Pickler Sandwich Shop

- 216 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017

In the bustling, fast-paced world of Midtown Manhattan, a great sandwich is a lifeline. It’s a quick, satisfying meal that can get you through a busy day. Pickler Sandwich Shop, located in Midtown East, has made a name for itself by elevating the humble sandwich with creative combinations and high-quality ingredients. More than just a simple deli, Pickler offers a trendy and casual atmosphere perfect for a quick bite. They have a menu that goes beyond the basics, with everything from classic sandwiches to inventive burgers and wraps, all crafted with a clear focus on flavor. For a hungry New Yorker, it’s a spot that’s easy to pop into and find something delicious, no matter what you’re in the mood for.

The name itself, "Pickler," gives a hint to one of the shop's key features—the inclusion of a complimentary pickle spear with every in-store order over a certain amount. This simple touch adds a bit of personality and a tangy counterpoint to their savory offerings. The shop caters to the modern diner with an easy-to-use kiosk ordering system, which, while it might take a moment to get the hang of, allows for a high degree of customization. The menu is a testament to comfort food, with options that are both familiar and unique. It's a great spot for college students and solo diners looking for a reliable, flavorful meal. From breakfast to lunch, Pickler provides a convenient and tasty option in a neighborhood where every minute counts.

Pickler Sandwich Shop is strategically situated at 216 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017, USA. This prime Midtown East location places it conveniently between Grand Central Terminal and the United Nations, making it an excellent stop for commuters, office workers, and tourists exploring the area. The neighborhood is well-served by multiple subway lines, including the 4, 5, 6, 7, and S trains at Grand Central, so getting there is a breeze. For those who prefer to drive, paid street parking is available, though it can be scarce in such a busy area. The shop is designed for easy entry, with a main focus on counter service and takeout, ensuring a quick and efficient experience for everyone, including those with pets, as dogs are allowed both inside and outside.

Pickler Sandwich Shop is designed for convenience, offering multiple ways for customers to get their hands on a delicious meal. The service model is fast-paced and streamlined to fit the needs of a busy urban crowd. The services available include:

• Dine-in: There is seating available for those who want to eat on-site and take a moment to relax.
• Takeout: A major service, allowing customers to quickly grab their food and go.
• Delivery: Pickler offers both standard and no-contact delivery, making it easy to enjoy their menu from the comfort of your home or office.
• Counter Service: The primary method of ordering is through a user-friendly kiosk system, which promotes a quick and efficient ordering process.
• Catering: For office meetings or group events, Pickler provides catering services with large-format options for their most popular sandwiches and sides.
• Breakfast Service: They offer a dedicated breakfast menu, including classic New York staples like the BEC (Bacon, Egg, and Cheese) and unique options like avocado toast.

What makes Pickler Sandwich Shop a go-to spot in Midtown are its distinctive features and menu offerings that stand out from the competition. Some of the most notable highlights include:

• The Pickle Spear: A signature and celebrated feature is the complimentary pickle spear that comes with every in-store order, a tangy and crunchy treat that has become a fan favorite.
• Diverse Menu: The shop is more than just a sandwich place; it’s a hamburger restaurant too. The menu is diverse, with a wide range of sandwiches, burgers, wraps, and vegetarian options.
• High-Quality Ingredients: Customers praise the quality of the ingredients and the freshness of the food, from the bread to the fillings.
• Great Coffee: For those looking for a morning or mid-day pick-me-up, the shop is known for its great coffee.
• Creative Combinations: The menu features creative and well-thought-out flavor combinations, such as the Prosciutto Grilled Cheese and the Buffalo Grilled Cheese.
• Vegetarian-Friendly: There is a dedicated section of the menu for vegetarians, including options like the Veg Burger, Avocado Sandwich, and Caprese Grilled Cheese.
• Casual & Trendy Atmosphere: The vibe is casual and trendy, making it a comfortable spot for a quick and informal meal.
• Fast Service: The ordering kiosks and efficient staff ensure that you get your food quickly, perfect for a short lunch break.

To place an order or to inquire about their menu and services, you can contact Pickler Sandwich Shop at the following:

Address: 216 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017, USA

With a menu full of enticing options, choosing a single item at Pickler Sandwich Shop can be a challenge. However, based on popular opinion and customer reviews, a few items are particularly worth trying. The Reuben and Hot Pastrami sandwiches are excellent choices for classic deli lovers, praised for their flavorful ingredients and satisfying taste. The Turkey Club and Chicken Club are also highly liked and are a great choice for those who want a reliable, hearty sandwich. For a creative take on a comfort food classic, the Buffalo Grilled Cheese has a perfect 100% rating and is a definite must-try. Another standout is the Buffalo Chicken Wrap, which is one of the most ordered items and has a high satisfaction rating. It’s important to note that some reviews suggest the wraps might be on the smaller side, so if you're very hungry, a sandwich or burger might be a more filling choice.

For those looking for something different, the Fried Chicken Sandwich and various burgers, like the Bacon Cheeseburger and BBQ Burger, are also great options. The vegetarian options are also noteworthy, with the Caprese Grilled Cheese receiving perfect scores and the Avocado Sandwich also being a highly-rated choice. The signature pickle spears, which are free with in-store orders over $7, are also a reason to choose Pickler. The fast service, coupled with the high-quality food, makes it a reliable and delicious choice for a quick lunch or a satisfying meal on the go. While a few customers have noted the portion sizes on some items, the overall consensus is that the flavor and freshness make the food well worth the price.

Pickler Sandwich Shop

216 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017, USA