Newfangled Kitchen

- 2258 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209

---

For those in Ohio seeking a sandwich experience that goes beyond the ordinary, Newfangled Kitchen in Bexley offers a delightful and distinct culinary adventure. This charming sandwich shop has carved out a unique niche, specializing in inventive and comforting sandwiches that consistently earn rave reviews from locals. It's a place where classic flavors meet creative twists, all served with a side of quirky charm.

Newfangled Kitchen is particularly celebrated for its meatloaf sandwiches, a beloved staple that has garnered a cult following and even earned the establishment national recognition. However, their menu extends far beyond this signature item, featuring a diverse array of hot, cold, and classic deli sandwiches, as well as fresh salads and unique sides. The philosophy here is rooted in serving high-quality, flavorful food with genuine hospitality, creating a memorable experience for every customer. What truly sets Newfangled Kitchen apart for Ohio patrons is its commitment to bold flavors, generous portions, and a nostalgic, unpretentious vibe that makes every visit feel like a special discovery, solidifying its reputation as a top-tier sandwich destination in the Columbus area.

---

Newfangled Kitchen is conveniently situated at 2258 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209, USA, placing it in a prime and easily accessible location within the charming community of Bexley. East Main Street is a central thoroughfare, ensuring that the shop is straightforward to find for residents throughout Columbus and the wider Ohio region, whether they are navigating by car or utilizing local transportation.

While the establishment operates primarily as a carry-out-only experience with no indoor seating, it does offer "limited outdoor seating" for those who wish to enjoy their meal on-site during pleasant weather. Parking in the area, being on a main street, typically involves street parking or potentially nearby public lots. As some customers note, finding a spot might sometimes require a little effort, but the overall accessibility remains good. The location in a "charming, walkable area" of Bexley, surrounded by other shops and businesses, further enhances its appeal, allowing locals to easily incorporate a visit to Newfangled Kitchen into their daily routines or leisurely outings in the vibrant Columbus community.

---

• Specialty Meatloaf Sandwiches: A signature offering with a variety of meatloaf sandwich creations, including "The Fang," "Lucifer's Hammer," "Swiss'shroom Melt," and the "Meatloaf Reuben," available hot or chilled.
• Hot & Grilled Sandwiches: A selection of cooked-to-order sandwiches such as "Shipyard Tuna Melt," "Georgia Reuben," "N.K. Reuben" (corned beef), "The Big Deal" (grilled bologna), and various chicken sandwiches.
• Cold Sandwiches: Classic cold options like "Chatty Kathy" (chicken salad), "Barnyard Caviar" (egg salad), and "High Five" (ham, turkey, bacon).
• Classic Deli Sandwiches: Traditional turkey, ham, chicken salad, tuna salad, corned beef, and egg salad sandwiches.
• Vegetarian Options: Includes the "Bella Donna" (portabellas, roasted red pepper, spinach, mozzarella) and "Low Country Grilled Cheese," along with vegetarian salads.
• Salads: Various fresh salads like "Pecan Dijon," "Tuna Nicoise," "Garden Salad," and "Asian Salad," with options to add protein.
• Sides: A selection of comforting sides including Dill Pickle Potato Salad, Cole Slaw, and Soft Pretzels with Pimento Cheese.
• Unique Beverages: Offers a rotating selection of interesting sodas, such as strawberry habanero and prickly pear, alongside standard options.
• Desserts: Features unique sweet treats like their Chocolate Kettle Chip Cookie.
• Carry-Out Only: The primary service model is takeout, with convenient counter ordering.
• Outdoor Seating: Limited outdoor tables are available for those who prefer to eat on-site.
• Online Ordering & Delivery: Available through various platforms (e.g., DoorDash, Uber Eats) for convenient home or office delivery.
• Gluten-Free Bread: Gluten-free bread options are available for most sandwiches (note: meatloaf itself is not gluten-free).

---

• Award-Winning Sandwiches: Consistently praised as one of the best sandwich shops in Ohio, and recognized nationally (e.g., on Yelp's Top 100 Sandwiches list), particularly for their meatloaf creations.
• Signature Meatloaf Sandwiches: The star of the show, featuring thick-cut, house-made meatloaf prepared in various innovative ways, from classic to spicy melts.
• Quirky & Nostalgic Atmosphere: A charming, relaxed vibe with unique elements like retro black and white wallpaper and a vintage vending machine selling VCR tapes and CDs, adding to the fun experience.
• Creative and Delicious Menu: Beyond meatloaf, the menu offers a diverse range of hot, cold, and classic deli sandwiches, with inventive flavor combinations and often praised for their freshness and taste (e.g., "fantastic" tuna melt, "delicious" Funky Chicken special).
• Friendly and Attentive Service: Customers frequently compliment the staff for being "friendly and timely," contributing to a positive overall experience.
• Unique Side Offerings: Alongside traditional sides, they offer distinct items like dill pickle potato salad and soft pretzels with homemade pimento cheese.
• Specialty Sodas: A selection of uncommon and highly-rated sodas (e.g., strawberry habanero, prickly pear) that provide a refreshing complement to the sandwiches.
• Commitment to Quality: Emphasizes high-quality ingredients and a dedication to making food with "love and sincerity," which is evident in the taste and preparation.
• Gluten-Free Options: Offers gluten-free bread, accommodating those with dietary sensitivities, making their delicious sandwiches accessible to more patrons.

---

For those in Ohio eager to experience the unique and highly praised sandwiches from Newfangled Kitchen in Bexley, you can reach them through the following contact details:

Address: 2258 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209, USA

Phone: (614) 817-1099

For direct mobile contact or alternative direct dialing, you can also use: +1 614-817-1099. These contact options provide convenient ways for customers in the Ohio area to connect with Newfangled Kitchen for inquiries, to place an order for pickup, or to learn more about their unique menu.

---

For the discerning residents of Ohio, especially within the Bexley and greater Columbus area, Newfangled Kitchen at 2258 E Main St stands out as an exceptionally suitable and highly recommended destination for a sandwich experience unlike any other. This establishment's distinct approach to classic comfort food, combined with its quirky charm, perfectly aligns with the local desire for unique, high-quality, and memorable dining experiences.

The primary appeal for Ohio locals lies in Newfangled Kitchen's celebrated menu, particularly its renowned meatloaf sandwiches. These aren't just ordinary sandwiches; they are crafted with care and creativity, earning them accolades as some of the "best sandwiches in Ohio and maybe even the world," and national recognition. This dedication to elevating a comforting classic makes it a must-try for anyone seeking bold flavors and satisfying portions. Beyond the meatloaf, the consistent praise for items like the tuna melt and daily specials such as the "Funky Chicken" underscores the broad appeal and quality across the menu.

Furthermore, the unique and nostalgic atmosphere, complete with vintage vending machines and quirky decor, adds a layer of charm that enhances the overall experience. While it's primarily a carry-out establishment with limited outdoor seating, this streamlined model caters perfectly to the fast-paced lives of many Ohioans who desire high-quality food quickly. The friendly and efficient service, as noted by numerous customers, ensures a pleasant interaction with every visit.

Although the price point for some items might be slightly higher than generic fast-food options, the value is perceived to be high due to the quality of ingredients, generous portions, and the unique culinary creations. For Ohio locals who appreciate creative, thoughtfully prepared sandwiches, a quirky ambiance, and a commitment to genuine hospitality, Newfangled Kitchen provides an unparalleled option. It’s a place that consistently delivers on its promise of deliciousness and uniqueness, making it a beloved and frequently revisited spot in the heart of Bexley.

Newfangled Kitchen

2258 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209, USA