O'Toole's Way: Your Premier Bar & Grill in Hudson Yards

O'Toole's Way Introduce

Nestled in the heart of New York City’s dynamic Hudson Yards neighborhood, O'Toole's Way offers a vibrant escape from the everyday hustle. This isn't your typical pub; it’s an elevated bar and grill that masterfully blends traditional Irish comfort with modern American culinary flair. Located just steps from the High Line and Javits Center, O'Toole's Way has quickly become a local favorite for its unexpectedly delicious food, lively atmosphere, and genuinely friendly service.

The moment you step inside, you'll be greeted by an airy, high-ceilinged space with an interior that balances cozy charm and trendy design. Exposed brick walls and beautiful floor tiling create a welcoming ambiance that makes it perfect for a casual lunch, a lively dinner, or a celebratory gathering. The restaurant’s "unexpected" quality is a common theme among reviews—patrons who might assume a simple pub atmosphere are pleasantly surprised by the high-quality, inventive, and flavorful dishes on the menu.

O'Toole's Way is a true neighborhood tavern, a spot where everyone feels at home. Whether you’re a local grabbing a beer after work, a tourist exploring the city's West Side, or a family looking for a satisfying meal, the restaurant caters to all. Its reputation for having "surprisingly good food" is well-earned, with a menu that goes far beyond standard bar fare. From signature cocktails to a wide selection of beer and wine, O'Toole's Way is the perfect destination for any occasion, ensuring an unforgettable dining experience.

Location and Accessibility

O'Toole's Way is ideally located at 518 W 30th St, New York, NY 10001, USA. Its position in the Hudson Yards area makes it a convenient and sought-after destination. This is a particularly great spot if you’re attending an event at the Javits Center or exploring the High Line and Hudson Yards attractions.

The restaurant is easily accessible for all. It features a wheelchair accessible entrance, restroom, and seating, demonstrating a commitment to welcoming every guest. For those driving, paid parking lots are available nearby, a valuable amenity in this busy part of the city. The multi-level layout includes two floors of indoor and outdoor seating, with a year-round terrace that overlooks the High Line, providing a perfect setting to enjoy your meal with a view.

Services Offered

O'Toole's Way provides a comprehensive range of services to cater to every need, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable experience for all guests.

Dine-in: Enjoy the full experience in the restaurant's inviting and lively atmosphere, with comfortable seating and an open kitchen concept.
Outdoor seating: The restaurant features a fantastic outdoor patio and a year-round terrace, perfect for enjoying a meal or a drink while taking in the neighborhood's urban energy. Dogs are also allowed in the outdoor seating area.
Takeout: For those on the go, the full menu is available for takeout, allowing you to enjoy O'Toole's Way's delicious food at home or at work.
Delivery: Convenient delivery service ensures you can get your favorite dishes brought right to your door.
Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, which is a great option for planning ahead, especially for groups or during peak dining hours.
Catering and Events: O'Toole's Way is an excellent venue for private events, offering spaces for everything from business dinners to wedding receptions, with a capacity for up to 220 seated guests.

Features and Highlights

O'Toole's Way sets itself apart with a number of standout features that enhance the dining and social experience.

Great Drinks: The bar offers an impressive selection of drinks, including a "great beer selection" with popular drafts like Guinness and a curated list of bottles and cans. Their creative and "amazing" cocktails, including classics like the Espresso Martini and unique creations like the High Line Julep, are a major draw.
Sports Viewing: With multiple flat-screen TVs and a dedicated sports focus, O'Toole's Way is a fantastic spot to catch a game. The atmosphere is casual and lively, making it a great place to cheer on your favorite team.
Fast and Attentive Service: Despite its popularity, the restaurant is known for its fast service and an attentive staff. Customers consistently praise the friendly and accommodating nature of the team, from the waiters to the managers.
Diverse Menu: The menu is not just expansive but also thoughtfully designed, blending Irish pub classics with modern American fare. It includes everything from small plates and salads to large entrees, bar pies, and a dedicated weekend brunch menu.
Family-Friendly and Accessible: The restaurant is great for kids, offering high chairs and a special kids' menu, and is also wheelchair accessible, creating a welcoming environment for all.

