacon, ham and sausage.
French Toast Crunch $16.00
Coated with cinnamon toast crunch.
Waffles $13.00
Add two eggs / bacon / ham / sausage / turkey sausage / turkey bacon / canadian bacon for additional charges.
Fried Chicken & Waffles $19.00
Includes coffee or tea and juice.

Moonstruck Eatery Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great dessert

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Coffee
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Wine

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Checks
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs

Moonstruck Eatery Photos

Moonstruck Eatery Location

Moonstruck Eatery

New York New York County New York East 58th Street

250 E 58th St, New York, NY 10022, USA

Moonstruck Eatery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.1 from 497 user reviews.

pricesbreakfastbrunchturkeyareaavocado toastdeliverybathroomgyrosalmon

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Small but great diner experience. The three times I’ve been here now, the BF has had the gyro twice and Caesar salad with chicken, I’ve had one of the veggie omelettes and the salmon burger, twice.He enjoyed both. I liked the omelette a lot and love the salmon burger. Their raspberry lemonade is amazing. Same guy has been our waiter each time and he’s very friendly and accommodating. The desserts look amazing but we haven’t tried them yet.
August 14 · Brette Grice
Best hot chocolate and pie in NYC hands down. High quality, exceptional service and much lower prices than the inferior tourist or franchised venues. I even got a free music show. If you're going to RI make sure you pop in.
December 24 · Ernie Zibert
At first I was skeptical, but after... I've had a great experience. It's a cute clean place. The down fall of it tho is that the bathroom was entirely too small and smelled funny, but other than that everything was great. Their rice pudding was to die for. I will return in the near future.🙂
August 13 · LITE MARTINI
Beautiful experience on a semi rainy day! Excellent service with the nicest staff! Delicious breakfast and strawberry lemonade!! Don't skip those truffle fries!! 😋
July 27 · Jazz Luna
Made a reservation online via Google assistant and did not have to wait on a Saturday at 11. Their coffee was just okay but their service was attentive to get our orders and food came decently fast. My sister did not enjoy the chicken soup bc it tasted really sour/tasted off and stopped eating it 2 bites in. I ordered the breakfast wrap which did not have much flavor! I ordered the fries well done and they had three perfect crunch and saltiness! My friends really enjoyed their breakfast sandwiches!
December 21 · Steph W