Papa Johns Pizza Photos










Papa Johns Pizza Introduce
Welcome, Ohio pizza lovers! If you're searching for a reliable and delicious pizza experience right here in Columbus, you've likely come across Papa John's Pizza. This guide is designed to give you a comprehensive overview of the Papa John's location at 1721 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, helping you understand what makes them a go-to spot for many in our community. From their commitment to quality ingredients to their convenient services, we'll delve into everything you need to know about getting your next pizza fix.
Papa John's has built a reputation on the promise of "Better Ingredients. Better Pizza." This philosophy guides their approach, aiming to deliver consistently good pizzas made with fresh, quality components. For residents of Columbus and the surrounding areas, this means access to a well-known brand that strives for a certain standard in the competitive world of pizza. Whether you're planning a family dinner, a casual night in with friends, or just craving a classic pepperoni, understanding the local Papa John's can help you make an informed decision.
Beyond just the food, a local pizza restaurant often becomes a part of the community fabric. It's a place where memories are made, from celebratory meals to quick weeknight dinners. We'll explore the practical aspects of visiting or ordering from this specific Papa John's, ensuring you have all the details at your fingertips.
The Papa John's Pizza location we're focusing on is conveniently situated at 1721 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA. This address places it within a vibrant area of Columbus, making it easily accessible for many residents across different neighborhoods. South High Street is a significant thoroughfare, ensuring that finding the restaurant, whether by car or public transport, is straightforward.
For those traveling by car, there is typically parking available, though it's always advisable to be mindful of peak hours. The location's presence on a main road means it's generally easy to spot and navigate to. If you rely on public transportation, various COTA bus routes operate in the vicinity, offering an alternative for getting to and from the restaurant. We recommend checking the latest COTA schedules and routes for the most up-to-date information.
Being centrally located in Columbus, this Papa John's serves a broad customer base, from local families and students to professionals working in the area. Its accessibility is a key factor in its appeal, allowing for convenient pick-ups or quick stops when you're on the go. The ease of access contributes significantly to its suitability as a local pizza option for residents within a reasonable radius.
- Online Ordering: Papa John's provides a robust online ordering system through their website and mobile app, allowing customers to customize their pizzas, select sides, and arrange for delivery or carryout with ease. This is a popular option for convenience and often includes special online-only deals.
- Delivery Service: For those who prefer to enjoy their pizza at home, Papa John's offers delivery services. While third-party delivery services like DoorDash may be involved, the core service is designed to bring your order directly to your doorstep. It's always good practice to confirm delivery hours and service areas when placing your order.
- Carryout/Pickup: Customers have the option to place an order online or by phone and then pick up their food directly from the restaurant. This is often a quicker option for those who live nearby or are passing by the location.
- Customizable Menu Options: Beyond traditional pizzas, Papa John's offers a wide array of customizable options, including different crust types, a variety of sauces, an extensive list of toppings, and a selection of sides like breadsticks, papadias, and desserts. This allows customers to tailor their meal to their specific preferences.
- Special Offers and Deals: Papa John's frequently provides various promotions, discounts, and special bundles. These can often be found on their website, app, or through local advertisements, offering opportunities for savings on your order.
- "Better Ingredients. Better Pizza." Philosophy: This is a core tenet of Papa John's, emphasizing their commitment to using quality ingredients, which they claim leads to a superior-tasting pizza. This includes fresh, never-frozen dough, vine-ripened tomatoes for their sauce, and quality cheese.
- Signature Garlic Sauce and Pepperoncini: Every Papa John's pizza comes with a cup of their unique garlic dipping sauce and a pepperoncini pepper, which are distinctive additions that many customers appreciate and associate with the brand.
- Consistent Brand Experience: As a national chain, Papa John's aims to provide a consistent experience across its locations. This means customers can generally expect the same menu items, quality standards, and ordering processes, regardless of which Papa John's they visit.
- Online Tracking: For online orders, Papa John's often provides an order tracker, allowing customers to monitor the progress of their pizza from preparation to delivery. This feature provides transparency and helps manage expectations regarding wait times.
- Convenient Location in Columbus: The 1721 S High St address is a key feature, offering ease of access for local residents in Columbus, particularly those on the south side and surrounding areas, making it a convenient stop for a quick meal.
Address: 1721 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA
Phone: (614) 443-7272