Contact Information

For more information or to make a reservation, you can contact O'Toole's Way using the following details:

Address: 518 W 30th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

Phone: (646) 558-5706

What is worth choosing?

When you visit O'Toole's Way, you’re faced with an array of delicious choices, but a few dishes and drinks consistently receive high praise from those in the know. For a true taste of the restaurant's quality, start with the small plates. The Espresso Rubbed Chicken Wings, particularly with the Buffalo sauce, are a must-try. Customers also rave about the Irish Nachos, which are a unique twist on a classic, and the "shockingly good" House Chips.

For a main course, the “Proper Fish and Chips” is a top contender, celebrated for being extra crispy and authentic. The O’Toole’s Burger is another crowd-pleaser, described as juicy and well-prepared. And for those seeking a more traditional Irish dish, the Short Rib Cottage Pie is a hearty and flavorful choice.

The bar pies are also a highlight, with the Margherita and Garden Squash pizzas earning specific mentions for their freshness and flavor. For a drink, you can't go wrong with their extensive beer list, especially a perfectly poured Guinness. If cocktails are your preference, the creative and delicious options like the Espresso Martini are highly recommended.

What truly makes O’Toole’s Way worth choosing, however, is the complete package: an inviting atmosphere, a diverse and delicious menu, and stellar service. It's a place where you can feel comfortable whether you're in a large group or dining solo, and where the quality of the food and drinks consistently exceeds expectations. The combination of a cozy setting and a vibrant, "fun and festive" crowd makes it a standout spot in Hudson Yards. It's the perfect place to grab a bite, catch a game, or simply relax with a drink.

O'Toole's Way Menu

IRISH BREAD SERVICE
HOUSE CHIPS $14.00
irish cheddar onion dip
HOUSE-MADE SODA BREAD $13.00
whipped marmite butter

SMALL PLATES
RED PEPPER HUMMUS $16.00
market vegetable crudités
IRISH CHEESE PLATE $24.00
irish cheddar - cashel bleu - gubbeen - crackers - quince - fig - pear
ESPRESSO RUBBED CHICKEN WINGS $15.00
buffalo or bourbon bbq - bleu cheese dressing - crudités
DEVILS ON HORSEBACK $12.00
dates - goat cheese - bacon - port reduction
IRISH NACHOS $15.00
house chips - cheese sauce - bacon - pickled fresnos - sour cream - scallions
SAUSAGE ROLL $16.00
hand rolled spiced irish sausage - puff pastry - hp sauce
TABLE-SIDE STEAK TARTARE $26.00
egg yolk - crostini
SIRLOIN STEAK ON TOAST $48.00
14oz ny strip - grilled, sliced - crostini - thumbit sauce

SOUPS AND SALADS
salad additions: shrimp +15 / chicken +12 / salmon +14 / steak +15
NYC BURRATA SALAD $18.00
heirloom tomato - olive oil - aged balsamic - basil
TRADITIONAL COBB $18.00
bleu cheese - egg - avocado - bacon - mkt greens - red wine vinaigrette
KALE CAESAR $19.00
parmesan - croutons - charred lime - caesar dressing
PUB SALAD $16.00
market veggies - sherry vinaigrette
THE HIGH LINE $18.00
quinoa - hummus - dried cranberry - broccoli - toasted almonds - carrot - maple dressing

BAR PIES
PROSCIUTTO $22.00
goat cheese - arugula - hot honey
GARDEN SQUASH $20.00
mozzarella - pepita pesto - parmesan
MARGHERITA $18.00
tomato - mozzarella - basil
TIER OF ALL THREE $58.00

