Discover Over The Counter: Your Modern American Eatery in Worthington, OH

Over The Counter Photos

Over The Counter Introduce

For those in the Columbus area, particularly in Worthington, seeking a spot that blends classic American comfort food with a modern diner vibe, Over The Counter is a name that often comes up. Located conveniently on North High Street, this American restaurant aims to provide a lively and welcoming atmosphere for all its guests. While individual experiences can vary, Over The Counter is recognized in the community for offering a diverse menu that caters to different tastes, from hearty brunch options to satisfying burgers and sandwiches.

Over The Counter endeavors to be a go-to spot for locals looking for a relaxed meal. The restaurant has garnered attention for its efforts to create a clean and vibrant environment where patrons can enjoy their food. With a menu that spans traditional breakfast and brunch items to lunch and dinner favorites, it strives to offer something for every craving throughout the day. While some customer experiences highlight areas for improvement in service consistency and food quality, many others have lauded its delicious offerings and the overall positive atmosphere, especially during busy times like Sunday brunch. It's a place that, when hitting its stride, provides a truly enjoyable dining experience for the Worthington community.

---

Over The Counter is strategically located at 5596 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085, USA. This address places it squarely on North High Street, a primary thoroughfare that runs through Worthington, making it highly accessible for residents within the community and those traveling from adjacent areas of Columbus. Its prominent location ensures that it is easy to find and reach.

Accessibility is a key advantage for Over The Counter. For those driving, the restaurant is situated within a strip mall, which typically offers parking. While the main lot can get crowded during peak hours, particularly on busy brunch mornings, there are often additional parking options available on nearby side streets, alleviating potential concerns. This convenience allows patrons to easily integrate a visit to Over The Counter into their daily routines or weekend plans. The restaurant's presence on such a well-known street also means it's often close to other local businesses and attractions in Worthington, making it a convenient stop before or after other activities in the area. The easily identifiable location invites diners in for a taste of their modern American fare.

---

Over The Counter aims to provide a comprehensive dining experience with a variety of services to meet customer needs.

Dine-In Service: The restaurant offers indoor dining with both high tables (some with bench seating) and a bar area with plenty of seats and televisions. It is designed to accommodate various group sizes.
Brunch Service: A significant focus is on their popular brunch, available on Saturdays and Sundays from 10 AM to 2 PM, featuring classic breakfast and lunch items.
Lunch and Dinner Service: Beyond brunch, Over The Counter serves lunch and dinner Tuesday through Saturday from 11 AM, offering a wide array of sandwiches, salads, soups, and larger entrees.
Outdoor Dining: A patio area with umbrellas is available for outdoor seating, weather permitting, providing an alternative dining environment.
Takeout: Customers can place orders for carry-out, allowing them to enjoy their meals at home. Online ordering is available through platforms like Toast.
Delivery Services: For added convenience, Over The Counter partners with third-party delivery services such as Uber Eats, enabling delivery to specific areas in Worthington.
Happy Hour: A happy hour is offered Monday through Friday from 3 PM to 6 PM, appealing to those looking for post-work drinks and appetizers.
Full Bar Service: The restaurant features a well-stocked bar, offering a range of alcoholic beverages including cocktails, beer, and wine (with carry-out options for state minimum wine & beer).

---

Over The Counter presents several features and highlights that are often praised by its patrons, contributing to its appeal in the Worthington dining scene:

Lively Atmosphere: Many customers describe the atmosphere as "lively," indicating a vibrant and energetic environment that enhances the dining experience, particularly during busy brunch hours.
Popular Brunch Spot: Over The Counter is considered a "great spot for brunch," with many diners specifically coming in on busy weekend mornings for their breakfast offerings like the OTC breakfast and creative takes on eggs benedict.
Clean Restaurant Environment: Reviewers note that the restaurant is "clean," which contributes significantly to a positive and comfortable dining experience.
Helpful and Positive Staff (Often): While experiences can vary, many customers commend the staff for being "helpful" and "friendly," suggesting a generally positive and welcoming service approach.
Diverse American Comfort Food Menu: The menu offers a wide range of American comfort food. Beyond brunch, popular items include burgers (like the "Counter Burger"), various sandwiches (Pulled Pork, Italian Chicken, Tuna Melt, Sloppy Joe), and appetizers such as fried pickles and pretzel bites with beer cheese.
Quality Ingredients: Descriptions of dishes suggest a focus on quality, with items like "house made cheese sauce" for their Mac & Cheese and "fresh cut fries with rosemary oil."
Cocktail and Drink Selection: The presence of a well-stocked bar and a variety of cocktails, including unique concoctions like the "Elderflower Martini" and "Jalapeno Pineapple Margarita," is a highlight for those seeking adult beverages.
Outdoor Patio: The small patio with umbrellas offers an appealing outdoor dining option during warmer months, providing a pleasant alternative to indoor seating.
"Modern Diner" Aesthetic: The interior combines relic decor and original flooring, creating a unique and quirky ambiance that some find special and enjoyable, distinct from a traditional diner.

---

To contact Over The Counter for inquiries, reservations, or to place an order, please use the following information:

Address: 5596 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085, USA

Phone: (614) 846-1107

---

Over The Counter in Worthington, Ohio, is well-suited for locals looking for a reliable and engaging American dining experience. Its location on the bustling North High Street makes it incredibly accessible for residents across Worthington and the surrounding Columbus area, providing a convenient option for various dining occasions, from a spontaneous lunch to a planned brunch with friends. While individual customer experiences can occasionally highlight inconsistencies, the consistent positive feedback on its lively atmosphere, cleanliness, and the deliciousness of many menu items – particularly brunch favorites and burgers – solidifies its place as a valued community establishment.

