Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar, Rita`s Italian Ice, Custard & Subway Sandwich Introduce
Located in the heart of New York's bustling Financial District, Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar is a unique culinary destination that offers a truly diverse menu. This isn't your typical single-concept eatery; instead, it combines three popular dining options under one roof: Pizza Plus, Rita's Italian Ice & Custard, and a Subway Sandwich shop. This innovative setup makes it a perfect one-stop shop for a quick, satisfying meal and a refreshing treat, whether you're a local on a lunch break or a tourist exploring the area. The atmosphere is casual and designed for efficiency, catering to the fast-paced life of downtown New York. From savory slices of pizza to sweet, creamy Italian ice, this spot has something for everyone in the family, making it a convenient and practical choice for any time of day.
The concept of a multi-brand restaurant is particularly well-suited for the vibrant downtown crowd. It provides a wide variety of options without the need to visit multiple locations. This convenience, combined with a focus on quick service, makes it an ideal spot for a lunch break, a solo dinner, or a simple bite to eat while on the go. The establishment's proximity to major landmarks, including Battery Park and the Staten Island Ferry Terminal, also makes it a popular stop for travelers and families seeking a fast and reliable meal. The friendly and efficient staff, as noted by customer reviews, ensures that even during busy times, the service remains quick and pleasant, adding to the overall positive experience.
Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar is situated at a strategic location:
4 South St, New York, NY 10004, USA
. This address places it right in the heart of the Financial District, an area known for its vibrant mix of businesses and major tourist attractions. The restaurant is located inside the Staten Island Ferry Terminal, making it an incredibly convenient spot for commuters and tourists taking the ferry. Its accessibility is one of its most significant advantages.The location is a transportation hub, with easy access to various bus routes and subway lines, ensuring a hassle-free journey from almost anywhere in the city. The area is highly walkable, and its proximity to Battery Park, the Statue of Liberty cruise terminals, and the bustling downtown core makes it an ideal stop for a meal. For those driving, the presence of paid street parking and nearby garages provides options, though public transportation is often the most practical choice in this busy area. The restaurant also offers a wheelchair-accessible entrance, making it welcoming and convenient for all patrons.
This establishment offers a wide array of services to accommodate the diverse needs of its customers, prioritizing speed and convenience.
Dine-in: The restaurant provides a casual setting with seating where you can enjoy your meal. It's a great spot for a quick break from your day in the city.
Delivery: For those who can't make it to the restaurant, no-contact delivery is available, bringing hot food and cool treats directly to your doorstep. This is a perfect option for a quiet night in or a working lunch at the office.
Takeout & Curbside Pickup: You can place an order for takeout and pick it up at your convenience. Curbside pickup is also available, offering a fast and seamless way to get your food without having to leave your car.
Counter Service: The food is ordered and served at the counter, which contributes to the fast and efficient nature of the service, perfect for a quick bite during a busy day.
The variety of service options highlights the restaurant's adaptability and commitment to customer convenience. Whether you need a quick meal on the spot or a delivery to your home, this multi-brand concept is set up to serve you efficiently. The focus on a smooth and quick transaction is a major draw for both locals and tourists.
Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar, Rita's Italian Ice, Custard & Subway Sandwich stands out for several unique features and highlights that make it a compelling choice.
Combined Concepts: The main highlight is the combination of a pizza place, a dessert shop (Rita’s Italian Ice & Custard), and a sandwich shop (Subway) under one roof. This provides unparalleled convenience and variety, allowing different members of a group or family to get exactly what they want without going to multiple locations.
Quick & Efficient: As a popular spot for lunch and a quick bite, the restaurant is known for its fast service. The staff is efficient, ensuring that you can get your food and be on your way without a long wait, which is crucial for busy New Yorkers.
Variety of Offerings: The menu is extensive and includes pizza by the slice for a quick snack, full pizzas for sharing, classic hot heroes, and a range of desserts from Italian ice to frozen custard. The drink options are also varied, with soft drinks and bottled water available.
Live Music & Sports: The restaurant offers a lively atmosphere with live music and the broadcast of sports events. This adds an entertaining element to the dining experience, making it a great place to hang out and enjoy a meal in a more festive setting.