SANDWICHES AND BURGERS
with house chips or market salad, substitute fries +4
O’TOOLE’S BURGER $25.00
american cheese - caramelized onions - burger sauce - b+b pickles - brioche bun
“DANGEROUS DAVE’S” DUBLIN DIP $34.00
shaved prime rib - irish cheddar - caramelized onions - horseradish - ciabatta - “with its own gravy”
CHICKEN CHOICE OF FRIED OR GRILLED $22.00
pickled fresno - hot honey - slaw - remoulade - brioche bun
HAM + CHEESE TOASTIE $23.00
house cured & carved ham - coleslaw - irish cheddar - toasted brioche

FOR THE TABLE
FRIES $10.00
ZUCCHINI $10.00
lemon - parmesan
GRILLED ASPARAGUS $15.00
COLCANNON $10.00
irish mashed potatoes

LARGE PLATES
FILLET OF SALMON $30.00
salsa rosa - arugula - charred lime
PROPER FISH AND CHIPS $30.00
guinness battered cod - crushed peas - tartar - salt and vinegar
GRILLED AHI TUNA $30.00
roasted tomato - black olive dressing
MUSSELS AND FRIES $28.00
irish cider - garlic - cream - lemon - parsley
SUMMER SQUASH AND CAULIFLOWER CURRY $26.00
aromatic couscous
“POTATO PASTA” RAVIOLI $24.00
spinach + goat cheese - peas - parmesan - truffle oil
BRICK CHICKEN $28.00
buttermilk caesar slaw - charred lemon - fries
SHORT RIB COTTAGE PIE $30.00
colcannon - irish cheddar
BERKSHIRE PORK CHOP $32.00
charred carrots - carrot top chimichurri - apple cider and bourbon reduction
STEAK FRITES $48.00
14oz prime ny strip - espresso rub - watercress - truffle butter - roasted garlic - fries

COCKTAILS
WET THE TEA $19.00
grey goose vodka - yuzu - honey - lavender - lemon - blue cornflower
BOOTLEGGER $19.00
ghost tequila - milagro blanco tequila - hibiscus - rockey's botanical - lime - rose salt
RATTLIN’ BOG $19.00
ilegal mezcal - chinola passion fruit - agave - turmeric
BIG TICKET $19.00
milagro tequila - chinola mango - lime - tajin
MORNIN’ DEW $19.00
hendrick’s gin - cucumber - lemon - elderflower liqueur
HIGH LINE JULEP $19.00
great jones bourbon - honey - mint - lemon - peach bitters - ginger beer

SPRITZ MENU
perfect for sippin’ on the paddy-o!
APEROL $18.00
aperol - la gioiosa prosecco - seltzer
SARACCO $18.00
saracco moscato d’asti - alb vodka - lemon - seltzer
ROSÉ $18.00
ruggeri rosé prosecco - gin - grapefruit soda - elderflower
PIMMS CUP $18.00
cucumber - mint - lemon - ginger beer

OLD FASHIONEDS
smoked +1
ANGELS ENVY $21.00
cherry bitters - demerara
PATRON REPOSADO $21.00
grapefruit - agave
MICHTER’S RYE $21.00
black walnut and peach bitters
HUDSON BRIGHT LIGHTS BIG CITY BOURBON $21.00
orange bitters

CLASSICS - THE O'TOOLE'S WAY
MANHATTAN $19.00
makers mark bourbon
NEGRONI $18.00
tanqueray
ESPRESSO MARTINI $19.00
albany vodka - cold brew - faretti coffee liqueur
IRISH ESPRESSO MARTINI $19.00
jameson whiskey - faretti coffee liqueur - cold brew
TRADITIONAL IRISH COFFEE $15.00
bushmill’s irish whiskey - coffee cream available iced or hot or try something a lil’ fancy:

LIE-BATIONS
crafted with n/a spirits less than .05% abv
ST AGRESTIS PHONY NEGRONI $15.00
AMALFI SPRITZ $16.00
lyre’s classico grande sparkling and italian spritz aperitif
SOBER WATER $10.00
cucumber-mint-lime soda pineapple-ginger fizz hibiscus lemonade

