Penn Station East Coast Subs

- 2500 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209

---

For residents of Ohio craving a robust, satisfying sandwich experience, Penn Station East Coast Subs stands out as a distinctive option. Located in Bexley, this sandwich shop brings the authentic flavors and style of East Coast delis to the heart of Ohio. Unlike many quick-service sandwich establishments, Penn Station specializes in hot, grilled subs, crafted to order with a focus on fresh ingredients and bold flavors. Their menu is renowned for classic offerings such as their famous Cheesesteak, alongside a variety of other grilled and cold deli-style sandwiches, all served on freshly baked bread.

What truly sets Penn Station apart for local Ohio patrons is its commitment to quality and the "made-to-order" philosophy. Each sandwich is prepared right in front of you on a grill, ensuring that meats are hot, cheeses are perfectly melted, and vegetables are sautéed to perfection. This dedication extends beyond their subs to their highly popular fresh-cut fries, which are made from Idaho potatoes and cooked in cholesterol-free peanut oil, and their signature hand-squeezed lemonade, prepared fresh throughout the day. This combination of grilled perfection, fresh sides, and refreshing drinks provides a complete and satisfying meal that has garnered a loyal following among those in the Ohio area looking for something beyond the ordinary cold cut sandwich.

---

Conveniently situated at 2500 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209, USA, Penn Station East Coast Subs is easily accessible for locals across Bexley and the wider Columbus metropolitan area. This prime location on East Main Street places it along a key commercial artery, making it a straightforward destination for a quick lunch, a casual dinner, or a convenient pickup. The strategic positioning ensures that whether you're commuting, running errands in the vicinity, or simply seeking a satisfying meal, reaching Penn Station is generally uncomplicated.

While the parking lot might be described by some customers as "a little small," especially during peak hours, it is generally manageable. As one review notes, even during busy times like 6 PM, finding parking can be "easy." This suggests that with a bit of planning or a willingness for a short walk, accessibility remains a strong point for this location. The interior of the shop is often praised for being "cute with lots of table seating," providing a comfortable environment for those who choose to dine in. This blend of a central location and an inviting atmosphere makes Penn Station a practical and pleasant dining choice for the Ohio community.

---

• Hot Grilled Subs: Specializing in made-to-order subs grilled right in front of the customer, including popular options like Cheesesteak, Chicken Philly, Chicken Teriyaki, Reuben, and Classic Grilled Italian.
• Cold Deli Classics: A selection of traditional cold sandwiches such as the Cold Club, Turkey Provolone, and Classic Cold Italian.
• Wraps: Many of their signature subs, both hot and cold, are available as wraps, offering a lighter alternative.
• Fresh-Cut Fries: Hand-cut Idaho potatoes, flash-fried in cholesterol-free peanut oil, renowned for their fresh taste and crispy texture.
• Hand-Squeezed Lemonade: Freshly squeezed throughout the day, a signature beverage that complements the subs.
• Freshly Baked Cookies: Sweet treats like chocolate chunk cookies baked in-house daily.
• Salads: Various salad options featuring their quality meats and fresh vegetables, providing a lighter meal.
• Cheesebread: Authentic, hearth-baked bread topped with provolone, parmesan, and oregano, with an option for pizza sauce.
• Dine-In Seating: Comfortable and inviting indoor seating for customers who wish to enjoy their meal on-site.
• Takeaway/Carry-Out: Convenient options for picking up orders to enjoy at home or on the go.
• Delivery Services: Available through third-party platforms, allowing customers to have their favorite subs delivered to their door.
• Catering: Offering options for larger groups and events, providing their popular subs and sides for gatherings.

---

• Signature Hot Grilled Subs: Penn Station's primary distinguishing feature is its focus on hot, grilled subs, cooked to order with high-quality meats, cheeses, and fresh vegetables, offering a unique flavor profile compared to cold subs.
• Fresh-Cut Fries Made to Order: Their hand-cut Idaho potato fries are a standout, flash-fried in cholesterol-free peanut oil upon order, ensuring maximum freshness and crispiness.
• Hand-Squeezed Lemonade: A fan-favorite, this refreshing beverage is freshly squeezed several times a day in each restaurant, providing a perfect complement to their savory subs.
• Quality Ingredients: Commitment to using fresh, quality ingredients, from USDA Choice steak for their cheesesteaks to freshly baked bread and crisp vegetables.
• Customizable Orders: Patrons have the option to customize their subs with various toppings, sauces, and preparations to suit individual tastes.
• "East Coast" Inspired Flavors: The menu reflects classic East Coast deli traditions, appealing to those who appreciate that specific regional culinary style.
• Comfortable Dining Atmosphere: The Bexley location often offers a "cute" interior with ample table seating, providing a pleasant environment for dining in.
• Variety of Menu Items: Beyond subs, they offer wraps, salads, and delicious sides like Cheesebread and freshly baked cookies, providing a comprehensive menu.

---

For those in Ohio looking to savor the grilled subs and fresh-cut fries from Penn Station East Coast Subs in Bexley, you can reach them through the following contact details:

Address: 2500 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209, USA

Phone: (614) 231-7366

For mobile contact or alternative direct dialing, you can also use: +1 614-231-7366. These details ensure that customers in the Ohio area can easily connect with the Bexley Penn Station for orders, catering inquiries, or any other questions they might have about their menu and services.

---

For the diverse and discerning residents of Ohio, especially within the Bexley and greater Columbus area, Penn Station East Coast Subs at 2500 E Main St offers a compelling and distinct dining experience that aligns well with local preferences. While some customer feedback might occasionally touch upon aspects like service interaction or the consistency of certain ingredient applications, the core appeal of Penn Station for locals remains strong, rooted in its unique product offerings and overall value.

One of the most significant reasons this establishment is suitable for Ohio locals is its specialization in hot, grilled subs. In a market saturated with various cold sandwich options, Penn Station provides a refreshing alternative with its made-to-order, hot-off-the-grill creations. This approach delivers a more substantial and comforting meal, particularly appealing during Ohio's cooler months or for those seeking a heartier lunch or dinner. The freshness of the ingredients, from the grilled meats and melted cheeses to the crisp, fresh-cut fries cooked in peanut oil, genuinely sets it apart. These fries, often praised in reviews, are a significant draw on their own, offering a perfect, savory complement to any sub.

Furthermore, the availability of hand-squeezed lemonade, made fresh throughout the day, elevates the beverage experience beyond standard fountain drinks, adding a touch of homemade quality that many locals appreciate. The atmosphere, described as "cute with lots of table seating," provides a comfortable and casual environment for dining in, whether for a quick bite or a relaxed meal with family and friends. While the parking lot might require a bit of navigation during peak times, its central location on East Main Street ensures it remains easily accessible for most within the community.

Despite isolated feedback regarding specific order issues or quiet staff, the overall positive sentiment around the "very good" sandwiches and fries, coupled with employees being "incredibly nice," suggests a generally positive experience for the majority of patrons. This commitment to fresh, grilled food and a unique menu positions Penn Station East Coast Subs as a valuable and suitable option for Ohio residents looking for a delicious, distinctive, and satisfying sandwich experience that stands out from typical fast-casual offerings.

Penn Station East Coast Subs

2500 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209, USA