For residents of Columbus, Ohio, Papa John's Pizza at 1721 S High St presents a readily available and familiar option for satisfying your pizza cravings. Despite occasional service challenges noted in customer feedback, the fundamental appeal of Papa John's lies in its brand recognition and its commitment to a consistent product. When you choose Papa John's, you're generally opting for a known quantity – a pizza made with their signature fresh, never-frozen dough and vine-ripened tomato sauce, accompanied by their distinctive garlic dipping sauce and a pepperoncini.
The convenient location on South High Street makes it an accessible choice for pick-up, whether you're commuting through the area or live in a nearby neighborhood. The robust online ordering system and delivery services, while sometimes subject to the pressures of high demand or third-party logistics, offer the flexibility and convenience that modern consumers expect. This means you can often place an order with ease from the comfort of your home and have a meal delivered directly to you.
While individual experiences can vary, the overall value proposition of this Papa John's for locals is its ability to provide a quick, relatively affordable, and generally satisfying pizza experience. It's a convenient solution for busy weeknights, casual gatherings, or simply when the desire for a classic, recognizable pizza strikes. For many, Papa John's is more than just a pizza place; it's a reliable local eatery that fits seamlessly into the rhythm of daily life in Columbus, offering a consistent product with the ease of online ordering and local accessibility. It remains a viable and popular choice for many seeking a straightforward and familiar pizza option in their community.
Papa Johns Pizza Location
Papa Johns Pizza
1721 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA
Papa Johns Pizza Reviews
Ordered a pizza at 10:15pm not realizing it would be delivered by door dash. Was supposed to arrive within 40 minutes but kept getting pushed back finally was cancelled at 11:50pm. Called and the guy was incredibly rude, said door dash had my pizza, said they were closed (website and the voice recording said open til 1am on Sunday), said he was the only one working, told me if I wanted my pizza I should come make one myself, then said he was going to get the name of the GM (which I did not ask for) from someone else because he didn’t know his GM’s name, then hung up on me. I gave benefit of the doubt that it was a mistake and tried to call back twice and no one answered. I never raised my voice or said anything rude only said that I ordered through them not door dash, that their website said they were open, and that I wanted a refund. Called door dash and found out they gave the pizza to the wrong delivery driver, the correct delivery driver was willing to wait for them to remake it, and that door dash had already refunded papa John’s so I will call papa John’s corporate number I guess.
May 19, 2025 · Margaret CellarWhen you want to simply have a pizza delivered after a long day, this is not the place to go. Ordered online at 5:50, expected delivery 6:24-6:34. At 6:15 we noticed the tracker hadn’t updated so we called to confirm the order went through. After four times calling, once waiting 4 minutes, no one ever answered. The tracker eventually updated and we got our pizza at 7:45, two hours after ordering.The DoorDash driver said he was there waiting for it for 15+ minutes and there were only two employees. Thankfully we’d already placed a Dominos order, because when it did finally arrive the pizza was cold (unsurprisingly), messy, and unevenly cut. The garlic sauce was also opened and spilled all over. Such a disappointment.
May 15, 2023 · Jess PriceI placed mobile order at 10:50 and it said it was ready at 11:15. When I arrived they said it wasn’t ready and they “accidentally” clicked the button that it was ready. They said it was in oven and will be done soon. I waited until 12:05 almost an hour for a pizza that was supposedly already done. The manager was very rude and said it was oven when I arrived but it don’t take an hour in the oven. They forgot 2 sauces that come with cheese stick and pizza and my pizza was missing a topping. Avoid this location at all cost!!
Mar 29, 2025 · Autumn EltzrothI ordered a pepperoni pizza and 10 wings.Wings had a dollop of sauce in the middle pizza was cheese only and gross af. messed with it. Called the store manager was horrible and rude and didn’t care my pizza was fondled. Waiting corporate now.
Jan 28, 2024 · Lisa SaundersI don’t expect much from papa John’s and it being the worst pizza chain and disgusting fat food. If you enjoy this place you probably have diabetes. I ordered this place on DoorDash at 2 am drunk cause I never would eat this poison sober. Anyways this literally might be the absolute worst pizza I’ve ever seen and had. I took one bite out of this goop and wanted to vomit. I spit it out and the little bit I swallowed is destroying my stomach and digestive system. This place should shut down and everyone that works here should sit in a dark room and think about what they have done.
Dec 22, 2024 · Jason McCord
More Best Restaurants Near Me

76 E Innis Ave, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

1586 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

1881 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

1904 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

181 E Innis Ave, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

181 E Innis Ave, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

1471 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

2108 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

116 E Moler St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

1290 S High St, Columbus, OH 43206, USA

Parsons Avenue &, E Welch Ave, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

1650 Parsons Ave, Columbus, OH 43207, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Bites & Banter Posts