BEER - DRAUGHT
GUINNESS $11.00
stout - ireland 4.2% (20oz)
STELLA ARTOIS $10.00
lager - belgium 4.8%
SAM ADAMS SEASONAL $10.00
BLUE POINT TOASTED $10.00
lager - long island 5.5%
MODELO $10.00
lager - mexico 4.4%
KONA BIG WAVE $10.00
golden ale - hawaii 4.4%
MONTAUK JUICY $11.00
ipa - ny 6.8%
CONEY ISLAND MERMAN $10.00
ipa - ny 5.8%

BEER - BOTTLES & CANS
AMSTEL LIGHT $8.00
light lager - netherlands 3.5%
BUDWEISER $8.00
lager - st. louis, mo 5%
BUD LIGHT $8.00
light lager - st. louis, mo 4.2%
CORONA $8.00
lager - mexico 4.6%
CONEY ISLAND MERMAID $8.00
pilsner - ny 5.2%
HEINEKEN $8.00
pale lager - netherlands 5%
MICHELOB ULTRA $8.00
light lager - st. louis, mo 4.2%
MAGNERS $9.00
hard cider - ireland 4.5%
NUTRL $12.00
vodka seltzer - seasonal flavors
SUN CRUISER $12.00
vodka iced tea
SURFSIDE $12.00
vodka and lemonade
HEINEKEN 0.0 $8.00
non-alc - netherlands .05%
GUINNESS ZERO $9.00
non-alc - ireland .05% (20oz)

WINES BY THE GLASS - SPARKLING
PROSECCO
la gioiosa - italy
ROSÉ PROSECCO

WINES BY THE GLASS - ROSÉ
CHÂTEAU MARIS
france (organic)

WINES BY THE GLASS - WHITE
PINOT GRIGIO
castello di gabbiano - italy
SAUVIGNON BLANC
paul buisse - france
CHARDONNAY
potel - france
MOSCATO D’ASTI
saracco - italy

WINES BY THE GLASS - RED
PINOT NOIR
boen - california
MALBEC
finca el origen reserva estate - argentina
SUPER TUSCAN
villa puccini - italy
CABERNET SAUVIGNON
juggernaut hillside - california

WINES BY THE BOTTLE - SPARKLING
CHAMPAGNE $68.00
cremant d’alsace brut: lucien albrecht - france
CHAMPAGNE $185.00
moët & chandon brut imperial nv - france

WINES BY THE BOTTLE - WHITE
PINOT GRIGIO $65.00
terlato - italy
SAUVIGNON BLANC $65.00
white haven - new zealand
ALBARIÑO $55.00
burgans - spain
SANCERRE $70.00
mason chavet - france
CHARDONNAY $60.00
anthony road *unoaked - ny

WINES BY THE BOTTLE - RED
PINOT NOIR $80.00
annie aime - willamette valley
CHIANTI CLASSICO $65.00
collazzi bastioni - italy
SUPER TUSCAN $65.00
brancaia - italy
RED BLEND $95.00
leviathan - california
CABERNET SAUVIGNON $165.00
jordan - alexander valley
CABERNET SAUVIGNON $195.00
silver oak - alexander valley

DRINK YOUR DESSERT
GREEN STREET HOOLIGAN $19.00
pistachio liqueur - alb vodka - coffee cream - vanilla *dairy allergy
CHOCOLATE MARTINI $19.00
alb vodka - bailey’s chocolate liqueur - demerara *dairy allergy
ESPRESSO MARTINI $19.00
albany vodka - cold brew - faretti coffee liqueur
IRISH ESPRESSO MARTINI $19.00
jameson whiskey - faretti coffee liqueur - cold brew
ask about our whiskey selection

IRISH BREAD SERVICE
HOUSE CHIPS $14.00
irish cheddar onion dip
HOUSE-MADE SODA BREAD $13.00
whipped marmite butter