Good for Kids: The wide selection of food and treats, from pizza to ice cream, makes this a very family-friendly destination. It’s a place where everyone, including children, can find something they love.
These features collectively define the experience at Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar. The combination of different cuisines and the focus on a lively atmosphere and quick service make it a dynamic and appealing spot for a wide range of customers.
For all inquiries or to place an order, you can contact Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar, Rita's Italian Ice, Custard & Subway Sandwich directly.
Address: 4 South St, New York, NY 10004, USA
Phone: (212) 943-1800
The restaurant accepts both credit and debit cards, providing convenient payment options for all customers.
What is truly worth choosing at this establishment is the incredible variety and convenience it offers. For a quick and classic New York meal, a slice of pizza is a perfect choice, with options ranging from a classic Cheese or Pepperoni to more unique selections like Buffalo Chicken or BBQ Chicken. The hot heroes, such as the Chicken Parmigiana Hero, also provide a delicious and filling option. However, the true highlight that sets this place apart is the combination of savory food with the sweet offerings from Rita's Italian Ice & Custard.
After a slice of pizza or a hero, the perfect follow-up is a refreshing treat from Rita’s. Customer reviews praise the Italian ice for being "smooth, flavorful, and packed with real fruit taste," while the frozen custard is described as "rich and creamy." This combination of a warm, savory meal and a cool, sweet dessert makes for a perfect dining experience, especially after a trip to a nearby landmark like the Statue of Liberty. The staff, noted for their amazing customer service, adds to the pleasant experience. For those looking for a fast, delicious, and diverse meal in a convenient location, this unique restaurant concept is an excellent choice that delivers on all fronts, providing a complete dining experience for a quick stop in the city.
Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar, Rita`s Italian Ice, Custard & Subway Sandwich Food & drink
Beverages
- 20 Oz. Bottle Soda $3.75
- Gatorade $3.75
- Minute Maid Juice $3.75
- Powerade $3.75
- Snapple $3.75
- Water $2.50
- Dasani 20 Oz. Bottle Water $2.75
Hot Heroes
- Eggplant Parmigiana Hero $6.99
Indulge in our Eggplant Parmigiana Hero! Enjoy crispy, breaded eggplant slices topped with marinara sauce and gooey melted mozzarella cheese, all nestled in a toasted hero roll. It’s a satisfying and flavorful Italian classic that’s sure to delight.
- Chicken Parmigiana Hero $6.99
Enjoy the classic flavors of our Chicken Parmigiana Hero! A succulent, breaded chicken breast is topped with zesty marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese, all served on a crispy, toasted hero roll. This hearty sandwich is perfect for a satisfying meal.
- Meatball Parmigiana Hero $6.99
Enjoy the classic taste of our Meatball Parmigiana Hero!!! This sandwich features savory meatballs, covered in zesty marinara sauce and topped with melted mozzarella cheese, all on a toasted hero roll. It’s a satisfying and delicious choice for a hearty meal.
Pizza
- Cheese Pizza $30.00
- White Pizza $39.99
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza $39.99
- Mushroom Pizza $34.99
- BBQ Chicken Pizza $27.99
- Pepperoni Pizza $30.00
- Hawaiian Pizza $38.99
- Vegetable Pizza $34.99
- Supreme Meat Lover's Pizza $45.99
Pizza by the Slice
- Cheese Pizza Slice $3.75
- White Pizza Slice $5.99
- Sicilian Cheese Pizza Slice $6.49
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice $5.99
- Mushroom Pizza Slice $5.49
- BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice $5.99
- Pepperoni Pizza Slice $5.49
- Hawaiian Pizza Slice $5.99
- Vegetable Pizza Slice $5.51
- Supreme Meat Lover's Pizza Slice $6.99
- CHICKEN BACON RANCH $6.99
Italian Rolls
- Chicken Roll $6.99
Enjoy our Chicken Roll, a delicious combination of juicy chicken, fresh vegetables, and savory sauce all wrapped in a soft tortilla. It’s a perfect blend of flavors and textures that makes for a satisfying and portable meal.
- Pepperoni Roll $6.99
Indulge in our Pepperoni Roll, where spicy pepperoni and melted cheese are wrapped in a soft, flavorful dough and baked to perfection. This roll is a savory treat that’s perfect for a satisfying snack or a quick meal.
- Spinach Roll $6.99
Enjoy our Spinach Roll, featuring tender, seasoned spinach wrapped in a soft, golden dough. This flavorful roll combines the freshness of spinach with a touch of cheese and herbs, creating a delicious and satisfying option for a light meal or snack.
- Sausage Roll $6.99
Enjoy the classic flavor of our Sausage Roll!!! Juicy, seasoned sausage is wrapped in a flaky, golden pastry, creating a satisfying and delicious snack or meal that's both savory and comforting.
Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar, Rita`s Italian Ice, Custard & Subway Sandwich Details
Service options
- Curbside pickup
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Live music
- Sports
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Offerings
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
Atmosphere
- Casual
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar, Rita`s Italian Ice, Custard & Subway Sandwich Photos










Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar, Rita`s Italian Ice, Custard & Subway Sandwich Location
Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar, Rita`s Italian Ice, Custard & Subway Sandwich
4 South St, New York, NY 10004, USA
Pizza Plus & Margarita Bar, Rita`s Italian Ice, Custard & Subway Sandwich Reviews
ferryice creamwingspepperonispringranchconversationcashierpeoplecheese pizza
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1This is a perfect spot for a refreshing treat! Their Italian ice is always smooth, flavorful, and packed with real fruit taste, while the frozen custard is rich and creamy. The staff is friendly and efficient, ensuring quick service even on busy days. Whether you're craving a classic gelati or trying a new flavor, Rita’s never disappoints. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a sweet and satisfying dessert.
March 19 · Naima NoorenJashim was amazing. Great customer service. The pizza tasty and the ice cream was the perfect treat after leaving Battery Park / Statute of Liberty cruise! Now to the subway and heading to Time Square!
August 08 · BentleyThis is one of the beat pizza spots in NY i come here every year and always stop by after riding the staten island ferry to grab a slice the staff are very kind and service is excellent
March 21 · JohnJashim has great customer service. He smiled and made sure we was happy with our order. My pizza was fresh and full of flavor. I’ll definitely visit again
August 08 · Mia HarleyI got served by Jeshim and I must say, as a Belgian tourist, I was blown away that pizza from a transit station cornershop would taste this good, like, I did NOT see that coming. Would've liked a bit more sitting space, but the pizza was GREAT. New York City truly does not lack when it comes to pizza!
August 04 · Rik Keersmaekers
More Best Restaurants Near Me

Terminal, 4 South St, Manhattan, NY 10004, USA

4 South St #202, New York, NY 10004, USA

4 South St #204, New York, NY 10004, USA

10 Peter Minuit Plz, New York, NY 10004, USA

1 New York Plaza, 1 FDR Dr, New York, NY 10004, USA

Water Street &, Whitehall St, New York, NY 10004, USA

1 Water St, New York, NY 10004, USA

1 New York Plaza, FDR Dr, New York, NY 10004, USA

1 New York Plaza, FDR Dr, New York, NY 10004, USA

1 New York Plaza, 1 Water St, New York, NY 10004, USA

Concourse Level 1 New York Plaza, 1 Whitehall St, New York, NY 10004, USA

1 Battery Pl, New York, NY 10004, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Bites & Banter Posts