The restaurant's commitment to offering a diverse menu of elevated comfort food ensures that there's something to satisfy almost any craving, from savory breakfast platters to hearty sandwiches and salads. The option for both indoor and outdoor dining, coupled with a full bar, adds to its versatility, making it suitable for different preferences and seasons. For Worthington residents, Over The Counter provides a community hub where they can enjoy quality food, a vibrant social setting, and often, friendly service that enhances their day. It embodies the spirit of a local American eatery, making it a pertinent and appealing choice for those seeking a comforting and enjoyable meal close to home.

Over The Counter Location

Over The Counter

Ohio Franklin County Worthington Colonial Hills North High Street

5596 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085, USA

Over The Counter Reviews

We stopped in on a Saturday afternoon for lunch. We got a cup of chicken and wild rice soup, I got a pulled pork sandwich with fries, and my partner got an Italian chicken sandwich with fries. When the food came to the table both were missing the fries, so the waitress brought back two baskets of waffle fries and left. We both had high hopes for this place as most of the reviews were very positive; however, the food we got was not very good and mostly went uneaten. The soup was not hot, it was lukewarm at best. The bbq was room temperature and did not have much meat, the sauce on the side was cold like it came straight from the refrigerator. The bbq sandwich was mostly two large onion rings. The chicken sandwich was mostly lettuce and tomato.The service was pretty bad as well. We were mostly ignored, our drinks were left empty and only refilled once after the group of employees saw us looking at them. These employees were too busy eating, talking, laughing and playing on their cell phones to attend to the customers. The location was not busy during this time, there were the two of us, a gentleman sitting at the bar, a couple on the patio. The group of people sitting at the end of the bar shown in the photos were the staff and that was where they remained the entire time we were there. There was no reason for the service to have been this bad and very disappointing. Based on this experience I would not recommend this place.
Aug 02, 2025 · Alex Alford
Over the Counter is a great spot for brunch. The atmosphere is lively, the restaurant is clean and the staff is helpful. It is always busy when I come in. Came here on a busy Sunday morning, and I ordered the OTC breakfast with a Bloody Mary. Delicious. I have also had the burger here. Another great choice. It can be difficult to find parking in the main lot if it's crowded, but there's plenty other places to park around the restaurant on side streets.Thanks!
Feb 23, 2025 · Xavier Casey
Cool place! It's a bit of a retro hip diner vibe. We had the veggie appetizer, which was really good with a lighter almost a tempura like texture, which I really enjoyed. They have mostly sandwiches, wings and salads. I had the Cobb salad with french onion soup. The salad was was crisp and cold and the ranch was homemade and really good. The toppings were fresh although fairly skimpy for a Cobb salad. The french onion soup was the star. It was savory, a touch sweet, a bit tangy, had abundant nicely caramelized onions topped with a nice crusty layer of cheese and crouton. I also tried the mac and cheese and it was creamy and the noodles were perfectly cooked. It has more of a Velveeta style cheese sauce which isn't my favorite, but I would absolutely eat it again. The service was good and was clean and very reasonablely priced. I look forward to going back to see what else is good.
Nov 04, 2024 · Perro Miramas
At brunch, my corned beef hash tasted only of salt. The over-easy egg whites were runny. The “bed of potatoes” looked like the frozen sliced kind. The “toast” wasn’t toasted.I don’t know how you make an over-easy egg with runny whites. When I make eggs at home, I flip the egg, and within a couple of seconds the whites are no longer runny. Some of Over the Counter’s whites looked like snot.The other folks at my table had nice looking meals. I didn’t stick around long enough to find out if they liked them.Between the undercooked food, the hard rock music at 10 a.m., and the too-cold air conditioning, I sent back my meal, said goodbye to the group and popped gum into my mouth to get rid of the taste of salt.I was with a large group, and the server said they were short a cook, so maybe the food is normally better. Portions are large.
Jul 20, 2025 · Arlene Armstrong
First off, let me say our server was great. She was friendly, helpful, and came to check on us frequently. So in that sense, the service was as great as she could make it. Unfortunately, the food took forever -- nearly an hour for two fish sandwiches. There was a party of 12 present that apparently held up the food for the rest of the restaurant, but tables were at less than half capacity, so the one large party should not have backed up the kitchen that much.I'd been here before a few years back and remembered it having a more cute retro diner vibe with brighter lighting. Since then, it seems to have undergone more of a "bar" (sports/dive?) rebrand that I don't care for. Music was entirely too loud and made conversation difficult, which became very apparent with the long wait.We tried the Amaretto & Grand Marnier cocktail and that was great. All of their cocktails sounded good.As for the fish & chips sandwich, it comes with one piece of cod that only fills half the bun, with the rest filled in with waffle fries. It comes with a side of crisps (potato chips, not the fry-chips you're expecting), but this can be substituted for more waffle fries, which I suggest doing. You get some cole slaw, tartar sauce, and a pickle spear, but it doesn't come with any lettuce, tomato, etc. (I should've asked for some, but I was so hungry from waiting that I just did without.) Everything was too salty and my mouth still tastes like salt hours later. I'd had the same item when I visited some years ago and remembered it being one of the best fish sandwiches I'd had -- this wasn't it.I don't know if they've since changed management or something. If you're in the area and want to swing by for a cocktail or maybe a light brunch, it might be worth a visit. For dinner, I'd give it a pass.
May 24, 2025 · Gregory Wheeler