SMALL PLATES
TABLE-SIDE STEAK TARTARE $26.00
egg yolk - crostini
SAUSAGE ROLL $16.00
hand rolled spiced irish sausage - puff pastry - hp sauce
ESPRESSO RUBBED CHICKEN WINGS $15.00
buffalo or bourbon bbq - crudités - bleu cheese dressing
RED PEPPER HUMMUS $16.00
market vegetable crudités
DEVILS ON HORSEBACK $12.00
dates - goat cheese - bacon - port reduction

BAR PIES
add fried egg +3
PROSCIUTTO $22.00
goat cheese - arugula - hot honey
GARDEN SQUASH $20.00
mozzarella - pepita pesto - parmesan
MARGHERITA $18.00
tomato - mozzarella - basil
TIER OF ALL THREE $58.00

MORNING THINGS
HANGOVER SHORT RIB COTTAGE PIE $30.00
colcannon - irish cheddar
EGG PLATTER $18.00
two eggs any style - home fries - toasted sourdough - bacon
IRISH BREAKFAST ROLL $22.00
bacon - sausage - fried eggs - hp sauce
CHICKEN AND WAFFLE $22.00
hot honey - marmite butter
‘THE SAND HOG BREAKFAST’ $34.00
espresso rubbed grilled skirt steak - breakfast potatoes - grilled tomato - fried eggs - bt sauce
AVOCADO TOAST $14.00
smashed avocado - grilled sourdough - charred lime
EGGS BLACKSTONE $14.00
poached eggs - toasted sourdough - bacon - grilled tomato - hollandaise
BRIOCHE FRENCH TOAST $18.00
honey crisp apple & cinnamon syrup - calvados whipped cream cheese
SMOKED SALMON $24.00
guinness brown soda bread - salted butter - capers - lemon crème fraîche

SALADS
shrimp +15 / chicken +12 / salmon +14 / steak +15
TRADITIONAL COBB $18.00
bleu cheese - egg - avocado - bacon - mkt greens - red wine vinaigrette
KALE CAESAR $19.00
parmesan - charred lime - croutons - caesar dressing
PUB SALAD $16.00
market veggies - sherry vinaigrette
THE HIGH LINE $18.00
quinoa - hummus - dried cranberry - broccoli - toasted almonds - carrot - maple dressing

BRUNCH ‘TOOLE-BOX
ASK ABOUT OUR SPRITZ MENU!
PROPER IRISH COFFEE $15.00
bushmill’s irish whiskey - coffee cream ...or try something a lil’ fancy:
MIMOSA $14.00
choose your flavor: pineapple - orange - peach bellini
BLOODY MARY $17.00
vodka - house mix - tajin
IRISH ESPRESSO MARTINI $19.00
jameson irish whiskey - faretti coffee liqueur - cold brew

SANDWICHES
with house chips or a market salad substitute fries +4
O’TOOLE’S BURGER $24.00
american cheese - caramelized onions - burger sauce - b+b pickles - toasted brioche
“DANGEROUS DAVE’S” DUBLIN DIP $32.00
shaved prime rib - irish cheddar - caramelized onions - horseradish - ciabatta - “with its own gravy”
FRIED OR GRILLED CHICKEN $22.00
pickled fresno - hot honey - slaw - remoulade - brioche bun
HAM AND CHEESE TOASTIE $23.00
house cured & carved - irish cheddar - coleslaw - toasted brioche

FOR THE TABLE
FRIES $10.00
HOME FRIES $9.00
BACON $9.00
TOAST $8.00
sourdough or guinness brown soda bread marmite butter

BRUNCH
served saturdays and sundays. for kids 12 and under
"I DON'T KNOW" $10.00
pancakes, berries, maple syrup
"I DON'T CARE" $10.00
scrambled eggs, tater tots, bacon

LUNCH + DINNER
for kids 12 and under. with fries or tomato + cucumber salad
"I'M NOT HUNGRY" $10.00
chicken fingers
"I DON'T WANT THAT" $10.00
grilled cheese
"WHATEVER" $10.00
cheeseburger
"FINE" $10.00
mac + cheese

PUDDINGS
BROWN BUTTER CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE SKILLET $13.00
vanilla ice cream - jameson whiskey salted caramel
DANGEROUS DAVE’S KEY LIME PIE $10.00
toasted coconut - chantilly cream
PAVLOVA $10.00
mixed berries - vanilla cream

AFTER DINNER DRINKS
ask about our whiskey collection
ESPRESSO MARTINI $19.00
albany vodka - faretti coffee liqueur - cold brew
IRISH COFFEE $15.00
hot or iced - bushmill’s irish whiskey - coffee cream
CHOCOLATE MARTINI $19.00
alb vodka - bailey’s chocolate liqueur - demerara *dairy allergy
GREEN STREET HOOLIGAN $19.00
pistachio liqueur - alb vodka - coffee cream - vanilla

COFFEE AND TEA
COFFEE $5.00
decaf available
ASSORTED TEAS $4.00
ESPRESSO $5.00
CAPPUCCINO $6.00
LATTE $6.00

O'Toole's Way Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Sports

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Hard liquor
Late-night food
Small plates
Wine

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Groups
Tourists

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Paid parking lot

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

O'Toole's Way Photos

O'Toole's Way Location

O'Toole's Way

New York New York County New York West 30th Street

518 W 30th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

O'Toole's Way Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 357 user reviews.

bartenderburgermusicguinnessdipfish and chipswalkingserverold fashionedsitting

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Unexpected result. Attending NY Auto show with friends and we needed a rendezvous spot. Heard the name OToole's and snobbish-ly (?) assumed it would be a run down dump on 11th Ave. I couldnt have been more wrong. Airy, high ceilings, interesting architecture, good music, but most important, lovely staff and surprisingly good food. Shout out to Gabriella for recommendations, kudos to the chef for serving up delicious food. We went in blind on dirty fries. Shockingly good. Annihilated the chips and dip, needing a second set of chips. Chicken Wings (Buffalo sauce) are juicy and sauce is spot on. If you find yourself near Javits Center or Hudson Yards and need a spot, highly recommend. Also appears to be great for families and kids.
April 19 · Jamie King
Pizza fresh out of oven delish.Steak on grassini toast tasty. Sauce also appropriate.Extra crispy fish and normal fries chips.Slider with onion rings very good.Proper food as advertised. Not as much fan for potato. Nacho good.Service attentive. Manager checking-up.Nice bar scene. Sports watchable.
July 29 · Sam Hahn
Food was fine but there was nothing memorable or special. The price felt reasonable compared to Little Spain across the street, which I always consider expensive. The service was a little slow, with no host to be found until we eventually tried to seat ourselves.
March 24 · A Shen
My friend and I have eaten at O'Toole's many times and always had a great experience. But the true test of a restaurant is when something isn't perfect. This happened on our most recent visit. Our fried fish batter was overly salty. I am actually glad it occurred because the staff was a text book example of handling the feedback in exactly the right way.Our server, Andrew, immediately apologized and offered to replace both entrees. We declined but really appreciated his offer.Shortly afterwards, the Manager, Kelly, came over to tell us that we were correct: the batter had been over salted. They discarded it and made a fresh batch. Both Kelly and Andrew again apologized, gave us a complimentary order of fish to take home as well a complimentary dessert (delicious! )Their response was so gracious they have won us as loyal customers.BTW, the food is delicious and highly recommended.One additional note: the response by Kelly and Andrew is a good reason why diners should always quietly approach staff and give them a chance to make things right rather than rushing on line to criticize a small mistake.
August 16 · jlandis10
10/10 Everyone was so nice and welcoming. The server made me smile and laugh so hard. She’s so lovely, definitely will come back for her.( should have wage raised 100%). Tried to take a picture of the pizza we ordered, but I couldn’t stop myself…🤤
June 04 · Andrea Posadas